B

Baroness Davies of Devonport (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, in moving Amendment 75, I will also speak to Amendments 275 and 276, which stand in my name. I first apologise for bringing my laryngitis voice with me, but today’s amendments were too important for me to stay in bed. The two key themes of my amendments are transparency and accountability. Before I turn to each amendment, let me set out the context. Thousands of patients, many of them young, have been given hormones and referred for life-changing surgeries by NHS services that cannot say what became of them. The Levy review found an absence of any patient outcome data across all nine adult gender clinics in England. No other area of the NHS would be allowed to operate without knowing whether its treatments help or harm. When the NHS commissioned a study to find out, adult clinics refused to share their data, as the Government have confirmed. Their refusal should prompt more scrutiny, not more of the same. A service that never follows up its patients can never be held to account for what happens to them, so I ask the Minister: what do these clinics not want us to look at? The consequences of the failed oversight are becoming increasingly visible. As recently reported, at the WellBN GP clinic in Brighton, 78 young patients were potentially harmed after puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones were prescribed without proper checks. This is just the tip of the iceberg. In Wales, surgical referral rates were two, three or four times those of English clinics, yet this went unnoticed until freedom of information requests exposed it. Around 60 operations have since been paused. At WellBN, concerns came to light through family complaints and legal action. Neither there nor in Wales did NHS oversight find the problem. We know that where clinicians fear speaking out, failures go undetected. The chilling effect is such that clinicians in adult gender services told the Cass review they would face complaints if they delayed putting patients on hormones. Clinicians have described being ostracised and bullied for refusing to put patients through without proper exploration. This is why Amendments 75 and 275 make the collection of data a legal duty. No individual clinician should have to stand alone in deciding whether to report. Meanwhile, funding for adult clinics has more than doubled, with no NICE evaluation and no independent evaluation of what that money achieves. On top of that, the NHS spends up to £21 million a year on gender surgeries. New freedom of information figures suggest the bill this year will be more than double that, at £45 million. The cost does not end with the operation. These procedures mean lifelong hormones, monitoring and other further surgeries. In pooled studies, around one in five vaginoplasty patients needed another operation. The NHS pays for that too, with no one tracking the total. This is taxpayers’ money.

More from Baroness Davies of Devonport (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.