Health Bill
Tuesday, 17 November 2026
Contributions
Committee (5th Day)
Northern Ireland, Scottish and Welsh l egislative c onsent sought . Relevant document: 12th Report from the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee
Clause 16: Regulations about commissioning by integrated care boards
Amendment 66
Moved by
66: Clause 16, page 12, line 10, at end insert— “(3) Regulations must impose duties on integrated care boards with respect to waiting times for treatments or other services provided to children which they arrange in the exercise of their commissioning functions.(4) Regulations under subsection (3) must include provision as to the arrangements integrated care boards must make where a specified treatment or other specified service for a child is not provided within a specified period.(5) The first regulations under subsection (3) must be made before the end of the period of 12 months beginning with the day on which section 16 of the Health Act 2026 comes into force.(6) In this section “child” means a person under the age of 18.”Member’s explanatory statement This amendment would require the Secretary of State to make regulations imposing waiting-time duties on integrated care boards in respect of children including a requirement on integrated care boards to take action where a child does not receive a specified treatment or service within the specified period.
Baroness Cass (CB)
My Lords, the Government have set themselves the welcome ambition of raising the healthiest generation of children ever, but in this Bill children are not writ large or even small; they are largely absent. I recognise that this is a Bill about structures and systems, rather than specific populations, but past experience shows that health systems are designed around adults, and children need to be the subject of explicit mention in legislation and guidance lest they be forgotten. I make no apology for the fact that this is a large group aimed at prioritising children and young people in this reformed health system. I start with Amendment 66, which is on waiting times. One of the clearest examples of children being overlooked are the excessive waiting times for elective and community health services. For children, a delay in treatment can cause irreparable harm because it impairs physical, and often mental, development. As a result of long waits, children may miss developmental milestones and fall further behind their peers. The report into audiology services by my colleague Camilla Kingdon, another past college president—they keep us engaged after we demit—was published last year and highlighted the issue of long waits. For cochlear implants, implanting at around nine months of age will give children the best chance of natural speech development. The older a child is when they receive their implant, the less their brain is able to rewire itself to recognise the signals. The review quoted one child who waited three and a half years for surgery for a cochlear implant. This is not an isolated incident. Across child health services, we are seeing significant delays for treatment. Only 48% of children and young people are seen within 18 weeks for community services, compared with 86% of adults. Only about two-thirds of children waiting for paediatric hospital services are seen within 18 weeks. Amendment 66 would require the Secretary of State to make waiting-time regulations for children within 12 months. These would require ICBs to act where a child does not receive a specified treatment or service within the specified period. In doing so, it would strengthen accountability for timely access to services and ensure children’s waiting times are routinely measured, monitored and reported, rather than being obscured by broader improvements elsewhere in the system. Amendment 232 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, and my Amendment 249 are aimed at improving transparency for children’s services metrics, focusing on multiple levels within the system. They aim to produce better reporting and a clear strategy to improve outcomes and reduce inequalities. In the interest of efficiency, I will leave the noble Baroness and my noble friend Lord Russell to speak to these amendments. Amendment 279QG is on monitoring emerging risks from digital technology, which I will illustrate with a couple of medical stories. In 2021, a paper appeared in a paediatric journal describing a Covid-19-related increase in childhood tics and tic-like attacks. The authors said: “There is an urgent need to collate systematic data on this group as this is a rare and unusual subtype of tics”. Typically, childhood tics start around five to seven years of age and more commonly affect boys in a ratio of four to one. This new surge of referrals consisted of adolescent girls with a sudden onset of motor and vocal tics of what the authors called a “complex and bizarre nature”. The clinicians concluded that this was a psychological rather than a neurological problem and, in some cases, heavily driven by TikTok influencers. In fact, you could sometimes recognise the influencer from the pattern of the patient’s tics. Because this was a prominent publication, the problem was gradually recognised and understood, helped by the fact that it was also picked up by mainstream media. By contrast, another tragic problem went on for many years before it was acted on: toddlers being accidentally strangled by blind cords. Historically, accidental strangulations from looped blind cords were viewed by families and coroners as isolated, tragic anomalies. These events happen quickly and silently, so they can occur while a parent is briefly elsewhere in the house. In 2004, child death overview panels—CDOPs—were established under the Children Act, so there was more careful scrutiny of child deaths. However, it took until 2018 before the National Child Mortality Database was formed to collate the CDOP data, and suddenly these were no longer isolated incidents but part of a clear pattern. In June 2020, the NCMD issued a safety notice about the dangers of looped blind cords to toddlers and young children. That was a significant delay. The power of sharing information informally and, more importantly, systematically cannot be underestimated. When my noble friend Lady Kidron and I convened a meeting with the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges, the shock in the room was palpable, as college presidents and leaders from different specialties talked about their experiences of the harms from social media. Although each had been worried about what they were seeing in their own arena, the combined impact across so many specialties and the enormity of the problem was instrumental in shifting the dial on the need for action. We do not want to wait until children die and then look at trends on the NCMD. That is why this amendment, which is supported by Health Professionals for Safer Screens, calls for a national system to enable healthcare professionals to report physical, developmental, sensory, psychological or behavioural effects in children that they consider may be associated with digital technology. However, reporting is of no value unless someone is analysing the results and acting on them. Noble Lords will shortly hear from my noble friend Lady Kidron on how that response may work. I end my comments on digital safety by expressing my support for Amendment 279P from the noble Baroness, Lady Barran. It addresses the important issue of the safety of the technology that we in the NHS provide to children and where there should be even greater expectations of safety by design and assessment of any potential harms. My final amendment in this group is about health services for adolescents and young adults. Getting this right is not a trivial matter because, leaving apart the human cost of providing inadequate services for this key group, the financial cost will be incalculable. Between 29% to 34% of 16 year-olds have long-term term physical, mental health, disability or other illnesses, and they should rightly expect holistic and seamless services. If we do not address health problems in adolescence, we will be looking at more young adults who are NEET—that is significant given the release of that report today—and facing lifelong ill health and lost opportunities to participate in and contribute to society. Adolescent and young adult healthcare needs to start in local communities and be delivered through a network of services up to and including specialist care for those with the most complex needs. At present, there is very little mention in the young futures hubs about the inclusion of health. This is a serious missed opportunity, akin to missing out health from the otherwise excellent Sure Start programme.
Noble Lords may recall me mentioning the Well Centre at Second Reading. This is a primary care-based centre serving Lambeth and Southwark for young people aged 11 to 20. It can assess problems from acne to anxiety, sexual health, trauma or depression. Dr Lamb, the GP leading the services, has received comments from her young patients such as, “Thank you for always creating a safe space for me to come to”, and “You supported me so much through the toughest of times”. Imagine the impact of services such as this across the NHS, some potentially co-located with young futures hubs. Yet Dr Lamb has to spend her spare time seeking out charitable funds to supplement her work.
At the other end of the spectrum, we need specialist services for young people with very complex problems. For example, a 14 year-old with severe post-Covid symptoms was confined to bed, with his parents having to wash and feed him. With comprehensive support and rehabilitation, that young man is now in college and living life to the full. Yet we are desperately short of the kind of specialist services that provide this essential and truly life-saving rehabilitation and help.
Between these two poles, we have young people with diabetes, renal impairment, rheumatological conditions, epilepsy and a range of other conditions who need to make a smooth transition to adult services, yet all too often this is not well managed or orchestrated, precipitating setbacks in physical or mental health. Simple measures, such as having a hospital transition lead, can improve outcomes, yet very few hospitals support time for this in consultant job plans. I call on the Secretary of State to take these issues seriously and develop a strategic plan and implementation framework specifically for these services.
Finally, I will mention two other amendments that I support. The first is Amendment 161 in the name of the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Leicester, on retention of the NHS number following adoption, which I fully support. From my work in gender services, I saw tangible examples of the risks when parts of a child’s medical history were lost due to changes in the NHS number. Adopted children should not be subject to the same risks. Secondly, Amendment 243 in the name of my noble friend Lady Finlay pulls together a series of crucial measures around communication when a child is close to death, which, if implemented, would help to avert end-of-life court cases and make a lifelong difference to parental grief. I beg to move.
Baroness Penn (Con)
My Lords, I support all the amendments in this group but, again, in the interests of efficiency I shall speak only to those in my name, which are Amendments 98A, 279F and 279G. I am grateful to other noble Lords and noble Baronesses for adding their names to these amendments. These amendments seek to understand how the DHSC, the NHS, integrated care boards and local authorities are approaching children’s digital environments as a public health issue. During the passage of the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill, I pressed the Government to provide advice to parents and carers of children under five on the safe and appropriate use of screens and technology, and I welcome the fact that this has been taken forward, with similar guidance for six to 18 year-olds to follow. I also pressed for guidance for early years settings, where young children spend so much of their time and which are a source of advice and guidance to their parents. Health has been a missing piece of this puzzle. I should confess that, despite having worked on several previous health Bills, I lack the expertise of many in this Committee on the systems and structures of our health system, so my amendments may get some of the technicalities wrong and I would welcome correction from the Committee or the Minister. Nor do I claim that the proposals are necessarily the solution to ensuring that children grow up in a safer digital environment. We must have higher standards, safety by design, a stronger Online Safety Act and collective action through schools, communities and a whole host of other areas. These amendments are designed to sit alongside those efforts, not instead of them. What I am keen to hear from the Committee and the Minister is whether they agree that a children’s digital environment has sufficient impact on multiple aspects of their health that it warrants proper attention and action from our health system. If so, is the approach taken in these amendments the right one, or is there a better way forward? On the first question, the impact of the digital environment on children’s health, I believe that the evidence is clear. Let us take just three examples. On eyesight, a 2025 meta-analysis covering 300,000 children found that each additional hour of daily screen time was associated with 21% higher odds of myopia. On language, the Government’s own Children of the 2020s study, published by the DfE, found that two year-olds in the highest fifth for screen time could say 53% of a list of common words, compared with 65% of those in the lowest fifth. These outcomes held when accounting for family income, parental mental health and the home learning environment. The authors note that the greatest apparent impact came when screen time exceeded roughly an hour and a half a day, which is less than the average time that a two year-old spends on screens in the UK at the moment. On physical activity, children who are sedentary in front of screens are, by definition, not doing the active play that their development needs. These risks become even more real when you look at the data on how much time children are spending on screens or in the digital rather than the physical environment. Some 98% of two year-olds watch screens on a typical day for an average of over two hours. Only a third meet the WHO’s recommendation of no more than an hour of sedentary screen time, and that is down from 46% a decade ago. For one in five two year-olds, the average is not two hours but over five hours a day. My amendments propose to do three things. First, they would ensure that the health professionals who see almost every family and child—such as health visitors, GPs, practice nurses, school nurses and speech and language therapists—have evidence-based guidance and training on children’s use of screens and digital technology. Amendment 279F would require the Secretary of State “to publish guidance for health professionals” within six months, covering children of all ages but with particular attention to those aged nought to five. It would also require the Secretary of State to use existing duties under Section 1F of the National Health Service Act to make training available for those health professionals and would require consultation with the royal colleges, a review of the guidance every three years and a report on the availability and uptake of training within two years. Secondly, Amendment 279G seeks to build digital environments into the healthy child programme reviews. The five mandatory reviews for children under five are the only universal contacts that pre-school children may have with anyone outside their home. There is currently a single-line reference to discussion of healthy routines and screen use within the guidance for those checks. Although many other areas of messaging are closely related—for example, the sharing of relational health messages and safeguarding considerations—there is nothing detailed or explicit about children’s digital environment and the impact it can have. The healthy child programme also extends to more targeted interventions for those aged six to 18, where children’s digital environments may again be a key consideration in any health issues that they have. Thirdly, Amendment 98A to Clause 25 would require local authorities and integrated care boards, when preparing neighbourhood health plans, to “consider the effects … of children’s digital environment”, particularly for the under-fives, and to set out how any needs identified will be met, involving “health visitors, school nurses and family hubs”. None of this asks health professionals to become experts in technology. It asks that the people who families already trust are equipped with consistent and evidence-based advice and that the system as a whole is designed to deliver it. I would be grateful for the Minister’s reflections on these proposals. In particular, can she explain how children’s digital environments are being integrated into public health and the healthy child programme? What training do health visitors, GPs and other health professionals currently receive on this and what further plans do the Government have in this area?
