Health Bill
Tuesday, 17 November 2026
Contributions
Committee (5th Day) (Continued)
Debate on Amendment 75 resumed.
Baroness Cass (CB)
I was pleased to hear several of the points that the noble Baroness, Lady Davies, made. As I am still the DHSC adviser on children’s gender services, I will limit my remarks, because it is clearly for the Minister to respond to many of the points that the noble Baroness made, but I have already stated on the record my concern about the conduct of adult services in not co-operating with the collection of data that would have enabled children and, indeed, young adults to have better information about their treatment choices. On detransitioners, as the Committee will know, setting up services was one of the recommendations of my review. Again, there is information that has unfortunately not been shared—by a psychiatrist who probably had the greatest experience of seeing detransitioners. He had seen 75, and that is probably the largest series that was examined by a psychiatrist. There was considerable resistance to him sharing that data by the Tavistock, and he has unfortunately now died, so we have lost some valuable data. My Amendment 279QP relates to another Bill, the draft conversion practices Bill. It relates to the way in which we should assess and treat gender-related distress in children and young people. It is relevant because there is such controversy on what should be a straightforward issue. After giving evidence to the Draft Conversion Practices Bill Committee yesterday, I went to the theatre to see a production of “Cranford”. The friend I went with thought it would be quite important, given that this is such a stressful and toxic area, for me to relax and see a quiet Victorian drama that was far removed from these issues. The opening scene, which I do not remember in the book, was a father beating his son, who was dressed as a woman. So, it is an issue that follows me. On a serious note, it conveys that these practices have been going on for an extraordinary time, and I do not think that anyone in the Committee would consider conversion practice to be anything other than entirely abhorrent. The draft conversion practices Bill covers both adults and children, and it encompasses sexual orientation and gender identity, but developmentally, there are important differences between the emergence of sexual orientation and gender identity. It is normal for young people to go through a period of sexual exploration and become clear about their sexual orientation at different ages, although for some, it is a matter of certainty from a very young age. Clearly, there is a complex interplay of biological, genetic and prenatal factors that we do not understand. However, it is clear that this is not a transient phenomenon, regardless of the complexity of family and social circumstances, and that is why conversion therapy is not only abusive but ineffective, even with the consent of the individual. Gender incongruence or dysphoria in children has much more complex origins and mixed outcomes, and it can be transient. In some cases, biopsychosocial determinants mean that the young person can go on and have a stable trans identity into adulthood. For them, a medical or surgical pathway may be the only way that they can live comfortably without ongoing distress. However, for many other children and young people, the transgender identification may be a response to a wide range of other issues, including confusion or rejection of being gay, bodily or psychological distress, feeling different—possibly related to a diagnosis of autism and not feeling that they belong in their peer group or same-sex group—trauma and early stressors or sometimes very premature social transition by parents. All these presentations have been described in my review and in a wide range of publications. They have also been seen by clinical staff in the first two years of the new services. In those instances, careful exploration with the child or young person may sometimes lead to the realisation that their gender dysphoria was related to other factors. In some cases, they may revert to their birth-registered gender identity and in some cases they may not. It is important to state that such exploration is not driven by a preference for one outcome over another—something that is already unacceptable in clinical practice—but rather by the recognition that taking an irreversible medical step when the underlying condition may have been transient will lock that young person into a lifetime of medical treatment. If the trans identity proves to be enduring and stable, the cost of medical treatment in terms of risks and side-effects is trivial compared with the distress of not living in their identified gender. However, it is a very high price to pay when other factors that could resolve over time might not have been identified and addressed. The majority of children and young people who go through a period of this kind of incongruence resolve it without a medical transition. Teachers will describe the fluctuation in gender identity within their classrooms. Many parents spoke to me during my review about how their child’s gender incongruence had subsequently resolved. It is therefore strange that there is still such intense polarisation about the correct approach to assessing and treating this population. If you go on social media, you will find that I am a conversion therapist, as is the right honourable Wes Streeting, as are many therapists in private practice and those in the new NHS gender services. Distress is an inevitable part of the therapeutic encounter that can surface difficult or painful feelings. It is all too easy for a young person to leave a consultation feeling hurt, unhappy and angry that they have not received the medical treatment that they want. I have seen social media posts from bad actors who are already circulating and seeking out young people online who may have had an adverse experience with a healthcare professional in this circumstance in an attempt to undermine explorative approaches. If the practitioner is then accused of having fallen far below the standards expected of them, which will then take them out of the carve-out in this Bill, by causing the young person serious alarm or distress, that leads to the question of who should determine those correct standards and how they will be assessed by regulators, the CPS and the courts. This amendment is an attempt to clarify the position, since professional organisations differ in what they believe those appropriate standards should be. I do not anticipate that the amendment will solve all these problems, since complainants might not accept the findings of my review and the standards that I am proposing. In addition, the real problem is that healthcare professionals will query why they should work in an area where they may be exposed to the risk of criminal prosecution, even if they are subsequently exonerated. This is not a theoretical risk. There are real concerns today in all four of the new services. None the less, I bring this amendment which tries to define an appropriate standard for clinical practice in the hope that it will at least sharpen focus, enable us to consider the lack of consensus and broaden the debate. There is no carve-out for parents, who are arguably at greater risk within the Bill but are not subject to this amendment. I hope that other ways will be found to protect their appropriate parenting of vulnerable children.
Lord Singh of Solihull (Con)
My Lords, I support Amendment 279QP in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Cass. She has made the clinical case with her customary clarity; I wish to add a moral one. I declare my interest as an NHS consultant psychiatrist with expertise in youth mental health. Let me begin with what is not in dispute: to coerce, threaten or abuse a person because they are gay or trans is indeed abhorrent. Those who have endured such practices have been grievously wronged. I do not doubt that the Government’s intentions in publishing the draft conversion practices Bill are honourable, but good intentions are not a legal test. Coercive control, harassment and cruelty to children are already unlawful. The question, therefore, is what the Bill adds and how its provisions will operate in practice. My concern is that unless it is carefully framed, it brings the criminal law into clinical judgment and family life—areas where precision, professional discretion and respect for the family are essential. The draft Bill adopts a broad approach to conversion practices that may unintentionally include the exploratory conversations and therapeutic engagement that are a legitimate part of any clinical assessment. Many young people who come to us are already struggling and distressed. In that state, it will be very hard to say whether any harm flows from the therapeutic assessment or the distress that brought them to us in the first place. Depending on how the Bill’s provisions are interpreted, an ordinary clinical exploration or loving conversation within a family could be alleged to meet the Bill’s threshold. My concern, which is one shared with me by other clinicians, is that the way the Bill is worded blurs the line between legitimate therapeutic exploration and unlawful conduct. Distress alone is not evidence of wrongdoing. In medicine and psychiatry, difficult conversations may cause distress while serving the patient’s long-term interest. The oncologist who gives a diagnosis of cancer causes distress; the psychiatrist who declines to validate a patient’s distorted view of reality may make the patient angry and upset. We do not call this abuse—we call it medicine. The challenge for Parliament is to ensure that legislation directed at genuinely abusive conduct does not inhibit professional judgment exercised in good faith. The draft Bill provides that healthcare is not a conversion practice, unless the practitioner “acts in a way that falls far below the standards reasonably expected of a person in their position”. The Explanatory Notes tell us that this is equivalent to gross negligence, but gross negligence is still measured against a standard. What standard? How is it set and by whom? Nationally and internationally, professional bodies and clinical authorities are yet to agree on the appropriate assessment and treatment of gender-related distress in young people. A protection that rests on contested standards is bound to invite complaints, investigations and prolonged legal uncertainty. That is why the noble Baroness’s amendment matters: it asks Parliament to provide greater clarity about the standards against which clinical conduct should be judged. Furthermore, a law need not lead to convictions to have unintended consequences. The prospect of a complaint, a regulatory investigation or a police interview may itself change behaviour. One can foresee clinicians becoming reluctant to undertake the careful exploration that good practice often requires. Some therapists may conclude that such work is simply not worth the risk. If that happens, the loss will fall on vulnerable young people who need clinicians capable of exploring, rather than assuming, the causes of their distress. For parents, the position raises a different concern. As the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, pointed out, parents have no equivalent statutory carve-out. That naturally raises questions about how ordinary parental conversations might be viewed if disputes later arise about what was said and why. The same lack of clarity that troubles clinicians will trouble families too. Here I come to my moral point: the family is not a creature of the state. Parents were guiding their children through doubt, uncertainty and adolescence long before any statute. An anxious or frightened child turns to a parent in the middle of the night, not to a Minister. Our law has long recognised the importance of family life. In public law proceedings, the family courts reserve compulsory intervention for cases in which a child is suffering or likely to suffer significant harm. The right to respect for private and family life is likewise deeply embedded in our law. Every parent of an adolescent knows that the words “wait”, “not yet” and “let’s think us about this” may sometimes cause anger, frustration or distress, but these are also very often the words of prudence, responsibility and love. A free society should not leave parents unsure whether their ordinary efforts to guide and support their children may later be construed as an offence.
The Minister assured the Committee that the Bill is not intended to regulate legitimate medical care or interfere with ordinary parenting. I accept that assurance as sincerely given, but the courts have to give effect to the words enacted by Parliament. Hence, ministerial assurances are at their strongest when the legislation itself clearly reflects them. We should protect the abused, and if the law falls short we should strengthen it, but we should also ensure that clinicians can undertake careful, evidence-based assessments, and that parents can continue to guide and support their children without fear that ordinary conversations may later be misconstrued. For these reasons, I strongly support Amendment 279QP.
Baroness Barker (LD)
My Lords, this is a very important debate on a very important set of amendments. It is important that we recognise at the outset that data and information exist within a context. We are talking about gathering this data in the context of a campaign that has run for the past 10 years, with a constant theme throughout: that being trans is bad and that trans people are a danger to the rest of us. Day after day, we see articles in our newspapers and other media with that subtext. It is a very clever, extensive and well-funded campaign, and has gathered a lot of traction by sheer force of repetition. We already have within the NHS requirements to gather data. Also, principally because of the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, we are working towards an emerging dataset gathered in a neutral way. I happen to be a member of a community that has quite often been on the receiving end of dodgy dossiers and so on produced by those who do not like LGBT people, all using data gathered in a particular way to come to a certain conclusion. This is a welcome moment to throw light on all this. Actually, trans people deserve to have services that are evidence based and to know that the medicine being practised on them is done correctly. They would welcome greater transparency, yet they are fearful of clinicians being forced to gather data in particular ways to arrive at pre-determined outcomes. That is something we need to be very wary of when we look at this. For example, I am interested to know what the noble Baroness, Lady Davies of Devonport, would consider to be “evidence-based medicine”. On her Amendment 275, in the Cass study there is already a legal route for this, but the proposed new clause would make evidence of disclosure go on indefinitely, with no opportunity for anybody to opt out. Consciously written into that is an overriding of patients’ rights. It would be good to get data on detransitioning, too. I would be interested in seeing it, because we have heard different numbers. The noble Baroness, Lady Davies of Devonport, referred to thousands of detransitioners; the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, said 75. It is important that we have reliable data before we go any further with this. I come to the noble Lord, Lord Singh of Solihull. I am an ambassador for the Albert Kennedy Trust, a homelessness charity for LGBT young people who have been kicked out of their homes, as nobody wants to know them. The large majority have been kicked out of their family homes and quite a large number of these young people, who come to us with nowhere else to go, are trans. So not every family is of the loving nature that the noble Lord described. Those young people will inevitably find their way into services. I hope that those services are understanding of them and do not treat them in the dismissive way that others may do. That is what I think the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, was trying to tell us about having therapeutic settings that are not judgmental and do not predetermine an outcome. I know people are saying that it is incredibly difficult to do that—that is what they always say about conversion practices—but I hold to this: people in religions know when they are on the receiving end of conversion practices, as opposed to kind religious ministration. The distinction is not vastly different in medical services. That said, I would welcome a greater emphasis on reliable data, but I question the assumptions that lie behind some of these amendments. Amendment 279QQ by the noble Baroness, Lady Cash, in particular, would pre-empt a whole number of decisions on matters that are currently being investigated by the process led by the noble Baroness, Lady Cass.
Lord Hunt of Kings Heath (Lab)
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Barker. We have had a very good and dispassionate debate on these issues, which is not always the case. When the noble Baroness, Lady Davies of Devonport, asked in her first amendment that adult gender services should be nationally accountable, I think she was absolutely right. I hope that Ministers accept responsibility for the way that the NHS runs and operates these services, as I do not think that that can be left to integrated care boards to undertake. Secondly, I very much take the point from the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, that evidence-based information is essential. We do need information about people who detransition and to make sure that there is proper support for them, without making any judgment whatever, which I would not seek to do. I also accept what the noble Baroness says about some young people having to leave their homes because of a lack of parental support. We have to reflect on that and accept that trying to define what a parent can and cannot do is what makes the legislation on conversion practices so difficult. We have seen that in the debate on the medical profession. The noble Lord, Lord Singh, quoted from Clause 1(3) of the draft conversion practices legislation, which is the opt-out for healthcare professionals. It says that: “Conduct which … (a) is carried out by a person towards an individual with such an intention, but … (b) is carried out in the course of providing health care services to the individual concerned … is not a conversion practice unless the person acts in a way that falls far below the standards reasonably expected of a person in their position”. This is qualified or explained in subsection (4), which relates to subsections (5) and (6). This states that “whether conduct involved in a conversion practice carried out on an individual amounts to an abuse of the individual… The question whether conduct amounts to an abuse of the individual is a question of fact to be determined by reference to all the circumstances of the case, including in particular the nature of the conduct”. Subsection (6) then describes some aspects of what that conduct might be. The substantive point here is whether, at the end of the day, clinicians will understand what they can and cannot do. This is the problem with the current definition in the draft legislation. Members may have read the article in the Times yesterday in which Zubir Ahmed, the Labour MP for Glasgow South West, speaking as a clinician, referred to what he describes as a “draft bill … wading into a contested clinical space, where live and often bitter debates between medical professionals continue to happen even after the Cass review”. He went on to say: “For example” the “key test” in the draft legislation “for whether behaviour is an offence or not is whether it is ‘abusive’ — but this word isn’t defined in the draft”. Clearly, the risk here is that clinicians will, in the end, simply not want to advise young people at all, because of the fear of what might happen to them and because what they can and cannot do is ambiguous. In the last debate, the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, talked about Section 28 of the abominable legislation passed in 1988 that prohibited local authorities so that they could not “intentionally promote homosexuality or publish material with the intention of promoting homosexuality” or “promote the teaching in any maintained school of the acceptability of homosexuality as a pretended family relationship”. It was not repealed until 2003. The important point here is that Section 28 of that Act did not make it illegal for teachers to discuss homosexuality, provide pastoral support to gay pupils or give advice about sexual health, but teachers felt that they could not talk to their students about homosexuality and being gay. The big risk here is that doctors will feel the same. I could not help thinking that my noble friend Lady Smith—Jacqui Smith—when she was a Minister in the other place, was asked a Question about Section 28 a long time ago in 2000. She said then that, although “Section 28 … has never applied to schools … it is clear that it has had a significant effect on teachers’ perceptions. In research carried out in over 300 secondary schools by the Health and Education Research Unit at the Institute of Education … some 44 per cent. of the teachers responding said that section 28 of the Local Government Act 1988 had made it more difficult for them to address the needs of gay, lesbian and bisexual pupils”.—[ Official Report , Commons, 15/2/2000; col. 471W.] Anyone who taught then will confirm that issue. The point I make to my noble friend is that, if doctors are left in any doubt whatsoever about their position on the law, they will simply disengage from being able to give advice or, indeed, treatment. We need to avoid that. The noble Baroness, Lady Cass, has put forward a suggested way forward. Clearly, as the noble Baroness, Lady Barker said, we have to await the outcome of the Joint Select Committee that is looking at the draft legislation. But in the end, this question about how absolute clarity is to be given to clinicians in particular, but also to parents in the circumstances in which they wish to talk to their young children, will have to be answered.
Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to speak after the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, who is very much an expert in this area. My remarks are supplemental to hers. I want to pick up a couple of points. The first was something said before we took a rather long break by the noble Baroness, Lady Davies, on Amendment 75, which is about adult gender dysphoria services. She said that the taxpayer is paying the cost. It is worth making the point that of course trans people are taxpayers too and are, like everybody else, entitled to the treatment they need on the NHS, whether that is a one-off treatment or ongoing treatment. It is terribly important that that is not in any way questioned.
We have recently been focusing on the amendment from the noble Baroness, Lady Cass. As the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, just said, these issues are currently being debated in the other place on the draft conversion practices Bill. It will come to us in due time, as something to which the Government committed in their manifesto, but it is important in the meantime that the debate is not one-sided. We have certainly seen a one-sided drive in the media about it.
We have discussed parents. I point noble Lords who wish to find out more about this to the website of FFLAG, a national charity focused on supporting families with LGBT+ loved ones. Many of the people active in that charity are parents. They want to protect their children from gender conversion practices. It is really important that we understand the fear that parents have and their desire to protect their children through that Bill, which they are speaking in favour of.
I have been reflecting on the Domestic Abuse Act, which quite a number of noble Lords who I see around the Committee were heavily involved in. Your Lordships’ House spent a great deal of time making that Bill as strong as it could be because they wanted to stop abuse. But there is an area of abuse not currently covered by the law: gender conversion practices and, potentially, other conversion practices. If that is not clearly identified, the support is not there for people who have suffered from it. We are not as a society taking action to stop it, and we very clearly should.
Members of the Committee might not have seen what has happened on the other side of the world, but it is useful to note that, in Australia, the National Health and Medical Research Council review has just made its interim recommendation about puberty suppressants and said that they
“should be available for young people aged under 18 with gender incongruence”.
There is going to be a lot of discussion about this terminology. It says that this is conditional, but that:
“Different treatment choices may be appropriate for different people, so the decision must be tailored to the young person’s circumstances, values, goals, and health needs”.
The acting chief executive of the NHMRC said that these are
“national clinical guidelines … to support careful, individualised clinical decision-making”.
That decision has been made in a country that has many cultural similarities to our own. The federal Health Minister is reported as saying that
“governments have a ‘clear responsibility’ to ensure Australians are receiving the best medical advice and care available”.
I hope we can all agree with that.
