Lilian Greenwood

Lilian Greenwood

Labour — Nottingham South

Speaking in the House of Commons on 17 November 2026

Debate

Department for Work and Pensions: Synergy Contract

Contribution

I understand why hon. Members are asking questions about this programme. It is important to say that it began in 2023, under the previous Government. I can assure the hon. Gentleman that this decision was reviewed at appropriate points, including by my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State, but in each case, the alternative threw up significant legal, commercial and delivery risk, along with inevitable delay costing millions of pounds in taxpayers’ money. We have, however, chosen to bring the technology, oversight and co-ordination of the end-to-end service in-house, and those will be managed by the Synergy shared services hub. My hon. Friend the Member for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East will appreciate that because he asked, given Capita’s failure on pensions and the Government’s commitment to look at insourcing, why we are not reversing the decision to award this contract to Capita and bring it in-house. Preparation for the Synergy transition is now well underway, and changing course midway would cause significant service disruption, laying a second major transition on top of the existing one, adding high-level risk and significant cost. Given that Capita is, to date, performing against its contractual obligations in respect of this programme, there is no basis on which to terminate the contract, other than voluntarily, which would likely involve paying Capita millions of pounds without requiring it to deliver. I turn to our approach to assurance and oversight. Accredited contract management professionals, supported by senior commercial and legal advisers, will hold suppliers to account. Contractual levers include the ability to step in and temporarily take over delivery from Capita in the event of serious failings, payment deductions for service failures or delays, and limits on costs and Capita’s profit margin. The current Secretary of State sought and received written assurances from the Capita leadership, including the commitment to a charter on ways of working, which is now in place. Synergy’s strategic partnership forum meets monthly, bringing together senior leaders from the technology and business process services partners and the current supplier to support a smooth transition. The programme senior responsible officer meets fortnightly with chief executive officers and senior delivery partner leaders for early escalation and oversight. I understand the concerns raised by hon. Members on behalf of civil servants, and I too have asked those questions. That is why engagement with the recognised trade unions is so important. The Synergy trade union forum has been established, and it met for the first time on 25 September. It plans to meet every two months to share information, listen to concerns and answer questions that representatives rightly ask on behalf of their members. Finally, I want to explain how and why Synergy is different from the civil service pension transition, as it is important to answer people’s legitimate concerns. Before each Department moves to the new service, payroll assurance will include detailed technical testing, numerical payroll testing, business assurance and operational payroll testing. There are important differences between the civil service pensions programme that was established under the previous Government and this one. First, Synergy has not outsourced the full service as a package. It has separated the build, testing and delivery of the technology platform from the transactional processing provider. It is using a separate globally-proven technology provider, Oracle. Secondly, Synergy has acted to avoid the backlogs and data issues seen with pensions, to which a number of Members referred. The Departments work closely with the current supplier to identify and address those in real time. The programme controls data migration, and two successful migration trials have already been completed. Thirdly, the transition to new services is contractually supported by the existing supplier, with equal emphasis on it to ensure stability at transition. Most importantly, there is no contractual cliff edge. The current SSCL contracts continue until October 2028, which means that Synergy will not go live until all the appropriate testing of payroll and other critical processes is fully assured. We have learned lessons from what happened with civil service pensions. I understand the importance of civil servants getting their pay when they need it. We will not allow this system to go live until we are confident that it can do so. My hon. Friend the Member for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East asked me a number of questions, and I will try to respond to them. First, the contract was published on 6 March, according to procurement rules. Secondly, the DWP has responded to the PAC recommendations, and we are working with the Cabinet Office on them. The cross-Department engagement with trade unions has started—it is already happening. We cannot pause the contract without substantial losses, but we will continue to look at the issues that people have raised about assurance and contingency, and we will ensure that there are not the problems that we have seen in relation to pensions. Finally, I assure my hon. Friend that there are strong commercial and contract management arrangements in place to hold Capita to account. The Synergy programme will use established strong commercial controls, contract management arrangements and governance structures to continue to hold suppliers to account throughout mobilisation, transition and live service delivery. Its focus remains on delivering a better service for civil servants and the best overall value for taxpayers. I welcome the opportunity to answer questions today and give that assurance to hon. Members present.

More from Lilian Greenwood

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Lilian Greenwood's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Lilian Greenwood report card.