Baroness Barran (Con)
My Lords, it is a great privilege to follow my noble friend Lady Penn, who once again speaks with great authority on this subject. I apologise that I was unable to speak at Second Reading, but I hope that the Committee will permit me to contribute at this point, given my involvement in some of the issues relating to my amendment in earlier legislation. I also thank the cosignatories to my amendment. My amendment seeks to apply to digital medical technology that is required or prescribed for children some of the same principles that apply to what we might describe as traditional or physical medical technology. I hope that that is not controversial and I hope that the Minister, when she comes to sum up, will reassure me and the Committee that this is covered. My amendment sets out that an NHS body can prescribe or recommend a digital technology or tool only where it is satisfied that there is evidence both of its effectiveness and of its safety, with reference to any standards or guidance set out by NICE—or perhaps I should add the MHRA. It would also require any NHS body to assess the risk of harm resulting from the use of the device on which the technology operates. The Committee will be familiar with the types of risk set out in the amendment: access to social media, messaging services, AI chatbots and AI companions and, specifically, functions that are not needed for the medical technology to work. The amendment would also require the relevant NHS body to provide written guidance to parents and carers on the risks, on how to limit access to other functions and on the safe management of overnight alerts and use. Further, it would prioritise giving children under 16 a device that is purely dedicated to its medical purpose, as one configured to restrict access to its wider functions, as in the case of a smartphone. All of this is subject to the caveat that such restrictions must not impair the clinical effectiveness of the medical technology. The amendment is needed because children with type 1 diabetes are currently being provided with smartphones carrying an app to monitor their glucose levels. That is obviously essential from the perspective of their diabetes, but some of these—very young—children have ended up seeing pornography and worse on the smartphone that carries that app. In normal circumstances, they would have been far too young to have access to such a device unsupervised. More broadly, mental health apps are becoming more widespread, which at the very least risks children having their phone by their bed as they use, say, a meditation app to fall asleep. We can all imagine that they may use the phone for other purposes as well. More worryingly, children risk becoming reliant on AI companions and chatbots. I understand that the NHS has assessed the efficacy of a number of these apps. My amendment seeks to close the loophole that means that the device on which those apps sit carries a set of increasingly alarming risks that are neither assessed nor managed currently. As I say, I look forward very much to the Minister’s reply. Briefly, I am also delighted to add my name to the amendments in the names of my noble friend Lady Penn and the noble Baroness, Lady Cass. When we were debating the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill, now the Act, my noble friend Lady Penn spoke with great clarity and good sense, as she has again today. Her amendments bring a comprehensive and coherent approach to addressing the risks posed by the digital environment in preparing the neighbourhood health plan and to giving health professionals the training that they need to understand these risks. In particular, Amendment 279G would ensure that the parents of every child aged nought to five who receives a universal health review would be able to discuss the risks that their child faces from the digital environment.
Finally, in relation to Amendment 279QG in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, I hope very much that the Minister will accept the importance of the changes that the amendment would make. Her Government spent many months arguing that they did not have the evidence of causation on which to act in relation to the harms from social media. Happily, the Government’s position has changed and we look forward to further action in that area, but we should not make the same mistake twice. As the noble Baroness said—and I know from health professionals to whom I have spoken —health professionals are among the first to notice trends in myopia, delayed speech, mental health problems and more linked to children’s use of social media and screens. An early warning system, such as that set out in the noble Baroness’s amendment, would allow a more rapid and effective response in future, which is all the more needed given the pace of change that we see in technology at the moment.
The Lord Bishop of Leicester
My Lords, Amendment 161 in my name would allow a child’s NHS number to remain the same when they are adopted. It is a small but specific change—one that can have a huge positive impact for adopted children. I declare an interest: my wife is a designated doctor for looked-after children and the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health lead in this area. She serves on a national working group on adoption and NHS numbers. It is through her work that I have come to understand this issue and why it matters to some of the most vulnerable children in our country. I begin with the purpose of the Bill, specifically its aim to create a single patient record, bringing together a person’s health information into one place so that those caring for them can see the whole picture. This is an aim that I wholeheartedly support. Similarly, it makes complete sense for the NHS number to be the single identifier and for this to apply across schools and social care. However, as it stands, the Bill risks excluding one group from these significant changes. It is an unintended consequence, I am sure, but one that will affect some of the most vulnerable people in our society: namely, adopted children. The amendment in my name is about ensuring that adopted children also benefit from the advantages that the Government believe a single patient record can offer. Currently, when an adoption order is made, the child is given a brand-new NHS number and, with it, a fresh medical record. Everything that came before—the investigations, the diagnoses, the immunisations, the appointments—is left behind under the old number. In theory, the pre-adoption medical record is technically retrievable, but in practice it often is not, because only the child’s GP is automatically notified of the new number. Hospitals and community services are not notified. While NHS England has issued guidance to try to ensure that adopted children have a continuous health record, this has by no means fully resolved the problem—something that I believe the noble Lord, Lord Young of Cookham, will be addressing. The upshot is a significant clinical risk for a highly vulnerable group of children. To give a sense of the scale, around 3,000 children are adopted from care in England each year and some 4,000 adoption orders are made across England and Wales once step-parent and private law adoptions are included. Children midway through investigations have had to start them all over again because earlier results could not be traced, repeating scans and tests that incur both unnecessary costs and distress. If a child has a chronic condition, they can simply fall off a pathway. Without allergy or adverse reaction records, a child can be prescribed a medicine that they have already reacted to, one which interacts with treatment that they are already receiving, or experience an interrupted supply of an essential medicine. Ultimately, this can mean missed or delayed diagnosis and treatment or even inappropriate treatment and care, none of which, I know, this Government would want, not least for a cohort who have a particularly high incidence of complex need. Children adopted from care have, on average, markedly higher rates of complex and overlapping health needs than the general child population, including neurodevelopmental conditions, developmental delay and physical health conditions. The Government’s own survey of looked-after children found that about half have a diagnosable mental health condition against roughly one in 10 children in the wider population. In other words, adopted children badly need continuous high-quality care and, as it stands, changing their NHS number stands in the way of that. This is a small, targeted change that is true to the Bill’s purpose and that would prevent real harm to some of our most vulnerable children. Therefore, would the Minister agree to meet me to discuss this amendment before Report?
Baroness Tyler of Enfield (LD)
My Lords, I will speak to my Amendment 232, and I thank the noble Lord, Lord Russell, for adding his name to it. As the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, has highlighted, my amendment is closely related to some important amendments that she has discussed, on waiting times, improving child outcomes and transparency. More broadly, I am sympathetic to all the amendments in this group; it is a wide-ranging set of amendments, but they are important. I do not have time to go through them all individually, but because it is an issue that I have discussed in the past, I signal my strong support in particular for the amendment from the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Leicester on adopted children requiring the retention of an NHS number—without that, those children can too easily fall through the cracks. This important group is all about promoting and protecting children. We talked about this a little in a few previous groups in Committee, but we have not heard enough about it. My Amendment 232 seeks to promote and safeguard outcomes for babies, children and young people in the reformed healthcare system envisaged by the Bill. It seeks to address a fundamental question of accountability. As the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, has said, at present children are largely invisible in this important piece of legislation and, in my view, that happens too often in our debates on the NHS. The broad purpose of my amendment is to strengthen the focus on improving outcomes for children and young people by holding the structures that deliver services for them accountable for their progress. My amendment has three key elements. First, it would require the Secretary of State to publish a national report on children’s outcomes and associated targeted investments. Secondly, it would place a duty on the Secretary of State to establish and publish a national definition of children’s outcomes, aligned with the babies, children and young people’s modern service framework, which I understand is due to be published shortly—the Minister may be able to give an update on this. In essence, this would provide a consistent basis for measuring and reporting progress across England. Thirdly, the amendment would also introduce a new duty on integrated care boards to publish an annual statement, setting out the outcomes achieved for children and young people in their area, detailing any targeted investments made during the financial year to improve those outcomes and explaining how those investments relate to the outcomes reported. That is technically what the amendment seeks to do. Why do we need this? Past experience shows that children need to be the subject of explicit accountability measures or they simply get overlooked. I point back to the important work of the Darzi report, which highlighted concerns around children’s health services’ capacity and capability to deliver high-quality care for children. It identified deteriorating child health outcomes, raising demand for services as children faced increasing waiting times compared to adults, a shortage of specialist staff and a jarring £191 million cut to their services. There is currently no consistent reporting on how child health outcomes are improving or deteriorating and how these changes are influencing decision-making, either at national or local level. It is difficult for us to judge how the Government are achieving their ambition, which I strongly support, of raising the healthiest generation of children ever, if there is limited transparency around the extent to which children’s outcomes inform these important investment decisions. If we are serious about achieving that ambition, which I am sure we are, we need to start answering these questions. How are children’s outcomes informing investment decisions? How are children being prioritised in limited resource decisions when ICBs are facing workforce shortages? The consequence of this current lack of accountability is something that we need to be concerned about. As a brief reminder, the report this year of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, T he State of Child Health , paints a worrying picture, with most measures of child health and well-being worsening or showing stalled progress, alongside stark inequalities in outcomes. A new analysis published very recently by the King’s Fund reinforces the urgency of the challenges and very much picks up on those themes that I mentioned from the Darzi report. For children, as we have heard, these delays can have lifelong consequences. Missing a crucial developmental window can affect speech and language, mobility, physical and social development and learning. Against that backdrop, it becomes even more important that we can join up all the dots on what we spend on children’s services, where the money goes, what we get for it and the outcomes that children experience. In my view, the Bill gives us an important opportunity to strengthen that accountability, and my amendment does just that. Finally, I want to be clear about what such an approach would not do. It does not in itself prescribe a particular level of spending on children’s services. That is important. Rather, it gives Parliament, policymakers, ICBs and the public much better information about how resources are being allocated, how that varies between areas, what outcomes are being achieved and, ultimately, whether further investment or action is needed. In short, it gives us a much clearer basis on which to hold both national and local systems to account for improving children’s health.
Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (CB)
My Lords, I am delighted to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler. My noble friend Lady Cass introduced this whole group, setting out how the amendments are critical, as they state that policy must have a specific focus on children’s health. My Amendment 243 in this group concerns the experience of parents, who when their child is near death have a peri-death situation. Some children have long-standing disabilities and gradually deteriorate. Others have an ongoing serious condition. These children may suddenly become very ill, and a decision has to be made over how active ongoing intervention should be. But there is another group: those children who are fit and well and active one day, and, within an hour or even a minute, life is changed by overwhelming infection, accident or event and the child appears potentially moribund. A 999 call or a “scoop and run” to A&E in a panic takes the child into resus, where parents are told, “We are doing all we can”. When stabilised, the child is often transferred to a major centre. Blue-lighted there, parents are met by bewildering tubes and machines, their world changing before their eyes, clinging to the hope from the words, “We are doing all we can”. Rapidly, they try to adapt, but panic can make some sound aggressive, others dumbstruck. Frantic phone calls attempt to update others in the family and arrange for other children to be cared for. The turmoil goes on. In all this, parents often feel excluded from decision-making. They cannot take in the wealth of information coming their way. All the time, they are hoping for recovery. Then, the body blow: they are told that nothing more can be done and resuscitation measures are to cease, with ventilation withdrawn. If they object, they may be told that the hospital will go to court for a ruling to cease artificial life-sustaining measures. They cannot take it in. Trust evaporates. In desperation, they seek any input they can. Sometimes they hit a brick wall when they ask to see the clinical record, a copy of scan reports and other investigations. When parents are involved at every moment, respected and listened to, they can be taken down to reality gently, in stages. Little acts of kindness are essential. They need to feel and see that clinicians sincerely care. If they feel that staff talk down to them, take a superior “we know best” approach and fail to be open, it all gets worse. These parents carry the grief and scars for the rest of their lives. If their child is dying and they want to take the child home, allowing their last hours to be surrounded by a loving family, then why not? If they want a second, independent opinion, then why not? Resources are no excuse. Care in the community for the child’s extubation, whether in the home or in a children’s hospice, can be far less expensive than in a paediatric intensive care unit.
Martha’s rule has already revealed how important it is that staff listen to relatives. This is not an extension of Martha’s rule per se; it is a different situation. I have met several of these parents. They do not want money. They simply want a less traumatic experience for others: for them to be heard and considered when the ultimate tragedy happens. James Asser MP met Tafida Raqeeb’s mother and, after writing to the Secretary of State, he received a reply on 20 October, from which I quote: “Clinicians should respect families’ requests for a second opinion, and children’s services are encouraged to help arrange independent expert advice and keep families involved throughout the process. Specialist children’s services may draw on mediation services, clinical ethics committees and multidisciplinary teams to support open communication, considering different perspectives, and help families and clinicians work collaboratively in the best interests of the child”. Sadly, this ideal is not always happening. This amendment simply calls for that respect and collaboration to be universal.
Lastly, I turn to Amendment 279QG. The harms of social media are potentially enormous. In recent weeks, the promotion of AI toys has revealed a startling new danger to small children. These cuddly-looking bunny-type toys are listed for three-plus years old but, inside them, the AI chatbot has no age boundaries at all. These toys are cheap, sold online and have no meaningful parental controls. On testing by Alliance 4 Children and by the University of Cambridge in an AI systematic study, they gave very inappropriate responses to over a quarter of questions. These included—this is for small children—giving graphic sexual details and telling a child where to find matches, knives and plastic bags. In one test, the toy provoked suicide by encouraging a child to “fly” off a balcony. They have been banned in California for under-16s, and New York has published a moratorium. This cannot be ignored. The precautionary principle must be invoked, and that is why this amendment is so important for the future health of our children.
Lord Russell of Liverpool (CB)
My Lords, I am glad we are talking about this group at a decent time in the morning. I was going to comment the other evening that we were going to talk about children well past their bedtimes and well past some of our bedtimes, so I am glad we are doing it at a time when most of us are more or less awake. I am in broadly in favour of all these amendments. They all point to the fact that, at the moment, we do not have clarity across our health system on exactly what is happening to children, what money is being spent on them, how it is being spent and how effectively it is being spent. That is clearly not a situation we would like to be in. In her Amendment 66, my noble friend Lady Cass spoke about waiting times. As we all know, any delays in the key stages of brain and physical development for young children can have lifelong consequences, not always for the better. I had the privilege of being in the meeting she referred to, which she and my noble friend Lady Kidron held, and which had the heads of many of the royal colleges there. As my noble friend Lady Cass said, there was a sort of “Aha” moment as each of the heads of the royal colleges realised that the concerns they had, and the worrying data they were getting back from clinicians in the field about what they were seeing in children, was being mirrored and echoed in the other colleges. That was a real wake-up moment for all of us, but particularly for them. In relation to Amendment 232, in the names of the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, and myself, if you do not measure, monitor, collate, understand, publish and debate children’s health outcomes, you are flying blind. You have to enable the identification of best practice and innovation where that is working, and enable careful targeting when one finds areas that are simply not working as they should. I turn briefly to the amendment from my noble friend Lady Finlay. I must confess that I was not familiar with this area, but I know that she speaks from deep personal and professional experience. I can only imagine—I do not even want to imagine—what parents in that situation are going through. It seems that the least we should ask for is that they are treated with a level of understanding and sensitivity, at what is probably one of the worst moments of their lives. To the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Leicester, I have to declare an interest; I am an ex-trustee and governor of Coram. We have been involved in adoption since we were founded in 1739, so we are very familiar with the area. What he described should not really be happening, but it is happening to just over 4,000 children a year. As he mentioned, many of these children, before they are adopted, have had an early life that was pretty traumatic. What has happened to them in early life is not immediately evident at the time they are adopted. It is incredibly important that there is clarity and continuity in understanding exactly what treatment and diagnosis have been made prior to them being adopted, to help the parents understand some of the dilemmas and behaviours that they are encountering, which probably bewilder them, and also the clinicians who are trying to help the families deal with these children. In relation to the many digital amendments on the effects of social media, we all know that this is a real problem. The commonality in all these amendments is a cry for the Government, their advisers, clinicians and all specialists who deal with children, including educationalists, to have a much better understanding than they do of the clearly pernicious effects of technology on the very young. I think the Government are listening. It is one thing to listen; it is another to have to take a clear set of decisions about what you are then going to do about it, and how you will measure whether what you think you should do is actually going to work. That is why I hope the Government will listen carefully to my colleagues such as my noble friend Lady Cass and the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron, who, unlike many of us, actually know what they are talking about. I will now speak to Amendment 249, tabled by my noble friend Lady Cass, which is about health inequalities. A paper by UNICEF UK, Held Back from the Start , shows that health inequalities are already well established, I am afraid, in the first five years of life. The Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health has published a paper this year, State of Child Health , which demonstrates that those inequalities are actually widening. Despite facing longer waits on average and poorer access to services, children under 18 are excluded from age discrimination protections when it comes to accessing public services and are therefore at risk of being overlooked. Without specific mention of children, health inequalities for children are likely to be ignored. Infant mortality in the most deprived areas of this country is about 5.3 deaths per 1,000—more than double the rate in the least deprived areas. Severe obesity is about 9% in the most deprived areas—four times the rate of 2.2% in the least deprived areas. Tooth decay affects one in three children in the poorest communities, as opposed to one in 10 in the most affluent. Those inequalities are staring us in the face. Behind all these statistics are children whose health is being shaped by factors that are wholly outside their control, including poverty, poor housing, food insecurity and unequal access to support. Children in deprived communities are more likely to be exposed to air pollution, damp, mould and overcrowded housing, all of which contribute to worse asthma outcomes. Health inequalities are driven by the conditions into which children are born and grow up. Reducing those inequalities requires action across all departments, not just the NHS and the DHSS, which is why this amendment would require a cross-government strategy and create a duty for all Ministers to have regard to that strategy. The Government, laudably, have produced strategies for men’s health and women’s health, but not for children’s health, and I regard that as unacceptable and a failure of the duty of care.
Baroness Benjamin (LD)
My Lords, I support all the amendments in this group and I have put my name to several of them. Amendment 66, in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, is about community health services, which support some of the most vulnerable children in our society, including those with complex health conditions, developmental disorders and safeguarding needs. Rising demand and increasing complexity of need have placed these services under enormous pressure, leading to growing waiting times. Nationally, we may be on course to meet the target of 78% of community activity taking place within 18 weeks by 2028. However, only 48% of children are currently seen within 18 weeks, compared with 76% of patients overall. These delays are not simply an inconvenience. For children, time lost cannot be recovered. As I always say, childhood lasts a lifetime, and early childhood is a period of rapid growth and development, so long waits can have lifelong consequences for health, education and well-being. They can also place enormous emotional and financial strain on families, with some feeling they have no option but to pay privately for support. One family described how their child experienced speech, language and communication difficulties from toddlerhood. Despite seeking early help, they faced repeated waiting times for assessment and therapy. With school approaching, and after around two years of waiting, they spent several thousand pounds of their own savings to access private assessment and speech and language therapy. Their daughter was diagnosed with a developmental language disorder and made good progress once support was finally available. However, she started school significantly behind her peers and had to struggle to fully participate in nursery and build friendships during those vital early years. This type of experience highlights why children’s waiting times cannot remain hidden and ICBs must be held to account to specifically reduce long waiting lists for children. This is what this amendment is all about. I will now speak to Amendments 98A, 279F and 279G in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Penn, which concentrate on children’s digital environment and health. I congratulate her on her work in the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act, where she focused on the excess use of screen and digital technology by very young children. Digital technology is now embedded in almost every aspect of children’s lives, including education, even at preschool stage, as well as entertainment, communication and social relationships. However, children’s use of screen time can be associated with poorer language, social and emotional outcomes.
Also, excessive use of screen time can affect several aspects of children’s healthy development, including sleep. Screen use, particularly before bedtime, can delay sleep and disrupt sleep routines. Insignificant sleep can affect mood, concentration, memory, behaviour and physical development. Non-physical activity—children not playing outdoors or taking part in exercise and other physical activities—is harmful, which in turn can cause obesity, an increased risk of unhealthy weight and poor physical fitness. Also, prolonged device use can contribute to eye strain, headaches, neck pain and poor posture. Importantly, it can cause increased anxiety, low mood and depressive symptoms.
There is also the matter of safeguarding. Children of all ages are increasingly exposed to online safeguarding risks, which include harmful content, being manipulated, harassment and sharing intimate images that can be distributed without consent or used to blackmail them. This is why these amendments are so important: they concentrate on children’s health and mental and physical well-being.
Finally, I support Amendment 279P in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Barran. We need the same protections for digital health services as we do for other medical devices, especially when it comes to the safety of children. Currently, this is not the case. We all know that digital devices, such as diabetes monitoring, can be life-saving, but they also give children unregulated access to the internet, social media and AI chatbots. Not surprisingly, children have accessed harmful and unsuitable material as a result. In fact, very young children, even some of primary school age, have done so. This is not good for their well-being.
