Department for Work and Pensions: Synergy Contract
Tuesday, 17 November 2026
Contributions
[Emma Lewell in the Chair ]
Andy McDonald (Middlesbrough and Thornaby East) (Lab)Labour
I beg to move, That this House has considered the role of the Department for Work and Pensions in the procurement of the Synergy contract. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Ms Lewell, and I draw Members’ attention to my entry in the Register of Members’ Financial Interests as a proud trade unionist. This debate comes at a time when the failures of outsourcing have become increasingly apparent and when this Government have made a welcome commitment to insourcing public sector expertise, strengthening accountability and ensuring public money is spent delivering services rather than financing private profit. The outsourcing of Government payroll and administrative services has its origins in the Conservative-Liberal Democrat coalition. In 2013, work previously carried out within government was transferred to Shared Services Connected Ltd, a company that was then 75% privately owned; the Government sold their remaining shareholding in 2023. The award of the Synergy contract to Capita continues that approach. The question is whether this Government will take the opportunity to reconsider it in keeping with their commitment to insourcing. Synergy is a programme to bring together payroll, human resources, finance and purchasing systems across several Government Departments, led by the Department for Work and Pensions. It covers the Home Office, the Ministry of Justice, the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs and other public bodies and provides services for more than 250,000 civil servants. There is a good case for sharing modern technology and reducing duplication, but modernisation does not require outsourcing. I should make it clear that there are ongoing legal proceedings concerning the procurement of the Synergy contract. I will not address the competing bids, the evaluation of the tender or the merits of those proceedings—those are matters for the courts. My concern is with the wider policy of outsourcing essential services, the risks it creates for workers and the public, and whether the Government should reconsider continuing with private provision. The stakes are considerable. Civil servants must be paid correctly and on time. Payroll failures can mean missed mortgage payments, rent arrears and serious financial hardship. The failures in Capita’s administration of civil service pensions demonstrate what can happen when essential services are outsourced and they go wrong.
Jim Shannon (Strangford) (DUP)Democratic Unionist Party
I commend the hon. Gentleman on introducing the debate, which is important to my constituents because I represent many serving and retired UK civil servants, including Home Office staff at our ports and airports who have already endured months of distress and financial hardship due to Capita’s severe backlogs with the civil service pension scheme. Given the record of failure, does the hon. Gentleman agree that DWP showed a troubling lack of due diligence in handing the very same company a £900 million 10-year contract to run frontline payroll and HR systems and that our civil servants, of whom much is expected, should have had a working system put in place instead?
Andy McDonaldLabour
The hon. Gentleman makes a really valid point. That is the concern and worry throughout the United Kingdom; it is experienced in every constituency, so he is right to highlight it.
Lara Bird (Arbroath and Broughty Ferry) (SNP)Scottish National Party
I reiterate the thanks to the hon. Member for securing this debate. It is on an issue that many of my constituents have brought to me because they are so concerned about Capita’s ability, given the ongoing scandal. I want to mention several of my constituents whose cases span years because of Capita’s mismanagement, but they are no further forward. My office has been told repeatedly that, despite ongoing conversations with Capita, there is simply no update for them. As a result of a massive delay by Capita, one of my constituents is in a critical situation: they are left to live on less than £100 a month in the escalating cost of living crisis. Does the hon. Member agree that Capita simply cannot be trusted with an operation at this scale?
Andy McDonaldLabour
Those are egregious instances of complete and utter failure, and it is right that hon. Members bring those experiences to the House. Our constituents deserve their cases to be raised, and the hon. Lady has done that incredibly well. On 26 October the Parliamentary Secretary to the Cabinet Office confirmed that Capita had missed its recovery milestones. Figures reported by the Public and Commercial Services Union on 12 November show approximately 156,000 outstanding pension cases, including 1,700 complex cases more than a year old.