Lord Scriven (LD)
My Lords, this has been an important debate on a subject that too often generates more heat than light. I thank noble Lords who have spoken for the tone in which the debate has been held. In particular, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, whose review has done more than anything else to move the debate from slogans to trying to get us to follow the evidence. We should start with where the law stands today on puberty blockers, because it matters. The sale and supply of in-person puberty blockers to under-18s for gender dysphoria outside a clinical trial has been banned indefinitely since the start of 2025 and the PATHWAYS trial has now been approved by the regulator. In March this year, NHS England paused new prescriptions of cross-sex hormones for under-18s. In February, the Government laid an order under the Gender Recognition Act so that the data linkage study can lawfully go ahead. A great deal has changed, but this Bill will abolish NHS England and almost every one of those commitments lives in NHS England’s policy documents, not in law. The question for the Committee is simple: when that body goes, who will hold the pen and who will answer to Parliament? I would welcome the Minister’s answer to that. These Benches—as I am sure all Benches do— approach this from three principles: the evidence should lead; every person who walks into a clinic, whether they are seeking to transition, to explore or to detransition, deserves dignity and proper care; and people’s privacy must be protected. I do not believe that those principles are in conflict, as the review of the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, showed. They all belong together. On Amendment 75, the Levy review found that waits for a first appointment were heading towards 15 years and that clinics could not say whether the treatment they gave had worked, because outcomes were not systematically recorded. A national specification, national commissioning, outcome data and a single waiting list are not an attack on anybody; they are what you would expect of any other specialised service. As the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, said, this is probably not the responsibility of an ICB. Can the Minister tell us who will be accountable for each of Dr Levy’s 20 recommendations once NHS England has gone? On the list of specialised commissioning, do the Government expect this to be a national commissioning service or a local ICB commissioning service? I turn to Amendment 275 on the data duty. The noble Baroness, Lady Davies, raised some important points, but, as my noble friend Lady Barker said, we have to consider the context of what is happening in looking at a data duty. Six of the seven adult clinics did not give data to the Cass review. This is not acceptable for any public body or any publicly funded service. It has left us with a bit of a gap for young people in terms of what happened to those who went before them. A legal duty may be justified, but, because this is some of the most sensitive data that the NHS holds, the safeguards matter—ethical approval, pseudonymisation and use for that study only. Can the Minister say whether the February order does the job for the Cass study? If so, will such orders extend that same protection to other approved studies? There is an issue, as my noble friend Lady Barker said, about the time limit on collecting such data. On Amendment 276, people who detransition have often been invisible—unwelcome in some gender services and unknown to everybody else. They deserve care without judgment. The Government have told this House that consultation on a service specification will not come until autumn 2027. A statutory deadline and anonymised annual reporting would help us learn. Learning is not blaming, and that is the point. Is that timeline still applicable? In relation to Amendment 279QP, I sit on the Draft Conversion Practices Bill Joint Committee. I will not prejudge its work, but it is grappling with and well aware of some of the issues that noble Lords are talking about. Clinicians must be confident that they can treat a young person’s autism, anxiety or trauma and explore their distress without presuming an outcome and without fear that this will be called a conversion practice or that they will be held to a criminal charge. Equally, genuinely coercive practices must be outlawed, and proposed new subsection (5) in the amendment recognises that. Getting that line right matters to everybody, and I would welcome the Minister’s views on how this amendment fits with the draft Bill. Does she feel that it would be useful or not in terms of the issues that noble Lords have raised? Finally, I turn to Amendment 279QQ. There seems to be an inconsistency in the current position. If the evidence is strong enough for the NHS not to start a 16 year-old on these hormones, how do the Government explain that the same young person can obtain them from a private or overseas prescriber online, outside of any specialist assessment? Closing that gap may be a safeguarding issue, so I would welcome the Minister’s view. The review of the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, asked us to remember that these are children, young people and adults who deserve the same standard of evidence-based care as everyone else. That is not a position on either side of a deeply divided or polarised argument; it is simply good medicine. I look forward to the Minister’s reply.
Baroness Cash (Con)
My Lords, I am grateful to all noble Lords who have spoken in this important group. I am particularly grateful to my noble friend Lady Davies and the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, for tabling their amendments. It is pleasing, to say the least, to see consensus emerging in this area, because we are talking about some of the most vulnerable young people likely to encounter healthcare. The amendments in this group share some objectives: the treatment of children and young adults for gender distress needs to rest on evidence, as the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, rightly pointed out; and we must be absolutely clear on who is accountable for the services provided to them. I support my noble friend’s Amendments 75, 275 and 276, which really amount to questions about accountability. I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, for saving me from making some of the same points and asking some of the same questions of the Minister. I largely agree with what he posed in respect of accountability around the standards of care to be applied. I am also grateful for the expertise of the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, and the noble Lord, Lord Singh, to whom I defer as practitioners with expertise in the care of children, and in mental health and therapeutic care in the case of the noble Lord. Evidence is being heard by the Select Committee at the moment in pre-legislative scrutiny, but it is an enormous worry that, listening to the medical expertise today, it is unclear to practitioners that they will be safe to carry out what everyone who has spoken today agrees on regarding the safety of care of these young people. It needs to be possible, as the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, said, to explore autism, anxiety or any of the other comorbidities we know about. We also know that a very high proportion of cared-for children present with gender dysphoria. I noted that, with her typical wisdom, the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, distinguished between sexual orientation and gender dysphoria because of the significance of desisting and detransitioning which takes place around gender dysphoria. It is far from clear in many of these young people. In fact, there is data to suggest that the majority of them desist and grow up to be young gay people. I am pleased that we have finally achieved some consensus in all this and understood that, together, our priority is the right care and standards for these young people. It is in that spirit that I have tabled Amendment 279QQ on the prescribing of masculinising and feminising hormones—I will say, “cross-sex hormones”, if noble Lords do not mind, because that is quite a mouthful, although I appreciate the correct terminology—for children under 18. The Government deserve credit for the steps they have already taken regarding puberty blockers, a ban they made permanent in 2025. They also stopped the starting of new prescriptions for cross-sex hormones, as the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, pointed out, under the then Health Secretary, Wes Streeting, who explained in full to Parliament why he had done that, with the evidence reviews finding very limited and weak evidence to support their use. GPs have been advised not to enter shared care with unregulated providers. All those steps taken by this Government were right, and I support them.
The difficulty is that NHS decisions bind only the NHS, and there is still a bit of a Wild West. A 16 year-old or 17 year-old refused hormones by the NHS can still obtain them from a private clinic or on a prescription from a doctor elsewhere in Europe that can then be dispensed here. Without reference to, or supervision by, adequate health providers, doctors or others, this is simply not safe. We have heard all the evidence why these very powerful hormones can cause lasting change and damage to young people.
I do not suggest that this is necessarily the correct amendment or the correct wording; that is for exploration in the Committee. I tabled the amendment because, while supporting all the steps taken and the banning within the NHS of the prescribing of cross-sex hormones, I hope to explore with the Minister how to close the current loopholes. This would make a much safer environment for young people, who, as we have heard multiple times and know from the evidence, in a majority desist and resolve their gender dysphoria as they get older. I understand that there is currently a review into this matter. That has been happening for some time, but the work has stalled through successive changes of Secretary of State, and so I want to use the opportunity of the Health Bill and the debate now to ask the Minister what the Government propose to address these very worrying issues.
We know that the hormones can cause permanent risk of blood clots and possibly stroke. In a study of a large American cohort, thickening of the blood was found from testosterone change, and changes to the voice, fertility and the genital tract just cannot be reversed. These are not small harms; they are, in many cases, permanent, including infertility, sexual dysfunction and impaired bone density. As we have heard from the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, those harms are not proportionate when one thinks that many of these children, without being placed on those drugs, would have resolved in a different way.
There is real concern in society about “transing away the gay”. I cannot emphasise enough the wisdom of the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, in drawing the distinction between sexual orientation and gender dysphoria and how much I agree with her concern. We have seen instances in the US, in Bible Belt areas, where parents are posting, due to their extreme evangelical faith, how pleased they are that their effeminate gay boy child is now the little girl they always should have had, because their own religious beliefs could not accommodate the child being gay. This is an incredibly worrying area and of course we are all concerned, and no one would disagree that coercive practices should be abolished. At the same time, there are extremely vulnerable, at-risk children who need adequate care and to be protected from the unlawful, improper and excessive prescription of these hormones.
I hope that my amendment would close that gap, but I am very happy to discuss it with the Minister, and hope for the opportunity to do so, ahead of Report.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Health and Social Care (Baroness Merron) (Lab)
My Lords, I am grateful for the debate that we have had on these amendments and the points that have been put forward. I will address the amendments together as well as, indeed, focusing on the Health Bill. I make that point as I am about to turn first to Amendment 279QP tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, and spoken to by the noble Lord, Lord Singh; and my noble friend Lord Hunt also made reference, as did other noble Lords, to matters relating to the conversion practices Bill. I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, for speaking about his involvement in this matter. Of course, as the noble Lord was referring to, that Bill is subject to pre-legislative scrutiny, to which noble Lords are welcome to contribute and I certainly hope that that they will do. My noble friend Lord Hunt and the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, spoke in particular to the point that children and young people who are questioning their gender identity deserve compassionate care that takes account of their individual needs and circumstances. That is a duty upon the health service as well as upon all of us. Your Lordships’ House will know that this Government, working in full partnership with NHS England, are continuing to implement the findings and the recommendations of the review, conducted by the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, of the NHS Children and Young People’s Gender Service, which was commissioned during the term of the previous Government. I am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, for both her previous work and her continuing work, as well as for the clarity that she brings to this matter. I will speak to the noble Baroness’s points about standards for gender services, which are key. Since the review’s publication in 2024, four new regional services are providing holistic care, centered on psychosocial support. They have opened and are seeing patients on the waiting list. In April, as the noble Baroness will of course be aware, NHS England published the new service specification. I am, perhaps, saying this more for the benefit of your Lordships’ House than that of the noble Baroness herself, but I think it is worth reminding ourselves. This requires the services to use the Cass review’s holistic assessment framework and to train clinical staff using a standard professional competence framework designed by the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges. All clinicians working in the NHS Children and Young People’s Gender Service must follow the service specification. I turn now to Amendment 75, moved by the noble Baroness, Lady Davies. May I say, as she did refer to it, how sorry I am, as I am sure the whole House is, to hear of the circumstances of the death of her mother, about which she spoke before the break. I can tell the noble Baroness that the national review of adult gender services, chaired by Dr David Levy, was published in December last year. It marks a significant step forward in our commitment to improving gender dysphoria services across the NHS. The noble Lord, Lord Scriven, asked about accountability. As we have discussed in earlier groups, Ministers—in particular, the Secretary of State—are accountable to Parliament, including for these services. The point about the commissioning of these services is of interest to my noble friend Lord Hunt as well. Again, as I confirmed in an earlier group, we anticipate being able to share the list of specialised nationally commissioned services before Report. We are not expecting a great change from what we currently have. We have publicly committed to implementing the findings and recommendations of the review chaired by Dr David Levy, and the Department of Health and Social Care is working in full partnership with NHS England, which will include the publication of an updated national service specification, as I have mentioned, for adult gender services. If I had to emphasise one point, it would be that the abolition of NHS England will not impact the work to improve adult gender services. We have made public commitments on the implementations of reviews and recommendations, and that will not change. Effective governance is indeed in place. The noble Baroness, Lady Davies, referred to the WellBN GP practice. Again, I put on the record that when I talk about the “care” provided by that GP practice, I mean that it was totally unacceptable, and we are working to ensure that those affected are properly supported. I say to all noble Lords that for children and young people with gender dysphoria, and for their safety and well-being, any action taken will always be led by clinical evidence. On Amendment 275, also in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Davies, good progress has already been made towards delivering the data linkage study that is referenced in the amendment and was recommended by the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, in her review. On 20 March, an order made by the Secretary of State under Section 22 of the Gender Recognition Act 2004 came into force. That order facilitates lawful data sharing as part of the study, and I am pleased that the Health Research Authority has now improved the study. NHS England has undertaken further positive engagement with data-sharing partners and expects all commissioned adult gender services to collaborate, which is a different situation from what has existed. NHS England will also publish patient information materials shortly, marking the formal launch of the study. Study findings, reported on an aggregated and anonymised basis, will be published once the analysis is complete, and the study forms part of a wider programme of research, again as recommended in the Cass review. As is the case for all publicly funded research, all studies will adhere to ethical data and legal requirements. On Amendment 276 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Davies, the independent Cass review and the NHS review of adult gender services recommended that NHS England should ensure that there is provision for people who are considering detransition. NHS England is acting on those recommendations by developing a clinical pathway for detransition services, and the department will support this work after abolition. It is therefore our view that the amendment is not necessary. I remind your Lordships’ House that there is very limited evidence to inform this work. NHS England held a call for evidence last year, and a description of a proposed clinical pathway and detransition service will be shared for stakeholder engagement as soon as it is possible to do so in advance of a public consultation. That is likely to include proposals for improving the evidence base through data collection, research activities and clinical audit. Lastly, on Amendment 279QQ in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Cash, Section 62 of the Medicines Act 1968 allows the Secretary of State to restrict the sale and supply of medicines where it is necessary to protect patients’ safety. It is a significant order that has been used sparingly. Except in an emergency, that law requires consultation with relevant parties and advice from the independent expert body before restrictions are introduced. Those safeguards are to protect patients and to inform the decision of the Secretary of State. The amendment would require the Secretary of State to introduce restrictions for particular drugs used for a particular purpose, and it would remove the opportunity to consult independent expert advice before deciding whether those restrictions were needed. I therefore hope the noble Baroness will understand our reservations about the amendment.
Baroness Barker (LD)
The noble Baroness, Lady Cash, went to considerable lengths to say that there was extensive consensus. Not entirely: I do not accept some of the arguments she deployed. “Praying away the gay” is a line that regularly comes from anti-trans organisations that pretend to be LGB protection organisations but are in fact out to pursue a number of different strategies that are anti-trans. If the amendment from the noble Baroness, Lady Cash, went through and there was no improvement in access to hormones via the NHS, that would be tantamount to preventing people transitioning. That would be a material effect. The noble Baroness, Lady Cass, looked at that danger in relation to children. She was concerned about the non-availability of hormones and people getting them from other sources because they could not get them from the NHS. Does the Minister understand that the proposal from the noble Baroness, Lady Cash, has to be taken in the context of the improved service that she is talking about?
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I understand the point that the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, is making. I could make a number of points on masculinising and feminising hormones, but the point raised particularly by the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, and the noble Baroness, Lady Cash, was about unsafe online and international prescriptions. The General Pharmaceutical Council, the CQC and the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency have powers to investigate and act. They have our full support. I should add that last year we sought evidence on private prescribing, including online services and medicines obtained from prescribers in the European Economic Area. We are looking at the responses before deciding on next steps, because we recognise the concerns of the noble Baroness and the noble Lord. The noble Lord, Lord Scriven, asked about the order made in February this year for the study under the Gender Recognition Act. I can confirm that we are confident the order provides the necessary legal protections to facilitate the sharing of data required for the study.
Baroness Davies of Devonport (Con)
I thank the Minister and all noble Lords for their contributions today. The least we must expect from our National Health Service is evidence-based medicine and mandatory data collection, so that we can base that evidence on data we have collected that is mandatory and correct. Our children cannot be yet another live experiment, particularly vulnerable young children with complex needs. We have had several experiments over the last few decades, and the cover-up has always been worse than the original sin; it is really important that we have transparency and accountability. Historically, up to 2010, 80% of children who identified as transgender, if allowed to go through puberty with watchful waiting, desisted. A large majority of those were same-sex attracted. Puberty is not an illness; we must not treat it as such. On funding, the only funding I have ever seen is women crowdfunding to fight their cases to protect their female-only spaces. I would like to add one little thing about the experiment. I was competing with East Germans during the 1970s and 1980s. Those young women were given testosterone all the way through puberty. Every single one of those young girls is sick or ill, or died or had disabled children. We have done this experiment. Please stop pretending we have never done it before, because that is not true. With that, I echo the comments made by the noble Baroness, Lady Cash, and the noble Lord, Lord Singh, and I welcome the comments made by the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, on the unworkable conversion Bill. I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment 75 withdrawn.
Clauses 18 to 20 agreed.
Clause 21: Performance assessments of integrated care boards
Amendments 76 to 80 not moved.
Clause 21 agreed.
Clause 22: Membership of integrated care boards
Amendment 81
Moved by
81: Clause 22, page 16, line 16, leave out “mayor of each mayoral” Member’s explanatory statement This amendment, and others in the name of Lord Lansley, would ensure that the NHS can enter into arrangements with local authorities who have social care and other health-related functions and with all the new strategic authorities, including single foundation strategic authorities, and not only those with mayors.
Lord Kamall (Con)
My Lords, my noble friend Lord Lansley apologises for not being in his place; I think he was rather optimistic about the progress of the Bill. He has asked me to make a few points on the intention behind his amendments. Amendments 81, 84 and 87 are all for the purpose of including a member of an ICB from each strategic authority, not just mayoral strategic authorities, and of Clause 41 including all strategic authorities in the definition of “local authority” for Section 75 arrangements between ICBs and local authorities. My noble friend says that the noble Baroness, Lady Merron, in her letter of 11 November, said that guidance to ICBs would tell them to bring the views of non-mayoral strategic authorities into their membership. This may be possible through the statutory role of an upper-tier local authority under Clause 22, but it does not give the same statutory role of a mayoral strategic authority to a foundation strategic authority. A clear example is Cornwall, and Kent and Medway may also go to a non-mayoral foundation strategic authority status. My noble friend suggests that we can all agree that the intention is clear: all ICBs should work in co-operation with their strategic authorities, as well as with local authorities that have public health and adult social care delivery responsibilities. My noble friend asks the Minister to consider the intention and wording of these amendments before Report.
Lord Patel (CB)
My Lords, I will speak to my Amendments 83 and 241, which relate to public health. I previously spoke to a similar amendment about the duties of the Secretary of State on public health. In response to my previous amendment, the Minister said that the Secretary of State will get his advice from a clinical council that will be set up to advise him on issues related to healthcare and particularly public health. Today’s amendments are focused on what the Bill removes. The Bill removes important statutory safeguards for public health and clinical leadership, including NHS England’s duty to obtain public health advice, which was the subject of my previous amendment. In line with the Government’s ambition to strengthen prevention and neighbourhood health and population health approaches, it seems rather odd that there is no direct advice to the Government or the ICBs. I believe the Bill is an opportunity to strengthen public health representation and clinical leadership. To this end, with the ICBs’ responsibility to help develop population health, it would be appropriate to have a public health consultant as a member of the board, as there is no other clinician advising on the subject. An effective public health system must also protect public health professionals, enabling them to speak out, advise and publish in the interest of population health, even if the advice does not align with the Government’s agenda. This could be achieved by moving the public health agenda back to the NHS, but it is not happening. In response to my previous amendment, as I mentioned, the Minister said that the Secretary of State would get such advice from the clinical council. In light of that response, does she accept that my Amendment 241, which asks for a statutory requirement for a regular independent review of the public health system to assess its overall condition, identify emerging provisions and ensure parliamentary scrutiny, would be appropriate as a function of the expert clinical council advising the Secretary of State? I look forward to the Minister’s response.