Children are being prescribed the use of a range of mental health apps. They may be helpful, but can the Minister confirm what testing is being done on both their safety and effectiveness? These apps often involve a child listening to meditation on a smartphone as they fall asleep, but this goes against everything that the Government are doing in relation to protecting children from late-night scrolling and spending hours on the internet when they should be asleep. Parents need clear advice on how to manage this. Given how much the Government are doing to protect children online, surely it makes common sense to close this loophole and support this amendment.
I know how passionate and committed the Minister is to making a difference and changing lives, which is what these amendments propose to do. I urge her and the Government to support the amendments in this group and make a difference to children’s lives.
Lord Young of Cookham (Con)
My Lords, this group of amendments, so ably introduced by the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, identifies a range of challenges that today’s children face, and the amendments come up with a range of solutions that, I hope, will address them. Speaking as a grandparent, I believe that my children face far more challenges bringing up their children than I ever did, for all the reasons that we have been hearing in the debate so far. I have added my name to Amendment 161 from the right reverend Prelate, which would require an adopted child to keep the same NHS number rather than it being changed. It is worth mentioning that, under the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act, every child will have an SUI—single unique identifier—which will enable the child to be tracked through the whole range of services that they may come across. The SUI is going to be the NHS number, which means that, if the adopted child has a new number, they will be the only child not protected by the reforms in the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act—and those may be the children who most need those services. I welcome the guidance that has been given. GPs have been asked to merge the new and the old, but implementation is variable and inconsistent. I will come back to that in a moment. Looking at the current process for issuing a new number, it struck me as excessively bureaucratic. I crave the patience of the Committee to read from the NHS website what actually happens: “The Personal Demographics Service (PDS) National Back Office (NBO) receives notification from the General Register Office (GRO) of all adoptions in England and Wales ... The NBO invalidates the pre-adoptive NHS number on PDS, if it can be identified, and sends the patient’s details … and registered GP practice to PCSE”— Primary Care Support England. “At the same time the NBO will send a patient removal to the practice which will end the patient’s registration with the practice”. It then speeds up: “The NBO allocates a new NHS number with the post-adoptive details as recorded in the adoption order, and sends the details to PCSE ... PCSE sends the details of pre and post adoptive details to the GP practice. PCSE will email the main contact held for that practice, if available. It is important that all practices maintain up-to-date contact details in PCSE Online. PCSE sends a new patient medical record envelope with the new patient updated details and new NHS number to the GP practice”. Two things strike me about that. First, we have a long way to go before an analogue NHS becomes a digital NHS, with envelopes flying around the country. Secondly, it strikes me as rather cumbersome and unnecessary. There is a high risk of error, as the right reverend Prelate identified. Practices have to merge two records, remove the demographic details of family members, add sensitivity reminders and manage disclosure for any subject access request, all manually and child by child. Much of this depends on what particular software the GP practice is using. There is no enforcement, no legal duty and no audit of what actually happens. The question I pose is: what is the information in the original record that prevents it being used? Would it not be much simpler to redact that and keep the same number? The NHS concedes that this could happen. Another NHS website, Dealing with Medical Records for Adopted Patients: a Guide for GP Practices , says: “If the patient is staying registered with your practice … You should not make any changes that conceal or alter the patient’s clinical history, however, steps should be taken to prevent disclosure of their pre-adoptive identity—for example blocking out all references to the previous name and any information that may identify members of the birth family”. Well, why on earth do we have to go through all the processes that I outlined at the beginning if it is simply possible to redact the relevant bits from the records and continue to use those? It seems to me, unless there is a powerful reason to the contrary, that that would be a common-sense approach to the issue that the right reverend Prelate has identified.
Baroness Kidron (CB)
My Lords, it is hard not to moved by all the amendments in this group. The words of my noble friend Lady Cass in opening the group keep echoing in my mind as everybody speaks. She said that children need explicit mention, lest they will be forgotten; maybe that is the message of the group in its entirety. I was very pleased to add my name to Amendment 279QG. I thank Arabella Skinner, director of Health Professionals for Safer Screens, for her work in identifying the issues that my noble friend Lady Cass set out and for originally bringing them to our attention. Had I got there in time, I would have also added my name to Amendments 279F and 279G, in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Penn, and indeed to Amendment 279P from the noble Baroness, Lady Barran. I was a huge supporter of the work that the noble Baroness, Lady Penn, did during the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill. She is absolutely right about the need to raise awareness of digital harms to healthcare professionals in the way that she set out. I really hope that the Minister is listening hard, as is the noble Baroness, Lady Barran, whose amendment would ensure that NHS-provided technology is effective, age-appropriate and not connected to unnecessary commercial services. Research by the Digital Futures for Children centre at the LSE, which I chair, has repeatedly found such connections in educational technology. It is unacceptable in education and unacceptable in health. I wish the noble Baroness well with her amendment. Moving to Amendment 279QG, my noble friend Lady Cass has already very ably explained that the difference between an isolated incident and a recognised pattern of harm is often merely the existence of a reporting system. Without that system, warnings are missed, patterns remain invisible and children continue to be exposed. Government Ministers tell us time and again that technology moves too fast for us to anticipate risk and harm, but the record tells a different story. In recent weeks, we have seen headlines across the world about hacked fridges and the dangers of AI toys, as though these were entirely unforeseen developments. In fact, I warned about the risk of connected fridges in 2021, yet only a few weeks ago the Government refused to include food production and distribution in the cyber security Bill. I also instigated a campaign about the risk of AI toys during Covid, and only now are we seeing action. The problem is not the risks emerging too quickly; it is that we respond to the warnings too slowly. We repeatedly make the mistake of failing to act on evidence for an absence of evidence itself, and it is children who pay the price for our delay, yet Governments of all stripes have resisted proposals for the very systems that would allow us to identify those warnings before more harm is done. In the case of online safety, the warnings are all around us. Parents, children and front-line professionals are telling us what they see, but their evidence is too often dismissed as anecdotal rather than recognised as the early warning signs of emerging harm. Tech sector lobbyists insist that evidence is inconclusive, even as recent court disclosures reveal that companies have known about harms associated with their products for years and fought tooth and nail to keep that knowledge secret. Meanwhile Ofcom, our regulator, sets the bar for evidence so high that it has failed to implement certain parts of the Online Safety Act as Parliament intended. For example, Section 11 requires “giving separate consideration to children in different age groups” while Section 12 requires providers to “mitigate and manage the risks of harm to children in different age groups”. Yet Ofcom has said: “we do not currently have a sufficient evidence base on the risk of harm for different age groups”. In 2025, two years after Royal Assent, it called for more research “to build our evidence base to develop additional measures to strengthen our Codes”. More than 18 months later—nearly four years after Royal Assent, which itself came after an eight-year process—those age-differentiated protections are still absent from the children’s codes. That is 12 years in total—there is the maths.
Anyone who has spent time with a child knows that a five year-old and a 15 year-old need different protections. Yet we have created a vicious circle where front-line professionals see harms, their observations are not systematically gathered, the regulator says that the evidence is insufficient and the children are left exposed. It is a cycle that has been repeated across multiple risk factors and harms, and it has undermined the very effectiveness of the Online Safety Act. We cannot continue to demand conclusive proof of harm before we are even prepared to collect the evidence. Nor should we allow tech companies to roll out minimum viable products, exposing children to risks that may become apparent only after launch, without having systems in place to identify emerging harms. That is precisely the gap that this amendment seeks to fill. It would give health professionals a means to raise the alarm when they begin to see those harms.
This is not a radical departure from established public health practice. We have the Yellow Card scheme, through which health professionals can report suspected adverse reactions to medicines without having to prove causation. Those reports are brought together and analysed to identify emerging patterns of harm. This amendment would apply the same principle to the digital environment. Crucially, it would allow health professionals to report suspected harms without first having to establish that digital technology caused them. That is the whole point of an early warning system: to identify risks that warrant investigation, not to wait until the harm is conclusively proven.
As my noble friend Lady Cass made clear, reporting is of little value unless someone is analysing the evidence and acting on it. That is why this amendment goes further: it would require a designated body to identify emerging patterns of harm, recommend research and alert both the Secretary of State and Ofcom. Where a credible risk is identified, the Government must take proportionate protective measures. Crucially, a lack of full scientific certainty cannot be used as an excuse for delay. We do not have to wait until harm is proven beyond doubt before taking steps to protect children. We cannot allow the technology sector to be treated as an exception to the standards of safety and surveillance that we already expect in other areas of public health.
This amendment is not a silver bullet. We still need Ofcom to take children’s lived experience more seriously, to use its information powers as Parliament intended and to ensure meaningful independent research access. We cannot afford a system in which warnings are observed but never brought together or where they are identified but never acted on. Amendment 279QG would create a route from clinical observation to investigation and proportionate protective action. It would require the Secretary of State to report annually to Parliament, including explaining decisions not to act on the advice received. I hope that the Minister will work with us to ensure that this critical gap in our arrangements for protecting children is addressed.
Baroness Morgan of Drefelin (Lab)
My Lords, I will speak in support of Amendment 161, to which I have added my name. I thank the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Leicester for tabling the amendment and explaining the situation so clearly. The origin of these practices—the changing of the NHS number on adoption—comes from the days when adoption was all about a complete and permanent break between the child and their birth family: a new name and a new birth certificate and, with them, a new medical record. But now things really have changed, as we have heard. The Adoption and Children Act 2002 requires courts and agencies to consider the child’s relationship with their birth relatives. Life-story work is now standard practice, with many adopted children keeping in contact with their birth family. We understand now that a child’s history is not something to be erased, but something to be stewarded for them for when they are ready. Yet, as we have heard, the NHS number change practice sticks to the old model. That is not to say that this change is legally stuck here. There is no legal requirement for the NHS numbers to be changed on adoption, in either adoption-related or health-related legislation. I very much hope that the Minister will take this opportunity to think about how this can be addressed. Nobody supporting this amendment is asking noble Lords to choose between safety and the need to keep a continuous history. When it comes to it, we have shown with children in similar situations that it is possible to do both. For example, a child under a special guardianship order or in long-term fostering kinship care does not have to have their NHS number changed. Their records also contain birth, family details, previous addresses and, sometimes, a child protection history every bit as sensitive as that of an adopted child. So it is happening already, but in different groups. The NHS manages the sensitive data in these cases through information governance: flagging the record as sensitive, updating the demographics, redacting, as we have heard, or restricting references to previous names and addresses. It is all happening, but with different groups of children. That protects the child without needing to clean the record. There is no reason why adopted children should be treated differently. I emphasise the point that the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, made at the start of this important debate. Last year, the Sullivan review on data on sex and gender concluded that issuing children with new NHS numbers posed a “serious safeguarding risk” and should be halted urgently. The Secretary of State responded positively, directing that the process of changing NHS numbers for people under the age of 18 be stopped with immediate effect. So the Government have already formally accepted that changing a child’s NHS number and the loss of the continuity of that record can cause clinical and safeguarding harm and they have shown that it can be stopped using the same national back-office process that the noble Lord, Lord Young of Cookham, explained so eloquently. It can be done. If it is a serious safeguarding risk for one group of children, I suggest that it should be tackled for all groups of children. I finish with some words from an adopted child, who said: “I would rather my NHS number stayed the same, because it leads to confusion of what has happened to me before I was adopted. This means key information about me isn’t easily known, like medical conditions I’ve had, and I don’t want this to lead to more problems in my future. Being adopted can make you feel out of place, like you have a big label that says, ‘Look at me: I’m different’. I’m the same boy I was before I was adopted. Even though things have changed in good ways for me, I still want to feel properly connected to who I was before”. I hope that the Minister will be able to consider practical ways of addressing this challenge.