Tom Gordon (Harrogate and Knaresborough) (LD)Liberal Democrat
I congratulate the hon. Member on securing this important debate. At first, after this blew up and became a big, high-profile issue—addressed in the statements to which the hon. Member refers—we saw some positive signs of being able to liaise with Capita and get some of the issues fixed. That now seems to be going off the boil and we find it more and more difficult to get Capita’s casework teams to push cases forward. Does the hon. Member agree that the Government need to consistently push to make sure that people do not go without in retirement?
Andy McDonaldLabour
The hon. Gentleman makes a valid point. The description of cases as being somehow complex masks the inability of Capita to resolve matters. Behind the figures that I recited are people who spent their working lives in public service only to face uncertainty and hardship in accessing their pensions. PCS reports that some have even been forced to postpone their retirement. There is also a cost to the taxpayer. PCS reports that more than 100 civil servants have been deployed to help to restore the pension service, at a cost of £12.5 billion. Taxpayers are paying a private contractor to deliver a service while public servants and public money are deployed to rescue it. That raises a fundamental question about whether outsourcing delivers value for money.
Ian Lavery (Blyth and Ashington) (Lab)Labour
I congratulate my hon. Friend on securing this important debate. I bet every MP has sackloads of correspondence from individuals with complaints about that pension scheme. Capita cannot pay the pensions. It cannot give predictions on what pension individuals will get on retirement. People are dying without getting their pensions, yet the Government agreed to give Capita the Synergy contract, which is worth £900 million. Does my hon. Friend agree that that is bizarre in many ways?
Andy McDonaldLabour
I wholeheartedly agree with my good and hon. Friend. It is a very strange situation. PCS believes that the failures justify removing Capita from pensions administration. I agree that where contractors repeatedly fail to deliver essential services, the Government must be prepared to end those arrangements and bring the work back in-house. Pensions administration and payroll are different services. Problems in one do not mean that the other will fail, but those problems demonstrate why effective oversight, safeguards and contingency arrangements are essential. Those concerns prompted my right hon. Friend the Member for Hayes and Harlington (John McDonnell), as chair of the PCS parliamentary group, to write to Ministers in July to call for the Synergy contract to be paused and reassessed because of the potential consequences for civil servants’ pay. Staff at the DWP are already under enormous pressure. A recent PCS survey of almost 5,000 members in the DWP found that 73% reported backlogs caused by staff shortages—and these are the people we will depend on to deliver on the Milburn reforms and provide intensive job coaching. Civil servants delivering essential services on which millions depend should not also have to worry about whether their wages will arrive on time. They are entitled to ask, “Am I going to be left waiting for my salary each month?” Ministers must be able to answer that question with confidence. This is also about the wider financial case for outsourcing. The Public Accounts Committee warned in July that the Government’s wider shared services strategy was at risk of failure. The Government claim the programme will deliver more than £4 billion in benefits, but the Committee found that the Government have failed to establish a clear overall financial case for their shared services strategy. Crucially, the PAC also questioned the value-for-money case for outsourcing Synergy to Capita, rather than delivering those services in-house, as with the Unity programme. Surely, Ministers must now establish whether outsourcing really offers better value than direct public provision. I acknowledge that Ministers have raised concerns about reversing existing contractual arrangements, and I have no doubt the Minister will warn of the financial, legal and operational risks associated with reversing the reward. Those risks must be taken seriously. Nobody wants to jeopardise payroll continuity for hundreds of thousands of civil servants, but there is a fundamental distinction between recognising those risks and accepting that outsourcing must continue without serious reconsideration. The Government should review the decision to continue outsourcing Synergy’s essential administrative services and establish whether they can be brought back into direct public provision. I have sought this debate not simply to catalogue the failures of outsourcing, but because the Government have recognised the need for a different approach. On 26 October, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Cabinet Office told the House that she had instructed officials to examine future delivery options for civil service pensions, “including insourcing all core business operations.” —[ Official Report , 26 