Contribution
I will do my best, and your Lordships can be the judge.
I am grateful to noble Lords for teasing out a number of the challenges. I am particularly grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Kamall, for taking us back to past discussions and the tensions there are. That is realistic about where we are starting from.
The noble Lord, Lord Scriven, made broad remarks that, in his view, the amendments are irrelevant for the reasons that he explained to do with the Secretary of State’s powers. I take us back to the discussion we had last week and re-emphasise to noble Lords that we expect the Secretary of State—and all future Secretaries of State—to use the power of direction proportionately. I have every confidence that that will happen. The whole point about putting things in primary legislation is to guide all Secretaries of State about expectation, no matter who they are.
Amendments 81, 84 and 107, tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, were introduced by the noble Lord, Lord Kamall, and spoken to by the noble Lord, Lord Redwood. As set out in the Rewiring the State statement, the Government will not impose mayors on areas that do not want one. We consider that directly accountable mayors represent the strongest form of governance available. It is right that we make statutory provision for mayoral nominees to sit on ICBs, as areas with mayors will have greater powers available to them.
That said, we recognise the variation in devolution arrangements across England. I want to reassure noble Lords that, for areas without mayors, we will set out in guidance that ICBs should make appropriate provision for board members nominated by those authorities. I expect this to promote collective action, including on the wider determinants of health. We need to bear in mind that directly set out health and social care matters are not always the only determinants of health, as we have discussed a number of times; those wider determinants are so key in driving health outcomes and demand.
I understand the points about local representation and expertise. That is why, having heard those concerns in the other place, we amended the Bill to restore the requirement that every ICB includes a local authority member, jointly nominated by the relevant upper tier local authorities. I hope that is helpful.
While I am dealing with this, I will pick up the point from my noble friend Lord Bradley, who had such confidence that I would be able to simplify an answer to his question. I will be pleased to write to him and place a copy in the Library to unpickle all the points he made.
I turn to Amendment 82, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, on primary care service providers; Amendment 81A, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, on allied health professionals, which my noble friend Lord Bradley and others spoke to; and Amendment 83, tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Patel, on directors of public health. Although it is our view that we do not feel it necessary to amend ICB membership requirements, I agree with noble Lords on how essential clinical leadership is to effective commissioning. That is why every ICB is required to have appropriate clinical leaders as board members—typically, a medical director and nursing director. In addition—I hope this will be helpful on a number of the points raised—ICBs should ensure that expertise, including that of primary care, allied health professionals and directors of public health, is embedded within ICB decision-making. I emphasise that, where relevant, as it will be increasingly, that expertise should also support work around neighbourhood health.
The noble Lord, Lord Kamall, spoke to the reassurance that I want to give your Lordships: we believe in the importance of local flexibility. That is why it is within the gift of ICBs to make provision for membership and participation as they deem appropriate within their structures. That said, they have a duty to keep the membership of their boards under review to ensure the necessary expertise and experience. It is also important that boards are effective decision-makers, which is why we are removing providers from ICB boards, in line with our commitment to simplify and focus NHS accountability.
On Amendment 87, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, and spoken to by the noble Lord, Lord Patel, and the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, we have retained the requirement for an ICB to engage with its system partners in the exercise of its planning and commissioning activities, including providers of primary care services. Full engagement with providers, including primary care, is universally recognised as fundamental to good commissioning. That is the job of an ICB, as is reflected in the strategic commissioning framework.
ICBs will continue to engage local representative primary care committees. They must also comply with their duty to obtain appropriate advice from persons who have a broad range of professional expertise in the prevention, diagnosis or treatment of illness and the protection or improvement of public health. I hope that will be helpful to a number of noble Lords.