Baroness Cash (Con)
My Lords, I am very grateful to all noble Lords who have contributed to this thoughtful and important debate on children and young people. I pay special tribute to a number of Peers who have repeatedly, and with enormous expertise, brought to the House the issues of the digital exposure of children. Notably, I thank my noble friends Lady Penn and Lady Barran for their amendments in this group. I also thank the noble Baronesses, Lady Kidron, Lady Cass and Lady Benjamin, and those who have supported their amendments today. Their work has shone an important light on the growing influence and damage done to children’s health and development. I know that the Minister will give this serious consideration. We have had a lot of different amendments in this group, but the theme is about ensuring that children’s voices are heard and that their health is given the due regard and attention that it deserves, particularly where differences in wait times can make such an enormous and consequential difference to their life chances. It is right to ask whether our systems, professionals and regulatory frameworks are keeping pace with the profound changes in the worlds of so many young people. Ensuring that health professionals are equipped with the right guidance and training, and that digital health technologies used by children are safe and effective, are objectives that deserve careful consideration. I hope that the Government and the Minister will take away these amendments and that, when we return on Report, perhaps we will see some versions of them from the Government. I am particularly grateful to the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Leicester for raising the issue of the NHS number. I also thank noble Lords who supported that amendment. The important quotation from the noble Baroness, Lady Morgan, reminds us that there is a human being here: a young person whose identity is so fundamental to who they are. It is not just about their healthcare; it is about feeling that continuity, respect and dignity in their life, regardless of the circumstances they are going through. I hope that, given what has already been done regarding unique identifiers in the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act, we can resolve this issue once and for all by a simple amendment in this Bill. A further amendment I want to draw attention to is the one about collating the flags that healthcare professionals are in a unique position to observe and identify. I am extremely grateful to the noble Baronesses, Lady Cass and Lady Kidron, for this amendment. This Bill is in part about the single patient record. It is about the collation of data and providing a better repository in the health service for continuity of care and the flagging of dangers. Yet these harms and risks to young people are not yet systematically collated and shared across the very people who can best advise and inform their outcomes. Sadly, in my own community, when my child was at nursery, we lost a child in the class to a blind-cord strangulation. It was quite challenging hearing the chronology of the time it took to make those changes, because that child might have been saved. I draw attention to that simply to highlight the fact that there is no time to delay with something such as this. I urge the Government to take that away and, whether it is in the form of the amendment before us today or some other form, resolve the collation of those harms and the prevention of the damage done. Given the time we have been debating, I will bring my remarks to an end. I conclude by paying tribute to so many noble Lords today. The expertise shows the House at its very best and I am very grateful to all who spoke.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Health and Social Care (Baroness Merron) (Lab)
My Lords, I am most grateful to all noble Lords for laying these amendments and speaking to them, because this is an important topic. I want to confirm that I have heard the points being made, which have gone across a wide range of issues to do with children and young people. I will endeavour to focus on the amendments, as I know noble Lords will understand. Turning first to Amendment 66, tabled in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, I can give her the assurance that the duties in the Bill on the Secretary of State and ICBs apply to everybody. The Bill deliberately does not identify specific groups. I understand the reason for her suggesting it, but it specifically does not do that: first, to protect the universality of the National Health Service, but also to avoid more of what we might call cliff edges between different groups, something that I know is of major concern across our Chamber. However, I absolutely agree with the noble Baroness and other noble Lords that national access and waiting time standards drive consistency, transparency and accountability. I draw your Lordships’ attention to new Clause 16, which already allows Ministers to set waiting times through regulations. Existing standards, including the 18-week referral to treatment and the cancer standards, already cover children and young people, and that will continue. NHS England now publishes monthly elective waiting list data, with demographic breakdowns, which comes out alongside information and targets on children’s and young people’s community service waits. We are also working to support, through NHS England, the most challenged NHS trusts, and I can give the assurance that that will continue after NHS England is abolished. I will address the noble Baroness’s other amendments, Amendments 249 and 279QN. As the noble Baronesses, Lady Cass and Lady Tyler, and other noble Lords referred to, it is a commitment of this Government—a laudable one, I think we can all agree—to raise the healthiest generation of children ever. That is why we are in the process of developing a modern service framework for babies, children and young people, which will be an evidence-based and ambitious delivery plan for ICBs to make a real step change in response to the needs of this group. The noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, asked about specific timelines. I cannot give those today because the framework is in development but, of course, when I have information, I will be very pleased to update noble Lords. We will also shortly be setting out our vision for mayoral strategic authorities, so that we can better align local services around the needs of their communities, including those of children and young people. The modern service framework will cover children and young people up to the age of 18. On a point that noble Lords have rightly raised on other occasions, it will also cover children and young people up to 25, which I know has been a matter of concern. That will be in respect of those with SEND, mental health and neurodevelopmental needs. Earlier this year, NHS England published guidance for those aged nought to 25 to support the transition, which we know has presented challenges, for a child or young person as they grow older and move through children’s services into adolescent and adult services. On the point made by the noble Baroness, Lady Benjamin, speech and language support is being provided through Best Start Family Hubs, ELSEC and Experts at Hand. There is now national guidance that ICBs must commission speech and language therapy. The noble Lord, Lord Russell, raised the matter of how we reduce health inequalities, which runs throughout the 10-year health plan. The national outcomes are set out clearly, are measurable and are core to the 10-year health plan, as I said. We have also strengthened national oversight of how we reduce health inequalities. On measuring performance, which was also a point raised by the noble Lord, Lord Russell, children’s health outcomes are already monitored and reported through the Fingertips platform and the local outcomes framework. It is therefore our view that new statutory targets would be duplicative and would risk diverting capacity away from delivering on the existing commitments. We absolutely share the ambition behind Amendment 232, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler. But it is important to set out that it is our view that the health outcomes for children are not driven by NHS investment alone. ICBs operate within a much wider system, with outcomes shaped by many wider determinants of health, as we have discussed on a number of occasions, including, for example, housing, to name just one. It is our view that, as the amendment requires ICBs to link specific investment directly to outcomes, that would risk giving a misleading picture of what is driving change and would not actually get us to the place that we seek to get to. On Amendment 161, tabled by the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Leicester and spoken to with immense understanding and support by a number of noble Lords—and I understand why—including my noble friend Lady Morgan, the noble Lords, Lord Russell and Lord Young, and the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, I am in full agreement that adopted children deserve safe, continuous healthcare, as do all children regardless of circumstances. It matters that relevant health information follows them through adoption. Specifically on the amendment, I hope the right reverend Prelate will appreciate that placing the duties in primary legislation would inadvertently—and I know that is the word—remove the flexibility to protect a child’s identity in certain circumstances where a new NHS number may still be necessary, for example to protect their safety, and I know all noble Lords will understand that. I can confirm that work is ongoing to understand the detailed policy, technical and safeguarding implications, and I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Young, for his common-sense suggestions as to various ways forward. I certainly commit to updating the Committee on progress in this regard, and I would be very pleased to meet the right reverend Prelate. We have to safeguard children in what can be very challenging circumstances. On Amendment 243, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, I share the view that decisions about the care of a critically ill child can be distressing as well as urgent, as the noble Baroness referred to. It is crucial that families and medical professionals communicate, and, where possible, that they reach agreement on what is in the child’s best interests. To this point, the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health is updating its framework for clinical practice on navigating decisions to provide, limit or withdraw treatment. There is also an NHS e-learning platform to support staff in communicating with and involving families in decision-making and de-escalating disagreement. These resources are already helping to embed best practices on shared decision-making and communication with parents across the system. Finally, I will address the amendments tabled by the noble Baronesses, Lady Penn, Lady Cass and Lady Barran. On Amendment 279P, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Barran, I assure her that the safety of digital health technologies is taken seriously. Local NHS bodies are already required to assess digital health technologies against the digital and technology assessment criteria before purchasing them. This assesses compliance with various national standards, including for clinical safety, privacy and data protection, cyber security, interoperability, usability and accessibility. On the point raised about AI chatbots, both by the noble Baroness, Lady Barran, and the noble Baroness, Lady Benjamin, yes, people are indeed using them, as we know, for mental health advice. The noble Baroness gave one example. My point would be that these must not replace trained professionals. The reality is that they can be unsafe and can give unsuitable advice. However, we do see a role for AI chatbots and their potential for safe use in routine work—for example, in making appointments, taking notes and answering basic inquiries—and any AI that is introduced into NHS services must comply with standards for safety, effectiveness, ethics and data protection. More broadly, clinical observations can provide valuable early warning signals. To the noble Baroness, Lady Penn, I say that, yes, we do recognise the physical and mental health impacts of screen time and content, and that is why we are taking a number of the actions that noble Lords have referred to. However, the amendments that propose statutory reporting systems spanning digital devices, services and content would require clear criteria and careful co-ordination with existing regulatory arrangements. On those, we feel that the priority should be to strengthen existing routes for surveillance, evidence gathering and regulatory action, rather than starting afresh. That said, I take the points that have been made. I turn to Amendment 98A—
Baroness Barran (Con)
I hope the Minister will forgive me if she is about to address this. In relation to my Amendment 279P, she went through a list of standards—forgive me, I did not capture the name of the specific standards—that included data protection, cyber et cetera. The point I was trying to capture in my amendment was the latent risk in a child having a smartphone, which allows them to do a number of other things, including accessing entirely age-inappropriate and unsafe material. I will understand if the Minister needs to reflect on that, but perhaps she could write to me if that is the case.
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I am happy to come on to broader points. I particularly want to address the noble Baroness’s amendments in respect of health technology, which made her amendments different from the others in the group. On Amendment 98A, in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Penn, through local neighbourhood health plans, local partners are already expected to reflect the needs of the whole population, including children. If necessary, we can look at whether we need to provide guidance to reinforce that message. I emphasise to all noble Lords, who have made salient points, that digital harms can be considered alongside other factors affecting children’s health, with plans setting out how identified needs will be met. To address the underlying concerns of Amendments 279F and 279G, we are already taking action to support key professionals working with children and families, providing them with tailored guidance and training. I say to all noble Lords, especially the noble Baroness, Lady Penn, that the healthy child programme is central to all this. It reinforces the need for healthy routines for screen use, alongside all the other measures that we are taking across government. I am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron, for her reflections on the broad environment in which children and young people are operating.