Baroness Gerada (CB)
My Lords, I am pleased to support Amendment 87 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon. Many years ago, I served on a local commissioning group, working out how best to care for people with addiction problems. At the same time, I led a local drug and alcohol service. I had an interest—some would say a conflict of interest—and I declared it, but I argued then that the value of that interest far outweighed the risk of a conflict. I knew where the gaps were, who was falling through them and what would work best for patients. More recently, I served as a GP on the board of a foundation trust. I felt then, as I feel now, that it mattered to have a GP in the room where decisions were made, rather than being consulted after they were taken. The Government’s case for removing the primary care seat on integrated care boards is that ICBs should act as strategic commissioners and avoid conflicts of interest. I understand that. But the same assessment also recognised that removing a formal mechanism for collaboration between ICBs and local partners, including primary care, could make that less effective. The Government acknowledge this risk. Conflicts are managed every day through registers, declarations and recusals, as we do in this House. They are not solved by silence. A board that hears from fewer people is not neutral; it is less informed. Let us notice what this amendment does not ask for. It does not ask for a seat. For my part, I would support keeping a GP seat on ICB boards, and so would the Royal College of General Practitioners. But the amendment asks for something much more modest. It asks ICBs to take all reasonable steps to involve primary care in service redesign, in integration, in neighbourhood health and in population health planning. This means early involvement, proper information, a real chance to influence decisions, and feedback on how those views were heard. The board must then publish an annual statement. This is accountability, not capture. Primary care’s voice is also essential to this Bill. The Bill formally sets out how ICBs’ responsibility for commissioning primary care will work. The whole neighbourhood health vision rests on general practice, pharmacy, dentistry and optometry. It would be extraordinary to commission a sector and design its future without consulting it. As the RCGP put it: “GPs bring a unique understanding of how the NHS functions across organisational boundaries because they work at the interface between patients, hospitals, community services, mental health services and social care. They see first-hand where fragmentation, delays and inefficiencies create poor patient experiences and additional pressure across the system”. That is exactly the sort of knowledge that an ICB needs in the room. Like many in this Chamber, I have lived through more NHS reorganisations than we can count. When things worked, it was not only because of the change in structure; it was because of the relationships and trust between those planning services and those delivering them. The Government say that ICB chairs remain free to involve primary care, but a chair’s discretion is not a duty. It depends on good will, which rarely survives tight budgets or a change of chair. Does the Minister accept the principle that ICBs should have a duty to involve primary care in its decisions? If she does, but cannot accept this amendment, how will that involvement be secured?
Lord Redwood (Con)
My Lords, I support the amendments in the name of my noble friend Lord Lansley and spoken to by my noble friend on the Front Bench, which say that a strategic authority should have a direct relationship with the NHS, whether it is an executive mayoralty or not. We are in a long period of transition. We may not ever be in a position where everywhere has executive mayors, so it would be prudent to cover this issue. Other noble Lords in their amendments have made good points about the importance of public health and primary care, and the need for those issues to be fully taken into account by integrated care boards. I endorse that judgment, but I am not sure that it would particularly help to specify that there has to be a named person with a named responsibility on each of those boards. It would open up all sorts of questions about how they would qualify, whether they would need particular qualifications, whether they must have some other job that shows that they are involved in that contemporaneously or whether they have to have had that job previously to avoid conflict. It is best left to local areas and to those responsible for appointments to these boards to craft a board that has the right balance, while there must clearly be an overall duty on all boards that they do not neglect their involvement in public health and their close involvement in primary care—nor should anything detract from the main aim of this legislation, which is to give the principal responsibilities to the Secretary of State. I would not want to prejudge how any individual Secretary of State and the department advising him or her might think they could best understand these matters and fulfil their duties. We elect them, we have to trust them, and we get rid of them if they are no good.
Baroness Thornton (Lab)
My Lords, I wanted only to make one small remark. This has been a contentious issue from when the Bill was published. In my Second Reading speech—which I know I am not supposed to mention—I said that local authorities had been left out. They were left out when we dismantled the Lansley legislation several years ago as well. This House had to fight to make sure that they were in. This debate is important, because devolution is going on at the same time. I want to be assured that the legislation will allow those parts that are being reorganised, with new democratic methods and so on, to be properly represented, with their voices properly heard, on ICBs. Of course, most of the ICBs have already been created.
Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (CB)
My Lords, I have Amendment 81A in this group, and I declare my role as the president of the Chartered Society of Physiotherapy. I have signed the amendment in the name of my noble friend Lord Patel. When we look at strategic commissioning and those taking decisions over it, we see that one difficulty is that they need to be in command of up-to-date knowledge and evidence and to be able to horizon-scan for what is coming along. If we are to move services increasingly into the community, that evidence base needs to be maintained and strengthened so that strategic commissioning decisions do not end up increasing waste or commissioning services for which the evidence is weaker than others. On the reason that I put down an amendment on allied health professionals being involved, there has been talk about doctors and nurses being involved, but this is a completely different group of healthcare professionals. They are very highly qualified, with their degree qualifications, and they operate as independent clinicians. There are about 300,000 allied health professionals across the NHS altogether, and they have some critical roles in prevention, tackling health inequalities, moving care closer to the home—particularly during rehabilitation—and in that process getting people back to work and decreasing the sickness burden on the country overall. Previously, about half of ICBs had allied health professionals in leadership roles, but this been cut and the number is now down to four. There is a real problem here. Often those representing medicine and nursing do not know what they do not know. They are not up to speed with the evidence base for the different parts of the allied health professions. Similarly, I completely accept all that my noble friend Lady Gerada has said on the role of primary care, but when you are looking at consultant-led services in highly specialised areas, there is a wealth of knowledge that is not necessarily known at all to those who may be coming from a primary care background and representing the voice of those services at commissioning level. In order to have a complete flow across the NHS, we need to have input, however it is organised—I am not insisting on it being at board level, but it must be at consultation level—to make sure that the best evidence is brought forward to underpin commissioning decisions, so that the NHS and community services can function better and in a more integrated way.
Baroness Cass (CB)
My Lords, my Amendment 94A seeks to require every integrated care board to appoint an executive lead for children and young people aged from nought to 25. We made the case for this very strongly in the group on children earlier. Although this is a statutory role currently under NHS England, the NSPCC did an audit and found that implementation was very patchy. Large numbers of ICBs did not have such a lead or, if they did, they had this role as part of a very wide range of other duties and there was variable expertise and backgrounds in those undertaking it. With the reducing numbers in ICBs, there is a significant risk of children and young people getting lost. That is why I propose that this should go into the Bill.
Lord Scriven (LD)
My Lords, every noble Lord who has spoken has raised an important point about who should sit on an ICB board so that that board can come to an opinion about what is best for that local area’s health outcomes. However, I remind noble Lords that Clause 11 gives quite interesting powers to the Secretary of State. There are two new powers. First, NHS England in its present form cannot direct an ICB if it is performing well; under this Bill, we could have the best people with all the knowledge, but the Secretary of State can completely ignore anybody who is on the ICB and direct that it carries something out even if that ICB is working well. Secondly, and importantly, noble Lords are asking for these members to sit on ICBs so that the ICB can form an opinion on what is correct in its area. The other new power in Clause 11 is that the Secretary of State can direct an ICB regardless of whether it has come to an opinion at all. It is the Secretary of State’s opinion that matters. I say to the Minister that these amendments would be irrelevant because the real power over what an ICB does and who ultimately decides is with the Secretary of State.
Lord Bradley (Lab)
My Lords, I strongly support the amendment on allied health professionals tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay. I will ignore the fact that the amendments may be irrelevant and carry on with my speech. Allied health professionals make up the third-largest section of the health workforce and have a crucial role to play in the delivery of services. Speech and language therapists—I declare an interest as the honorary vice-president of the Royal College of Speech and Language Therapists—are one of the 14 allied health professionals. They support people of all ages—babies, children, young people and adults—who have communication disability, difficulty and differences, which are particularly relevant to eating, drinking and swallowing. They also support family members and carers of people with communication and swallowing needs, and the wider workforce supporting those people, through advice and training. Allied health professionals, including speech and language therapists, work across a range of settings such as education, health, justice and social care. It is in that context that I fully support Amendment 81A from the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, because it is critical that the expertise of the wider allied health professional clinical workforce is reflected in strategic decision-making, service planning, commissioning and the development of integrated neighbourhood health services. AHPs are a vital part of the NHS community workforce and provide essential expertise across the full patient pathway, from prevention and early intervention through to diagnosis, treatment, rehabilitation and ongoing management of long-term conditions. Their contribution extends beyond individual clinical intervention to population health, reducing health inequalities, supporting independent living and preventing avoidable hospital admissions. Without formal AHP representation, there is a risk that ICB decision-making will not adequately reflect the breadth of clinical expertise required to plan and deliver integrated multidisciplinary and preventive services. The amendment would therefore ensure that allied health professionals have a meaningful voice at ICB level, rather than relying solely on ad hoc consultation or representation through other professional groups. Without an AHP voice on ICBs, there is a risk that the AHP workforce needed for neighbourhood health and rehabilitation will not be properly planned for. If the amendment is rejected, how do the Government intend to ensure that allied health professionals and their experience and expertise are represented within ICB governance arrangements? On Amendment 81, I would be grateful if my noble friend the Minister could clarify the accountability of ICB chairs. I understand that there is a proposal that the mayor will appoint a health service commissioner as a deputy mayor, and this person could also be the chair of the ICB. This is further suggested in the Milburn review published today for the development of a youth opportunity service. In terms of public accountability and transparency, will the ICB chair be accountable to the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, or to the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government through the mayor’s office, or to both, or will another member of the Government take ultimate responsibility? I am sure the Minister has a simple answer for me.
Baroness Pidgeon (LD)
My Lords, getting the membership of ICBs right is essential to ensure that they deliver local health services for the communities they serve. My Amendment 82 would strengthen the voice of primary care within the governance of ICBs. As we heard, primary care is the front door of our health service. General practice, community pharmacy, dentistry and optometry manage the overwhelming majority of patient contacts with the NHS and play a vital role in prevention, early intervention and the management of long-term conditions. Yet too often strategic decisions are made without sufficient input from those delivering care closest to patients and communities. I read the letter from the Minister last week on this and feel it misses the important point that primary care needs to be at the table, on the board, helping to shape things, given its crucial role as the front door to much of the NHS. This amendment would help ensure that ICBs benefit from the practical experience—as we heard outlined by the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, in the example she gave from her work as a local GP—and insight of many primary care professionals when making decisions about service planning, resource allocation and the integration of care. If we are serious, as we keep debating throughout this Committee, about shifting healthcare from hospitals into the community and delivering more preventive care, primary care must have a meaningful seat at the table where those decisions are made. I am almost surprised that we even need this debate. Primary care needs to be at the core of each ICB. Amendment 87, to which the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, has added her name, would require integrated care boards to consult primary care providers when exercising their functions. Given the letter last week, I hope that the Minister may support this. Those working on the front line of primary care have an unparalleled understanding of local health needs, service pressures, the barriers patients face in accessing care, and the needs of the different communities they look after. Effective consultation is not just a tick box every now and then; it is essential to good decision-making. Ensuring that ICBs engage properly with GPs, community pharmacists, dentists and optometrists before significant decisions are taken would help produce policies that are more practical, more responsive to patient needs and, frankly, more likely to succeed in implementation. Decisions that affect local services are invariably better when informed by those delivering them every day. This amendment would help embed that principle within the operation of the new system. The amendment of the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, requiring a lead for children and young people in each ICB, is very sensible and would help with some of the issues we discussed today and last week about commissioning. The amendments of the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, are rather similar to ones he tabled on the Railways Bill about making sure we take into account the new types of authority. Again, that is very sensible. The noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, raised the important role of allied healthcare professionals at ICB level, which is important and was spoken to so passionately by the noble Lord, Lord Bradley. My noble friend Lord Scriven highlighted once again the constant tension in the Bill between centralisation, with everything going into the hands of the Secretary of State, versus devolving things to ICBs and the role they actually have. I hope the Minister will be able to shine a light and clarify all of this for us.
Lord Kamall (Con)
Before the Minister shines a light—
Baroness Pidgeon
Do not turn it off.
Lord Kamall
I promise the noble Baroness that I will not turn it off. I am grateful to all noble Lords who spoke in this debate, raising important questions about how integrated care boards draw upon the expertise and experience across our health and care system. I am sure that there is little disagreement among noble Lords about the valuable contribution made by allied health professionals, primary care practitioners, some public health specialists, paediatric experts and those working in secondary care. It is quite clear that effective partnerships will be essential if we are to deliver genuinely integrated services that meet the needs of patients and communities. I completely understand the motivation behind these amendments and the desire to ensure that important voices are heard within local decision-making structures. The amendments from my noble friend Lord Lansley, spoken to by my noble friend Lord Redwood, prompt us to consider whether our future arrangements adequately reflect the changing landscape of local and regional governance. For that reason, they are valuable amendments. There is a legitimate question about how far Parliament should go in prescribing the precise membership of integrated care boards, as spoken to by a number of noble Lords. One of the arguments advanced when integrated care boards were established—I remember this well from discussions on the Health and Care Bill in 2022—was that local leaders should be given greater freedom to organise services around the needs of their populations. There is a risk that, with every additional statutory requirement, we move further away from that principle. So one of the tensions in this Bill is that we want better local decision-making and to move from hospital to community but, at the same time, as identified by the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, we have Clause 11. I turn back to the Health and Care Bill. Noble Lords who remember that—whether fondly or not—will know that almost every sector lobbied to have their representative on the integrated care board or integrated care partnership. In the end, both the Government at the time and the Opposition agreed that including everyone would lead to unwieldy integrated care boards. The compromise we made at the time was something like “to have due regard to”. Many felt that that was too weak, and we still have not resolved the tension between having regard to various experts and, at the same time, making sure that integrated care boards are not unwieldy. We have to acknowledge—and I do not know how we challenge this—the hierarchies that exist. At the ICB level, there is no doubt that they are often dominated by the large trusts and that other voices struggle to be heard. At the primary care level, often it is GPs who dominate, and others, such as pharmacists or optometrists, may struggle or feel left out by the GPs seeking to represent all primary care. It just shows that there is so much granularity at that level, but we cannot put them all on the integrated care board. On top of that is the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, that, even if we did get them all on the integrated care boards, the Secretary of State could, with a swipe of a pen, decide that it is all irrelevant. While I am sympathetic to the objectives of many of these amendments, these Benches remain cautious about placing ever more detailed governance requirements in primary legislation, especially given the tension that would be created by insisting that the Bill provides for specific expertise on integrated care boards, which would leave us with unwieldy boards, recognising that we still have not resolved the issue and made sure that all voices are heard. This is why, like the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, I am hoping that the Minister will be able to shine a light and help us out, and show us the way.
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I will do my best, and your Lordships can be the judge. I am grateful to noble Lords for teasing out a number of the challenges. I am particularly grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Kamall, for taking us back to past discussions and the tensions there are. That is realistic about where we are starting from. The noble Lord, Lord Scriven, made broad remarks that, in his view, the amendments are irrelevant for the reasons that he explained to do with the Secretary of State’s powers. I take us back to the discussion we had last week and re-emphasise to noble Lords that we expect the Secretary of State—and all future Secretaries of State—to use the power of direction proportionately. I have every confidence that that will happen. The whole point about putting things in primary legislation is to guide all Secretaries of State about expectation, no matter who they are. Amendments 81, 84 and 107, tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Lansley, were introduced by the noble Lord, Lord Kamall, and spoken to by the noble Lord, Lord Redwood. As set out in the Rewiring the State statement, the Government will not impose mayors on areas that do not want one. We consider that directly accountable mayors represent the strongest form of governance available. It is right that we make statutory provision for mayoral nominees to sit on ICBs, as areas with mayors will have greater powers available to them. That said, we recognise the variation in devolution arrangements across England. I want to reassure noble Lords that, for areas without mayors, we will set out in guidance that ICBs should make appropriate provision for board members nominated by those authorities. I expect this to promote collective action, including on the wider determinants of health. We need to bear in mind that directly set out health and social care matters are not always the only determinants of health, as we have discussed a number of times; those wider determinants are so key in driving health outcomes and demand. I understand the points about local representation and expertise. That is why, having heard those concerns in the other place, we amended the Bill to restore the requirement that every ICB includes a local authority member, jointly nominated by the relevant upper tier local authorities. I hope that is helpful. While I am dealing with this, I will pick up the point from my noble friend Lord Bradley, who had such confidence that I would be able to simplify an answer to his question. I will be pleased to write to him and place a copy in the Library to unpickle all the points he made. I turn to Amendment 82, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, on primary care service providers; Amendment 81A, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, on allied health professionals, which my noble friend Lord Bradley and others spoke to; and Amendment 83, tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Patel, on directors of public health. Although it is our view that we do not feel it necessary to amend ICB membership requirements, I agree with noble Lords on how essential clinical leadership is to effective commissioning. That is why every ICB is required to have appropriate clinical leaders as board members—typically, a medical director and nursing director. In addition—I hope this will be helpful on a number of the points raised—ICBs should ensure that expertise, including that of primary care, allied health professionals and directors of public health, is embedded within ICB decision-making. I emphasise that, where relevant, as it will be increasingly, that expertise should also support work around neighbourhood health. The noble Lord, Lord Kamall, spoke to the reassurance that I want to give your Lordships: we believe in the importance of local flexibility. That is why it is within the gift of ICBs to make provision for membership and participation as they deem appropriate within their structures. That said, they have a duty to keep the membership of their boards under review to ensure the necessary expertise and experience. It is also important that boards are effective decision-makers, which is why we are removing providers from ICB boards, in line with our commitment to simplify and focus NHS accountability. On Amendment 87, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, and spoken to by the noble Lord, Lord Patel, and the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, we have retained the requirement for an ICB to engage with its system partners in the exercise of its planning and commissioning activities, including providers of primary care services. Full engagement with providers, including primary care, is universally recognised as fundamental to good commissioning. That is the job of an ICB, as is reflected in the strategic commissioning framework. ICBs will continue to engage local representative primary care committees. They must also comply with their duty to obtain appropriate advice from persons who have a broad range of professional expertise in the prevention, diagnosis or treatment of illness and the protection or improvement of public health. I hope that will be helpful to a number of noble Lords.
On Amendment 94A, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, I assure her that the statutory guidance that requires ICBs to have a named executive board lead with responsibility for children and young people will be maintained and will be reissued by the Secretary of State. I heard what the noble Baroness said: it might be in place, but is it happening? The intention of reissuing and maintaining that statutory guidance is to ensure that ICBs have appropriate executive leads for children and young people on their boards. In addition, the guidance will be explicit that ICB websites should clearly identify the executive board member who has lead responsibility for children and young people up to the age of 25.
Finally, I will touch briefly on Amendment 241, tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Patel. It is important that the Secretary of State ensures that the health service is working effectively, of course. It is our view that adding a requirement for a regular independent review of public health into primary legislation would increase bureaucracy. Our priority is to use existing evidence and accountability mechanisms. For example, we will hold ICBs to account through the NHS outcomes framework. The annual assessment of ICBs will also look at how they have met their statutory duties. In using the existing mechanisms, we will work to understand and improve that performance as necessary to protect the public’s health.
Lord Kamall (Con)
My Lords, I will do my best to impersonate my noble friend Lord Lansley. I am sure that he is very grateful for the response from the Minister and will, no doubt, consider this before Report. He also begs leave to withdraw his amendment.
Amendment 81 withdrawn.
Amendments 81A to 84 not moved.
Clause 22 agreed.
