Contribution
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir John. I thank the right hon. Member for Tatton (Esther McVey) and the hon. Member for Blackley and Middleton South (Graham Stringer) for bringing this matter to the House today.
I want to start today by referring to two incredible people, who became heroes of mine after I watched “Mums v Big Pharma” last week. I sat with my husband and watched it, and we ended it in tears. I know about sodium valproate, because over the years many of my constituents in Lagan Valley have raised it with me as an issue. I also know about pelvic and hernia mesh, for the same reason. But it is not until you see the damage that these products have wrought on families that it is really brought home.
I want to get to the heart of an issue that I feel is critical in all this. Hon. Members from across the House have already said that they feel there is a barrier, and potentially a conflict of interest, and they have questioned the foundation of the MHRA itself and its status as an arm’s length body. I think there is something deeper going on. Whether it is sodium valproate, Primodos, thalidomide, mesh or one of many other things, there is an issue of class. That might be uncomfortable or controversial, but many people in this country trust the medical profession and regulatory authorities without question, to the extent that we have tried to bring in interventions such as the Hillsborough law so that there are barriers and systems to ensure that those bodies are beyond reproach. But if we expect members of the public to be the lone voice against pharmaceutical giants and we disregard them, where is the robustness in that system?
I look at Emma Murphy and Janet Williams. They describe themselves, in our parlance in Northern Ireland, as two wee women. Well, I will tell you what: they are some women. They faced barriers and discrimination for years, and where did it leave us? Hundreds of thousands of families up and down the country have been impacted—damaged—unnecessarily. I look at the guardrails that Members across this House have raised many times, and I question their efficacy and effectiveness. Let me point out, too, that this has damaged everyone in society—men, women and children—but there is a particular issue around women’s health, and I find the issues raised by the hon. Member for Washington and Gateshead South (Mrs Hodgson) particularly concerning.
I say to the House today that we have to stop this reverence. We have to listen to people. People have questioned how robust and effective the yellow card system is, but we do not empower people in this country; we tread on them. We close ranks—professional ranks and medical ranks—and we gaslight them. We tell them they are the problem. We hear about the “fruitless anxiety” that was mentioned in reports. We hear about not wanting to concern people. Meanwhile, we know that people are consuming a drug that we know to have teratogenic impacts. How disgusting, and how wrong.
The final insult is that the redress promised to so many families across the UK is still outstanding. But this is not about the redress; it is about the fact that we have a system that is clearly not fit for purpose. We have to ensure that these regulatory bodies are indeed beyond reproach. It is not enough for links to be based on an old school tie, class references or anything else; we have to ensure that they are robust.
I want to conclude by expressing my heartfelt thanks to the families up and down the country that have been failed by the MHRA and the state. They deserve nothing but our applause and adulation, but the applause is meaningless unless we change this absolutely wrong system, which has damaged people and left many of us in this House without confidence in it. There is nothing more important than health and, frankly, it sits extremely uncomfortably with me that over many decades we have not taken action when we should have done. I again thank the right hon. Member for Tatton and the hon. Member for Blackley and Middleton South for bringing this issue to the House. I urge Members not to give up this fight, and to fight for those families.