Nadia Whittome

Nadia Whittome

Labour — Nottingham East

Speaking in the House of Commons on 17 November 2026

Debate

Immigration and Asylum Bill

Contribution

This Bill is harmful on many fronts. It makes it harder for refugees to get settled status and reunite with their families. It significantly weakens our response to trafficking and modern slavery. It replaces the first-tier tribunal with an appeals body staffed by adjudicators who are not legally qualified. However, in the short time I have to speak, I will focus on its impact in relation to violence against women and girls. VAWG sector organisations describe the Bill as “far-reaching and devastating, particularly on those who are already vulnerable and who face severe marginalisation and discrimination.” Under its proposals, a migrant woman who is a victim-survivor of gender-based violence can lose her right to stay in the country due to the consequences of the abuse she has faced. The Bill’s public interest considerations will count against migrant women who are not financially independent, and it will heavily penalise those with criminal convictions. These proposals will punish women who have experienced economic abuse and exclusions from education or employment, women who have convictions relating to acts they were coerced or pressured into committing to meet their own basic needs, and women who have been criminalised for behaviour resulting from their own experiences of abuse or exploitation, exacerbated by the rise in perpetrator counter-allegations. For example, if a migrant woman retaliates after years of abuse by her British husband, and despite reporting the abuse to the police, is convicted and spends time in prison, this Bill would put her at high risk of deportation and being left with no route to settlement. The Bill also proposes that “no weight” should be given to family or private life formed when a person did not have leave to enter or remain, and that little weight be given to family life formed when someone’s immigration status was precarious. But many migrant survivors of male violence face immigration abuse from their perpetrators and therefore have no control and often no awareness of their immigration status. Coupled with the new earned settlement plans, a woman who has been a lawful resident of the UK for 10 years or more could be told she has no right to respect for the family and private life she has built here. That is so clearly wrong and so clearly at odds with the Government’s mission to halve violence against women and girls. If that mission is to mean anything, it must apply to all women, including migrant women. My amendment 42 would require a court or tribunal to take into consideration the effects of violence against women and girls when deciding whether an interference with a person’s article 8 rights is justified. In Committee, the Government argued against including a public interest consideration relating to VAWG in the Bill, since courts can already consider relevant circumstances. However, campaign groups such as Hibiscus Initiatives and Rights of Women make clear that a statutory requirement is needed to ensure that courts give VAWG appropriate consideration, which, in their experience, all too often does not happen. I fear that without amendments to the Bill, this Government will unwittingly punish many women twice for their own abuse and exploitation. Surely none of us can live with such a legacy. I urge the Government to reconsider.

More from Nadia Whittome

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Nadia Whittome's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Nadia Whittome report card.