Ian Byrne

Ian Byrne

Labour — Liverpool West Derby

Speaking in the House of Commons on 17 November 2026

Debate

Department for Work and Pensions: Synergy Contract

Contribution

I ask the Minister to address that issue. It is a vital point. This comes down to the fundamental issue of outsourcing that bedevils this place. That is responsible for the failure of Capita. We are told that outsourcing delivers efficiency and transfers risk, but after Capita’s failures, we have seen civil servants stepping up and clearing the backlog, employers providing hardship funds, and Government-appointed auditors and MPs becoming an escalation route. Put simply, outsourcing has proven to be a failed Thatcherite ideology followed by successive Governments, delivering the opposite of the promised aim of efficiency and putting the burden on ordinary people. The number of Government contracts that we have outsourced is terrifying. It feels as though we have been captured by these companies, and we are now in a position where, if one topples, we are absolutely terrified of the consequences. Whether it is Fujitsu in the case of the Post Office Horizon scandal, our failing water industry or the Capita civil service pension scheme, this House must accept that this political experiment has failed completely and Governments must now begin to reverse it. We look forward to seeing the Government’s proposals on insourcing, because I fully support the call for a wholesale programme of insourcing. That was a manifesto pledge that we stood on but, unfortunately, it is not moving quick enough. I finish with a couple of questions for the Minister. Will she pause the contract and review it? Will the Government publish contingency plans to guarantee that every civil servant is paid on time, if this contract goes the way of the pensions? Will she open genuine negotiations with the recognised trade unions, including PCS, that have done so much to protect the workers involved and, rightly, are hugely concerned about the workers being paid on time and in full?

More from Ian Byrne

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Ian Byrne's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Ian Byrne report card.