October 2026; Vol. 792, c. 31.] I very much welcome that approach. Given the continuing failures, the assessment must proceed urgently and include the option of ending the existing, outsourced arrangement. I also welcome the Government’s new central insourcing unit, established to help Departments bring outsourced work back under direct public management. The Government’s updated guidance rightly requires consideration of the full costs over time, service reliability, accountability and the skills needed to deliver services directly. Where skills have been lost through outsourcing, the Government should consider how to rebuild them. Alternatives already exist within the Government’s own shared services programme. In the Unity contract, which includes His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs and the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, previously outsourced work has been brought back into HMRC with staff transferring into the Department. In the Matrix contract, including the Department for Education, the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade and other Departments, plans for full outsourcing were halted in favour of public sector provision. If those alternatives are possible elsewhere in the Government, why should the future of Synergy not be examined on the same basis? The Government need not choose between immediately cancelling a contract without adequate preparation and allowing outsourcing to continue indefinitely; they can review the decision, examine the contractual options and develop the staff, skills and systems needed to bring the work back into public provision. That review must also protect the workforce. PCS has consistently called for guarantees against compulsory involuntary redundancies arising from these programmes, for work transferred overseas to be brought back into the UK civil service and for the protection of employment terms and conditions. I support those demands. Bringing services back in-house should strengthen the civil service, protect jobs and employment conditions, and rebuild the skills and expertise that have been lost through outsourcing. The objectives should be to rebuild the expertise of the civil service, protect workers, and ensure that essential public services are delivered reliably. Workers must have a meaningful role in shaping that future. I pay tribute to PCS, the PCS parliamentary group and the Insource Now! campaign for keeping this issue on the agenda. The Synergy programme has recently established meetings to share information with trade unions, but PCS has made it clear that these do not yet amount to meaningful consultation or negotiation. It is insufficient to leave consultation entirely to individual Departments when Synergy is introducing common arrangements across them. Ministers should ensure that recognised unions can negotiate at the level at which decisions are actually being made, as well as within individual Departments. I want to ask the Minister to commit to one central objective: an urgent review of the decision to continue outsourcing Synergy’s essential administrative services with a proper assessment of how and when they could be brought back into public provision. I have five specific requests. First, will the Government publish the Synergy contract, subject to the necessary redactions, and explain the safeguards for payroll continuity and what happens if the contractor fails to deliver? Secondly, will they urgently review the outsourcing decision and assess the costs and practicalities of bringing the services in-house, including opportunities to review or end existing contractual arrangements? Thirdly, will the Government respond to the Public Accounts Committee’s recommendations and explain why the public sector approaches used in Unity and Matrix cannot also be considered for Synergy? Fourthly, will the new central insourcing unit examine Synergy as an early test of the Government’s policy, drawing on the lessons of the failures in civil service pensions administration? Fifthly, will Ministers establish meaningful negotiations with recognised unions across the participating Departments, with guarantees on jobs, offshoring and employment conditions? The Government have made a very welcome commitment to a new wave of insourcing. The challenge now is to turn that commitment into practice. I am not asking Ministers to jeopardise payroll services or prejudge matters before the courts; I am asking them to reconsider whether outsourcing is the right model for these essential functions, and to begin the work necessary to bring them back under direct public management. For too long, outsourcing has been treated as the default, with public provision required to justify itself as the exception. The Government have an opportunity to reverse that presumption. Modernisation should mean building a more capable state, not simply transferring essential functions to private contractors. Public money should be directed towards delivering excellent public services with public accountability, rather than unnecessarily financing private profit. I hope Ministers will seize that opportunity.