Amendment 85
Moved by
85: After Clause 22, insert the following new Clause— “Women’s centresAfter section 14Z35 of the National Health Service Act 2006 insert—“14Z35B Duty to cooperate: integrated care boards and women’s centres(1) Each integrated care board must, in the exercise of its functions, cooperate with women’s centres for the purpose of—(a) tackling health inequalities affecting women, and(b) improving the prevention, diagnosis and treatment including awareness of and access to treatment of women’s health needs and wellbeing.(2) The duty in subsection (1) includes, in particular, a requirement for the integrated care board to—(a) secure the involvement of women’s centres in the planning of commissioning arrangements and decisions about the provision of services relevant to women’s health, including services for women experiencing multiple disadvantage,(b) arrangements under subsection (2)(a) may include, in particular—(i) delivery of NHS services from, or in connection with, women’s centres,(ii) the commissioning of services from women’s centres,(iii) the establishment or enhancement of referral pathways between NHS services and women’s centres, and(iv) other forms of cooperation which the integrated care board considers likely to improve women’s access to health care or reduce health inequalities,(c) have regard, when exercising its functions under sections 14Z35 (duties as to reducing inequalities) and 14Z45 (public involvement and consultation), to the views of women’s centres,(d) work with women’s centres to identify, monitor and review health inequalities and barriers to accessing health care provision affecting women in the integrated care board’s boundary, and(e) have regard, in exercising its functions under this section, to any strategy or policy statement relating to women’s health published or approved by the Secretary of State. (3) In complying with subsection (2), an integrated care board must secure that women’s centres are, so far as reasonably practicable—(a) involved in the preparation and review of any strategy or plan prepared by the integrated care board that relates to women’s health, and(b) consulted on proposals by the integrated care board that may have a significant impact on the provision of services to women in its boundary.(4) In this section—“women’s centre” means a locally based community organisation within the board’s boundaries that specialises in supporting women, that—(a) is a social purpose body,(b) provides multi-faceted and therapeutic support to women experiencing multiple disadvantage, and(c) provides women-only services or facilities appropriate to the needs and safety of the women using those services;“multiple disadvantage” means a person’s experiences of two or more of the following—(a) poverty or financial exclusion,(b) homelessness,(c) victimisation including domestic abuse, sexual violence and exploitation,(d) contact with the criminal justice system,(e) mental ill health, physical ill health and substance dependence, and(f) other circumstances as may be prescribed;“social purpose body” means any body corporate or unincorporated association whose primary purpose is to advance charitable, community, social, environmental, cultural or other public benefit objectives, and whose governing arrangements ensure that any profits or surpluses are applied wholly or principally in furtherance of those objectives rather than for private distribution;“therapeutic support services” means services whose principal purpose is to improve or maintain the mental, emotional, physical or social wellbeing of individuals through therapeutic, rehabilitative, preventative or recovery-focused interventions, and includes services provided in community, residential, educational or healthcare settings.””Member’s explanatory statement This new clause would require ICBs to work collaboratively with women’s centres in assessing needs, planning and commissioning services, and tackling health inequalities affecting women, and to have regard to any strategy or policy statement relating to women’s health published or approved by the Secretary of State.
Lord Hunt of Kings Heath (Lab)
My Lords, I have two amendments in this group. Amendment 85 is concerned with women’s centres and ICBs. Amendment 210 is rather wider and concerns a duty of co-operation between NHS bodies, in which ICBs have a pivotal role to play; really, it will get us back to the debate about the role of local government in the health service. Amendment 85 would require ICBs to work collaboratively with women’s centres to support women facing multiple disadvantages to access timely, joined-up healthcare, particularly including women in the criminal justice system, by helping tackle drivers of offending and improving health and well-being outcomes. It would also help tackle entrenched health inequalities for women affected by physical and sexual abuse, homelessness, poverty, ill health, substance dependence or criminal justice contact facing severe needs and barriers to mainstream care by working with groups including the NHS, ICBs and local authorities. Many noble Lords here will be well aware—we have had many debates on this over the years, particularly more recently—of the value of women’s centres and the services they offer. My understanding is that they are particularly valuable in providing trauma-informed support and act as a bridge to the NHS and other services. Partnerships between the NHS and women’s centres exist, but often this is patchy and depends on local priorities and relationships. It is interesting that the Ministry of Justice’s Women’s Justice Board has recommended that the Government enhance the female pathway to timely, appropriate support for all women, including requirements for local operational partnership plans to involve women’s specialist services and other health agencies. I would argue that investment by the NHS in these services and supporting these vulnerable women would pay huge dividends in both the life outcomes of those women and the demands being placed on the health service. My amendment would involve women’s centres in commissioning plans and service decisions, including services for women experiencing multiple disadvantages. That might include practical partnerships, having regard to centres’ views, and identifying, monitoring and reviewing health inequalities and access, reflecting national women’s health policy. I want to make a general point about ICBs. They do not have a great reputation in relation to working with NGOs and voluntary bodies. This is a real problem. Many national NGOs do not have the resources to relate to the individual ICBs. At the local level, too, they can sometimes find that the health service shuts the door to having proper discussions. My concern about all this is ICBs’ capacity: at the same time as they are being asked to do more things, they have fewer people to do them. There is a real concern here. This is why a lot of our amendments are aimed at keeping services run at the national level. We just do not think ICBs can do this. I make a particular appeal here for women’s centres, because they are so vulnerable in terms of funding and support. Moving on to my Amendment 210, on partnership, the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, has her own Amendment 94 and her Clause 24 stand part notice, which fit the bill very well. It is really a question of how the Government see the partnership between the NHS and local government going forward. We are in some difficulty. In a sense, this Bill was written before Andy Burnham became Prime Minister. We have a very different attitude of government towards devolution, but unfortunately the Bill is rather stuck in a pre-Burnham era, although the Government have made some welcome changes, including retention of Healthwatch and, of course, the requirement now for ICBs to have a local authority member. We are still left a little vague about where this is going. My noble friend Lord Bradley has asked me three or four times who the heck the nominee of the mayor is accountable to, and I could not provide the answer.
Lord Scriven (LD)
My Lords—
Lord Hunt of Kings Heath (Lab)
I will give way if the noble Lord can help me.
Lord Scriven (LD)
It is in South Yorkshire that the first health commissioner has been appointed, and the press release—although you cannot believe everything in a departmental press release—says that the commissioner will be jointly accountable to the mayor and to the Secretary of State for Health.
Lord Hunt of Kings Heath (Lab)
That makes sense, because clearly, the ICB itself is accountable to the Secretary of State and is generally acting under delegated powers. Clearly, the mayoral nominee is accountable to the mayor. Hopefully, because there is joint responsibility, that will work well. However, the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, will then ask why Clause 24 is abolishing the partnerships between health and local government. There is another question about delegation and devolution. I have been surprised that the arrangements in Greater Manchester, where the combined authority has much wider responsibilities in relation to the NHS than in other parts of the country, have not been extended to other parts of the country. The noble Lord, Lord Stevens, is not in his place, but those changes were made basically because George Osborne reached an agreement with the chief executive and mayor of Manchester City Council. It was done without consulting NHS England, which had just been announced, and it fought tooth and nail against it. That is a great pity. I am not saying that everything is rosy in Greater Manchester—as a West Midlander, I have views on that—but there is no doubt that there is strong evidence, and I have seen research by Manchester University, to show that there have been improved outcomes because of that partnership. What one is really looking for here is some assurance from the Government that they recognise that they need to go further. We need to get this partnership working. If ever one wanted a reason for it, the Milburn report refers to the role of mayors in trying to deal with the horrendous problem we have with young people at the moment. It must have a strong health element. I am afraid this is a bit of a disparate group of amendments. It all comes back to the same thing: recognising that health and local government have to work together. I hope that the Government can respond in a way that gives us confidence that they recognise that, and that we can build on that in future.
Baroness Manzoor (Con)
Does the noble Lord agree that until budgets for social care and health are combined in a meaningful way, there will always be anomalies between the two sectors? We really need to target that in light of what has already been said.
Lord Hunt of Kings Heath (Lab)
Yes, but I point to Northern Ireland, where health and social services were brought together in 1974. I am afraid I do not think that provides a model because, in theory, they had a joint budget but, in practice, they did not and ran it separately. We have to wait for the outcome of the current review into social care before we can come to a conclusion in relation to that. In the meantime, although there is always going to be a cost shift between health and social care, I still think we can make these partnerships stronger.
Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)
My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath, and to find that we are pointing in the same direction, which is perhaps not always the case. The noble Lord has already made the case, and I think we will hear it from others, about Amendment 85 on women’s centres, so I agree and will park that one. I will focus on my Amendment 94, my opposition to Clause 24 standing part, and Amendment 210 in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Hunt. If Clause 24 continues to stand part, and depending on what we hear from the Minister, we could usefully combine Amendments 94 and 210 in some way if we need to come back to this. Amendment 94 begins with the principle that the NHS should be organised around co-operation between services, not competition between providers. It would place a clear duty on ICBs to promote collaboration and integration between NHS bodies and other relevant health and care organisations. The purpose of our health service is to meet the needs of the population. It is not to create a market in which organisations compete for contracts or where individual providers have incentives to put their own interests above the needs of patients. We have seen how the purchaser/provider split and the growing involvement of commercial providers can fragment services and make it harder for the different parts of the health service to work together. When services are commissioned separately, there is a risk that organisations become focused on their own contracts and responsibilities rather than on the needs of the patient moving between them. That is why we need collaboration. We need to ensure that commissioning decisions strengthen the NHS as a whole, provide continuity of care and support services working together. As the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, said, it is very clear that ICBs have a crucial role here. They make the decisions about the commissioning of services across large populations. Those decisions can either support collaboration or create further fragmentation.
This amendment would require ICBs to plan services with people and organisations delivering them. It is a co-creation process. It would require them to consider how commissioning decisions affect continuity of care and the long-term provision of NHS services. It would encourage NHS organisations to work together rather than unnecessarily splitting the provision between different providers. That last point is particularly important. Commissioning decisions are not simply administrative exercises. They shape the services available to patients, the relationships between professionals and the ability of local communities to access care. A decision that looks efficient on paper, just on the numbers, may have very different consequences when it breaks up an established service or makes it harder for patients to move between different parts of the health system.
I note a cross-reference with the earlier amendment from the noble Baroness, Lady Barker. This amendment also recognises the contributions of voluntary and community organisations. Those organisations often have a very detailed understanding of the communities they serve, including the people who face the greatest barriers in accessing healthcare. They should be partners in planning, not simply organisations brought in at the end of the commissioning process. I note that this amendment would also require ICBs to report annually on how they have fulfilled this duty.
I can already foresee the potential objections to this about unnecessary bureaucracy. I stress that this amendment does not require a separate report or another layer of administration. The assessment would simply be included in the ICB’s existing annual report. I also note that, despite my amendments elsewhere, this amendment does not stop private providers delivering NHS services. It would require ICBs to consider whether commissioning arrangements support integration and continuity rather than unnecessary fragmentation.
I come now to Clause 24, which the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, has already spoken about. It removes the existing requirement for health and well-being boards to prepare and publish a joint local health and well-being strategy, replacing it with a new system of neighbourhood health plans. On the surface, that sounds good, local and in line with our current Prime Minister’s direction of travel. I understand the Government’s arguments that local systems need flexibility and that planning arrangements should not become an exercise in producing paperwork. But there is a difference between removing unnecessary paperwork and removing statutory expectations that encourage organisations to work together. That is why I have tabled this clause stand part notice.
The existing strategies provide a framework for local authorities, the NHS and other partners to assess local needs and agree how those needs should be met. They provide a way of looking beyond the immediate pressures on individual organisations and considering the health of the whole population. The Government say that neighbourhood health plans will provide a more effective alternative, but a plan is not the same as a duty to co-operate. Organisations can produce a neighbourhood plan without necessarily making the commissioning decisions needed to deliver it.
There is a wider concern here. Clause 22 removes requirements for joint forward plans, Clause 23 abolishes integrated care partnerships and their strategies, and Clause 24 removes the requirement for joint local health and well-being strategies. Taken together, these changes could make it much harder for health services to work together, just when the Government say they want them to work more closely. We should be moving away from the fragmentation created by market-based approaches to healthcare, not making it easier for that fragmentation to continue.
As noble Lords are aware, local organisations already face considerable pressures. Local authorities are dealing with severe financial constraints. NHS providers are managing waiting lists, workforce shortages and increasing demand. Voluntary organisations are trying to maintain essential services on limited, insecure and all too often short-term funding. In these circumstances, co-operation cannot simply be left to good will. It needs leadership and clear responsibilities.
There is also the question of who gets to shape these plans. A genuinely bottom-up approach must mean more than asking local people their views. It must mean that local knowledge, the experience of front-line workers and the expertise of community organisations can be part of decisions about how services are commissioned and delivered. We need that statutory foundation. The Government cannot claim to want an integrated NHS while removing the structures that support collaboration. Nor can they claim to be serious about integration while failing to provide a clear duty on those making commissioning decisions. We need more than plans promising joined-up care. We need a health service that is organised to deliver it.
Baroness Royall of Blaisdon (Lab)
My Lords, I was pleased to add my name to the amendment tabled by my noble friend Lord Hunt of Kings Heath. I will make three quick points. We have spoken much about inequality in our debates on the Bill. I believe that women’s centres are vital in connecting women, especially those with multiple disadvantage, with healthcare. They really do address inequalities and they are trusted by women who feel let down by countless other parts of our system. They help to ensure that a woman’s needs are addressed before they result in a crisis. Early co-ordinated support for women also reduces the impact on our public services, and therefore the cost. I believe that the definitions of “women’s centre” and “multiple disadvantage”, in proposed new subsection (4) in the amendment, are particularly important. They would ensure that the severe and entrenched inequalities faced by women are addressed comprehensively. Providing a one-stop shop for women in a complex system would be an enormous strength. It could at times be a lifeline, including for women who have been in the criminal justice system, as my noble friend mentioned, and for women who are homeless. I will give a quick shout-out for a campaign launched yesterday by the WI, entitled No Woman Without a Home. This amendment would help those women who are being helped by the WI. There is clear evidence that the support provided by women’s centres works. This amendment would ensure that they were a consistent part of our healthcare system, enabling it to work better.
Lord Redwood (Con)
My Lords, Amendment 94 invites us to support the idea of integration and collaboration, led by the ICBs, between all the other health bodies in their area. These are two rather different words. Integration is a very popular word with those who are doing the integrating. They assume that their view will prevail, that they have the perfect answer for an integrated service and that they will make the wise decisions. But those who are being integrated might not see it like that. They might feel that the integration plan dilutes their role. It may damage their approach to the problem, which may be a perfectly reasonable approach, or it may even entail the loss of their job. The integrators normally get the good jobs; the anti-integrators are usually the ones on the losing side. It would be a pity to put into legislation a requirement that ICBs had to develop a plan for integrating local services when they might have much more pressing things to do, to sort out the quality of the services for which they are directly responsible. There may be no easy integrated plan that carries sufficient support or can be carried through without dislocation and damage to local services. It is more difficult to disagree with collaboration. It is a very warm word. Many of us here like to collaborate more than we go in for political disagreement. It is one of the characteristics of your Lordships’ House, which means that we can quite often make a contribution by working together. But the danger of embedding collaboration as a supreme virtue into this legislation is that there have been quite a lot of examples in the past—under Governments of all different hues—of collaborative working between different parts of the public sector, under loosely organised arrangements, so that no one is ever to blame. What then happens is that, instead of the collaborative working getting rid of the gaps in service or making sure that people do not fall down the gaps, there are gaps in service that none of the participants in the collaborative scheme feels it is their duty to fill; or they assume wrongly that someone else is filling it. We then have disasters, and inquiries that identify that there were strategic problems. They say it was a system failure because no one in the collaborative system—often there are many well-paid people in the collaborative system—placed themselves in a position where they took responsibility and, therefore, could take the blame. Again, I think we should proceed with caution on an amendment that, well-intentioned though it is, suggests that there is some new, higher level of collaboration out there, which has not far been achieved, that would be uniquely virtuous and uniquely wise, capable of filling gaps and dealing with service deficiencies. If you have systems that are completely integrated under a single controlling mind—or, more often, a group controlling mind—it is then difficult to get innovation and positive change, and it is difficult for people who have been badly handled by that system to get proper redress. The system closes around and defends itself. It defends all its actions, both upwards, for those above at Secretary of State level who might criticise, and certainly downwards, where patients are harmed or do not get the service they want but are told that all is perfect because, “Isn’t it wonderful that we have an integrated collaborative service?” I rest my case.
Lord Bradley (Lab)
My Lords, I add my strong support for Amendment 85 and for women’s centres in general, particularly their role in supporting women who may find themselves hitting against the criminal justice system or who have been in the criminal justice system. Since the publication of Baroness Corston’s report in 2007 and my own report in 2009 regarding mental health, learning disabilities and the criminal justice system, I have advocated, as I know many other Peers have done, for the comprehensive development of women’s centres across the country. I should declare a current interest here as a member of the advisory board of the charity One Small Thing, founded by the philanthropist Lady Edwina Grosvenor, which is developing a small residential women’s centre. The first is in Hope Street in Southampton, a wonderful facility for women in that area. Over the years, I have seen for myself the brilliant work that is undertaken to support vulnerable women, often with complex needs, in a safe place. I am a former member of the Government’s advisory board on women offenders, and we developed a strategy to reduce the population in women’s prisons with a range of initiatives to support alternative provision in local communities. Since there are only 12 women’s prisons across the country, they are often remote from the offender’s home, family and children. Women’s centres were at the heart of that strategy. The need for their services is further reinforced by looking at the women’s prison population, which is, as we speak, around 3,000. Many of those women are on remand, awaiting a court appearance, and are subsequently not sentenced or receive a short sentence, which, because of the relatively low level of offence, has already been served during the remand period. During this time, huge damage is done to the family, particularly of offenders or alleged offenders, who may lose their home or their employment and their children are taken into care—all at huge cost to the state. The Gauke review on sentencing understood this, and the Government have introduced legislation to reduce short-term sentences and, wherever possible, to impose a community sentence instead, often accompanied by a treatment order, including for mental health, drugs and alcohol. For that approach to be successful, though, the services to tackle these complex needs have to be based locally, co-ordinated and comprehensively available for vulnerable women. I believe that women’s centres are the most appropriate place for this purpose.
However, from my visits and discussions with women’s centres, charities and their advocates over the years, it is clear that there are still two fundamental problems. First, there needs to be capacity to ensure that all women have access to the services, and this may be compounded by the welcome increase in the number of community sentences. Secondly, there is a lack of long-term funding for the centres, as so clearly identified by my noble friend Lord Hunt. Across the country, women’s centres are often anxious about their future, relying on short-term grants, charitable contributions and short-term commissioning arrangements, often with a lack of a local commissioning plan to guarantee the resilience of services required in the much longer term.
I strongly believe that the immense value of women’s centres should be clearly identified in this Bill, to ensure that essential programmes are consistently commissioned in every ICB area to improve prevention, diagnosis, treatment, awareness of services and, crucially, access to them. If we are serious about reducing the number of women entering the criminal justice system, we must further develop upstream services for early intervention, such as liaison and diversion services, and community-based services supporting rehabilitation and resettlement, with women’s centres at their heart. This ambition must be embedded in this Health Bill if its mission to reduce health inequalities in every community is to be realised.
