Mr Paul Kohler

Mr Paul Kohler

Liberal Democrat — Wimbledon

Speaking in the House of Commons on 17 November 2026

Debate

Immigration and Asylum Bill

Contribution

Although I have recently assumed the role of my party’s immigration and asylum spokesperson, I am speaking today as a member of the Home Affairs Committee. Although I am not speaking on behalf of the Committee, I am, in the unavoidable absence of the Chair, offering reflections based on the Committee’s work in the areas covered by the Bill, rather than focusing on my party’s policy priorities. The creation of the independent immigration appeals authority under part 1 of the Bill risks perpetuating and almost certainly exacerbating the very problem it seeks to resolve. Staffing a first-tier tribunal with people from non-judicial backgrounds runs the risk of simply moving the backlog to the upper tribunal, as they discovered in Australia, where they had to abandon such an approach. Professor Richard Ekins of Oxford University warned of the very same thing in his evidence to the Bill Committee, and it is a point that the judicial head of the Danish Immigration Appeals Board also made when the Select Committee visited Denmark to observe its approach to asylum. The Select Committee learnt a large amount relevant to the Bill from its trip to Denmark, where the immigration system is often simplistically characterised as being hard-line on asylum. The reality is in fact far more nuanced and, in some respects, far more enlightened than the UK approach. In Denmark, accommodation is run mostly by non-governmental organisations, notably the Red Cross. It is an approach that changes the whole tone of the debate. Rather than making millions for “Asylum King” Graham King, the Danish Government award accommodation contracts on a not-for-profit basis. That contrasts with the UK, where such contracts are awarded on a cost-plus basis that incentivises commercial providers to spend more money, thereby increasing profits. The Prime Minister tells us he wants to roll back the tide of neoliberalism. Is there any more egregious example of its excesses than outsourcing for private profit the provision of substandard asylum accommodation, as seen on occasion by our Committee and as highlighted in last Sunday’s ITV documentary “Inside the Asylum Camp”, which highlighted deficiencies in the Crowborough camp in East Sussex, run by Graham King’s Clearsprings Ready Homes? That programme, which I urge all Members to watch, told a depressing story of inadequate safeguarding and considerable local hostility. The Danish approach, in contrast, takes a great deal of heat out of the issue, with local people volunteering to help inside the asylum accommodation, rather than protesting outside. The Committee was also told about one example of an asylum centre that the Danish Government sought to close but local people campaigned to keep open. Retrospective changes to the earned settlement rules were also considered by the Select Committee, which were of great concern to a number of its members. Indeed, I tabled an amendment articulating my concern that extending the length of time required for indefinite leave to remain for migrants who had played by the rules and already embarked on that path would cause “injustice, unintended consequences…damaging the UK’s reputation in the international labour market.” It is noteworthy that although my amendment was not accepted, some Labour Members either voted with me or abstained on the vote in Committee.

More from Mr Paul Kohler

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Mr Paul Kohler's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Mr Paul Kohler report card.