Hansard·Westminster Hall·Vol. 793

Wales: Prisons and Sentencing

Tuesday, 17 November 2026

15 contributions4 members

Contributions

  1. [Relevant document: Second Report of the Welsh Affairs Committee, Jagged Justice: Prisons, Probation and Rehabilitation in Wales, HC 137]

    View contribution permalink →

  2. Dr Rosena Allin-Khan (in the Chair)Labour

    I remind hon. Members that they may make a speech only with the prior permission of the Member in charge of the debate and the Minister. There will not be an opportunity for the Member in charge to wind up, as is the convention for 30-minute debates. I call Liz Saville Roberts to move the motion.

    View contribution permalink →

  3. Liz Saville Roberts (Dwyfor Meirionnydd) (PC)Plaid Cymru

    I beg to move, That this House has considered prisons and sentencing in Wales. Diolch yn fawr iawn. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Allin-Khan. It is that time of year again when Cardiff University’s Wales Governance Centre publishes its annual fact file on prisons and sentencing in Wales. As Plaid Cymru’s justice spokesperson at Westminster for over a decade now, I recognise the massive gap in knowledge and understanding of the reality of criminal justice in Wales. I firmly believe that we all owe a debt of gratitude to Dr Rob Jones for the work he has done since 2018 both to reveal the scale of our ignorance and to endeavour to remedy it. The justice system and crime affect all of us, some directly and some indirectly. That is why understanding the failings and successes of rehabilitation in Wales is so crucial. Let us start at the sentencing level in Wales. We all know that court cases are stacking up. While English Crown Court waiting times have been longer than in Wales since 2016, none the less the number of outstanding cases rose by 9% last year, and 16% in magistrates courts. While the Government tinker around the edges of court reform, taking away long-held rights to jury trial, they have failed to tackle the real issues, like the late delivery of prisoners to court, affecting all six court circuits in England and Wales, according to the Bar Council, with nearly a quarter of those delays lasting over five hours. Barristers on the Wales and Chester circuits tell of murder trials where prisoners arrived on time only once or twice out of 60 days of trial. Why do the Government tolerate that normalisation of delay? Surely work should be done to address that area. Black defendants are more likely to be remanded in custody than white defendants, with an over nine months longer average custodial length. That is an issue entrenched in the justice system across Wales. Recent south Wales police figures show that 24% of people selected for facial recognition checks last year were ethnic minorities, despite making up only 7% of the area’s population. The unavoidable fact is that people from black ethnic groups are the most represented ethnic group in prison, with 58 black people from Wales in prison for every 10,000 people in the population, compared with only 15 white people. That cries out for action, especially as the Home Secretary has blocked the Sentencing Council from at least recognising that that is a justice problem. I am sad to say that Wales has a women problem, too. The number of immediate custodial sentences handed to women in Welsh courts increased by 27% last year, with one in four given sentences of up to one month or less. Shockingly in my patch of north Wales, 63% of women sentenced to immediate custody at magistrates courts received a sentence of a month or less, much higher than in the rest of Wales. Those women, nearly two in five of whom had committed petty offences of theft from shops, were sent far away from home, across the 12 women’s prisons in England, predominantly to His Majesty’s Prison Eastwood Park in Gloucestershire or HMP Styal in Cheshire. That is despite the plethora of evidence against the use of that type of sentence. We have received such evidence for years. Next year marks 20 years since the publication of the Corston report into the experience of women in