Lord Patel (CB)
My Lords, I will speak very briefly. I added my name to Amendment 85 because I am a strong supporter of the development of women’s centres, particularly women’s health centres, which are the best development that has occurred. As has already been said, women welcome these centres and feel non-threatened, but there is still a long way to go to make them ideal—but that is by the way, and we can work on that. The important thing is that it is unlikely that the old ICBs will be consistent in how these centres are developed. The noble Lord, Lord Hunt, said that maybe ICBs are the wrong place for this task. I do not know whether it is possible for the Secretary of State or the Department of Health to take over or produce a framework that demands that all ICBs deliver to a standard. I have said that I am more interested in women’s health issues, and I now recognise that there is an opportunity for these centres to go beyond that and help women who are vulnerable in any way whatever. I strongly support this development.
Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (CB)
My Lords, I will speak briefly on women’s health hubs. I declare an interest; in my role as chair of the Bevan Commission in Wales, I have been mentoring Alan Treharne, a gynaecologist who has set up a women’s health hub in Ceredigion. It is a remote area, with a lot of people coming from rural communities, with very low health literacy among some of the women who have come forward. He has found phenomenal savings to the NHS and a much faster track—particularly for those with abnormal uterine bleeding who need pre-operative planning or who have post-menopausal bleeding and are particularly anxious—and an ability to triage appropriately. The lessons from this are that the hub is not just a place for people to go. It must be equipped with adequate diagnostic facilities. It must have up-to-date ultrasound, so it can do transvaginal ultrasound and a virtual hysteroscopy to avoid women having to have an invasive procedure. It must have all those facilities there, linked with contraceptive-type services and so on, so that it truly becomes a one-stop shop that people can feel comfortable with and where they can be fast-tracked to a very high quality of accurate diagnosis.
Lord Scriven (LD)
My Lords, this been a thoughtful debate but a pretty depressing one when you think about it—not the contributions but the concept that, through legislation, we are having to ask people in a system to work together to improve services for the people who they serve. Fundamentally, that is the basis of these amendments, but it does not detract from the importance of raising the issues and us having the discussion. Let me say from the outset that, unlike the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, we on these Benches support the direction of travel in this group. Integration, collaboration and co-operation are the right ambitions. I would have thought that nobody in the Committee would argue for fragmentation, duplication and services working against each other, but that is precisely my worry. Integration has become one of those words that everybody agrees with and almost nobody delivers. Too often in the NHS, integration is a slogan rather than a reality. Every Health Act I can remember has promised it, every reorganisation has been sold on it, and integrated care boards even have the word in their very title. Yet ask anyone who has spent time in a hospital—as a patient, relative or even as a member of staff—and they will describe something quite different. Even inside one hospital, integration between services can be a no-go area. Departments on the same corridor operate as though they are in different countries. If that is the picture inside one building, think about what it is like across the whole patient pathway. A frail old person goes from a GP to A&E, to an acute ward, to a community bed and back home to a social care package, and each step is run by a different organisation with a different budget, different IT system, different targets and a different board. For the patient and their family, the experience across the health and care system can be a nightmare. This is where I completely disagree with the noble Lord, Lord Redwood. The issue is not integration; it is about accountability for the whole patient pathway. Fragmentation means that accountability is less likely for the whole service.
Lord Redwood (Con)
I was talking about trying to integrate between different bodies. I entirely agree that there should be one doctor responsible for the whole patient progress within a single hospital.
Lord Scriven (LD)
The noble Lord makes my point. A person does not necessarily have one doctor or one service; they have multiple needs. Therefore, accountability is not brought about by greater fragmentation; it is about thinking about accountability for the whole pathway, rather than different bits of it. That doctor will have accountability for only part of potentially myriad services that the patient requires. Nobody intends it, nobody designs it and nobody is accountable for the whole. That is what we have to think about. The amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, requiring a report on the duties to co-operate under Sections 72 and 82 of the 2006 Act, is indeed very sensible. These duties have been on the statute book for a long time, so it is fair to ask a simple question: have they made any measurable difference? If the honest answer is not much then we need to know why before we pile on further duties. The proposed new clause from the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, would place a duty on integrated care boards to promote collaboration and to consider the effect of commissioning decisions on continuity and long-term provision. That captures something important. Commissioning that unnecessarily fragments a service carries a cost, even when it looks efficient on a spreadsheet. The requirement to publish an assessment in the annual report would add transparency and, importantly, may change some management behaviour. Our opposition to Clause 24 standing part raises a real question, which the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, talked about. Clause 24 abolishes integrated care partnerships and integrated care strategies. That is the statutory forum that brings the NHS and local government round the same table, with a duty to produce a shared strategy built on the joint strategic needs assessment. It is hard to reconcile a Bill that talks about integration with a clause that removes one of the few statutory bridges between health and local government. This is where I accept what the noble, Lord, Lord Hunt, said: this is a pre-Burnham prime ministerial Bill. There is a serious question for the Minister to come back to on Report: in light of the fact that the rewiring the state Bill and outcomes are not ready, would it not be wise to drop this whole part of the Bill and keep things as they are, so that when the rewiring the state Bill comes, we can have an integrated health and local government devolution approach, rather than what we are trying to do, which is to come up with a system for health and then later to come up with a system for local government? History tells us that that will not work. I know the Minister will not be able to give that commitment at the Dispatch Box, but I hope she will commit to go away and talk to government and to come back on Report to say whether it is feasible. It is a genuinely helpful suggestion, based on my own personal experience as a former NHS manager and a former council leader. It is a sensible thing to think about. The amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, on women’s centres deserves particular attention. Many noble Lords have talked about why those centres are important. The amendment recognises that the NHS too often forgets that some of its best routes into care and outcomes do not start in the NHS at all; they start in trusted local community organisations that reach women experiencing multiple disadvantages—women who the formal system frequently fails to reach. Bringing them into planning and commissioning is integration in the truest sense: built around the person, not the institution, bottom-up and rooted in the community. I commend the noble Lord for his amendment and those who have spoken to it, and I suggest that the Minister accepts it. I have to be candid with the Committee: each of these amendments, valuable as they are, adds to the duty to co-operate on top of a system whose very structure works against co-operation. We keep asking organisations to collaborate while designing a system that rewards them for not doing so. The bigger picture—I accept that it is a bigger debate than this group can resolve—is how the NHS is separated into different funding pots and autonomous trusts and organisations. Acute, community, mental health trusts, primary care, social care, and public health are each funded differently, governed separately and held to account for their own bit of the journey. Each can be judged a success, while the patient’s experience as a whole is a failure. While the Minister may be positive about some of these amendments, the true issues we have to look at are who is responsible for the whole of patient care, how it is funded, and whether the Bill will deal with real integration. I finish by saying again that I hope that the Minister will think carefully about the rewiring of the state and what is suggested in here, and that she will try to come back with an integrated Bill rather than two parts.
Lord Kamall (Con)
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have spoken to their amendments in this group, which clearly raise important questions about how our system of health and care works together with voluntary and community organisations in meaningful way. We should welcome efforts to improve co-ordination and co-operation between local authorities, NHS bodies and voluntary organisations. Each can bring their different experience and expertise, notwithstanding some of the comments made by my noble friend Lord Redwood. To look at some of those organisations, the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath, and the noble Baroness, Lady Royall of Blaisdon, are absolutely right to highlight the valuable role that women’s centres play, particularly when women face complex circumstances and might find it difficult to access or trust what we consider conventional health services. Given that those centres are quite often in the community and community-led, they are run by people who are trusted by very vulnerable women who do not trust the system otherwise. As other noble Lords have said, some of those women may have been offenders or repeat offenders, and the centres keep them out of the criminal justice system when they find themselves in bad conditions through no fault of their own. This area is important not only in respect of women’s centres. Noble Lords will have heard me speak about my scepticism about, for example, top-down public health. Local community-led public health organisations include those such as BRITE Box, which goes into families’ kitchens and helps them learn to cook and eat healthily, often on a budget, and Intergenerational Music Making, which brings people of different generations, age groups and abilities together around music, often tackling isolation and loneliness. Such organisations are far more effective and can make much more of a contribution to improving the health and well-being of our nation at an aggregate level.
I have a couple of questions for the Minister. If she deems that these amendments are not necessary, can she tell us how integrated care boards will draw on these experiences and whether they will be able to share good practice? On the point from the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, about Clauses 23 and 24 being removed and the requirements of integrated care partnerships, we know that bringing together different organisations quite often takes time and sustained effort, so what arrangements do the Government envisage for ensuring that local authorities, NHS providers, and the voluntary sector all have a meaningful role in planning such services? Looking ahead to neighbourhood health services, how will these arrangements relate to the proposed neighbourhood health plans?
In this group, we have raised a number of issues, but they come down to the effectiveness of voluntary and community organisations. Quite often, these are far more effective at understanding the people who need help and access to such services, and they are trusted far more than even a local hospital and particularly politicians in Westminster or civil servants in Whitehall or Victoria Street. If the Minister feels that these amendments are not necessary, how do we ensure that these organisations which play such a critical role continue to do so and feed into policy?
Baroness Merron (Lab)
My Lords, I welcome the debate we have just had on this group. I will start by noting the points about the Bill in general. I have heard the observations and points that noble Lords have made about the Bill, particularly in respect of devolution and the change of Prime Minister to Andy Burnham. It is not our view that the Bill conflicts with rewiring the state. This legislation has the flexibility to support devolution, which is not a one-off but rather a continuing process, as we have discussed before. However, I will of course reflect on the points that noble Lords have made. I turn to the Clause 24 stand part notice and Amendments 85, 94 and 210. Clause 24 abolishes the requirement for ICBs and their partner local authorities to form an integrated care partnership. It also abolishes the related requirement for this partnership to prepare and publish an integrated care strategy. I understand the concerns that noble Lords have raised, but these provisions address policy objectives of the 10-year health plan by streaming the number of plans that local health systems are required to produce and supporting local stakeholders to work together more flexibly and effectively —exactly what noble Lords are seeking. The changes recognise that, in many areas, integrated care partnerships have not had the expected impact on local health outcomes and come with significant opportunity costs. However, I assure your Lordships’ Committee that, where existing arrangements are working well, there is nothing in the Bill that prevents local areas continuing to come together to consider how best to integrate services and plan their approach to tackling the challenges they face. As we know, those challenges will vary according to locality. On Amendment 85, I am grateful to my noble friend Lord Hunt for bringing forward a discussion on women’s health centres and the join-up between health and social care. Regarding women’s health centres in particular—spoken to by my noble friends Lord Bradley and Lady Royall of Blaisdon—the existing duties already require integrated care boards to reduce inequalities and, to the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Kamall, to involve the public and voluntary sector partners in planning and commissioning. We have reinforced this through the Renewed Women’s Health Strategy and the NHS 10-year health plan. In both of these, as noble Lords will be aware, tackling inequalities is absolutely key. Additionally, we are prioritising the most disadvantaged areas and the most disadvantaged groups, rather than starting the other way around, which has happened in the past. We are walking towards the challenge, rather than away from it. The women’s health strategy has value way beyond health. It certainly goes into criminal justice, as my noble friend Lord Hunt referred to, and into the drivers of inequality. On how to work with community-based organisations in respect of women’s centres, raised by my noble friend Lord Bradley, there will be a period of design and engagement. Following that, we will set up a women’s voice partnership, through which we will very much focus on the organisations my noble friends have given examples of—those that represent the women who are most excluded from traditional services. I would absolutely expect women who are in contact with the criminal justice system, or who are in danger of doing so, to come into that category. The women’s voice partnership will allow the informing of decision-making and, over time, regional planning and delivery. We are looking to change how we are doing things and making sure that the most unheard women’s voices will be heard. However, the amendment mandates a statutory relationship with women’s centres. We feel that this risks reducing the flexibility ICBs need to design services around local needs and existing partnerships. I can certainly give the assurance, as outlined in the Renewed Women’s Health Strategy, that the role of women’s centres and women’s health hubs that the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, spoke to is absolutely key. They are a model of prevention work and of neighbourhood healthcare and support, and I hope they will inspire other areas. Turning to Amendment 210, we are strengthening the join-up of healthcare and social care so that people can experience more integrated and person-centred care via the development of neighbourhood health. As the Cabinet statement Rewiring the State sets out, co-operation at local level remains key to success to ensure that services work together as a single coherent system built around the priorities people have. There were questions and debate in this group about the relationship between health and local government. I re-emphasise that the Bill simplifies a rather complex legal framework, to put it mildly. In the future, as we have debated earlier, health and wellbeing boards will be the focal point for collaboration between the NHS and local authorities, to support locally led neighbourhood health plans. The new operating model will be supported by guidance, including the strategic commissioning framework, which makes it clear that effective strategic commissioning depends on partnership between health and local authorities. In addition, national oversight of ICBs will continue to consider the effectiveness of their partnership working, including through feedback from partners, which I think will give considerable opportunity to meet the concerns noble Lords are expressing. The noble Lord, Lord Kamall, asked, if these amendments are not necessary, which is what I am saying, how will ICBs draw on experiences and share good practice? We are able to provide ICBs with guidance, including best practice, and we will continue to do that, including examples of what has worked well. Turning to Amendment 94 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, ICBs already have existing duties, including a duty to promote the integration of health and social care services. They already have the duty to co-operate with local authorities, and their triple-aim duty requires them to consider the wider effects of their decisions on health and wellbeing, the quality of services, and the sustainable and efficient use of resources. It includes consideration of the effect of decisions on health inequalities, and they will be held to account by the Secretary of State in working in this way. I agree that collaboration—a word used by the noble Lord, Lord Redwood—between organisations is fundamental. I hope I can provide, and have provided, reassurance that this is already embedded in ICBs’ ways of working; so the additional requirement is unnecessary because it risks reducing the flexibility ICBs need to design services around local needs.
Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)
Before the noble Baroness sits down, I heard her talk about duties to deliver reductions in inequality. What my amendment is getting at, and which I did not hear from the noble Baroness, is the sense that the ICB is expected essentially to co-create: not just to tell these organisations what to do, but to get together with them to co-create. It might be useful, if the noble Baroness thinks that should happen, if she said so from the Dispatch Box.
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I might use a slightly different word, but I think they mean similar things, if not the same thing. Throughout the Renewed Women’s Health Strategy is the need for co-production, and that has been absolutely important. The strategic commissioning framework also makes it clear that being effective in commissioning depends on the partnership with primary care and local authority providers, as well as the VCSE sector. Throughout, ICBs are required to work with their local communities in order to serve them.
Lord Hunt of Kings Heath (Lab)
My Lords, it has been a very interesting debate. Regarding women’s centres, I am very grateful to my noble friends Lady Royall of Blaisdon and Lord Bradley, the noble Lord, Lord Patel, and the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay. Taken as a whole, their speeches described the fantastic work women’s centres do, and such work is very much cross-service and cross-sector: the criminal justice system, homelessness, the health service and many other issues. My noble friend talked about the Renewed Women’s Health Strategy and the women’s voice partnership, and that is very welcome. The question is, given that the outcomes of having effective women’s centres are so powerful, why is provision so patchy? What is it about public services generally that gives them this short-term funding? Are we going to see much more, and more consistent, provision across the country, and can we set these centres up on a sustainable footing? The noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, made the business case for that very clearly. On the amendments from the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, and the whole issue of integration, I say to the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, that the reason why integration is so important is that most of us have experience of relatives or friends—or ourselves—falling between the net of so many of these different statutory agencies at local level. I agree with him that there is an issue about accountability, though.
On integrated care boards, as the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, said, “integrated” is in their name, yet do we think they have done much to really integrate? I do not mean having papers that say, basically, “integration of rationing”; I mean real integration, where you would notice the difference if you were a patient or a social care client. The problem is that I do not think they know how to do it. I do not think they have the capability to do it, because it is hard work. In the health service, every attempt to set up colleges for leadership has failed. We simply do not invest enough in the people we are expecting to take on these jobs.
My noble friend the Minister accepts that integration is important. She is right about the Bill: it will allow you to do many things. If the Government wish to further devolve, they can easily do it under the Bill. The question is: can we hold local bodies accountable for starting to integrate? The jury is out on that, because the reality is that ICBs are judged on two things: keeping the finances under control and waiting time targets. Everything else is secondary. We have to make integration one of the top three issues. Having said that, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment 85 withdrawn.
Amendments 86 to 89 not moved.
Amendment 90
Moved by
90: After Clause 22, insert the following new Clause— “Integrated care boards: prisons and probationAfter section 14Z44 of the National Health Service Act 2006 insert—“14Z44A Duty as to prisons and probation etc(1) Each integrated care board must, in the exercise of its functions, comply with the conditions of this section.(2) The first condition is that they have due regard to the need to improve health outcomes for—(a) people in custody of the Prison Service, and(b) people under the supervision of the probation service in the community.(3) The second condition is that they take reasonable steps to ensure continuity of care for people—(a) sentenced to a custodial sentence,(b) moved between prisons,(c) moved between areas pursuant to a community sentence imposed by a court,(d) released from secure custody and remaining under the supervision of the probation service, or(e) leaving the supervision of the probation service.(4) The third condition is that they take reasonable steps to ensure that people mentioned in subsection (2) have access, in addition to any services commissioned by local authorities, to—(a) mental health support, including but not limited to acute mental health services and psychiatric treatment,(b) substance misuse support, including but not limited to opiate and non-opiate and alcohol recovery services,(c) addiction services, including but not limited to smoking cessation, and gambling disorder services, and(d) other specialised services determined appropriate by assessment of local community needs or delivered by local providers.(5) When complying with the conditions set out in this section, an integrated care board must have regard to any guidance issued by the Secretary of State.(6) The Secretary of State may issue guidance on specific services which must be commissioned by integrated care boards in order to comply with this section.””Member’s explanatory statement This amendment would require ICBs to have particular regard to improving the provision of healthcare for people in prison, serving community sentences, or under post-release supervision. It would also require that specialist services for these groups be commissioned where needed, and that continuity of care be protected where possible as people move in and out of custody.
