Liz Saville Roberts

Liz Saville Roberts

Plaid Cymru — Dwyfor Meirionnydd

Speaking in the House of Commons on 17 November 2026

Debate

Wales: Prisons and Sentencing

Contribution

The significance of probation is evident in rehabilitation. I will touch on the details in relation to Wales, but this is a common issue across the nations of the United Kingdom. Of course, Northern Ireland and Scotland have their own justice systems. Wales is part of England’s, but it is unique because many of the services that are integral to rehabilitation are devolved. That is why it is important that we tease out how things are different and how best practice can operate. When people continue their sentences after leaving prison, the rehabilitative element of criminal justice plays out. I am sad to say that the data for Wales does not make for light reading. Last year, for the fourth consecutive year, the number of people rough sleeping on release increased, this time by 24%. Two in five prisoners from HMP Cardiff alone were released without a fixed address in the year up to March. That worsening trend cannot just be brushed off. Housing is one of the critical first steps, if not the critical step, for rehabilitation, and homelessness is a risk factor for death after release, according to Nacro. Dying in a drug-related incident immediately post release is noted as a particular risk, so it is even more concerning that drug poisoning accounted for 37% of all deaths among prison leavers supervised in the community in Wales in 2024-25, compared with 21% across England and Wales as a whole. Wales faces distinct challenges, as health and housing policy are devolved. This is another example of where the jagged edge does damage, as the Welsh Government have to contend with whatever criminal justice policy decisions Westminster sends downstream, but they have no control over them. One of the challenges sent downstream is the Sentencing Act 2026. Placing significant added pressure on an already strained probation service without adequate investment is a recipe for disaster, especially without a workload management tool to quantify the extra workload for probation officers. Sadly, I am sure the Government could not have been shocked when Napo-affiliated probation staff successfully balloted for industrial action last week. Even working to contract will have far-reaching consequences across the whole arc of justice services. I do not want to ask the question, but how prepared is the Minister for the circumstances? As I say, it will play out across the whole of the justice system. The Justice Secretary said that “we have to build a new criminal justice system.” —[Official Report, 1 September 2026; Vol. 790, c. 86.] But to do that we need to pull the right levers and be in possession of the right tools. We need a royal commission to look at the entirety of the criminal justice system, including our prisons. We need full effective funding across the system, its sites and its workforces. As Dr Rob Jones, the author of the Cardiff University report, sets out, the Wales-specific data should make the UK Government assess whether the devolution settlement is adequate, whether it is fit for purpose, and whether the Welsh Government have the powers and policy levers they need to address the underlying causes of these problems. Before the Minister says this—I suspect it may be in her response—memorandums of understanding are political fig leaves. They cannot conceal the fact that only fully powered devolution, with clarity of funding and clarity of responsibility, can smooth over the jagged edge. We need a better devolution deal for Wales. In a meeting with Welsh Ministers, the Justice Secretary suggested that the “potential is high” on the devolution of justice. Will the Minister assure me that Wales can expect that to be realised in the Prime Minister’s upcoming 10-year devolution plan? We await news from the independent review of prisons and Lord Hogan-Howe’s review of police force structures, but that is just the first step in the criminal justice journey. This is an opportunity to respond decisively to the data in front of us. As somebody else said, approximately, when the facts demand change, we change our minds. When are we going to change our minds over justice in Wales?

More from Liz Saville Roberts

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Liz Saville Roberts's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Liz Saville Roberts report card.