prison. While successive Governments have accepted its recommendations, sadly the data tells us eloquently that so far nothing has changed. Meanwhile, this Labour Government have essentially abandoned plans for a residential women’s centre in Swansea, which was supposed to have been the start of a residential solution for Wales. Now we have been informed that it is not moving ahead, because the funding for it is not there. I ask whether the Minister is in a position to reconsider that decision, because it is clear that a trauma-informed alternative to custody for women in Wales is urgently needed. Even without a women’s prison, Wales has recorded a higher “in-country” imprisonment rate than England in every year since 2019. Last year, there were 155 Welsh people per 100,000 of the population in prison, compared with 138 in England. When faced with those figures, the Government cannot say that the status quo works for Wales, and while the rate of imprisonment in Wales has been rising, we have lost 100,000 years of cumulative prison officer experience since 2010. In fact, the report by the Welsh Affairs Committee into justice in Wales found that population pressures, coupled with chronic staffing challenges, have “undermined staff and prisoner safety and the effectiveness of rehabilitation work.” Those pressures do not come from nowhere; the impact of years of Tory underfunding is evident. But the Labour Government cannot continue to pass the buck indefinitely; responsibility now lies with them. The UK Government continue to underfund services in the public estate delivered by the Welsh Government, with no changes to the funding for prison health since 2014, which again was highlighted in the report by the Welsh Affairs Committee. That fact needs to be reiterated if we are to improve prisoner health in the public estate in Wales—prison health funding has remained the same for 12 years. That is extraordinary. Given that many of the 1,777 English prisoners held in Wales would likely receive that devolved support, it is even more egregious that the UK Government are cutting these corners. Forgetting the Welsh context comes easily in Westminster, including the fact that some prisoners actually speak Welsh. We know from Dr Rob Jones and Dr Gregory Davies that Welsh-speaking prisoners in HMP Berwyn have faced significant barriers, to the point that the Welsh Language Commissioner undertook a statutory inquiry into His Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service’s Welsh language scheme. I reiterate the commissioner’s call, and that of the Thomas commission years ago, that all justice bodies should be subject to the Welsh language measures of 2011. This is not a corner that should be cut in Wales. Sadly, we have come to realise that cutting corners is a common theme in prisons. Over a decade since privatisation, there are billions of pounds worth of maintenance backlogs, and the chief inspector of prisons has warned of “deteriorating infrastructure and long delays to essential maintenance in prisons.” The legacy of outsourcing is squalor, but where is Labour’s action to insource those contracts, and tackle the crumbling and vermin-infested prison estate? Sometimes when we talk about prisons, it feels like we are engaging in hyperbole, but it is all true. When I say “vermin-infested”, I mean “vermin-infested.” Surely in the 21st century, that can be remedied. I declare an interest because I am the chair of the all-party parliamentary group on justice unions, and six justice unions—the Prison Officers Association, Napo, the Public and Commercial Services Union, the University and College Union, the Royal College of Nursing and the Police Federation—have called for a royal commission into prisons and the wider criminal justice system, to work out what has gone wrong, whose fault it was and is, and how to fix it. Having such a royal commission was a promise made by the last Government, but it was never delivered. When we face a problem as serious as the prisons crisis, surely we need a serious commitment to seek a solution, such as would be implicit in a royal commission?