Lord Foster of Bath (LD)
My Lords, I apologise for not speaking at Second Reading. Unfortunately, I tested positive for Covid on the morning of the debate. Amendment 90 fits very neatly, following the discussion that your Lordships have been having about integration, partnership, collaboration, co-operation and, equally, the need for clear accountability for the pathway of care and treatment of individual patients. I am enormously grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Bradley, for his support for Amendment 90. It concerns the healthcare of a particular group of people—people in prison. Crucially, it also concerns the continuity of their care when they move between prisons, are released into the community after serving their sentence or move under the supervision of the Probation Service. It seeks to give integrated care boards a very specific duty to take account of their health needs, commissioning appropriate specialist services and, above all, ensuring the continuity of care. Why is that necessary? I will start with a really shocking statistic: a report published in July this year by Nacro shows that more than one person dies every day in the year following their release from prison. In the last five years, almost 2,500 people have died within a year of leaving prison. Around 40% of those deaths are associated with drug-related causes, but many others are linked to mental health problems, including those associated with alcohol and gambling, and many are preventable. Nacro estimates that up to one in seven drug-related deaths could have been avoided if everyone with a history of opioid dependence received appropriate substitution treatment, for instance, on the day they left prison, yet one in three simply do not. This is a healthcare failure with devastating consequences. It is not just about deaths: many people who leave prison subsequently return to custody. It is one of the greatest causes of overcrowding in our prisons. Often, the people who return have complex mental health, drug, alcohol or gambling problems that have not been adequately treated. For instance, around 40% of prisoners wait a month or longer for a GP appointment, compared with 12% of the general population. Without action, we are perpetuating a costly cycle of imprisonment, release and reoffending. These problems exist both inside prison and, particularly, at the point of release, but perhaps the biggest weakness is what happens when someone moves from one part of the criminal justice system to another. Somebody who receives treatment for a serious mental health condition or drug dependency in prison may well be released only to find that their medication, specialist appointments and treatment programme have not followed them. They may have no GP registration, settled accommodation or clear route into community mental health or addiction services. Essential information may not reach the receiving healthcare provider, and it might be that nobody is clear about who is responsible. My amendment has three main elements. First, it would require ICBs to have due regard to improving the health outcomes of people in prison and those under probation supervision. Secondly, it would require reasonable steps to secure continuity of care when people enter custody, move between prisons, move between areas under community sentences or leave prison and probation services. Thirdly, it would require ICBs to take reasonable steps to ensure access to appropriate specialist services including mental health treatment, drug and alcohol recovery, smoking cessation and gambling disorder services. I recognise that this represents a new and potentially challenging responsibility for ICBs. Their circumstances vary enormously. For instance, some have several prisons within their boundaries and others have none. But having no prisons locally does not mean having no responsibility, because people are released into every single community and their healthcare needs do not stop at the prison gates. Nor am I suggesting that every ICB should commission every specialist service independently. The Government’s own proposals for regional commissioning arrangements and national guidance could well provide the necessary expertise and consistency. It is welcome that NHS England is establishing a new governance arrangement for gambling harms treatment programmes, including the regional commissioning leads forum. My amendment is deliberately framed in terms of reasonable steps. It does not prescribe a single delivery model but establishes that these people must be properly considered when health services are planned and commissioned. It is not simply about improving healthcare for offenders; it is about preventing avoidable deaths, reducing reoffending and making our communities safer. If someone leaves prison without the medication, treatment or support they need, we should not be surprised when they become ill, relapse or return to offending. We have known about this problem for many years. In 2010 a report from the Care Quality Commission and HM Inspectorate of Prisons concluded that the continuity of healthcare when prisoners are released is “inadequate” and seems to be getting worse. In 2017, recognising “the need for better continuity of treatment for offenders on release into the community”, the then Government published Guidance for I mproving C ontinuity of C are B etween P risons and the C ommunity . Yet, despite this, by 2022 academic research papers concluded that the continuity of mental health care for those exiting prison is poor. The Mental Health Act 2025 addressed the problem of acute psychiatric care but did not address the everyday issues faced by the thousands of regular prisoners released each month. Reports, guidance and recommendations have come and gone, but the gaps remain. The Chief Medical Officer’s major report this year on the health of people in prisons and on probation specifically identifies the transition into prison, between prisons and back into the community as periods of particular risk. It also highlights the poor information sharing between prison healthcare and the wider NHS. The Bill gives us an opportunity to do something more concrete: to put responsibility firmly into the commissioning framework and ensure that continuity of care is recognised as an essential NHS responsibility. I hope that the Minister will recognise the importance of this issue and either support this amendment or explain how the Government intend to deliver the same clear statutory commitment by other means. We should not accept a system in which the prison gate becomes the point at which healthcare falls through the cracks. I beg to move.
Lord Bradley (Lab)
My Lords, briefly, I support this amendment, to which I have added my name. The excellent speech by the noble Lord, Lord Foster, captured all the key reasons for it. I agree with every word that he spoke. My report identified many of these problems. I made a raft of recommendations to address the issues. I am still determined to ensure that they are all implemented; it has taken only 16 years so far. Every time there have been legislative changes to healthcare structures and organisational responsibilities, including commissioning arrangements—there have been many—I have tried to prevent the interface between health and justice falling through the cracks or simply being forgotten or ignored. This amendment is essential in this latest Health Bill. The noble Lord, Lord Foster, made it clear that it is not special pleading for this group of people. It is recognising that if we are serious about reducing health inequalities in every community then these services, commissioned for that community, must encompass the whole population, including those who experience the criminal justice system. Listening intently to the Minister, I note her gently but firmly pushing back on every attempt to identify any group in the Bill and stating that the Secretary of State’s powers encapsulate the whole population for all health needs. Perhaps answering my question at Second Reading on whether this is a centralising Bill or a devolution Bill, I reiterate the question from the noble Lord, Lord Foster: how do the Government intend to deliver the same clear statutory commitment by other means rather than directly in the Bill?
Baroness Watkins of Tavistock (CB)
My Lords, I support this amendment and thank the noble Lords, Lord Foster and Lord Bradley, for their excellent speeches. However, we have not mentioned women. Women have babies in prisons. The reports show that the care and standards are extremely varied and not well co-ordinated. Can you imagine anything worse than giving birth in your local hospital, rushed from the prison but restrained, then perhaps four months later being released from prison, but without a real structure for a health visitor or a follow-up GP? I want to bring in the integration of prisoner health. Mental health needs to be at the forefront—noble Lords know that I would think that, with my background —but so must be people with severe disabilities, including amputees. Many of those who are in prison have served in our Armed Forces and have very poor care after being released from prison. They may have had very good care when they were in the forces but since then have had tough lives. I appeal to the Minister to think about how we can improve prison healthcare and the aftercare and probation, not only for people with mental health problems but for people with physical problems and for women who have had children while in prison.
Baroness Royall of Blaisdon (Lab)
My Lords, I fully endorse everything that has been said on this amendment. It is vital for offenders, ex-offenders, their families and society in general. With this Bill, ICBs will have direct statutory accountability for health and justice services, which should enable local commissioners to strengthen continuity of care when prisoners leave custody. I hope so; I am not sure that it will be the case, but I hope so. When people leave prison, they are significantly more likely to have poor mental health, as the noble Baroness, Lady Watkins, said, and substance misuse difficulties. They also experience homelessness more than the general population. They need care within the prison system and when they go out through the gate. Like the noble Baroness, I am particularly concerned about women, who need tailored services within prison and when they leave prison. The women’s centres that we discussed earlier are part of the solution. Prisons are struggling massively with overcrowding and a woeful lack of prison officers. That is not something that my noble friend the Minister can address, but officers on the landings do not have enough time to support prisoners who are struggling and for whom mental and physical conditions are worsening. I add one thing to this very short debate—social care. When ex-offenders leave prison, many are elderly and in need of social care. What do they do? Where can they go? There is an increasing need for prisons to address the needs of elderly offenders, some of whom have dementia or need social care within prison. They should not be filling up much-needed cells in our prisons but should be housed in some form of secure accommodation with the appropriate care. I ask my noble friend to take that back to the department with her.
Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (CB)
My Lords, I am most grateful to the noble Lords, Lord Bradley and Lord Foster, for bringing this amendment forward. Back in 1997, I wrote a paper on treating shackled prisoners and in 1998 one on managing terminally ill prisoners. The reality is that the life expectancy of people in prison is 20 years lower than that of the rest of the population. A large number of prisoners have terminal illnesses, often related to previous habits, such as smoking—there are a lot of cancers—or poor diet. One of the problems has been providing care for terminally ill prisoners in prisons. Following the work that I did, there was a requirement by the Prison Service that each prison formed a link with its local hospice wherever possible. Those hospice staff from the voluntary sector go into prisons and will provide care. An interesting discovery concerned a group of prisoners who could never be discharged for a variety of reasons, including for their own safety, because of the crimes of which they have been convicted. Some of those prisoners did not want to go into the sick bay and preferred to be looked after by the person with whom they shared a cell. That cellmate then also needed emotional support. We also discovered that a large number of prisoners had experienced deeply traumatic bereavements prior to their criminal activity, which had been a manifestation of unresolved grief and anger, quite often. This underlines the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Foster, about mental health services. Without managing those, the behaviours and manifestations of the prisoners are not improved. Please let us not forget that a significant number of prisoners become terminally ill. They need care in the prison from specialist services that can adapt to the difficulties that they face.
Lord Kamall (Con)
My Lords, I really do not have very much to add to the eloquent introduction to his amendment by the noble Lord, Lord Foster of Bath, except my own experience in this area. Earlier in the year, I was contacted by a campaign group representing female prisoners that was complaining about the unequal access that they had to healthcare, particularly around cancer. I will repeat the Written Questions that I asked and touch upon the Answer that the Government gave at the time, and ask whether noble Lords and the Minister believe that that reflects reality rather than perception. The first question I asked the Government was, “what action they are taking to ensure that women in prison with cancer … are treated by appropriately qualified clinicians, and … have consistent access to oncology specialists”. I then asked, “what action they are taking to address any failures in cancer care arising from fragmented commissioning arrangements between NHS England, health and wellbeing boards and prison healthcare providers”. I also asked the Government, “what steps they are taking to prevent disruption of cancer treatment for patients following imprisonment”. The last Question was, “what assessment they have made of whether women diagnosed with cancer in prisons in England receive healthcare equivalent in quality, timeliness and continuity as that provided in the community”. The Written Answer given by the Government at the time was that: “NHS England commissions all services across the prison estate”, and expects them “to be equivalent with those … in the community, including for cancer care. All people received into prison have an initial health screen on arrival”, and it then talked about risks. The Answer goes on to talk about a report from Chris Whitty called The H ealth of P eople in P rison, o n P robation and in the S ecure NHS E state in England , published in November 2025. I was sent a copy of that report. When I sent the campaign group those Answers, it was very angry—so angry that it did not suggest any follow-up questions, as it felt it was a waste of time. Given what the noble Lord, Lord Foster, has said today about the concerns around equity in treatment for those in prison—both those continuing treatment in prison and those starting treatment in prison and then having the same treatment outside prison—can the Minister address those points and the concerns raised by noble Lords across this Chamber from all Benches? Does she feel that, in reality, and given the Written Answers, that those people are getting the quality of care that they deserve, like anyone in the community?
Baroness Merron (Lab)
My Lords, I am most grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Foster, and my noble friends Lord Bradley and Lady Royall, as well as the noble Baronesses, Lady Watkins and Lady Finlay, for speaking to this amendment. I have spoken previously about people with disadvantages when it comes to dealing with health needs and I certainly recognise that the group of which we speak continues to suffer disadvantage. That is one of the reasons why the Chief Medical Officer’s report is so key, and I was very pleased to discuss it with him. To respond in part to the noble Lord, Lord Kamall, if groups or individuals that noble Lords are working with are unhappy about responses, they should by all means let me know precisely what it is that they seek and I will do my best to assist. Earlier this year, through NHS England, we launched a pilot scheme—probation health pilots—across four areas, placing NHS clinicians directly into probation appointments to provide physical, mental health and addiction support for roughly 4,000 offenders. We are updating the NHS England national health and justice service specifications and reviewing prison reception screening processes to better catch health needs upon arrival and improve out-of-hours care. The Department of Health and Social Care and HM Prison and Probation Service are working on a multi-year response to the CMO’s report. These are all works in progress, which I hope will be helpful. I am glad that the noble Baroness, Lady Watkins, made particular reference to women in this regard, because it follows on from our debate on a previous group. To speak briefly to the point of this amendment, providing appropriate care for people in custody is core to health and justice commissioning. To address the points raised by noble Lords, and indeed the amendment, ICBs will be required to meet all the reasonable needs of people who are in detention once the Bill transfers commissioning responsibility to them. The intention in transferring this responsibility is to support the joined-up care across the patient pathway that I think we all seek, which we know is not in place across the board, to improve access and outcomes, reduce inequality and strengthen the collaboration with local authorities. It is local authorities—the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, raised this point—that commission social care for those in detention, and community drug and alcohol treatment, and other aspects of public health. ICBs will have responsibilities for most of the health commissioning pathway from prisons and, to pick up the point about movement, to and from the community. I completely accept that health needs are no respecters of geographical boundaries or prison gates, as was referred to. Responsibility for the health commissioning pathway would ensure that commissioners are enabled to better do a joined-up job than is currently the case. On the point about moving ICB areas, we cannot expect people to stay neatly in areas. There will be national rules in place to identify which ICB has responsibility for care, and the single patient record will be greatly helpful in ensuring that health information follows the person. The last point that I will make is about specialist services such as RECONNECT. We expect ICBs, as strategic commissioners, to champion services such as RECONNECT, because they provide much-needed pathway support on a whole range of issues that reduce health inequalities. National services specs and standards have been developed with the input of clinical and lived experience involvement. As part of the assurance framework with model regions, we expect ICBs to meet these specifications and standards as a minimum, and for the model regions to assure against it.
Lord Foster of Bath (LD)
My Lords, I am grateful to all noble Lords who have spoken. I am grateful to the supporter of the amendment, the noble Lord, Lord Bradley, and to the noble Lord, Lord Kamall. I am particularly grateful for the support of the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, with all her long expertise and work in this area. I am grateful, too, to the noble Baronesses, Lady Watkins and Lady Royall, for raising the issue of women in prison, where, undoubtedly, even more needs to be done than perhaps in the male estate—they are absolutely right to pick that up. I am particularly grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Royall, for reminding us very clearly that people who go into prison are far more like to have mental health problems—whether drug, alcohol or gambling problems, or whatever they might be—than is the case in the regular population.
I remind noble Lords of a simple statistic: 80% of offending is reoffending. If we want to solve our prison crisis, it is vital that we try to reduce reoffending. Improving the healthcare of people—whether they are in prison, moving into the Probation Service’s control or whatever—is vital. The Minister accepted that those people are currently disadvantaged. The level of care and support in our prisons and other parts of the criminal justice system is, frankly, woeful. Reoffending costs this country a staggering £22.7 billion every year. If we start to reduce it and provide better treatment, real savings will come.
I am grateful to the Minister for her response, seeking to explain that there will be this continuity. She tells me that it is important that we have joined-up care, that she accepts that different ICBs are in different circumstances and so on, and that continuity of care will happen as it moves from one ICB to another, but she has not told me who is responsible and how that responsibility will be enforced. For the time being, while I hope further thought and discussion on these issues can continue, I beg leave to withdraw the amendment.
Amendment 90 withdrawn.
Amendments 91 and 92 not moved.
Amendment 93
Moved by
93: After Clause 22, insert the following new Clause— “Quality and outcomes for people living with inflammatory bowel disease(1) Each integrated care board must monitor and assess variation in the quality of care, access to services and outcomes for people living with inflammatory bowel disease within its area.(2) In carrying out an assessment under subsection (1), an integrated care board must assess its performance against the national standards and measures established under section (National strategy for inflammatory bowel disease). (3) For each financial year, an integrated care board must publish a report on its performance against the national standards and measures established under section (National strategy for inflammatory bowel disease), including any unwarranted variation identified within its area and the action taken or proposed to reduce it.(4) In this section, “inflammatory bowel disease” includes Crohn’s disease, ulcerative colitis and such related conditions as the Secretary of State may specify in regulations made under section (National strategy for inflammatory bowel disease).(5) The first report under this section must be published within 12 months of the day on which this section comes into force, and subsequent reports must be published annually.”Member's explanatory statement The amendment would require all ICBs to assess and report against the same national framework for inflammatory bowel disease.
Lord Hunt of Kings Heath (Lab)
My Lords, I have added my name to this amendment. The noble Baroness, Lady Young of Old Scone, who tabled it, cannot be here because she is chairing a Forestry Commission meeting in Bristol, so it falls on me to speak again. My interest in IBD comes from one of my sons, who has had it for nearly 20 years. His treatment has been excellent, from GP to Birmingham Children’s Hospital to Birmingham University hospital trust. Even when he moved to work in London for four or five years, he was allowed to continue treatment at Birmingham. The transition from children’s to adult services was excellent. The frustration is that quality of care is so patchy throughout the country. In a sense, this almost repeats the debate led by the noble Lord, Lord Foster. The conundrum is why it is so patchy when IBD is such a major issue. We know that it is a lifelong, relapsing condition which affects more than half a million people across the UK. There are two main types of IBD: Crohn’s disease and ulcerative colitis. IBD currently impacts one in every 23 of the population. We know that prevalence is rising and that it disproportionately affects people of working age, with most patients diagnosed between the ages of 15 and 30. At that young age, it can have a devastating impact on their lives. We have had advances in treatment, but the variation in quality of care across the country is quite extraordinary and indefensible. We know that too many patients experience regular flares and poor disease control. If it is poorly controlled, IBD can have a profound impact on a person’s education, employment, family life and overall quality of life. Symptoms of the disease can be debilitating. The NHS quality strategy rightly places quality improvement outcomes at the centre of health policy, but the issue is that the mechanism to drive accountability and improvement seems focused on a number of nationally prioritised conditions, and IBD is not regarded as a priority despite the half a million people affected by it. There are some really good programmes. NICE guidelines are very good, and Getting It Right First Time provides important guidance on what good care looks like, but, as we know, that does not always mean that you get a consistent approach. The GIRFT programme has identified substantial variation in the delivery of IBD care across the NHS, with clinical guidance and best practice not implemented consistently. We know that IBD carries a high cost to the NHS, of approximately £3 billion a year. Patients with active disease cost the NHS three times more than patients in remission. As IBD commonly begins in early adulthood, poorly managed patients can then accumulate decades of healthcare usage. As I have already implied, it impacts a patient’s ability to work and to be productive at work, so it has a big impact on the economy. In a sense, I feel sorry for my noble friend the Minister. As she knows, the scope of this Bill is wide and therefore we can have any amendment we like in relation to the provision of healthcare. We have taken advantage of that here, but this is a cry from the heart about the NHS. There are so many examples of this: in some parts of the country, as I saw in Birmingham, a brilliant service operates, but in other parts of the country, it is hopeless. Somehow, we do not seem able to get a grip on this. Even with programmes such as Get It Right First Time, it all seems vague. What I am asking for is some sense of the need to get a grip on these disease areas which have a huge impact on the economy, the health service and people’s lives. We need to say to the NHS, “Look, this patchy response is just unacceptable, because we know it can work well. We’d like to see it extended elsewhere”. I think that is what the noble Baroness, Lady Young, might have said. She would have said it with a good deal more assertiveness, but she would have said it. I beg to move.