Sarah Green (Chesham and Amersham) (LD)Liberal Democrat
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Ms Lewell. I congratulate the hon. Member for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East (Andy McDonald) on securing this debate. Every civil servant deserves to be paid correctly and on time. After decades of public service, receiving the pension they have earned should be the very least they can expect from the Government. However, like many hon. Members here today, my team and I have been helping former civil servants who have found themselves unable to access their pensions. This administrative failure has left people facing extreme financial hardship in the middle of a cost of living crisis, through no fault of their own. One constituent from Amersham retired in February this year after 35 years of public service. Almost nine months later, he has still not received a penny of his pension, and he has had no indication of when his payments will begin. Last October, the Public Accounts Committee, which I sit on, warned that there was a clear risk that Capita would not be ready to take over the civil service pension scheme. When Capita took over on 1 December, the backlog was more than double what the contract assumed. The warning signs were there, but the handover went ahead anyway. At our Committee’s joint hearing with the Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee in July this year, 5,700 people were still waiting for a pension quote after their retirement date had passed and more than 3,000 payments were outstanding. The Cabinet Office told us that Capita was in breach of contract and expected to fail 16 of its 21 performance targets that month. In parallel, in February this year, the DWP named Capita as the preferred bidder for Synergy, which covers pay, HR and finance for more than 250,000 civil servants. The Government were prepared to hand the same company responsibility for another quarter of a million people’s livelihoods. One of my constituents, who is a member of the PCS union, has warned that handing Capita the job of paying a quarter of a million civil servants risks importing that same chaos from the pension scheme directly into their monthly pay packets. Civil servants should not have to worry about whether the company responsible for their salaries is capable of paying it. At the July hearing of the Public Accounts Committee, the hon. Member for Sheffield South East (Mr Betts) asked for a guarantee: no new contracts for Capita until the pension scheme is fixed. The permanent secretary said that could not be guaranteed, because they have to abide by procurement rules. A company can fail thousands of pensioners, but the Government cannot guarantee that they will stop handing that same company more contracts. That is at the heart of this issue. A supplier can be in breach of contract, have money withheld every month and miss three quarters of its targets—and still not meet the bar for exclusion. The Procurement Act 2023 was meant to change that, with a debarment list for suppliers that fail. As far as I can tell, not one company is on that list. I ask the Minister: what conversations are taking place across Government to update the procurement guidelines, so that failure on one public contract counts against a supplier when it bids for the next? The Government have agreed to an independent review of whether shared services delivery remains viable. What assurances can the Minister give that that review will be completed and published before the services transfer to Capita in August 2027? Civil servants cannot endure another round of such failures.
Emma Lewell (in the Chair)Labour
Ian Byrne will the last Back-Bench speaker before I call Steve Darling for the Liberal Democrats.
Ian Byrne (Liverpool West Derby) (Lab)Labour
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Ms Lewell. This debate can be summarised in one simple question: why the hell are we handing a £950 million 10-year contract to a company that is failing on the last major public contract it was given, delivering a similar service to civil servants? Because that is precisely what is happening. That contract is, of course, the civil service pension scheme. I secured a debate on that matter in Westminster Hall only two months ago, with more than 30 Liverpool West Derby constituents facing difficulties in accessing their pensions. MPs from all sides of the House brought forward similar stories. I and my constituents who are affected are extremely grateful to my hon. Friend the Member for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East (Andy McDonald) for bringing this matter back to the fore. The most concerning issue with the contract award is that it was confirmed by the Government in March, while Capita’s failure in presiding over the civil service pension scheme was already well under way, with our mailbags full of correspondence from people affected.
Ian LaveryLabour
Only this week, I texted my wonderful caseworker, asking for an update on how many emergency cases we had with the PCS pension scheme. Paul Robertson, a very skilled caseworker, got back to me and asked, “How dare you ask that? Every case—every single case we’ve got—is an emergency.” I have to be honest, I thought he was being really cheeky, but I sat back and thought, “He’s absolutely right.” If individuals cannot get their pension, it is an emergency. If they cannot draw their pension, it is an emergency. If they cannot get a projection on what they should get in a year, it is an emergency. They are all emergencies.