    View contribution permalink →

  4. Jim Shannon (Strangford) (DUP)Democratic Unionist Party

    I commend the right hon. Lady for bringing this matter forward; every time she secures a debate on it, I always come along to support her. I am here again today to support her in her quest. It has been highlighted that probation staff in Wales are stretched to the limit and that without urgent investment the service will be overwhelmed. By the way, in Northern Ireland we have similar concerns about the retention of social work staff and the loss of experienced staff, which of course can affect the capacity of probation officers to manage their increasingly complex caseload. Does the right hon. Lady agree that the Minister needs to take steps to strengthen the capacity of probation boards across the UK and improve staff retention? The public should be assured that offenders are supervised effectively while also receiving the support they need to rehabilitate successfully.

    View contribution permalink →

  5. Liz Saville RobertsPlaid Cymru

    The significance of probation is evident in rehabilitation. I will touch on the details in relation to Wales, but this is a common issue across the nations of the United Kingdom. Of course, Northern Ireland and Scotland have their own justice systems. Wales is part of England’s, but it is unique because many of the services that are integral to rehabilitation are devolved. That is why it is important that we tease out how things are different and how best practice can operate. When people continue their sentences after leaving prison, the rehabilitative element of criminal justice plays out. I am sad to say that the data for Wales does not make for light reading. Last year, for the fourth consecutive year, the number of people rough sleeping on release increased, this time by 24%. Two in five prisoners from HMP Cardiff alone were released without a fixed address in the year up to March. That worsening trend cannot just be brushed off. Housing is one of the critical first steps, if not the critical step, for rehabilitation, and homelessness is a risk factor for death after release, according to Nacro. Dying in a drug-related incident immediately post release is noted as a particular risk, so it is even more concerning that drug poisoning accounted for 37% of all deaths among prison leavers supervised in the community in Wales in 2024-25, compared with 21% across England and Wales as a whole. Wales faces distinct challenges, as health and housing policy are devolved. This is another example of where the jagged edge does damage, as the Welsh Government have to contend with whatever criminal justice policy decisions Westminster sends downstream, but they have no control over them. One of the challenges sent downstream is the Sentencing Act 2026. Placing significant added pressure on an already strained probation service without adequate investment is a recipe for disaster, especially without a workload management tool to quantify the extra workload for probation officers. Sadly, I am sure the Government could not have been shocked when Napo-affiliated probation staff successfully balloted for industrial action last week. Even working to contract will have far-reaching consequences across the whole arc of justice services. I do not want to ask the question, but how prepared is the Minister for the circumstances? As I say, it will play out across the whole of the justice system. The Justice Secretary said that “we have to build a new criminal justice system.” —[ Official Report , 1 September 2026; Vol. 790, c. 86.] But to do that we need to pull the right levers and be in possession of the right tools. We need a royal commission to look at the entirety of the criminal justice system, including our prisons. We need full effective funding across the system, its sites and its workforces. As Dr Rob Jones, the author of the Cardiff University report, sets out, the Wales-specific data should make the UK Government assess whether the devolution settlement is adequate, whether it is fit for purpose, and whether the Welsh Government have the powers and policy levers they need to address the underlying causes of these problems. Before the Minister says this—I suspect it may be in her response—memorandums of understanding are political fig leaves. They cannot conceal the fact that only fully powered devolution, with clarity of funding and clarity of responsibility, can smooth over the jagged edge. We need a better devolution deal for Wales. In a meeting with Welsh Ministers, the Justice Secretary suggested that the “potential is high” on the devolution of justice. Will the Minister assure me that Wales can expect that to be realised in the Prime Minister’s upcoming 10-year devolution plan? We await news from the independent review of prisons and Lord Hogan-Howe’s review of police force structures, but that is just the first step in the criminal justice journey. This is an opportunity to respond decisively to the data in front of us. As somebody else said, approximately, when the facts demand change, we change our minds. When are we going to change our minds over justice in Wales?

    View contribution permalink →

  6. The Minister for Prisons, Probation and Reducing Reoffending (Catherine McKinnell)Labour

    Diolch, Dr Allin-Khan, and prynhawn da. I thank the right hon. Member for Dwyfor Meirionnydd (Liz Saville Roberts) for the opportunity to discuss the work of His Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service in Wales. Please excuse my Welsh pronunciation; I appreciate that it is far from perfect. The House will know that the Government inherited a justice system in crisis, but we are meeting the challenge with a wide-ranging programme of transformational reforms. The Government have now responded to the findings of Sir Brian Leveson’s independent review of the criminal courts, and the implementation of his recommendations began earlier this year. We know that it is only by pulling every lever that we have—investment, efficiency, reform—that we can relieve the upstream pressure in the criminal justice system, which the right hon. Lady rightly identified, and begin to deliver faster and fairer justice. Since taking office, the Government have passed and begun implementing the Sentencing Act 2026, to keep dangerous criminals locked up, stop the cycle of less serious offenders going in and out of custody and stabilise the crisis further downstream in our prisons. The implementation of the Act has been backed up by £700 million of additional investment in the probation service over the next few years. In addition to those reforms, we are delivering the biggest prison expansion since the Victorian era. We are working to add 14,000 prison places by 2031, and we announced on 1 September that we are bringing forward £110 million from existing budgets to deliver those places within the current estate. We are also looking to acquire additional land to build future prisons. In Wales, we anticipate early works for the 345-place uplift at HMP Parc to begin early in the new year. The Government have launched the independent review of the prison system, led by the right honourable Amber Rudd, whose recommendations are due shortly. The review is set to identify the reforms we need to build a prison system fit for the future, including in respect of security, safety, decency, capacity and staffing—all issues that the right hon. Member for Dwyfor Meirionnydd has rightly drawn attention to today—and visits to HMP Cardiff and HMP Parc were undertaken as part of its findings. We have and are taking thoughtful action to address the challenges, and we are making progress, but the Government recognise that there is much more to do. Delivering meaningful improvements for the people of Wales will take time as reforms are implemented across the justice system. The Department has reviewed the recent report published by the Wales Governance Centre, because we are committed to supporting academic research and constructive scrutiny wherever possible. The report makes a valuable contribution to the wider body of evidence, although we are keen to ensure that its findings are considered in the round, in terms of perspectives, rather than being taken in isolation.