Just this year, we refreshed the guidance under the healthy child programme and established new high impact areas, which are the public health priorities where health visiting and school nursing can most effectively contribute. This includes guidance on screen time and screen use for children at the 12-month, two-year and two-and-a-half milestones, and digital concerns such as online bullying, screen time and exposure to harmful content. We have published screen use advice for families who have children under five, and we are preparing guidance for five to 18 year-olds and supporting the “In Real Life” trial to test whether limiting social media improves mental health and sleep, because of the many understandable concerns about that. Broadly, what children experience and what they do online can matter as much as how much time they spend online, as noble Lords have said.
I am grateful to noble Lords, who have given us much to think about. I hope that I have addressed the points about the amendments and the matters that, although rightly raised, we feel are already covered.
Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (CB)
Following this debate, which has revealed that children are not just little adults, would the Minister consider a government amendment to the Bill to ensure that all the duties of the Secretary of State are appropriately focused on the age and developmental stage of each person as an overarching policy in health? That would then be compatible and link with the healthy child programme overall in other areas.
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I agree that children are not little adults; I am not sure I can say that adults are not sometimes larger children. I understand the point that the noble Baroness makes. However, the Secretary of State’s powers and the Bill do not identify specific groups for the reasons that I set out at the beginning. I refer the noble Baroness to those, although I understand the intent behind her point.
Baroness Kidron (CB)
I recognise the acknowledgement of my broader points, but we are absolutely desperate for evidence to give to Ofcom so that its regime works. Would the Minister be willing, before Report, to talk about creating a way for clinicians to record their concerns, so that they can be taken seriously by Ofcom and to close the loop?
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I understand the point the noble Baroness makes. I cannot commit to being extremely detailed before Report, but I can commit to taking on board the point she raises.
Baroness Penn (Con)
On my amendments, I appreciate that children’s digital environment can be addressed in the existing frameworks, but my question is whether it is indeed being addressed through existing frameworks. The Minister referred to guidance and training, and I would be grateful to hear more detail on that before Report, either through writing or engagement. On the child health programme, which the Minister acknowledged was crucial, as I said in my speech, there is a reference in those two reviews to screen time and healthy routines, but that was it, as far as I could find. My question relates to that guidance and training: what confidence do we have that these things are being addressed, not just that they could or can be addressed by those health professionals?
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I understand what the noble Baroness is saying. I would be very pleased to write to her.
Baroness Cass (CB)
I thank the Minister for taking us through the measures that the Government are taking in the areas that we have just discussed, in particular in terms of monitoring things such as waiting lists. I appreciate that there is all-age monitoring; that is a significant theme of the Minister’s comments in not separating children and young people from adults in the Bill. However, the reason why we have brought this group of amendments—which range from system level through our very broad concerns about the digital environment to some specific things, such as NHS numbers and children close to death—is because it represents a package of concerns about things that we feel are not working. You might almost think that we have colluded across the Chamber to pull this together. Although we appreciate that much is going on, none the less, it is not reassuring for us to feel that things are being monitored unless there is a plan for taking action. It remains the case that children’s outcomes and processes, such as waiting times, are falling behind those of adults and of children in other European countries. Adolescents, in particular, are different from others within the NHS in that they fall between the cracks of the children’s and adult services. We cannot afford to wait too long to do something about that significant gap. For all the reasons that we have said, the digital issues require us to be as proactive as possible. I am sure that some of us will be beating a track to the Minister’s door between now and Report on some of these issues. I thank colleagues across the Committee for their contributions. With that, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment 66 withdrawn.
Amendments 67 to 69 not moved.
Clause 16 agreed.
Amendment 70
Moved by
70: After Clause 16, insert the following new Clause— “Reservation and prioritisation of contracts for the voluntary, community and social enterprise sector(1) In exercising their commissioning functions, integrated care boards must take reasonable steps to secure the participation of voluntary, community and social enterprise organisations in the provision of services.(2) The Secretary of State must by regulations made by statutory instrument enable integrated care boards to reserve and prioritise contracts to be delivered by voluntary, community and social enterprise organisations as part of their commissioning process.(3) Circumstances in which contracts may be appropriate to be reserved and prioritised under subsection (2) include—(a) services that are, or could be, community-based,(b) services that are intended to reach populations that are underserved, marginalised, or experiencing health inequalities, or(c) where voluntary, community and social enterprise organisations are best placed to deliver person-centred or culturally competent care.(4) In exercising functions under this section, integrated care boards must have regard to—(a) the need to reduce health inequalities,(b) the importance of securing equitable access to services across different areas, and(c) the sustainability of voluntary, community and social enterprise provision.(5) A statutory instrument containing regulations under this section may not be made unless a draft of the instrument has been laid before, and approved by a resolution of, each House of Parliament.”Member’s explanatory statement This new clause would require integrated care boards to take reasonable steps to secure the participation of voluntary, community and social enterprise organisations in the provision of services through the ICB commissioning process.
Baroness Barker (LD)
My Lords, Amendment 70 is yet another attempt to understand what is left standing from the rubble of the destruction of NHS England and how its functions might fit into what remains of and what is to be built into ICBs. In particular, the amendment looks at the question of commissioning from the voluntary and community sector, because it seems to us that that has been missed in the Bill as it stands. NHS England has had an important role—particularly, I would say, in the field of HIV—in commissioning innovative service developments such as opt-out testing. We also know that in any local area, the voluntary and community sector is generally the one that follows patients before they arrive into acute care and when they leave. Therefore, it has a more complete picture of care pathways, or possible care pathways, than some of the people who are busy commissioning in the NHS. We can look to several different places where there have been innovative models of service provision that have started with the voluntary sector and then been taken up directly by the NHS. Let us not forget that, in some specialist areas, such as neurology, Parkinson’s nurses and dementia services, it is the voluntary sector that seed-funds services which then go on to be picked up by the NHS when they have been able to prove their efficacy. Amendment 70 would strengthen the role of the voluntary and community sector in neighbourhood health plans by requiring local authorities and integrated care boards to take reasonable steps to ensure that neighbourhood health plans are co-produced with meaningful involvement from the voluntary and community sector. My Amendment 163 is about another element of this process of transition, which I hope is an oversight and does not reflect deliberate intent. Section 251A of the Health and Social Care Act 2012 underpins the use of NHS numbers as unique identifiers for patients accessing services. The unique identifier will be central to the creation of the single patient record, as we know, because it will be used to link records across providers. That section of the 2012 Act also provides that NHS numbers are not required for patients for anonymous access to providers “whose services or care are, or may be, received by individuals anonymously due to the nature of the services or care”. The Explanatory Notes for that section specifically mention, for example, services related to sexual health and any other services. In practice, this law is routinely used by commissioners and bodies such as NHS England to permit services, including sexual health care, contraception and abortion providers, to maintain separate records. They have to maintain records; let us not run away with any false claims that they do not keep records. They do. It is just that they can be kept, and are usually kept, separately from GP records. That gives statutory protection for confidentiality for sexual health and related services that dates back over 100 years. It was the Public Health (Venereal Diseases) Regulations of 1916 that established that principle, and it has been reiterated eight times since. The reason for this is not a dry matter of law and technicality. It is about ensuring that people can access services, safe in the knowledge that their records will not be shared incorrectly. For example, in certain minority communities, there is a great reluctance to go to services because they are terrified that their data will be sent to the Home Office and that their immigration status will be compromised. Solely for public health reasons and for the care of women who need to access abortion services, I think it is important that we go out of our way to specifically re-establish in law that this principle remains on the statute book and will be adhered to. With those explanations, I beg to move.
Baroness Royall of Blaisdon (Lab)
My Lords, I support Amendment 70, recognising the invaluable role of voluntary, community and social enterprise organisations. They nurture innovation, as the noble Baroness said, and provide vital services. I also support Amendment 163, because it is also vital that people have the right to use sexual health services anonymously, for all the reasons given by the noble Baroness. I will speak to Amendment 91 in my name and that of the noble Lord, Lord Russell of Liverpool. We tabled this amendment following a visit to the harm reduction unit of the Cheshire Constabulary, led by the excellent DS David Thomason. The unit provides a shining example of best practice where stalking is concerned. One of the many issues we discussed was the substantial demand on NHS services that arises as a consequence of stalking. Our meeting came shortly after the Labour Party conference, in which the Secretary of State for Health announced the introduction of specialist domestic abuse services into the NHS to combat what she called the “disease of domestic violence”, with an investment of £50 million. She said that her department would work with the NHS, abuse survivors’ charities and local government to devise what she called a “public health approach” to combating domestic abuse.
Of course, I warmly welcome this. But I ask my noble friend the Minister for her assurance that the new services will cover stalking, understanding that not all stalking is related to a domestic relationship. Stalking is not simply an issue for the police. It is also a public health problem, a mental health problem, a violence prevention problem and a patient safety problem. The amendment does not seek to create a new bureaucracy. Rather, it seeks to require the NHS to become a full partner in responding to stalking. The NHS already carries the costs of stalking, with victims suffering anxiety, depression, PTSD, sleep disorders, self-harm, substance misuse and chronic stress-related conditions, often requiring ongoing mental health support. Victims arrive in GP surgeries, emergency departments and mental health services carrying the consequences of many months or years of fear, trauma and hypervigilance. The NHS currently has to treat the symptoms whereas, as in so many of our discussions on the Bill, it could and should be engaged in prevention.
It should also be noted that the crime itself is often driven by unmet clinical need. A UCL evaluation of the multi-agency stalking intervention programme, MASIP, found that perpetrators who completed health interventions in Cheshire demonstrated a reoffending rate of just 17.6%, which is extraordinary. The evidence from MASIP is clear: where health services become active partners, risk is managed, victims are better supported and money is saved. Preventing a single high-risk stalking case escalating can save enormous costs across health, policing, criminal justice and social care. With this amendment, the NHS would become a fully commissioned partner in tackling one of the most harmful forms of abuse and victimisation, enabling the truly multi-agency response that victims deserve.
The public health approach would be of huge benefit to both the NHS and the criminal justice system, and we should learn from Cheshire’s harm reduction unit, which has demonstrated that an integrated, multi-agency stalking management system saves money. For every £1 it spends on its MASIP, it saves the state £82, as well as delivering exceptional criminal justice outcomes. I trust that the Government will look at this seriously.
Lord Russell of Liverpool (CB)
My Lords, I have put my name to the amendment in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Royall. As she said, she and I went up to Cheshire to see the poster child in England and Wales for dealing with the problem of stalking. The genesis of this was about 10 years ago, when Dave Thomason—“Dave”, as he is known to the Victims’ Commissioner and lots of other people—realised that the current system was simply not working and was not joined up. Through his own initiative, he started trying to identify professionals he could work with who could look at the problem in a more holistic way than purely through a local constabulary or criminal way. We met one of the people he was first able to get to join him as part of our visit. He is a forensic psychologist who is part of the NHS in the Liverpool area. The problem with stalking, which is happening on a vast scale and with a huge knock-on effect and cost, is that there are different types. The different types of stalker can best be identified early on by somebody with the right psychiatric and psychological insight and experience, who understands very quickly what they are dealing with, what degree of harm it potentially involves, what behaviour one might expect and how best to protect the victim. That works and has been honed and fine-tuned over the past 10 years. Unfortunately, it is still the case, as we were told, that although Cheshire has an amazing process that looks after people so well, in an instance where somebody who lives in Cheshire is being stalked but the stalker lives over the border in Staffordshire, the ability of the harm reduction unit to work in an integrated way to deal with the stalker, as well as the person being stalked, is severely limited. This amendment therefore seeks to recognise not only that the impact on the NHS of stalking is a very considerable drain on services and cost but that there is a real need for the professional expertise within the NHS to be plugged in, as business as normal, with units such as the harm reduction unit to make it all work. Where we have examples of best practice and we have looked at the elements that make it work, we have seen that it is infinitely possible for that to be rolled out elsewhere. In this country, we have a besetting habit of trying to reinvent the wheel in our own image repeatedly. This amendment derives from an example of something that is not only working but working extraordinarily well. The individuals whom we met during this visit and who come from the NHS are entirely sold on the principle that the NHS should be integrally involved in this sort of approach. I hope that the Government are prepared to listen to what works, and I look forward to the Minister’s response.