Ian ByrneLabour
I thank my hon. Friend for that excellent intervention. He is absolutely right. To give the same firm who created these emergencies the opportunity to administer HR and payroll for more than 250,000 civil servants, while it is has failed to resolve the issues it has caused in running the pension scheme, is simply unacceptable. We are rewarding abject failure. People outside of this place will be scratching their heads, going “How? How is this possible?” Let us look at the numbers. At the beginning of October, around 150,000 civil service pension cases remained outstanding. Capita receives some 20,000 new cases a week, but even if not one more arrived, the backlog would be nearly two months’ work. How is it asking for another contract? Of the complex cases, nearly 10,000 are more than six months old and 1,700 are more than a year old. Behind every one of the statistics is, as has been said, a retired public servant waiting for the pension that they rightfully earned. Some are facing real hardship; some of the stories I have heard from constituents in West Derby are absolutely heartbreaking. People have been forced to postpone retirement and are using foodbanks. These are honourable people who have worked really hard and now find themselves in this position through no fault of their own. The Government have rightly accepted that this is a failure. The Parliamentary Secretary, Cabinet Office, the hon. Member for Doncaster Central (Sally Jameson), told the House that Capita has “comprehensively failed” and called its progress “abysmal”. We all completely agree, so why are we continuing to give it contracts? We are told that Synergy is different—but Synergy is payroll. It is how people pay their rents and mortgages. If Capita cannot pay a pension on time, why should anybody trust it to pay a salary on time? Those workers must be absolutely terrified about what is coming down the track. Workers whose pay has already been eroded since 2010, during austerity, cannot afford a missed payment. Many will be living month by month.
Andy McDonaldLabour
Has it occurred to my hon. Friend that there could be a situation where somebody is still working and is going on to that payroll, and is yet to receive their projection on what their pension may be so is living in some trepidation about that? They may end up with a double whammy of not being paid on time and no pension to look forward to.
Ian ByrneLabour
I ask the Minister to address that issue. It is a vital point. This comes down to the fundamental issue of outsourcing that bedevils this place. That is responsible for the failure of Capita. We are told that outsourcing delivers efficiency and transfers risk, but after Capita’s failures, we have seen civil servants stepping up and clearing the backlog, employers providing hardship funds, and Government-appointed auditors and MPs becoming an escalation route. Put simply, outsourcing has proven to be a failed Thatcherite ideology followed by successive Governments, delivering the opposite of the promised aim of efficiency and putting the burden on ordinary people. The number of Government contracts that we have outsourced is terrifying. It feels as though we have been captured by these companies, and we are now in a position where, if one topples, we are absolutely terrified of the consequences. Whether it is Fujitsu in the case of the Post Office Horizon scandal, our failing water industry or the Capita civil service pension scheme, this House must accept that this political experiment has failed completely and Governments must now begin to reverse it. We look forward to seeing the Government’s proposals on insourcing, because I fully support the call for a wholesale programme of insourcing. That was a manifesto pledge that we stood on but, unfortunately, it is not moving quick enough. I finish with a couple of questions for the Minister. Will she pause the contract and review it? Will the Government publish contingency plans to guarantee that every civil servant is paid on time, if this contract goes the way of the pensions? Will she open genuine negotiations with the recognised trade unions, including PCS, that have done so much to protect the workers involved and, rightly, are hugely concerned about the workers being paid on time and in full?
Steve Darling (Torbay) (LD)Liberal Democrat
May I say what a pleasure it is to serve under your chairship, Ms Lewell? I congratulate the hon. Member for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East (Andy McDonald) on obtaining a really important debate. What has been debated here today—how this juggernaut is allowed to continue—is nothing short of a scandal. We have heard from a number of Members how the most important people in this situation are the civil servants who are being poorly served by Capita; and that should not be a surprise, because it does have form. For my sins, I am still a councillor, and I have served on Torbay council for more than 30 years. My experience of outsourcing was quite disastrous: our street scene works, our recycling and our parks and gardens were outsourced to a company called TOR2. It was not until we got them back in-house that we turned things around. The staff were so much happier, and genuine investment was possible, whereas up until then it had felt like we were what I fear the Government are at the moment to Capita—a hostage client. It is able to get away with blue murder in the way it is dealing with this, and that is absolutely shameful. In Torbay, I am desperately worried about the Conservative council repeating the same mistake and outsourcing the heritage asset, Cockington Court. I fear for the future of that asset, because we have seen things go wrong historically elsewhere in Torbay, whether we are talking about Oldway Mansion or the Pavilion. To come back to the case in hand, there have been some really good questions, and I am looking forward to hearing those answered by the Minister. I also have a key question for the Minister. When outsourcing, it is important to ensure there is a fat enough client to hold the outside bodies to account. Is the Government’s client body too thin, and therefore not able to hold Capita to account?
