Contribution
It is a pleasure to serve under you in the Chair, Ms Lewell. I congratulate the hon. Member for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East (Andy McDonald) on securing this debate, and Members who have contributed.
Seeking efficiency in the civil service is the right thing to do, and the back office of Government is a logical place to start. Moving four Departments on to one HR and finance system, covering about 250,000 civil servants, is a sensible aim, but this debate is not about the aim; it is about how this contract has been handled and about one question that the Government have so far refused to answer: who is responsible? Frankly, this has been a mess.
Let us take a look at the timeline. In August 2024, the then Chief Secretary to the Treasury approved the first full business case for Synergy. In December 2025, the Government let Capita take over the civil service pension scheme, despite repeated warnings that it was not ready. By February 2026, the backlog stood at about 120,000 cases. In the same month, with that crisis already in the headlines, the Department for Work and Pensions named the very same company as the preferred bidder for Synergy.
What has happened since? By the summer, 100,000 people were still waiting for pension quotes. More than 7,000 of them were already past their retirement date. About 5,000 bereaved families were still waiting for money that they were owed. Last month, the Government had to rush a fix into the Budget, so that families whose death-in-service payments Capita had delayed would not be hit with a tax bill on top.
Those are not abstract numbers. Some 69 of my own constituents have contacted me about this, making it one of the largest single casework issues that we are currently dealing with in the office; other Members have also acknowledged the scale of the casework coming into their inboxes. The individual stories that I have heard in Fylde and from Members who have contributed here today and in other debates demonstrate the urgent need to get solutions for the people we represent.
To go back to the timeline, on 26 October, the Parliamentary Secretary, Cabinet Office, the hon. Member for Doncaster Central (Sally Jameson), came to the House and called Capita’s performance “abysmal”. She said that the company had been “flaky with the truth”. Her own remedial adviser found its recovery planning “wholly insufficient”. One Department tells us that it cannot trust Capita’s figures on pensions, while another hands the same company the pay of a quarter of a million serving civil servants—both cannot be right.
When the right hon. Member for Hayes and Harlington (John McDonnell) asked about Synergy, the Cabinet Office said that that was not within its remit and pointed to the DWP. Ask the DWP, and we are told that the process was robust. The Treasury signed off the business case, the Cabinet Office owns the strategy, DWP ran the procurement and, on pensions, we are told that Capita alone is accountable for the recovery. Everybody had a hand in this, but nobody will take responsibility for it. That is not good enough. If payroll goes wrong, it is prison officers, Border Force staff and jobcentre workers who will not be paid on time. The warning signs are already there: the Public Accounts Committee reported in July that the first moves on to the new service had slipped by five months. The Committee has asked the Government to confirm whether Capita’s bid came in around 40% below the Department’s estimate of what the work should cost. I will not stray into matters before the courts, but that is a question that this House is entitled to have answered at the appropriate juncture.
I have five questions for the Minister. First, which Minister took the decision to award this contract to Capita, and what did they know about the pension scheme when they took it? Secondly, what did the Cabinet Office tell DWP about Capita’s performance before the award, and will the Minister publish that? Thirdly, has the Department assessed what the remedial adviser’s findings on pensions mean for Synergy? If Capita’s planning was “wholly insufficient” there, why will it be any different here? Fourthly, what is the revised timetable for each Department? What have the delays cost so far, and will the Minister commit that no one’s pay will move until clear, published milestones have been met? Finally, if Capita fails, what is the contingency plan, and who pays for it?
The Cabinet Office Minister said that she would return to the House if there was no rapid improvement within a month. That month is almost up. Thousands of retired civil servants are still waiting, and now a quarter of a million serving civil servants are being asked to trust the same company with their pay. They deserve better than a Government that pass the buck from one Department to the next. Somebody signed this off. Somebody must take responsibility.