Baroness Coffey (Con)
My Lords, I tabled the stand part notices for Clauses 42 and 43 simply to try to understand how they will work in practice, because, regrettably, I did not get a full understanding from the Explanatory Notes. I also want to make sure that dispensing doctors, who are often used in rural areas, would not be penalised, and I will use this opportunity to explain why that role should be enhanced. The recent Policy Exchange report T he R ural P enalty gives a particular example of where the MenB vaccination was not made available to rural doctors who had that dispensing capability. That felt like a missed opportunity. Their access to medicines is quite often overlooked—that is how it feels. I was trying to understand this from the Explanatory Notes. I assume that, for Clause 43, the original proposal was about making some extra provision should a pharmacy close down, but I just wanted to check what the Government’s intention was for access to medicines in rural areas. On Clause 42, I understand the broader point that we open this up to a practice of doctors rather than individuals, but I do not understand why there was a need to remove the possibility to make arrangements with individual dentists. It says that this is “reflecting current models of NHS care”, but, as we discussed on a previous day in Committee, access to NHS dentistry is severely lacking. I am just trying to understand that. On Amendment 17, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, I agree with voluntary community organisations providing services, but I do not agree with the suggestion in her amendment that that should be prioritised ahead of other institutions. I have given examples before of where community hospitals have been shut down and the local NHS said that there would be, in effect, replacement services, but they never happened. They closed down because the community health organisation basically failed to provide nursing staff. I do not think that would have happened if we had been in a different situation where the major hospital had that responsibility. Commissioning decisions were made at the time and that community interest company is still operating, but there has definitely been a loss of certain services because of their failure to organise staff accordingly. That is one reason why I think they are important but should not be prioritised in legislation.
Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)
My Lords, I will speak briefly. I apologise if I sound a little strange; I would not have scheduled a major dental appointment at 10 am had I known the House would reschedule the timing of this debate. I commend the noble Baroness, Lady Royall, and the noble Lord, Lord Russell, for a really practical and important amendment. I hope the Government will take it on board. I also agree with Amendment 70 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, and the noble Lord, Lord Black. This crosses over and helps me to clarify the debate we had last week about public versus private provision. I very much regard the voluntary, community and social enterprise sector as public provision. It is being done for the public good, not for private profit. We all know how important it is, so it is crucial that we have this new clause inserted. I will speak chiefly to Amendment 163. The noble Baroness, Lady Barker, is the leader in this. I just saw this and thought it was really important and needed support, which is why I have swung behind it. As I was in the dental chair this morning, I was reflecting—as I said last week in the context of NHS IT contracts—that we all want to keep all our medical records private; it is a private matter. However, if we think about the biology of this, there is no particular reason that sexual health records should be any different from any other kind of health records. But we know that is not the reality, for all kinds of different reasons. I was at an event last night talking about the ongoing damage done by Section 28 over the decades, rebounding down through the generations. Attitudes towards sexual health needs should not be stigmatised, but they absolutely are. We know that, because of that stigma and the abuse attached to it, people will potentially not seek treatment unless they can be absolutely guaranteed that it will not be attached to their name. This is absolutely crucial, both in terms of individuals’ health and well-being and in the broader public health sense. We need to see sexual health issues being properly treated and dealt with.
Lord Evans of Rainow (Con)
My Lords, I am grateful to all noble Lords who have contributed to this debate, particularly the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, for her excellent contribution and the noble Baroness, Lady Royall, for her excellent amendment and example of best practice displayed by the Cheshire Constabulary. I am particularly pleased, as someone who once served in the Cheshire Constabulary, that it was described as a poster child by the noble Lord, Lord Russell. It begs the question for the Minister of how the Cheshire Constabulary’s excellent example can be shared with the Home Office to improve the performance of all police forces and avoid the situation of Staffordshire Police that the noble Lord, Lord Russell, rightly shared with the Committee. There should more ability for government departments to work together. This group of amendments raises important questions about how to ensure that healthcare services are accessible to those with particular needs and circumstances, especially individuals and communities who may face barriers to accessing support. We can all recognise the valuable contribution that voluntary, community and social enterprise organisations make in supporting local health services, particularly in reaching underserved communities and helping to tackle health inequalities. I recall that, when I was caring for my late mother, I was surprised to see the role of the local Church of England. I notice that the right reverend Prelate is not in his place, but the practical support that was given by the local church and the lay members meant that my mother had a full diary as dementia took over her life. She had something to do every day, and it was all down to those wonderful volunteers within the local Church of England church. Other amendments in this group draw attention to those who, too often, are overlooked within healthcare systems. While the appropriate approaches differ, they each seek to improve access to support and ensure that services are responsive to individual need. As ever, however, where amendments place new duties on integrated care boards or require additional commissioning arrangements, it is important that there is a clear case that existing structures are not already capable of delivering the intended outcomes, and that any new requirements generally add value, rather than creating further complexity within the system. Taken together, these amendments highlight the importance of ensuring that healthcare services remain accessible, responsive and focused on improving outcomes for those who need them most. I am grateful to noble Lords for bringing these matters before the House.
Baroness Merron (Lab)
My Lords, I am most grateful to all noble Lords who have tabled amendments and spoken in this debate. Turning first to Amendment 91, in the name of my noble friend Lady Royall, the Government’s commitment to halve violence against women and girls within a decade includes tackling stalking. I take the point that my noble friend made that not all stalking is specifically in that area. Nevertheless, this is a strong government commitment to be applauded. The Crime and Policing Act 2026 will require the Home Secretary to issue multi-agency statutory guidance on identifying stalking, supporting victims and tackling perpetrators, and healthcare authorities must have regard to it. Furthermore, the Victims and Prisoners Act 2024 requires integrated care boards, alongside police and crime commissioners and upper-tier local authorities, to collaborate on commissioning support for victims of domestic abuse, sexual abuse and serious violence; it also requires them to publish a joint strategy. I say to the noble Lords, Lord Russell and Lord Evans, that I am sure the Home Office is aware of the very good practice in Cheshire. I will of course ensure that that is known to it, but I expect that the Home Office is aware.
Lord Russell of Liverpool (CB)
The point that the noble Baroness, Lady Royall, and I were trying to make is that is fine for the Home Office to be aware of this and to be co-ordinating. What the harm reduction unit in Cheshire is hoping would be the case is that the Department of Health itself would take partial ownership of this and mandate it as best practice, and that as a matter of policy and practice, the NHS should be much more directly involved in this area, rather than waiting for the Home Office to perhaps include it in a strategy, which means that nothing may happen.
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I may have inadvertently given the noble Lord the wrong impression, but to restate: we are required to publish a joint strategy. The important thing about this year’s Crime and Policing Act is also that multi-agency statutory approach. Looking at good practice, as the noble Lord has said, is absolutely part of that. We also expect ICBs to commission specialist stalking services to meet the needs of their populations. This amendment would create a bespoke statutory health duty separate from the Home Secretary’s multi-agency framework, which I fear would risk duplication. I know that it would do so inadvertently but it could also create confusion in what is, as we are all agreed, a critical area. That brings me to Amendment 70 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Barker. The voluntary, community and social enterprise sector plays an absolutely vital role in health and social care, as we have discussed previously, but the Government do not feel that the amendment is the right route to promote its involvement. The provider selection regime already allows ICBs to weight social value and to directly award contracts to well-performing voluntary providers. The Bill also empowers ICBs to financially or otherwise support organisations whose activities benefit the health service. These routes support VCSE organisations according to local need, without guaranteeing work that others may be better placed to undertake. The concern about this amendment is that it would set a harmful precedent of choosing providers by type rather than their ability to provide—something which would go against the Bill’s commitment to neutrality with respect to providers, as we discussed at some length in relation to Clause 10. I turn to Amendment 163, which was also tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Barker; the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, also spoke to it. The noble Baronesses are right that confidentiality is essential in all healthcare settings, particularly in sexual health services. Clause 52 allows us to use regulations to set out which information can or must be made available and who can access it. Our intention is that access should be limited to the information that people need for their role in providing care, and that professionals accessing the record to provide direct care must remain subject to their duties of confidentiality. The anticipated detailed arrangements for sexual health information will need to address patients’ expectations of confidentiality. There are already important protections in law and guidance. Sections 251A and 251B of the Health and Social Care Act 2012 contain exceptions to the duties concerning the NHS number and information-sharing where information concerns, or is connected with, services provided by an anonymous access provider. Information about a person’s health or sex life is also protected as a special category of data. I turn to Clauses 42 and 43, which were spoken to by the noble Baroness, Lady Coffey. I will endeavour to assist if there are areas about which the noble Baroness is still unclear; I would be very happy to pick that up further with her. Clause 42 is a technical change. It brings the statute book on a specific area of commissioning in line with broader commissioning arrangements across primary care. It will not affect patients in rural areas who are eligible to receive medicines from dispensing doctors; they will continue to receive the same service. Clause 43 ensures that ICBs can respond swiftly when exceptional circumstances disrupt access to pharmaceutical services, while maintaining safeguards and national oversight. Section 133 of the NHS Act 2006 would already apply to a disruption affecting the provision of services by dispensing doctors as well as NHS pharmacies. Clause 43 therefore clarifies that ICBs may act in exceptional circumstances regardless of scale. It removes unnecessary provision which would require the Secretary of State themselves to make arrangements, and it clarifies that authorisation to ICBs should be given through directions.
Baroness Royall of Blaisdon (Lab)
Can I ask my noble friend the Minister for confirmation on one point? When the Secretary of State announced an investment of £50 million to combat the disease of domestic violence, I have no doubt that what she would have wanted to say is that this could be used to combat domestic violence and stalking. I would be grateful if that confirmation could be made.
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I will be very pleased to write to my noble friend with more details.
Baroness Barker (LD)
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who took part in this debate. It was a good thing to highlight the importance of the role of the voluntary sector, which often gets overlooked, not least because it tends to deliver additional services to that which are in a basic NHS-commissioned brief, and that sometimes gets lost. I ask the Minister to clarify this: am I right in understanding from what she said that Section 251 of the Health and Social Care Act 2012 will remain in force? Will it therefore still be the case that whatever detail is set out in regulation, there is still a right for people to access services anonymously?
