Andy McDonald

Andy McDonald

Labour — Middlesbrough and Thornaby East

Speaking in the House of Commons on 17 November 2026

Debate

Department for Work and Pensions: Synergy Contract

Contribution

I wholeheartedly agree with my good and hon. Friend. It is a very strange situation. PCS believes that the failures justify removing Capita from pensions administration. I agree that where contractors repeatedly fail to deliver essential services, the Government must be prepared to end those arrangements and bring the work back in-house. Pensions administration and payroll are different services. Problems in one do not mean that the other will fail, but those problems demonstrate why effective oversight, safeguards and contingency arrangements are essential. Those concerns prompted my right hon. Friend the Member for Hayes and Harlington (John McDonnell), as chair of the PCS parliamentary group, to write to Ministers in July to call for the Synergy contract to be paused and reassessed because of the potential consequences for civil servants’ pay. Staff at the DWP are already under enormous pressure. A recent PCS survey of almost 5,000 members in the DWP found that 73% reported backlogs caused by staff shortages—and these are the people we will depend on to deliver on the Milburn reforms and provide intensive job coaching. Civil servants delivering essential services on which millions depend should not also have to worry about whether their wages will arrive on time. They are entitled to ask, “Am I going to be left waiting for my salary each month?” Ministers must be able to answer that question with confidence. This is also about the wider financial case for outsourcing. The Public Accounts Committee warned in July that the Government’s wider shared services strategy was at risk of failure. The Government claim the programme will deliver more than £4 billion in benefits, but the Committee found that the Government have failed to establish a clear overall financial case for their shared services strategy. Crucially, the PAC also questioned the value-for-money case for outsourcing Synergy to Capita, rather than delivering those services in-house, as with the Unity programme. Surely, Ministers must now establish whether outsourcing really offers better value than direct public provision. I acknowledge that Ministers have raised concerns about reversing existing contractual arrangements, and I have no doubt the Minister will warn of the financial, legal and operational risks associated with reversing the reward. Those risks must be taken seriously. Nobody wants to jeopardise payroll continuity for hundreds of thousands of civil servants, but there is a fundamental distinction between recognising those risks and accepting that outsourcing must continue without serious reconsideration. The Government should review the decision to continue outsourcing Synergy’s essential administrative services and establish whether they can be brought back into direct public provision. I have sought this debate not simply to catalogue the failures of outsourcing, but because the Government have recognised the need for a different approach. On 26 October, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Cabinet Office told the House that she had instructed officials to examine future delivery options for civil service pensions, “including insourcing all core business operations.”—[Official Report, 26 October 2026; Vol. 792, c. 31.] I very much welcome that approach. Given the continuing failures, the assessment must proceed urgently and include the option of ending the existing, outsourced arrangement. I also welcome the Government’s new central insourcing unit, established to help Departments bring outsourced work back under direct public management. The Government’s updated guidance rightly requires consideration of the full costs over time, service reliability, accountability and the skills needed to deliver services directly. Where skills have been lost through outsourcing, the Government should consider how to rebuild them. Alternatives already exist within the Government’s own shared services programme. In the Unity contract, which includes His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs and the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, previously outsourced work has been brought back into HMRC with staff transferring into the Department. In the Matrix contract, including the Department for Education, the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade and other Departments, plans for full outsourcing were halted in favour of public sector provision. If those alternatives are possible elsewhere in the Government, why should the future of Synergy not be examined on the same basis? The Government need not choose between immediately cancelling a contract without adequate preparation and allowing outsourcing to continue indefinitely; they can review the decision, examine the contractual options and develop the staff, skills and systems needed to bring the work back into public provision. That review must also protect the workforce. PCS has consistently called for guarantees against compulsory involuntary redundancies arising from these programmes, for work transferred overseas to be brought back into the UK civil service and for the protection of employment terms and conditions. I support those demands. Bringing services back in-house should strengthen the civil service, protect jobs and employment conditions, and rebuild the skills and expertise that have been lost through outsourcing. The objectives should be to rebuild the expertise of the civil service, protect workers, and ensure that essential public services are delivered reliably. Workers must have a meaningful role in shaping that future. I pay tribute to PCS, the PCS parliamentary group and the Insource Now! campaign for keeping this issue on the agenda. The Synergy programme has recently established meetings to share information with trade unions, but PCS has made it clear that these do not yet amount to meaningful consultation or negotiation. It is insufficient to leave consultation entirely to individual Departments when Synergy is introducing common arrangements across them. Ministers should ensure that recognised unions can negotiate at the level at which decisions are actually being made, as well as within individual Departments. I want to ask the Minister to commit to one central objective: an urgent review of the decision to continue outsourcing Synergy’s essential administrative services with a proper assessment of how and when they could be brought back into public provision. I have five specific requests. First, will the Government publish the Synergy contract, subject to the necessary redactions, and explain the safeguards for payroll continuity and what happens if the contractor fails to deliver? Secondly, will they urgently review the outsourcing decision and assess the costs and practicalities of bringing the services in-house, including opportunities to review or end existing contractual arrangements? Thirdly, will the Government respond to the Public Accounts Committee’s recommendations and explain why the public sector approaches used in Unity and Matrix cannot also be considered for Synergy? Fourthly, will the new central insourcing unit examine Synergy as an early test of the Government’s policy, drawing on the lessons of the failures in civil service pensions administration? Fifthly, will Ministers establish meaningful negotiations with recognised unions across the participating Departments, with guarantees on jobs, offshoring and employment conditions? The Government have made a very welcome commitment to a new wave of insourcing. The challenge now is to turn that commitment into practice. I am not asking Ministers to jeopardise payroll services or prejudge matters before the courts; I am asking them to reconsider whether outsourcing is the right model for these essential functions, and to begin the work necessary to bring them back under direct public management. For too long, outsourcing has been treated as the default, with public provision required to justify itself as the exception. The Government have an opportunity to reverse that presumption. Modernisation should mean building a more capable state, not simply transferring essential functions to private contractors. Public money should be directed towards delivering excellent public services with public accountability, rather than unnecessarily financing private profit. I hope Ministers will seize that opportunity.

More from Andy McDonald

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Andy McDonald's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Andy McDonald report card.