T

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Health and Social Care (Baroness Merron) (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I am most grateful to all noble Lords for laying these amendments and speaking to them, because this is an important topic. I want to confirm that I have heard the points being made, which have gone across a wide range of issues to do with children and young people. I will endeavour to focus on the amendments, as I know noble Lords will understand. Turning first to Amendment 66, tabled in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, I can give her the assurance that the duties in the Bill on the Secretary of State and ICBs apply to everybody. The Bill deliberately does not identify specific groups. I understand the reason for her suggesting it, but it specifically does not do that: first, to protect the universality of the National Health Service, but also to avoid more of what we might call cliff edges between different groups, something that I know is of major concern across our Chamber. However, I absolutely agree with the noble Baroness and other noble Lords that national access and waiting time standards drive consistency, transparency and accountability. I draw your Lordships’ attention to new Clause 16, which already allows Ministers to set waiting times through regulations. Existing standards, including the 18-week referral to treatment and the cancer standards, already cover children and young people, and that will continue. NHS England now publishes monthly elective waiting list data, with demographic breakdowns, which comes out alongside information and targets on children’s and young people’s community service waits. We are also working to support, through NHS England, the most challenged NHS trusts, and I can give the assurance that that will continue after NHS England is abolished. I will address the noble Baroness’s other amendments, Amendments 249 and 279QN. As the noble Baronesses, Lady Cass and Lady Tyler, and other noble Lords referred to, it is a commitment of this Government—a laudable one, I think we can all agree—to raise the healthiest generation of children ever. That is why we are in the process of developing a modern service framework for babies, children and young people, which will be an evidence-based and ambitious delivery plan for ICBs to make a real step change in response to the needs of this group. The noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, asked about specific timelines. I cannot give those today because the framework is in development but, of course, when I have information, I will be very pleased to update noble Lords. We will also shortly be setting out our vision for mayoral strategic authorities, so that we can better align local services around the needs of their communities, including those of children and young people. The modern service framework will cover children and young people up to the age of 18. On a point that noble Lords have rightly raised on other occasions, it will also cover children and young people up to 25, which I know has been a matter of concern. That will be in respect of those with SEND, mental health and neurodevelopmental needs. Earlier this year, NHS England published guidance for those aged nought to 25 to support the transition, which we know has presented challenges, for a child or young person as they grow older and move through children’s services into adolescent and adult services. On the point made by the noble Baroness, Lady Benjamin, speech and language support is being provided through Best Start Family Hubs, ELSEC and Experts at Hand. There is now national guidance that ICBs must commission speech and language therapy. The noble Lord, Lord Russell, raised the matter of how we reduce health inequalities, which runs throughout the 10-year health plan. The national outcomes are set out clearly, are measurable and are core to the 10-year health plan, as I said. We have also strengthened national oversight of how we reduce health inequalities. On measuring performance, which was also a point raised by the noble Lord, Lord Russell, children’s health outcomes are already monitored and reported through the Fingertips platform and the local outcomes framework. It is therefore our view that new statutory targets would be duplicative and would risk diverting capacity away from delivering on the existing commitments. We absolutely share the ambition behind Amendment 232, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler. But it is important to set out that it is our view that the health outcomes for children are not driven by NHS investment alone. ICBs operate within a much wider system, with outcomes shaped by many wider determinants of health, as we have discussed on a number of occasions, including, for example, housing, to name just one. It is our view that, as the amendment requires ICBs to link specific investment directly to outcomes, that would risk giving a misleading picture of what is driving change and would not actually get us to the place that we seek to get to. On Amendment 161, tabled by the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Leicester and spoken to with immense understanding and support by a number of noble Lords—and I understand why—including my noble friend Lady Morgan, the noble Lords, Lord Russell and Lord Young, and the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, I am in full agreement that adopted children deserve safe, continuous healthcare, as do all children regardless of circumstances. It matters that relevant health information follows them through adoption. Specifically on the amendment, I hope the right reverend Prelate will appreciate that placing the duties in primary legislation would inadvertently—and I know that is the word—remove the flexibility to protect a child’s identity in certain circumstances where a new NHS number may still be necessary, for example to protect their safety, and I know all noble Lords will understand that. I can confirm that work is ongoing to understand the detailed policy, technical and safeguarding implications, and I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Young, for his common-sense suggestions as to various ways forward. I certainly commit to updating the Committee on progress in this regard, and I would be very pleased to meet the right reverend Prelate. We have to safeguard children in what can be very challenging circumstances. On Amendment 243, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, I share the view that decisions about the care of a critically ill child can be distressing as well as urgent, as the noble Baroness referred to. It is crucial that families and medical professionals communicate, and, where possible, that they reach agreement on what is in the child’s best interests. To this point, the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health is updating its framework for clinical practice on navigating decisions to provide, limit or withdraw treatment. There is also an NHS e-learning platform to support staff in communicating with and involving families in decision-making and de-escalating disagreement. These resources are already helping to embed best practices on shared decision-making and communication with parents across the system. Finally, I will address the amendments tabled by the noble Baronesses, Lady Penn, Lady Cass and Lady Barran. On Amendment 279P, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Barran, I assure her that the safety of digital health technologies is taken seriously. Local NHS bodies are already required to assess digital health technologies against the digital and technology assessment criteria before purchasing them. This assesses compliance with various national standards, including for clinical safety, privacy and data protection, cyber security, interoperability, usability and accessibility. On the point raised about AI chatbots, both by the noble Baroness, Lady Barran, and the noble Baroness, Lady Benjamin, yes, people are indeed using them, as we know, for mental health advice. The noble Baroness gave one example. My point would be that these must not replace trained professionals. The reality is that they can be unsafe and can give unsuitable advice. However, we do see a role for AI chatbots and their potential for safe use in routine work—for example, in making appointments, taking notes and answering basic inquiries—and any AI that is introduced into NHS services must comply with standards for safety, effectiveness, ethics and data protection. More broadly, clinical observations can provide valuable early warning signals. To the noble Baroness, Lady Penn, I say that, yes, we do recognise the physical and mental health impacts of screen time and content, and that is why we are taking a number of the actions that noble Lords have referred to. However, the amendments that propose statutory reporting systems spanning digital devices, services and content would require clear criteria and careful co-ordination with existing regulatory arrangements. On those, we feel that the priority should be to strengthen existing routes for surveillance, evidence gathering and regulatory action, rather than starting afresh. That said, I take the points that have been made. I turn to Amendment 98A—

More from The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Health and Social Care (Baroness Merron) (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.