    View contribution permalink →

  7. Liz Saville RobertsPlaid Cymru

    My office has had to help Rob Jones to gain access to information in the past. The report is critical because it shows the trends year on year, but he has, on occasion, had to make freedom of information requests, and I have had to table written parliamentary questions. Will the Minister commit to working with my office and with Cardiff University to ensure that we have all the detail we need to get the full picture?

    View contribution permalink →

  8. Catherine McKinnellLabour

    I recognise the challenge. For example, the Department is receiving an increasing number of freedom of information requests, which take time to work through. I assure the right hon. Lady that our annual Welsh justice data release, the observations in the Wales Governance Centre’s reports, and findings from other Welsh institutions will continue to form and inform the decisions that we are determined to make and deliver on in Wales. Of course, I will take on board any issues the right hon. Lady raises, and she can certainly contact me if there are challenges in that regard. The report’s data identifies genuine challenges, which the right hon. Lady set out, but it also shows areas of progress: self-harm incidents fell by 10% across Welsh prisons last year, while a growing proportion of offenders from Wales are serving sentences in Wales. We are acting on the challenges in the justice system, but many of the highlighted outcomes sit at the intersection of justice and devolved responsibilities in Wales. Our response must include not only justice reform but a bolder partnership with the Welsh Government, to ensure that progress can be made where matters are devolved. I am happy to take another intervention if the right hon. Lady so wishes. I am about to turn to other issues in the report.

    View contribution permalink →

  9. Liz Saville RobertsPlaid Cymru

    I welcome the Minister’s preparedness to take another intervention, and her comments about working boldly with the Welsh Government; will she explain that a little more, please?

    View contribution permalink →

  10. Catherine McKinnellLabour

    I will come to that later in my speech, if the right hon. Lady will forgive me. I was going to reflect on the meeting she drew attention to, the opportunities to work together and the particular areas where we have. If I do not respond to her question later in my speech, she can by all means intervene. The right hon. Lady is absolutely right to draw attention to women in our justice system. To ensure that we reduce the number of women in prison, where it is safe and appropriate to do so, and that women get the experience in the prison system that they should, the Government are investing nearly £32 million in women’s community and voluntary organisations over the spending review period, to divert women from the justice system. We are investing £1.9 million in Wales as part of the women’s diversion fund. From January, organisations will be able to start delivering services that will divert women away from the criminal justice system and help to reduce the numbers in prison.

    View contribution permalink →

  11. Liz Saville RobertsPlaid Cymru

    Will the Minister say more about the women’s residential centre in Swansea? Sending women so far away to prison is doing so much damage to them and their families.