Mr Andrew Snowden (Fylde) (Con)Conservative
It is a pleasure to serve under you in the Chair, Ms Lewell. I congratulate the hon. Member for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East (Andy McDonald) on securing this debate, and Members who have contributed. Seeking efficiency in the civil service is the right thing to do, and the back office of Government is a logical place to start. Moving four Departments on to one HR and finance system, covering about 250,000 civil servants, is a sensible aim, but this debate is not about the aim; it is about how this contract has been handled and about one question that the Government have so far refused to answer: who is responsible? Frankly, this has been a mess. Let us take a look at the timeline. In August 2024, the then Chief Secretary to the Treasury approved the first full business case for Synergy. In December 2025, the Government let Capita take over the civil service pension scheme, despite repeated warnings that it was not ready. By February 2026, the backlog stood at about 120,000 cases. In the same month, with that crisis already in the headlines, the Department for Work and Pensions named the very same company as the preferred bidder for Synergy. What has happened since? By the summer, 100,000 people were still waiting for pension quotes. More than 7,000 of them were already past their retirement date. About 5,000 bereaved families were still waiting for money that they were owed. Last month, the Government had to rush a fix into the Budget, so that families whose death-in-service payments Capita had delayed would not be hit with a tax bill on top. Those are not abstract numbers. Some 69 of my own constituents have contacted me about this, making it one of the largest single casework issues that we are currently dealing with in the office; other Members have also acknowledged the scale of the casework coming into their inboxes. The individual stories that I have heard in Fylde and from Members who have contributed here today and in other debates demonstrate the urgent need to get solutions for the people we represent. To go back to the timeline, on 26 October, the Parliamentary Secretary, Cabinet Office, the hon. Member for Doncaster Central (Sally Jameson), came to the House and called Capita’s performance “abysmal”. She said that the company had been “flaky with the truth”. Her own remedial adviser found its recovery planning “wholly insufficient”. One Department tells us that it cannot trust Capita’s figures on pensions, while another hands the same company the pay of a quarter of a million serving civil servants—both cannot be right. When the right hon. Member for Hayes and Harlington (John McDonnell) asked about Synergy, the Cabinet Office said that that was not within its remit and pointed to the DWP. Ask the DWP, and we are told that the process was robust. The Treasury signed off the business case, the Cabinet Office owns the strategy, DWP ran the procurement and, on pensions, we are told that Capita alone is accountable for the recovery. Everybody had a hand in this, but nobody will take responsibility for it. That is not good enough. If payroll goes wrong, it is prison officers, Border Force staff and jobcentre workers who will not be paid on time. The warning signs are already there: the Public Accounts Committee reported in July that the first moves on to the new service had slipped by five months. The Committee has asked the Government to confirm whether Capita’s bid came in around 40% below the Department’s estimate of what the work should cost. I will not stray into matters before the courts, but that is a question that this House is entitled to have answered at the appropriate juncture. I have five questions for the Minister. First, which Minister took the decision to award this contract to Capita, and what did they know about the pension scheme when they took it? Secondly, what did the Cabinet Office tell DWP about Capita’s performance before the award, and will the Minister publish that? Thirdly, has the Department assessed what the remedial adviser’s findings on pensions mean for Synergy? If Capita’s planning was “wholly insufficient” there, why will it be any different here? Fourthly, what is the revised timetable for each Department? What have the delays cost so far, and will the Minister commit that no one’s pay will move until clear, published milestones have been met? Finally, if Capita fails, what is the contingency plan, and who pays for it? The Cabinet Office Minister said that she would return to the House if there was no rapid improvement within a month. That month is almost up. Thousands of retired civil servants are still waiting, and now a quarter of a million serving civil servants are being asked to trust the same company with their pay. They deserve better than a Government that pass the buck from one Department to the next. Somebody signed this off. Somebody must take responsibility.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Work and Pensions (Lilian Greenwood)Labour