Baroness Pidgeon (LD)
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Young, and the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, for tabling these amendments, highlighting the issue of inflammatory bowel disease and setting out the impact on people, their lives and ability to work. As we heard, existing national strategies and performance frameworks remain focused on a limited number of chronic conditions. That leaves many others, such as IBD, without an equivalent national mechanism to identify variation, assess performance and drive improvement. We keep returning to this theme, day in, day out, in Committee on this Bill: people experience a postcode lottery, with significant variations in the quality of care they receive. Even when, as we heard, the Getting It Right First Time programme has identified those substantial variations, we do not see best practice then implemented across the country. I do not understand that. We heard in an earlier group of a great example of dealing with stalking in Cheshire. Why is that not being rolled out? It is good practice and we know it works. It is something I have never understood. Maybe, with all the power now going to the Secretary of State in this new model, it will work, and suddenly we will have the one person able to make sure that it works across the country. This really matters, as so many people live with IBD. We need to look at this as just one example of the issue we are trying to tease out from this whole Bill. We have national standards but still a postcode lottery depending on where people live. They may be lucky in Birmingham, but they may not be lucky elsewhere. I hope the Minister will be able to respond to this example, which is part of a bigger package and a bigger theme coming out in the debate.
Lord Evans of Rainow (Con)
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Young of Old Scone, and the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath. Although the noble Lord said he would not be as assertive as the noble Baroness, he always strikes me as a very knowledgeable and experienced, albeit frustrated, Member of the House. We always listen when he speaks. I thank him for tabling these amendments and raising the important issue of care for people living with inflammatory bowel disease. Recent research, commissioned by Crohn’s & Colitis UK and undertaken by the University of Nottingham, suggests that more than half a million people in the United Kingdom—approximately one in every 123—are living with Crohn’s disease, ulcerative colitis or unclassified inflammatory bowel disease. This is almost double the previous estimate of 300,000, which clearly raises important questions about the capacity of our health service to meet the needs of those affected. We are broadly sympathetic to the principles underpinning these amendments. We believe that monitoring outcomes regionally and examining differences between population groups is an important means of identifying and addressing inequalities in care. Indeed, the principles should inform our approach to all conditions: we should be seeking to eliminate the postcode lottery in healthcare and ensure that patients receive the same high standards of treatment regardless of where they live, their background and individual circumstances. We agree with the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, about best practice; why can the sector and the NHS not learn from best practice in outstanding NHS trusts and share best practice across the piece? That said, we are not necessarily convinced that every condition requires its own statutory national strategy or annual reporting framework. We must be mindful of the administrative burdens that such requirements can impose, particularly when we are seeking to reduce bureaucracy across the NHS. Nevertheless, we broadly welcome the opportunity to examine these issues and thank the noble Lords for bringing these probing amendments before the Committee. I look forward particularly to hearing from the Minister what steps the Government are taking to identify and address regional and demographic disparities in healthcare outcomes, both for people living with inflammatory bowel disease and across the health service more widely.
Baroness in Waiting/Government Whip (Baroness Hyde of Bemerton) (Lab)
My Lords, I am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Young, for bringing this discussion before the Committee today and to the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, for moving the amendment and bringing the personal experience of his son to this debate. As other noble Lords mentioned, I recognise the significant impact that inflammatory bowel disease, including Crohn’s disease and ulcerative colitis, can have on people’s lives. However, the Government do not believe that a separate national strategy is the best way to secure improvements in care. There are already national arrangements to support improvements for people with inflammatory bowel disease and consistent and high-quality IBD care. NICE guidance provides evidence-based recommendations for the diagnosis and management of Crohn’s disease and ulcerative colitis. Additionally, as mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, and the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, NHS England’s Getting It Right First Time gastroenterology programme has focused on reducing that variation in care, earlier diagnosis and proactive management. This supports local systems to better monitor and then report on service provision to identify that variation and enable them to improve services. NHS RightCare also supports that earlier diagnosis, with integrated multidisciplinary support, so that people can have proactive and personalised care plans. For example, “Hannah’s Story” promotes the streamlining of referrals, timely specialist input and planned follow-up. There are some green shoots and signs of progress. The latest September 2026 data show that around 16,000 fewer people are on the gastroenterology waiting lists than a year previously. We recognise concerns about variation in inflammatory bowel disease services, and our focus is therefore on supporting the NHS to improve quality and outcomes through the existing national guidance and improvement programmes, rather than by introducing a new statutory condition-specific strategy. Additionally, requiring every integrated care board to establish additional assessment arrangements for IBD care and to publish annual reports would risk duplication and add to administrative burdens, as alluded to by the noble Lord, Lord Evans of Rainow, rather than them focusing on supporting improvements in patient care. Our priority must be effective implementation of existing standards and improvement programmes. I hope that this reassures noble Lords that the Government recognise the importance of this issue.
Lord Hunt of Kings Heath (Lab)
My Lords, I am grateful to my noble friend for her sympathetic response. I should say to the noble Lord, Lord Evans, that I do not think I feel frustrated, but there is a big dose of déjà vu around the Chamber whenever we debate the restructuring of the NHS. Clearly, the gap between the aims of a restructure and what happens on the ground is often rather wide. The fact is that the various Members of your Lordships’ House who have been Health Ministers and presented health Bills would acknowledge that restructuring does not always achieve what it sets out to achieve.
My noble friend has rightly pointed to improvements and to the Get It Right First Time programme. However, they themselves point to huge gaps and variations. I hope that this debate serves to inform future policy but, ultimately, it is an issue of accountability. One of the questions that arises in this new structure, where Ministers are clearly more accountable to Parliament, is how that accountability should be discharged when it comes to the evident patchiness in so many of our services. That is the big question that we are puzzling with. Having said that, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.
Amendment 93 withdrawn.
Amendments 94 and 94A not moved.
The Deputy Chairman of Committees (Baroness Fookes) (Con)
Amendment 94B is in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Campbell-Savours. The noble Baroness, Lady Hayter, will move it on his behalf. Amendment 94B
Moved by
94B: After Clause 22, insert the following new Clause— “Independence and quality of life: musculoskeletal healthAfter section 14Z43 of the National Health Service Act 2006 (duty to have regard to wider effect of decisions), insert—“14Z43A Duty as to musculoskeletal healthEach integrated care board must, in the exercise of its functions—(a) tackle health inequalities affecting people with musculoskeletal health conditions that limit independence and mobility;(b) improve the prevention, diagnosis and treatment of musculoskeletal health conditions;(c) have regard, in exercising its functions under this section, to any strategy or policy statement relating to musculoskeletal health published or approved by the Secretary of State.””Member’s explanatory statement This new clause would require ICBs to tackle health inequalities affecting people with musculoskeletal health conditions that are the predominant cause of loss of mobility, independence and quality of life, and to have regard to any strategy or policy statement relating to musculoskeletal health published or approved by the Secretary of State.
Baroness Hayter of Kentish Town (Lab)
At my noble friend’s request, I will indeed move Amendment 94B, but I will also speak to Amendment 206 in my name. My noble friend’s amendment is actually rather simple and quite obvious. It is simply that every ICB must take steps to tackle the health inequalities for those with musculoskeletal health conditions, where improved prevention, diagnosis and treatment are urgently needed. In fact, that request is along the lines of that in Amendment 206, which stands in my name and those of the noble Baronesses, Lady Pidgeon and Lady Cass, and the noble Lord, Lord Black of Brentwood. We would all much prefer that we did not have to bring this amendment. We have always wanted and would prefer to work with Ministers to deliver on the commitment made by Labour in opposition before the election, and which the Labour Government have reaffirmed both in its 10-year health plan and the women’s health strategy. That commitment is to ensure that universal—that is the important word—access to fracture prevention services exists across England by 2030. It is an important promise, particularly for women over 50—from looking around, there are quite a few of us here—half of whom will have a fracture because of osteoporosis as, incidentally, will one in five men. We are talking about this being universal; that means available to all, not four hours’ travel away. Patients of this age in particular cannot make that journey. We need a nationally available service. There are 3 million people in England who live with osteoporosis, yet it is so often undiagnosed and therefore untreated. Having suffered from one fracture, these patients are at greater risk of another. I hardly need say that the consequences are devastating. A broken hip can rob some of their independence, force them into residential care and often shorten their life. Worse, this is unnecessary because we know how to prevent many of these fractures. We have safe, effective medicines, some costing as little as £1 a month. We have an established model of care, which identifies patients after a fracture, assesses their risks, provides treatment and then follows them up. This gives patients access to falls prevention, to strength and balance training, and to support to prevent further fractures. Sadly, however, we are having to table this amendment because too many people are being denied this cheap, cost-effective intervention. Only a quarter of fragility fractures in England are identified by prevention services. I am ashamed to say that, since the election, the number identified has increased by only 3%. This is desperately disappointing, particularly compared with Wales, where services were rolled out nationwide within 18 months, after a clear ministerial commitment and some pump-priming. The financial case is persuasive. The Royal Osteoporosis Society shows that universal high-quality services could prevent nearly 50,000 fractures over five years, including 15,000 hip fractures. Any of your Lordships who are still walking around with sticks, or who have had one of those hip replacements, know the inconvenience and hurt that it causes. More than that, perhaps, it would save about £300 million in acute hospital costs and probably close to £300 million in social care. It would release a quarter of a million hospital bed days. The investment to establish these services is a one-off £90 million. The ongoing costs would then be met by local savings. Such investment would therefore pay for itself within two years. So, what is not to like? Less pain, less harm and less money. It is incomprehensible why the Government will not fulfil their promise to save so much suffering, and save the NHS and social care so much cost. Fracture prevention services do not have to be provided by a single type of service or clinic; they can be organised in hospitals, primary care, community services or neighbourhood health settings. They offer the chance to put all three of the Government’s proposed shifts into practice—from sickness to prevention, from hospital to community and from analogue to digital—and be a vital part of the women’s health strategy. The amendment would reduce health inequalities, since people in the most deprived areas face a 25% higher chance of osteoporosis—this is always the same with all these issues. Promises do not fulfil themselves by wishful thinking; they have to be planned and made to happen. We have three years left to make Labour’s promise a reality, but we still have no road map for how that will happen. Access to prevention should be available, in the words of our Prime Minister, “in every postcode”. Amendment 206 is modest. It would require the Secretary of State to publish an implementation plan for delivering universal access by 2030. The plan would set minimum standards and annual milestones, which would be measured, and set out how the Government will address the area differences in access. There would then be a report to Parliament on the progress on the number of eligible patients being identified and treated. That is the important thing: how many patients it reaches. We are not setting out how every service should work—that is for local NHS organisations to design, provided patients receive the care—and we are not seeking to impose a duty to spend. We are asking the Government to set out how they will deliver the policy they have already committed to. We have support across the Chamber from Conservatives, Liberal Democrats, the Cross Benches and Labour. We also have medical colleges, trade unions, charities and newspapers—I am sure they are watching this debate tonight—backing us. I know that Ministers understand the importance of this and that the Government want to honour their 2030 commitment to provide services. But we are already two years into government and there is no implementation plan or timetable, yet 2030 is just three years away. The lack of a plan is worrying. If we could get an assurance from my noble friend that we will see an implementation plan with a timetable and measurable targets then we would be happy to work with colleagues, rather than having to bring this back on Report. Patients have waited long enough. We have seen enough of our colleagues on sticks to know of what we speak. Elderly folk—some of us—and, indeed, some much younger than us deserve to know when they will receive the care that could prevent the next fracture. I beg to move.
Lord Black of Brentwood (Con)
My Lords, I have added my name to Amendment 206. I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Hayter, on bringing it forward and on her passionate speech. It is a really important amendment because it has the capacity to save lives, help grow the economy, and save the taxpayer and the NHS hundreds of millions of pounds every year. It is not often that we get to debate something with such clear-cut outcomes and which would have such a profound impact on the lives of many hundreds of thousands of families. This is a very personal matter for me and one on which I have been campaigning since I made my maiden speech on this issue back in 2010. The noble Baroness, Lady Royall, was there and responded to it. My mother had very serious osteoporosis. It destroyed the last few years of her life, which she lived in great pain, unable to get out of the house or undertake any of the tasks someone in their 70s should be able to do. Ultimately, she lost her life too young due to complications arising from it. I lived that journey with her, caring for her as best I could, and I know how different her life would have been had she had early access to a fracture prevention service. She had no such support from an FLS and by the time she was diagnosed, very late, the damage had been done. That is why I have campaigned on this issue for 16 years: because I do not want anyone else’s mum, dad, grandma or grandpa to have to go through all that. It need not be like this; as the noble Baroness said, we have the capacity now, as a result of successful medication and effective prevention measures, to make sure that happens. But to date, inexplicably, it has not. That is a collective failure from Governments of all parties. This is not a political issue and these are not political points. None of us to date has got this right, despite good intentions. Most recently, those good intentions were underlined by this Government’s commitment, restated 100 times since the election, to a national rollout of a FLS by 2030. But the starting pistol, as I have often pointed out in debates and Oral Questions, has not yet been fired and, as the noble Baroness so powerfully put it, time is running out. Parliament now has a chance to act to make promises handed out over a generation a reality and to ensure a legacy for my mother and all those like her who continue to suffer because we cannot get our house in order. It is so simple and so cost-effective, and that is what the amendment would deliver. There is one other substantive point that I would make, which we perhaps focus on less often: the cost of osteoporosis to British businesses and our economy. Osteoporosis-related fractures are responsible for around 1.5 million working days lost each year, which costs employers an estimated £160 million annually. That is a staggering figure, particularly when we consider that the one-off investment required from central government to establish universal fracture prevention services is, as the noble Baroness, Lady Hayter, said, just £90 million. That is less than the amount employers lose every seven months. These are often experienced workers—people with decades of knowledge and skills, whose working lives can be disrupted or cut short by fractures that could have been prevented. Their colleagues and employers lose out too. Then there is the cost of younger people lost to the economy, who are forced to leave full-time employment to care for someone with fractures or advanced osteoporosis. Of course, with an ageing population, this will become ever more acute. As the population gets older, unless something happens, the number of hip fractures is projected to double by 2060, with huge implications for families, the NHS and, above all, the economy. We hear a great deal from the Government about growing the economy and getting people back to work. That is absolutely right, yet we continue to saddle British businesses with the cost of preventable ill health when we already know how to tackle it. This amendment is about health, of course, but it is also a growth measure from which everyone, whether they are affected by osteoporosis or not, will benefit. That is one of the many reasons why this amendment is so important.
I very much hope that this debate today will be a spur to get things moving. In an ideal world, the Minister would accept the amendment, which is, after all, just confirming government policy, and bring about an end to prevarication and obfuscation, to consultations, to bureaucratic stasis and to promises—action this day, as Churchill would have said. I hope that the Minister, who I suspect knows in her heart of hearts what must be done, will come back before Report with an action plan, a credible implementation timetable, arrangements for monitoring progress and funding—it is such a minuscule amount that the Treasury would regard it as a rounding error—and tell us that we are on our way. We would not then need to press this matter further. We on this side of the House, as I am sure my noble friend on the Front Bench will confirm, would be happy to work with her to do that. If she does not, I fear this House will have a duty—I use that word advisedly—as a last resort to come back to this amendment on Report to bind the Government to honour the commitment they made at the election. Trust in politics, and the lives of hundreds of thousands, are at stake here.
Baroness Gerada (CB)
My Lords, I will speak to Amendment 206 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Hayter, and Amendment 245 in my name. The challenge facing the NHS is not ageing. Ageing is a triumph. The challenge is frailty. Many in this House demonstrate that those in their 80s and 90s can and do remain vigorous and independent; we see them every day. Yet GPs often see patients decades younger living with frailty. Frailty means reduced physiological reserve. A relatively minor infection, a fall or a change of medication can tip someone from independent living into hospital. Preventing avoidable deterioration and preserving independence must therefore be central to how we care for people as they age. These two amendments address different but closely connected aspects of that challenge. Amendment 206, as we have heard so eloquently, focuses on fracture prevention, and Amendment 245 seeks to ensure that people living with frailty receive properly integrated care. I turn first to Amendment 206. As a GP, I have seen the devastating consequences of fractures in older people. As we have heard, a broken hip can mark the beginning of a steep decline in someone’s health and independence. I strongly support fracture prevention services, but we must ensure that they do not simply become yet another hospital-based specialty. When I first started in general practice, we worked closely with our district nurses. They would visit at-risk patients in their home and check for trip hazards, poor lighting, diet and whether someone needed a walking aid. Of course, preventing a fracture is important but, as we have heard, we must also ensure that when someone sustains a fragility fracture they are identified, assessed and treated to reduce another. That is the purpose of the fracture liaison services. Seven medical royal colleges —including the Royal College of General Practitioners, which I used to lead—support them, but local areas need staff and resources to deliver them properly. How do the Government intend to support community and primary care services, including district nursing, as part of the commitment to universal fracture prevention services? I turn to Amendment 245 in my name; I am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, for her support. It is a probing amendment. It would require integrated care boards to ensure that adults living with frailty, or at risk of it, are identified early, assessed promptly and supported by a multidisciplinary team, with hospitals, GPs, community services and social workers working together. ICBs would also have regard to national guidance and standards. In my engagement with Age UK leading up to this, it made a very important point to me: frailty reform cannot begin and end at the hospital front door. We need a pathway that runs end to end, from prevention and rapid assessment to proper support after discharge. Let me take each briefly in turn. The first area is the front door. When a frail person arrives at hospital, they need a rapid response and someone to ask whether admission can be avoided with the right support in the community. The NHS already knows what good looks like. Walsall shows what this can mean in practice. In one of the most deprived boroughs of England, the hospital runs an acute frailty service for at least 70 hours a week. Alongside it, an integrated front door team of experienced community nurses works in A&E seven days a week. They identify patients who can be cared for safely at home; arrange that care there and then, including up to 72 hours of crisis support; and hand people on to virtual wards and frailty case managers. The trust has avoided more than 5,000 admissions since December 2020 and supported over 1,800 earlier discharges. That is integration: community staff at the hospital front door. These sorts of initiatives are inconsistent within the NHS, as many are. Age UK reports that 32% of people aged 90 and over wait 12 hours or more in A&E. For a frail person, that is not an inconvenience; it causes them real, irreversible harm. The NHS aims for acute frailty services to run at least 70 hours a week in hospitals with a major A&E, but provision remains patchy. How many hospitals currently meet that ambition? Where they do not, what will the Government do about it? Has every A&E now delivered the front door health check that was promised in April 2025? The second area is assessment and treatment. A moderately to severely frail person may need a geriatrician, a nurse, a physiotherapist, an occupational therapist, a pharmacist and a social worker, all working together. When that does not happen, the cost is high. One in five people with frailty who are admitted as an emergency stay in hospital for more than 21 days, rather than being discharged within hours to community services. Yet the community services are under growing pressure. I mentioned on a previous amendment that the Care Quality Commission reports that we have half as many qualified district nurses per person over 65 as we did in 2012. We must not build a system that is good at spotting frailty but has nowhere to send people afterwards. Hospital assessment must be matched by community services for prevention, rehabilitation and follow-up, and by the staff to deliver. ICBs are responsible for NHS services. Adult social care sits with the local authorities, which are under severe financial pressure. How will the Government make sure that the two have the resources and incentives to work together? The third and final area is about people getting safely home. Age UK estimates that around 13,000 people are medically fit to leave hospital but are still there, and that is up by 70% since 2021. Too often, there is simply nowhere between hospital and home—but it was not always so. When I first started in general practice, the Tomlinson report was published and highlighted the need for intermediate care centres—step-down, low-threshold, community-based services such as the Lambeth Community Care Centre, where I worked as a GP until it closed in 2005. Patients could be admitted straight from home, receive nursing and rehabilitation, and go home when they were ready. Their own GP stayed involved throughout. That was continuity, integration and a team without walls. We cannot deliver a shift from hospital to community simply by announcing it. We have to rebuild the services that make that shift possible. The Government have promised a modern service framework for frailty and dementia, due soon, which is welcome, but a framework matters only if it changes care on the ground. I have these questions for the Minister: will the framework set clear, measurable expectations for ICBs? How will performance be monitored? What will happen if ICBs fall short? How will the lessons from the national frailty improvement collaborative reach each part of the NHS? I hope the Minister will set out how ICBs will be given the responsibility and the resources to deliver. Frailty is not a specialty; it is everyone’s business.