    View contribution permalink →

  12. Catherine McKinnellLabour

    The right hon. Lady is understandably impatient for justice and a better system for women in Wales, but I am coming to that very point. Swansea magistrates court is due to become the first intensive supervision court in Wales next year. I have seen at first hand how those courts work and their success in providing a robust, community-based alternative to short custodial sentences, combining judicial oversight with tailored support by multiple agencies to address the root causes of offending, which will ultimately reduce the number of women who need to go into custody and support better outcomes for them. We will continue to consider the options for the future of the residential women’s centre. I appreciate that it has had a challenging history under the previous Government and during the past spending review period, but we are keen to continue to engage with Welsh partners, including the Welsh Government, as part of that process and will continue to do so. The right hon. Lady mentioned the challenge around drugs and the conditions in prisons. We know that drugs are a challenge in our communities and in our prison system. We recognise that drug use in prisons is too high and share the concerns about the risks, because it fundamentally undermines our ability to reduce reoffending. We are focused on creating a safer, recovery-focused system that tackles the drugs getting into prison, improves support for prisoners with treatment, keeps people safe and equips staff with the skills and tools they need to achieve that. HMP Parc has been a particular concern in the Welsh estate, and significant work has been undertaken to address that. The latest quarterly review, from April to June 2026, indicates a significant year-on-year reduction in violence and self-harm, and in the January 2026 report the chief inspector recognised the considerable efforts made to tackle drug ingress and found that drug use had declined. That can be attributed to new security windows, stabilising staffing levels, a consistent regime and the roll-out of a peer mentoring model. Lessons from the improvements at HMP Parc will be applied right across the Welsh estate. Earlier this month, the Deputy First Minister of Wales and the Welsh Cabinet Minister for Government Effectiveness and the Constitution visited HMP Parc and the Parc young offenders institution. During their visit, they recognised the progress that had been made on safety and wellbeing. The right hon. Lady rightly mentioned the challenge around homelessness and ensuring that people have accommodation to go to when they leave prison. We recognise that this is a devolved responsibility, but HMPPS in Wales is providing local authorities with weekly data to identify individuals who are due to be released from custody, up to six months in advance. That is helping to improve outcomes. Where temporary accommodation is needed, HMPPS is providing a range of options based on the circumstances, risks and needs, so that we ensure greater movement into longer-term settled accommodation, and short-term accommodation where it is needed. We welcome the Welsh Government’s wider commitment to a housing-first approach and will continue to work together to ensure that prison leavers can benefit from that ambition, turn their lives around and build a more productive future. The right hon. Lady mentioned healthcare, the responsibility for which sits with Wales and the Welsh Government. But achieving the best outcomes requires co-operation across our respective responsibilities, which is why we are working with the Welsh Government and local health boards to improve healthcare across prison and probation services in Wales. In September, officials from the Welsh Government and HMPPS in Wales held a positive meeting about enhancing co-operation on health. Further steps are outstanding, and we will continue to work with partners. We need timely health interventions and evidence-based treatment for drug addictions, and we need to address the factors that contribute to reoffending, so that people can build safer lives and an alternative future.

    View contribution permalink →

  13. Liz Saville RobertsPlaid Cymru

    I am grateful that the Minister mentioned the devolved areas, in particular housing and health, but I must push her on the question of the devolution of justice which, as I mentioned, has been raised by the Secretary of State for Justice. When does the Minister think justice will be devolved to Wales, the only legislature in the United Kingdom—and possibly the world—without a jurisdiction?

    View contribution permalink →

  14. Catherine McKinnellLabour

    The right hon. Lady raises a point that I am clearly not able to give an answer on today. Conversations are ongoing between her Government and the UK Government here. It is important to recognise—I am sure she will be keen to do so—the areas on which progress can be made today. Let us not wait until tomorrow and what might come then. We are always working to improve things, and we do so together, but there are things that we can work on and collaborate on today to improve outcomes for people in Wales. That is what the Government and I are determined to do. The right hon. Lady raised imprisonment rates. In the Government’s recent response to the Welsh Affairs Committee report, we committed to engage with criminal justice system partners, the third sector and the Welsh Government to investigate further. I am pleased to inform the House that in December the Criminal Justice Board for Wales will be holding a dedicated discussion on the underlying factors that influence imprisonment rates. It will focus on practical ways to strengthen co-operation across justice and devolved services such as health, housing, education and social services, to address some of the inequalities that can contribute to driving offending or recall rates across Wales. Addressing inequality is a shared commitment that requires a partnership approach. It underpins the work of the criminal justice anti-racism taskforce for Wales and the All-Wales Women and Justice Board, where officials from both Governments work alongside criminal justice agencies and the third sector to identify disparities and drive improvement. In conclusion, I hope the right hon. Lady is reassured. The Lord Chancellor was in Wales last week to meet the Deputy First Minister of Wales and the Cabinet Minister for Government Effectiveness and the Constitution. They discussed how the UK Government and the Welsh Government can build a better, stronger and bolder partnership to make meaningful progress on shared ambitions to address inequality, support victims, prevent crime and break the cycle of reoffending across Wales. The Deputy First Minister’s social justice and equality portfolio provides a particular opportunity to renew and deepen co-operation across justice and devolved responsibilities, and deliver better outcomes for the people of Wales. I know the right hon. Lady is committed to that. We will continue to work with her, and with colleagues in this place and in Wales, to achieve our collective aims. Question put and agreed to.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5439291.