It is always a pleasure to serve with you in the Chair, Ms Lewell. I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East (Andy McDonald) on securing this debate, and I thank him for doing so. I understand hon. Members’ concerns about Synergy’s contract with Capita in the light of the civil service pensions debacle. We know that payroll is a must-not-fail service; I am sure we all have civil servants and retired civil servants in our constituencies who have been impacted by the civil service pensions failure. I have listened carefully to the issues and cases raised by the hon. Member for Chesham and Amersham (Sarah Green) and my hon. Friend the Member for Liverpool West Derby (Ian Byrne). I understand their anger and frustration, and I will make sure that those comments are drawn to the attention of the Parliamentary Secretary, Cabinet Office, my hon. Friend the Member for Doncaster Central (Sally Jameson) who has responsibility for the civil service pension issues. It was almost as if the shadow Minister completely forgot that that contract was awarded in November 2023 under the previous Government, but there we go. I turn to Synergy. It is the largest of the five clusters or groups of Government Departments working together under the Government shared services strategy. As a number of hon. Members have said, it will provide shared human resources, finance and commercial services for the Department for Work and Pensions, the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, the Ministry of Justice and the Home Office. It will transform back-office functions for around 250,000 civil and public servants with a shared services model designed by and for Government. Colleagues have asked a number of questions about other clusters. Each cluster has taken decisions based on its specific context and circumstances. It is important to note that the four Departments within this cluster already use shared services that are outsourced and delivered by Shared Services Connected Ltd, a wholly owned subsidiary of Sopra Steria. For three of the Departments, the current service relies on pre-2013 technology, which reaches the end of extended support in 2031. Synergy will replace that with modern technology and services. The delivery model gives the civil service greater control; I will explain how. We have a shared services hub, accountable for services, contracts and continuous improvement. There are common HR, finance and commercial processes, reducing complexity and duplication compared with all four Departments operating independently. Oracle software-as-a-service is managed by the hub and enables self-service and automation, with a separate business process services partner for high-volume transactions and day-to-day HR, payroll and invoice processing, and finance administration. It is important that there is that separation. The technology and systems integrator contract was awarded on 30 August 2024 to IBM, Deloitte and Oracle; they are known as the consortium. The business process services contract with Capita was signed on 2 March this year. Capita’s appointment followed a two-year procurement supported by commercial, legal and programme delivery experts. Functional experts from all four Departments evaluated the final bids. The procurement met regulatory requirements, with advice from His Majesty’s Treasury and the Cabinet Office, and passed their required controls. Because this is a critical service, the programme did not simply choose the cheapest option. Evaluation was weighted 70% on quality and 30% on cost. The programme did consider insourcing the whole service or parts of it. However, its business case and approvals concluded that continuing to outsource business process services was the most efficient and cost-effective option for Departments, Government and taxpayers.
Andy McDonaldLabour
I am grateful to the Minister for giving way. Given what she said about the insourcing proposal being considered, could she explain how that squares with the commitment to encourage greater insourcing? If that has failed on this occasion, what work has been done to further support the ability to progress those insource bids?