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I believe I referred to that, but I will check what I have said on the record. Again, I will write to the noble Baroness to be quite clear.
Baroness Barker (LD)
I would be thankful if she could do that, because I stand by the point that that principle remains an important part of providing comprehensive health services, in particular public health services. With that, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment 70 withdrawn.
Schedule 2 agreed.
Clause 17 agreed.
Amendments 71 to 74 not moved.
Amendment 75
Moved by
75: After Clause 17, insert the following new Clause— “Adult gender services: service specification, data and reporting(1) This section applies to gender dysphoria services for adults which, immediately before the abolition of NHS England, were commissioned by NHS England as specialised services.(2) The Secretary of State must—(a) maintain a national service specification for the services described in subsection (1), founded on the principles of evidence-based medicine,(b) ensure that every provider of such services submits, as a condition of its contract, complete quarterly data to the specialised services quality dashboard or its successor, including outcome and complication measures, and(c) maintain a single national waiting list for such services.(3) The Secretary of State must, within 12 months of the day on which this Act is passed, and annually thereafter, lay before Parliament a report on—(a) implementation of each recommendation of the Operational and Delivery Review of NHS Adult Gender Dysphoria Clinics led by Dr David Levy (published December 2025), including the identity of the body accountable for each recommendation following the abolition of NHS England,(b) compliance by each provider with the data duty in subsection (2)(b), identifying any provider that has failed to submit complete data, and(c) waiting times, referral volumes and discharge outcomes for the services described in subsection (1).”Member's explanatory statement This new clause seeks to preserve, on the abolition of NHS England, national accountability for adult gender dysphoria services, by requiring an evidence-based national specification, mandatory outcome data as a contractual condition, and annual reporting to Parliament on implementation of the Levy recommendations.
Baroness Davies of Devonport (Con)
My Lords, in moving Amendment 75, I will also speak to Amendments 275 and 276, which stand in my name. I first apologise for bringing my laryngitis voice with me, but today’s amendments were too important for me to stay in bed. The two key themes of my amendments are transparency and accountability. Before I turn to each amendment, let me set out the context. Thousands of patients, many of them young, have been given hormones and referred for life-changing surgeries by NHS services that cannot say what became of them. The Levy review found an absence of any patient outcome data across all nine adult gender clinics in England. No other area of the NHS would be allowed to operate without knowing whether its treatments help or harm. When the NHS commissioned a study to find out, adult clinics refused to share their data, as the Government have confirmed. Their refusal should prompt more scrutiny, not more of the same. A service that never follows up its patients can never be held to account for what happens to them, so I ask the Minister: what do these clinics not want us to look at? The consequences of the failed oversight are becoming increasingly visible. As recently reported, at the WellBN GP clinic in Brighton, 78 young patients were potentially harmed after puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones were prescribed without proper checks. This is just the tip of the iceberg. In Wales, surgical referral rates were two, three or four times those of English clinics, yet this went unnoticed until freedom of information requests exposed it. Around 60 operations have since been paused. At WellBN, concerns came to light through family complaints and legal action. Neither there nor in Wales did NHS oversight find the problem. We know that where clinicians fear speaking out, failures go undetected. The chilling effect is such that clinicians in adult gender services told the Cass review they would face complaints if they delayed putting patients on hormones. Clinicians have described being ostracised and bullied for refusing to put patients through without proper exploration. This is why Amendments 75 and 275 make the collection of data a legal duty. No individual clinician should have to stand alone in deciding whether to report. Meanwhile, funding for adult clinics has more than doubled, with no NICE evaluation and no independent evaluation of what that money achieves. On top of that, the NHS spends up to £21 million a year on gender surgeries. New freedom of information figures suggest the bill this year will be more than double that, at £45 million. The cost does not end with the operation. These procedures mean lifelong hormones, monitoring and other further surgeries. In pooled studies, around one in five vaginoplasty patients needed another operation. The NHS pays for that too, with no one tracking the total. This is taxpayers’ money.
Let me turn first to Amendment 75, which concerns adult gender services. The proposed new clause seeks to preserve, on the abolition of NHS England, national accountability for adult gender dysphoria services, by requiring evidence-based national data and annual reporting to Parliament on the implementation of the Levy recommendations. It is needed because the Bill abolishes NHS England, which currently commissions these services and is responsible for implementing the Levy review. Without this amendment, nobody is clearly accountable. The Levy review covered all nine adult clinics in England. It found that provision
“does not meet the service specification, nor does it meet the needs of the current patient cohort”.
It found that there were more than 40,000 people waiting, with an average wait time of five years and seven months. It found that referrals had doubled in two years to nearly 10,000, most aged between 18 and 25. It found minimal clinical audit. The Levy review recommends outcome reporting, and my amendment would make that a legal requirement.
There is plenty of evidence of harm. A review of 39 studies found more than three-quarters of patients undergoing phalloplasty experienced complications, yet adult clinics did not automatically follow up with patients after surgery. Referrals are running at the same level this year. These are complex patients. Around one-third of adolescents seen at the Tavistock gender service showed moderate to severe autistic traits, far higher than in the general population. Those adolescents are adults now. For patients like these, there is a real risk that the causes of their distress were never properly explored. There are irreversible operations being carried out on young adults by NHS services failing to track
“either the benefits or harms of treatment”.
Although NHS England is developing an updated service specification for adult surgical care to go to public consultation next year, Amendment 75 would ensure the new specification is founded on evidence-based medicine.
I turn to Amendment 275 on gender services and the disclosure of data for research. The proposed new clause seeks to turn the Government’s expectation that gender clinics will share data into a legal duty. It would place a legal duty on every NHS-funded gender service, for children and adults, to disclose all data to ethically approved outcome studies and would make compliance a condition of contract. It would remove the practical barriers: it would protect disclosure under Section 22 of the Gender Recognition Act and would allow records to be linked where an NHS number has changed. It would require a published timetable for the Cass review data linkage study, covering everyone treated before the age of 25, with findings laid before Parliament. It would require six-monthly reports to Parliament naming any non-compliant provider.
This is needed because the data linkage study was meant to follow around 9,000 former Tavistock GIDS patients into adulthood. It was not completed because adult clinics would not share data, despite approvals being in place, as the Minister confirmed in Written Answers in January and March this year. A 2022 order already gave clinics legal protection to share data, and the data still did not come. The 2026 order makes disclosure lawful but compels no one. This is not good enough given healthy bodies are at stake. A legal duty also protects clinicians who want to co-operate, which is essential given the well- documented chilling effect that we know about.
Other countries can answer these questions. Finland, for example, has linked national records for over 2,000 young patients and 16,000 controls. It found no evidence that medical transition improved their mental health. The need for specialist psychiatric care did not fall after treatment. It rose from around one in 10 to six in 10 for feminising treatment, and from one in five to over half for masculinising treatment. In other words, other countries can do this, so I do not understand why we do not or we cannot. Here, by contrast, practices run ahead of evidence.
In the Tavistock’s own study, 98% of the young people given puberty blockers went on to cross-sex hormones. Blockers were described as a pause. For almost all of them, they were the first step on a medical pathway that continued into adulthood.
Without data linkage, the outcomes of those 9,000 young people cannot be traced. Consent is informed only if patients are told the long-term risks. Without outcome data, no clinic can honestly tell them. The Cass review called for standardised data collection as long ago as its 2022 interim report, so what are the Government waiting for? What could the objection be? The data held is private, disclosed only to the study team and used for no other purpose.
Finally, I turn to Amendment 276 on a specialist detransition service, as recommended by the Cass review. It would require a specialist detransition service within two years, separate from gender services. The service must be open to everyone, wherever they were treated: the NHS, elsewhere in the UK, abroad or online. It must provide psychological, medical, endocrine and surgical care, including for the physical effects of previous treatment. With consent, it would record why people detransition and any concerns about assessment, consent or safeguarding. It would also anonymously report findings to Parliament every year, including the lessons for commissioning and regulation.
This amendment is needed because, despite growing numbers of detransitioners and desisters, there is no government-recommended care pathway for detransition anywhere in the UK. Both the Cass review and the Levy review recommended one. The Government have proceeded with a puberty blocker trial for trans-identifying children, yet have not established a service to support those who decide to desist. While NHS England began engagement in April 2025 and consulted stakeholders in October 2025, nothing is yet in place. This is not acceptable.
Detransitioners feel abandoned. Keira Bell, Ritchie Herron and Michael Kerr each describe being moved along a pathway, with too few questions asked, and finding no way back. They speak up to ensure that others do not go through the same thing. I pay tribute to them for this, but they are the ones who we know about. We should not have to rely on brave individuals telling their stories to learn what happens.
Clinics do not record detransition rates. Around 70% of patients disengage from adult services, and no one knows why. In a survey of 100 detransitioners, only one-quarter told the clinic. Dr Stella O’Malley, whose organisation, Genspect, works with detransitioners, is confident that UK numbers are “in their thousands”. What do they tell us? More than half felt that they had been inadequately evaluated before transition. Most say their distress turns out to stem from something else, such as trauma or a mental health condition that was not properly explored. That is why detransitioners need a special clinical service run by a skilled team, including psychiatrists who understand trauma and multifaceted complications, and that service must be separate.
The Cass review found that people who regret their transition may be reluctant to return to the service that treated them. Dr O’Malley hears the same: that detransitioners are mistrustful of doctors, feeling that their treatment was an experiment, and that trying to go back would just be another, new experiment. In the absence of a national service, support has been left to the voluntary sector. Genspect’s Beyond Trans is perhaps the most comprehensive international support platform for detransitioners, offering them psychological help online. Michael Kerr, who I mentioned a moment ago, has founded Detransition Pathway UK to give others the help he could not find. He asks for three things: an NHS pathway, proper data on how many people detransition and funding support. That is what this amendment would provide.
Regret can take years to emerge, typically eight to 10 years after surgery. The large cohort over the last decade is only now reaching that point, so the numbers needing help are very likely to rise. The service should be in place before they do and be open to people of all ages.
This is personal for me. My mum died because of the infected blood scandal, and I know what it means for a family when the health service does not look after them, does not ask and does not tell. The Infected Blood Inquiry found that the truth had been hidden and the disaster was “not an accident”. In a similar vein, at the Post Office, an institution insisted that its system was sound and would not look at the evidence that it was not. In both cases, the people harmed were told nothing was wrong. The Government looked the other way. It took campaigners and journalists, not official oversight, to bring the truth out. In both cases, the taxpayer is now having to pay the price.
The warning signs are the same: no outcome data, a refusal to share what exists and staff who are afraid to speak. The first duty of medicine is to do no harm. These services have altered young people’s bodies irreversibly and at public expense, and they cannot tell us whether they have kept that duty. Transparency and accountability should not be too much to ask of services spending tens of millions of pounds of taxpayers’ money on irreversible interventions. I beg to move.
Baroness in Waiting/Government Whip (Baroness Hyde of Bemerton) (Lab)
My Lords, the usual channels agreed that Committee should be paused at around 1.30 pm to allow time for the House to be readied for Oral Questions. The debate on this amendment is therefore adjourned and we will return to it this afternoon.
House resumed.
Sitting suspended.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5439325.