Contribution
I beg to move,
That this House has considered prisons and sentencing in Wales.
Diolch yn fawr iawn. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Allin-Khan.
It is that time of year again when Cardiff University’s Wales Governance Centre publishes its annual fact file on prisons and sentencing in Wales. As Plaid Cymru’s justice spokesperson at Westminster for over a decade now, I recognise the massive gap in knowledge and understanding of the reality of criminal justice in Wales. I firmly believe that we all owe a debt of gratitude to Dr Rob Jones for the work he has done since 2018 both to reveal the scale of our ignorance and to endeavour to remedy it.
The justice system and crime affect all of us, some directly and some indirectly. That is why understanding the failings and successes of rehabilitation in Wales is so crucial. Let us start at the sentencing level in Wales. We all know that court cases are stacking up. While English Crown Court waiting times have been longer than in Wales since 2016, none the less the number of outstanding cases rose by 9% last year, and 16% in magistrates courts.
While the Government tinker around the edges of court reform, taking away long-held rights to jury trial, they have failed to tackle the real issues, like the late delivery of prisoners to court, affecting all six court circuits in England and Wales, according to the Bar Council, with nearly a quarter of those delays lasting over five hours. Barristers on the Wales and Chester circuits tell of murder trials where prisoners arrived on time only once or twice out of 60 days of trial. Why do the Government tolerate that normalisation of delay? Surely work should be done to address that area.
Black defendants are more likely to be remanded in custody than white defendants, with an over nine months longer average custodial length. That is an issue entrenched in the justice system across Wales. Recent south Wales police figures show that 24% of people selected for facial recognition checks last year were ethnic minorities, despite making up only 7% of the area’s population.
The unavoidable fact is that people from black ethnic groups are the most represented ethnic group in prison, with 58 black people from Wales in prison for every 10,000 people in the population, compared with only 15 white people. That cries out for action, especially as the Home Secretary has blocked the Sentencing Council from at least recognising that that is a justice problem.
I am sad to say that Wales has a women problem, too. The number of immediate custodial sentences handed to women in Welsh courts increased by 27% last year, with one in four given sentences of up to one month or less. Shockingly in my patch of north Wales, 63% of women sentenced to immediate custody at magistrates courts received a sentence of a month or less, much higher than in the rest of Wales.
Those women, nearly two in five of whom had committed petty offences of theft from shops, were sent far away from home, across the 12 women’s prisons in England, predominantly to His Majesty’s Prison Eastwood Park in Gloucestershire or HMP Styal in Cheshire. That is despite the plethora of evidence against the use of that type of sentence. We have received such evidence for years.
Next year marks 20 years since the publication of the Corston report into the experience of women in prison. While successive Governments have accepted its recommendations, sadly the data tells us eloquently that so far nothing has changed. Meanwhile, this Labour Government have essentially abandoned plans for a residential women’s centre in Swansea, which was supposed to have been the start of a residential solution for Wales. Now we have been informed that it is not moving ahead, because the funding for it is not there. I ask whether the Minister is in a position to reconsider that decision, because it is clear that a trauma-informed alternative to custody for women in Wales is urgently needed.
Even without a women’s prison, Wales has recorded a higher “in-country” imprisonment rate than England in every year since 2019. Last year, there were 155 Welsh people per 100,000 of the population in prison, compared with 138 in England. When faced with those figures, the Government cannot say that the status quo works for Wales, and while the rate of imprisonment in Wales has been rising, we have lost 100,000 years of cumulative prison officer experience since 2010. In fact, the report by the Welsh Affairs Committee into justice in Wales found that population pressures, coupled with chronic staffing challenges, have
“undermined staff and prisoner safety and the effectiveness of rehabilitation work.”
Those pressures do not come from nowhere; the impact of years of Tory underfunding is evident. But the Labour Government cannot continue to pass the buck indefinitely; responsibility now lies with them.
The UK Government continue to underfund services in the public estate delivered by the Welsh Government, with no changes to the funding for prison health since 2014, which again was highlighted in the report by the Welsh Affairs Committee. That fact needs to be reiterated if we are to improve prisoner health in the public estate in Wales—prison health funding has remained the same for 12 years. That is extraordinary. Given that many of the 1,777 English prisoners held in Wales would likely receive that devolved support, it is even more egregious that the UK Government are cutting these corners.
Forgetting the Welsh context comes easily in Westminster, including the fact that some prisoners actually speak Welsh. We know from Dr Rob Jones and Dr Gregory Davies that Welsh-speaking prisoners in HMP Berwyn have faced significant barriers, to the point that the Welsh Language Commissioner undertook a statutory inquiry into His Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service’s Welsh language scheme. I reiterate the commissioner’s call, and that of the Thomas commission years ago, that all justice bodies should be subject to the Welsh language measures of 2011. This is not a corner that should be cut in Wales.
Sadly, we have come to realise that cutting corners is a common theme in prisons. Over a decade since privatisation, there are billions of pounds worth of maintenance backlogs, and the chief inspector of prisons has warned of
“deteriorating infrastructure and long delays to essential maintenance in prisons.”
The legacy of outsourcing is squalor, but where is Labour’s action to insource those contracts, and tackle the crumbling and vermin-infested prison estate? Sometimes when we talk about prisons, it feels like we are engaging in hyperbole, but it is all true. When I say “vermin-infested”, I mean “vermin-infested.” Surely in the 21st century, that can be remedied.
I declare an interest because I am the chair of the all-party parliamentary group on justice unions, and six justice unions—the Prison Officers Association, Napo, the Public and Commercial Services Union, the University and College Union, the Royal College of Nursing and the Police Federation—have called for a royal commission into prisons and the wider criminal justice system, to work out what has gone wrong, whose fault it was and is, and how to fix it. Having such a royal commission was a promise made by the last Government, but it was never delivered. When we face a problem as serious as the prisons crisis, surely we need a serious commitment to seek a solution, such as would be implicit in a royal commission?