Lilian GreenwoodLabour
I understand why hon. Members are asking questions about this programme. It is important to say that it began in 2023, under the previous Government. I can assure the hon. Gentleman that this decision was reviewed at appropriate points, including by my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State, but in each case, the alternative threw up significant legal, commercial and delivery risk, along with inevitable delay costing millions of pounds in taxpayers’ money. We have, however, chosen to bring the technology, oversight and co-ordination of the end-to-end service in-house, and those will be managed by the Synergy shared services hub. My hon. Friend the Member for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East will appreciate that because he asked, given Capita’s failure on pensions and the Government’s commitment to look at insourcing, why we are not reversing the decision to award this contract to Capita and bring it in-house. Preparation for the Synergy transition is now well underway, and changing course midway would cause significant service disruption, laying a second major transition on top of the existing one, adding high-level risk and significant cost. Given that Capita is, to date, performing against its contractual obligations in respect of this programme, there is no basis on which to terminate the contract, other than voluntarily, which would likely involve paying Capita millions of pounds without requiring it to deliver. I turn to our approach to assurance and oversight. Accredited contract management professionals, supported by senior commercial and legal advisers, will hold suppliers to account. Contractual levers include the ability to step in and temporarily take over delivery from Capita in the event of serious failings, payment deductions for service failures or delays, and limits on costs and Capita’s profit margin. The current Secretary of State sought and received written assurances from the Capita leadership, including the commitment to a charter on ways of working, which is now in place. Synergy’s strategic partnership forum meets monthly, bringing together senior leaders from the technology and business process services partners and the current supplier to support a smooth transition. The programme senior responsible officer meets fortnightly with chief executive officers and senior delivery partner leaders for early escalation and oversight. I understand the concerns raised by hon. Members on behalf of civil servants, and I too have asked those questions. That is why engagement with the recognised trade unions is so important. The Synergy trade union forum has been established, and it met for the first time on 25 September. It plans to meet every two months to share information, listen to concerns and answer questions that representatives rightly ask on behalf of their members. Finally, I want to explain how and why Synergy is different from the civil service pension transition, as it is important to answer people’s legitimate concerns. Before each Department moves to the new service, payroll assurance will include detailed technical testing, numerical payroll testing, business assurance and operational payroll testing. There are important differences between the civil service pensions programme that was established under the previous Government and this one. First, Synergy has not outsourced the full service as a package. It has separated the build, testing and delivery of the technology platform from the transactional processing provider. It is using a separate globally-proven technology provider, Oracle. Secondly, Synergy has acted to avoid the backlogs and data issues seen with pensions, to which a number of Members referred. The Departments work closely with the current supplier to identify and address those in real time. The programme controls data migration, and two successful migration trials have already been completed. Thirdly, the transition to new services is contractually supported by the existing supplier, with equal emphasis on it to ensure stability at transition. Most importantly, there is no contractual cliff edge. The current SSCL contracts continue until October 2028, which means that Synergy will not go live until all the appropriate testing of payroll and other critical processes is fully assured. We have learned lessons from what happened with civil service pensions. I understand the importance of civil servants getting their pay when they need it. We will not allow this system to go live until we are confident that it can do so. My hon. Friend the Member for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East asked me a number of questions, and I will try to respond to them. First, the contract was published on 6 March, according to procurement rules. Secondly, the DWP has responded to the PAC recommendations, and we are working with the Cabinet Office on them. The cross-Department engagement with trade unions has started—it is already happening. We cannot pause the contract without substantial losses, but we will continue to look at the issues that people have raised about assurance and contingency, and we will ensure that there are not the problems that we have seen in relation to pensions. Finally, I assure my hon. Friend that there are strong commercial and contract management arrangements in place to hold Capita to account. The Synergy programme will use established strong commercial controls, contract management arrangements and governance structures to continue to hold suppliers to account throughout mobilisation, transition and live service delivery. Its focus remains on delivering a better service for civil servants and the best overall value for taxpayers. I welcome the opportunity to answer questions today and give that assurance to hon. Members present.
Andy McDonaldLabour
I thank the Minister for her thorough and comprehensive response to the issues that were raised. I am grateful that she has made it abundantly clear that payroll is a must-not-fail function: that is exactly what we are saying on these Benches. That must obtain at all times. She alludes to assurances made by Capita. There is a lingering concern that they may not be wholly reliable, given what has gone on before. Past performance is no guarantee of future results, but it gives us a damn good idea. I suspect that all the things she alluded to in terms of the preparation for the contract may have been said when the pensions contract was first developed with Capita all those years ago. However, I am grateful to her for all that she has said. I hope that we can get further clarification from the Government as we go forward on how we will embrace the principle of insourcing as a default, because the annals of history are littered with cases such as Capita, Carillion and so on. In finishing, I would like to acknowledge the transformation in the position of the Opposition, who appear to understand that outsourcing has not worked in the way they had hoped. It seems that their love affair with Capita is at an end. Question put and agreed to. Resolved, That this House has considered the role of the Department for Work and Pensions in the procurement of the Synergy contract.
Sitting adjourned.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5439292.