L

Lord Kamall

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

I promise the noble Baroness that I will not turn it off. I am grateful to all noble Lords who spoke in this debate, raising important questions about how integrated care boards draw upon the expertise and experience across our health and care system. I am sure that there is little disagreement among noble Lords about the valuable contribution made by allied health professionals, primary care practitioners, some public health specialists, paediatric experts and those working in secondary care. It is quite clear that effective partnerships will be essential if we are to deliver genuinely integrated services that meet the needs of patients and communities. I completely understand the motivation behind these amendments and the desire to ensure that important voices are heard within local decision-making structures. The amendments from my noble friend Lord Lansley, spoken to by my noble friend Lord Redwood, prompt us to consider whether our future arrangements adequately reflect the changing landscape of local and regional governance. For that reason, they are valuable amendments. There is a legitimate question about how far Parliament should go in prescribing the precise membership of integrated care boards, as spoken to by a number of noble Lords. One of the arguments advanced when integrated care boards were established—I remember this well from discussions on the Health and Care Bill in 2022—was that local leaders should be given greater freedom to organise services around the needs of their populations. There is a risk that, with every additional statutory requirement, we move further away from that principle. So one of the tensions in this Bill is that we want better local decision-making and to move from hospital to community but, at the same time, as identified by the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, we have Clause 11. I turn back to the Health and Care Bill. Noble Lords who remember that—whether fondly or not—will know that almost every sector lobbied to have their representative on the integrated care board or integrated care partnership. In the end, both the Government at the time and the Opposition agreed that including everyone would lead to unwieldy integrated care boards. The compromise we made at the time was something like “to have due regard to”. Many felt that that was too weak, and we still have not resolved the tension between having regard to various experts and, at the same time, making sure that integrated care boards are not unwieldy. We have to acknowledge—and I do not know how we challenge this—the hierarchies that exist. At the ICB level, there is no doubt that they are often dominated by the large trusts and that other voices struggle to be heard. At the primary care level, often it is GPs who dominate, and others, such as pharmacists or optometrists, may struggle or feel left out by the GPs seeking to represent all primary care. It just shows that there is so much granularity at that level, but we cannot put them all on the integrated care board. On top of that is the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, that, even if we did get them all on the integrated care boards, the Secretary of State could, with a swipe of a pen, decide that it is all irrelevant. While I am sympathetic to the objectives of many of these amendments, these Benches remain cautious about placing ever more detailed governance requirements in primary legislation, especially given the tension that would be created by insisting that the Bill provides for specific expertise on integrated care boards, which would leave us with unwieldy boards, recognising that we still have not resolved the issue and made sure that all voices are heard. This is why, like the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, I am hoping that the Minister will be able to shine a light and help us out, and show us the way.

More from Lord Kamall

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.