Baroness Chisholm of Owlpen (Non-Afl)
My Lords, I wish to support Amendment 206 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Hayter. My noble friend Lord Black’s name is also on the amendment. With him, I have been involved with the Royal Osteoporosis Society for many years and have heard about the devastating consequences of fragility fractures. Indeed, I saw the consequences when I was a practising nurse. Due to research and the realisation of the importance of bone quality, and the increasing realisation of the importance of co-ordinated fracture liaison services, there has been a closing of the gap in the historic 80% of patients who went unscreened and untreated for underlying osteoporosis. However, progress is not fast enough. Without this amendment, I fear the implementation plan to secure universal access will not happen and will be postponed yet again. The postcode lottery will carry on; the cost to the NHS will carry on going up. Most importantly, people will carry on suffering following fractures that could have been prevented. We have heard passionate speeches tonight which make it seem essential that this amendment be accepted. Will the Minister give a firm assurance that the Government will publish an implementation plan, with measurable milestones and proper accountability, rather than leaving patients waiting for another promise?
Baroness Ritchie of Downpatrick (Lab)
My Lords, I support Amendment 206, tabled by my noble friend Lady Hayter. I want to focus on fracture prevention, social care and people living with dementia. We have already had quite a bit of discussion on this amendment. I warmly welcome the Prime Minister’s determination to fix social care. He has rightly described decades of political failure on this issue as a dereliction of public duty. Fracture prevention offers a practical way to start putting that right. More than 66,000 people break a hip in England every year. For many, it is the moment they lose their independence, a factor that has already been referred to by previous speakers. Around four in 10 go on to need new formal care, at home or in a care home, and more than half of those who return home rely on new help from family and friends. In the first four months alone, the social care cost of hip fractures across the UK is estimated at £1.25 billion. People living with dementia are especially affected. They are more likely to fall and break a bone, and a fracture may, in turn, speed up their cognitive decline. Almost a third of people who break a hip are already living with some form of cognitive impairment. Every hip fracture prevented avoids more than £15,000 in social care costs in the first four months. Analysis from the Royal Osteoporosis Society shows that universal fracture prevention services in England would save social care services more than £0.25 billion over five years. That is why I support Amendment 206. A clear plan would help people stay independent in their own homes for longer and make a real contribution to fixing the broken social care system that the Government, thankfully, have pledged to reform. I urge my noble friend the Minister to reply positively to this amendment by either accepting it here this evening or bringing back an amendment on Report showing that there is full consideration and full acceptance of it, because osteoporosis and dementia-related issues are definite markers in our society today.
Baroness Barker (LD)
My Lords, I will not speak for very long, but I want to reflect on something. I have shared with noble Lords my experience over the last five years of being a carer for somebody who was increasingly frail, admittedly with a neurological condition. Of all the people whom we met—and we met a lot over five years—there was one person, and one person only, who actually did something proactively that I would say constituted something like a care pathway. He had nothing to do with the NHS. He was Gary from parking, and he said, “You’ve got a blue badge. If you’ve got a blue badge, you might need some help around your house. Would you like me to send the people round? They can look at all the stuff that we can put round your house”. They duly did. That enabled my wife to stay at home and be cared for and looked after securely more than anything else that anybody did over five years. I am so fed up that we get to a point in discussion about the need for integrated care and, of course, it is said that it is the fault of social services not coming to play ball with the NHS. No, it is not. It is about the fact that the NHS does not realise that care does not begin and end at the doors of an acute hospital. Until such time as we all stop reinforcing that, all this stuff about three modal shifts is fantasy. Moving services, and nurses in particular—GPs have a role, but they are overloaded—and co-ordinating things like equipment services are going to do so much more than all the stuff that people talk about. Please, do not say the words “care pathway” without ever understanding who is in charge of making it happen and making it a reality.
Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (CB)
My Lords, in following that very informative and truly insightful comment from the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, I feel I can speak to my amendment, which is about a right to rehabilitation. The people who do the rehabilitation are physiotherapists, occupational therapists and those who will come into the house and put in handrails, stair rails, toilet seats that you can get on and off, and so on. There is strong evidence for a right to rehabilitation. If you are immobile in bed, you lose more than 1% of your muscle mass every day. If you are critically ill, that is doubled: more than 2% every single day. Rehabilitation is one of the most cost-effective yet under-recognised interventions in modern healthcare. It unlocks the value of high-tech, expensive interventions that come about through medicine and surgery. Those who have had good rehabilitation services from day one, if they are in intensive care, do better. They get home earlier; they manage better and they are restored even to a working life, when others who have not had day-one rehabilitation just do not get there. For people who have had a stroke, rehabilitation can reduce the risk of a further stroke by 35% and it gets people back to functioning. For cardiac rehabilitation in England, the uptake is, unfortunately, only 50%—I do not often like to boast about Wales, but I have to here, because ours is 61%. If referral and uptake for cardiac rehabilitation were increased to 85%, it would probably lead to about 50,000 fewer admissions to English hospitals. Beveridge at the end of World War II envisaged a comprehensive health and rehabilitation service. Rehabilitation is fundamental and should be an integral part of anything that we are talking about in healthcare. I ask the Minister: how is progress in rehabilitation going to be measured? As it is a fundamental part of healthcare, will it now be incorporated as a right to rehabilitation within the NHS constitution to deal with those very problems that have been highlighted and allow people to remain in the community, functioning as well as possible?
Lord Shinkwin (Con)
My Lords, I rise to speak in support of Amendment 206 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Hayter. I thank her and her co-signatories for tabling it. Its impressive array of cross-party signatories says all we need to know about how much the issue of fracture prevention services matters to your Lordships’ House. I will not rehearse the compelling arguments already made. As noble Lords know, I speak as someone who lives with a condition that makes my bones prone to fracture. I therefore empathise from lived experience with those who live with osteoporosis, for example. They deserve better than to be fobbed off with Whitehall jargon designed to conceal the fact that without an implementation plan and monitoring, the Government will not keep their promise to them to roll out fracture prevention services by 2030. This amendment provides an opportunity for the Government to discard the fig leaf of warm words and instead show that they recognise their duty to keep their word. I hope the Minister knows that your Lordships’ House will be united in applauding the Government should they do so. Today marks 11 years to the day since my introduction to your Lordships’ House. I struggle to recall another domestic policy issue in that time that has brought together so many otherwise disparate voices in your Lordships’ House. Commentators increasingly predict an early general election, so I close with this question to the Minister. Why on earth would any Government want to head into another election with this albatross of a broken promise around their neck? It just does not make sense. Surely, they want to be able to show to the electorate—particularly to people with bone conditions such as mine, or with osteoporosis, and their families—that they have kept their promise. At the moment, sadly, they absolutely cannot do that. The beauty of this amendment, so ably advanced by the noble Baroness, Lady Hayter, and her co-signatories, is that accepting it, if not today then before Report, would enable the Government to prove that they have kept their word. So I urge the Minister to show in her response that the Government are determined to do right by people with conditions such as mine—and before the Prime Minister fires the starting gun for the next general election.
Baroness Royall of Blaisdon (Lab)
My Lords, I am the last person before the Front Benches. When the noble Lord, Lord Black, was describing his mother, he could have been talking about my mother. She was a wonderful woman from whom I inherited many great things—along with osteoporosis, which was not so good. I give a shout-out to the Chelsea and Westminster Hospital, which is brilliant and has a fantastic rheumatology department, and to the Royal Osteoporosis Society, with which it works hand in glove. It has all been said, but I wish to place on record my full support for Amendment 206. I look forward to the Minister saying that the implementation plan will be along quite soon, that there will be a full strategy and that we look forward to there no longer being a postcode lottery for people with osteoporosis because we know that there will be fracture liaison services throughout the country. I thank my noble friend in advance for what she is going to say—or what I hope she is going to say.
Baroness Pidgeon (LD)
My Lords, I have added my name to Amendments 206 and 245. I am delighted to support the noble Baroness, Lady Hayter of Kentish Town, and commend her work in this area, along with that of the noble Lord, Lord Black, and the noble Baroness, Lady Cass. The case has been made very clearly, and investing to save is something the Government should like. It is so clear. The figures that the noble Lord, Lord Black, set out are quite astonishing. I am grateful to the Royal Osteoporosis Society for its campaigning on universal access to fracture liaison services. It is wonderful that the Government have committed to this. However, there are real and serious concerns about how the Government have reported progress towards universal fracture prevention services, including through Questions and Answers in this House. There have been several since I took over this brief before the summer. Ministers have cited figures suggesting 92% coverage in England, based on 23 out of 25 integrated care boards having at least one service. These are merged, larger ICBs, so some areas have had no change in service, but are now technically claimed to have a service as part of their larger ICB area. This is a bit like the point I made in Committee the other week: when is a trolley not counted as a trolley? When it has had its wheels removed and it becomes a bed. It is playing with statistics, rather than the reality on the ground that people experience. What matters is the proportion of patients reached, not simply whether a service exists. The point made by the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, about community delivery is an important aspect to ensure the accessibility of this service. The Office for Statistics Regulation recently responded to concerns about these figures, warning that inconsistent reporting could confuse the public about the Government’s commitment and progress towards delivering it. The OSR has called on the department to clarify what it means by coverage and to consider publishing consistent statistics. That is a serious intervention by the independent regulator. The national audit shows that only 24% of fragility fractures in England are identified by fracture prevention services. That is a very different picture from the 92% that we had cited. This demonstrates why Amendment 206 is needed: it would provide clear milestones, meaningful measures of patient access and regular reporting to Parliament. I think noble Lords can sense the strength of feeling across the Committee in this debate. Will the Government commit to measuring progress by the proportion of eligible patients identified and receiving appropriate care, rather than relying on whether services exist within particular geographical boundaries? Amendment 245 from the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, is about ensuring that ICBs establish and support an integrated frailty pathway across all disciplines. This is important if we are to shift to community and stop constant pressure and crisis in acute settings. Frailty, rather than ageing, is the key issue here, and it needs truly integrated care. The frailty front door model that has been described is key to making this work and preventing those long stays in hospital that I am sure we have all known with loved ones in hospital. We need to rebuild some of those services outside that hospital setting. The noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, set this out so clearly and with such knowledge. I hope the Minister will listen to her expertise and support this important amendment. My noble friend Lady Barker made a clear point to explain the reality of this on the ground. I hope the Minister will respond positively to the amendments in this group and the points that have been made.
Lord Kamall (Con)
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have spoken in this group. I was particularly struck by the contributions of the noble Baronesses, Lady Gerada and Lady Barker, on pathways, by the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay of Llandaff, on rehabilitation, and by my noble friend Lord Shinkwin and the noble Baroness, Lady Royall, who brought their experiences to the debate. In particular, I pay tribute to my noble friend Lord Black and the noble Baroness, Lady Hayter, on their persistence on fracture liaison services. The reason why they are so persistent is that we have not really had acceptable answers, frankly. What they are asking for is an example, in practice, of this whole shift from treatment to prevention. Perhaps noble Lords can think of a better example; I hope I will not get lots of emails from other people saying there are better examples. If you can identify and treat osteoporosis following an initial fracture, that can prevent further fractures, reduce hospital admissions, help people remain independent and, perhaps topically, help people to enter, remain in or re-enter work.
Just before the general election, the previous Conservative Government made a commitment to universal liaison services by 2030. The then shadow Secretary of State for Health and Social Care matched that commitment. This is not a particularly party-political issue when you had the Government of the day and the then Opposition, and the now Government of the day and the now Opposition, making this commitment. It seems one of those issues where successive Governments have been reluctant to spend a little bit of money now to save much more money in the medium or long term, perhaps out of fear that the other side might take the credit. This is one of those issues that takes me back to the work of Buchanan and Tullock on public choice theory, when you take the romance out of politics and look at how politicians act in their own self-interest rather than the public interest.
All noble Lords are asking for is answers to the questions raised in Amendment 206. Will the department set implementation milestones, set interim annual targets and report on progress between now and 2030? Can the Minister tell noble Lords who will be accountable for any failure to meet these targets and how they will make sure there is sufficient feedback to ensure that they get back on the road or continue to make progress towards the 2030 target? Can the Minister also reassure noble Lords that it will not be about the number of fracture liaison services in ever-growing ICBs but will be about the percentage of patients or the number of patients treated, on the point made by the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon?
Accepting Amendment 206, or the Government coming forward with their own amendment, could ensure that there is truly universal coverage of fracture liaison services by 2030, for which the noble Baroness, Lady Hayter of Kentish Town, and my noble friend Lord Black have campaigned for so long. For these reasons, we look forward to the Minister’s response.
Baroness Hyde of Bemerton (Lab)
I am grateful to noble Lords for raising this important issue, and to the many noble Lords who spoke with such passion and from their personal experience on it. I will do my best to address all the points raised by noble Lords. I also take the opportunity to thank Gary for his kindness and pragmatism towards the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, and her family. I turn first to Amendment 94B, tabled by my noble friend Lord Campbell-Savours and moved so ably by my noble friend Lady Hayter. We know that MSK conditions affect almost 18 million people in England, as of the 2023 figures. They cause great pain, stiffness and disability, and really affect quality of life. As the noble Lord, Lord Black of Brentwood, raised, those conditions can be costly in every sense. We agree that it is important that people can access services to manage their condition and maintain independence. ICBs are responsible for commissioning services, including MSK services, according to local need. In doing so, they should consider health inequalities and how services can support prevention, diagnosis and treatment, and have due regard to relevant strategies. Further, we are expanding access to MSK physical activity hubs in the community, providing physical activity interventions to adults with MSK conditions to reduce pain and fatigue, improve mobility and promote well-being. Existing work is under way and national guidance already supporting ICBs to plan, commission and improve MSK services. We do not believe, therefore, that an additional statutory duty is necessary. I welcome my noble friend Lady Hayter’s support for the Government’s commitment to rolling out fracture liaison services by 2030. I also welcome the commitment expressed across your Lordships’ Committee by many noble Lords, including the noble Baronesses, Lady Ritchie, Lady Royall and Lady Chisholm, and the noble Lords, Lord Black and Lord Shinkwin, reflecting the cross-party nature of the support and the commitment to rolling out FLS by 2030. I was asked many questions about that, and I confirm that we can offer a meeting ahead of Report to discuss some of the points raised, in particular those raised by my noble friend Lady Hayter and the noble Lord, Lord Kamall. We are working with NHS England to support local systems to deliver high-quality secondary fracture prevention and address the variation in access that noble Lords raised. However, we believe that ICBs are best placed to determine how services are organised to reflect specific population needs. As with all services commissioned by ICBs, this includes taking account of clinical evidence, inequalities, expected benefits and the resources available to ensure that the services commissioned meet the needs of their population demographics. We therefore do not consider that placing a separate statutory requirement on the Secretary of State in this area, as suggested by Amendment 206, is required or proportionate. Our focus is on ensuring that people at risk of fragility fracture can access high-quality prevention, diagnosis and treatment in the context, mentioned by some noble Lords, of those three shifts and the 10-year health plan. The presence of FLS at ICB level is just one measure. Our focus is on ensuring high-quality care for patients, and we are taking action by investing £2.6 million in 20 new state-of-the-art DEXA scanners across the country, building on the first wave of investment of £1.9 million in the past year. The new machines will help diagnose fragile bones earlier and prevent painful, life-changing fractures, particularly among older people and women, who, as noble Lords raised, are disproportionately affected by osteoporosis. We are also supporting the adoption of effective treatments and encouraging local systems to develop services that identify people at highest risk of future fractures and intervene early. I heard the passion when noble Lords were discussing the preventive element in early intervention and identification. I am sure noble Lords are aware that, since 2022, two new drugs have been recommended by NICE for the treatment of osteoporosis in postmenopausal women. Those medications really help strengthen bones, prevent bone loss and reduce the risk of fractures. On Amendment 245, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, we know that frailty can be particularly challenging. It is one of the most significant factors affecting hospital flow and A&E performance. Work is already under way to deliver care that identifies frailty when patients arrive at A&E and connects them to appropriate hospital or community support, as the noble Baroness describes in her amendment. The department and NHS England are already working to identify and support best practice. For example, the front door frailty project, launched in September, is bringing together three NHS trusts to adopt best practice from West Herts, Walsall and Homerton to improve care for people with frailty when they arrive at A&E. This builds on wider work, including the publication this year of the first ever modern service framework for frailty and dementia. I would be happy to update the noble Baroness as this work progresses, but I do not believe that additional statutory duties are needed at this time. Finally, on Amendment 279QK, I assure the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, that we share the aim of ensuring that people can access rehabilitation, but we do not believe that additional legislation is required. We are already working to strengthen the planning, commissioning and delivery of rehabilitation services, including through neighbourhood health, to ensure there are better-integrated services planned around local population health needs. NHS England has developed guidance on a number of rehabilitation areas to support ICBs in their strategic commissioning role. The department will continue to keep effective commissioning of rehabilitation services under review as we develop neighbourhood services. We are using the better care fund to strengthen that joint planning and investment across health. More than £9 billion is being pooled through the better care fund in 2026-27, with a focus on services that help people stay independent for longer, including intermediate care, bringing together rehabilitation, reablement and recovery services as a co-ordinated short-term health and social care offer. Local areas are being asked to align this investment with the development of neighbourhood health services, helping to ensure that the right capacity is available to prevent avoidable hospital and care home admissions, and to support timely discharge. Finally, I come to the point made by the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, about community services. It is for local employers to determine their workforce needs based on demand and capacity in their area. All provider organisations are currently embracing opportunities to drive productivity through the use of new technology, prevention and some service redesign. As I have previously highlighted, the modern service framework for frailty and dementia is due to be published later this year—which, by my calculations, means within the next six weeks—and I hope this will assure noble Lords that work is underway to improve and strengthen services in this area. I finish by congratulating the noble Lord, Lord Shinkwin, on his 11th anniversary of being in this House.
Baroness Hayter of Kentish Town (Lab)
I thank all noble Lords who have spoken, who have shown that there is support for this from across the Committee. I might say to the noble Lord, Lord Black, and my noble friend Lady Royall that their parents gave them not just a susceptibility to osteoporosis but a certain feistiness, and I would congratulate those mothers. I also thank the noble Baronesses, Lady Chisholm and Lady Barker, the noble Lord, Lord Shinkwin, my noble friend Lady Ritchie, and the doctors the noble Baronesses, Lady Gerada and Lady Finlay, for their support. I also thank the Front Benches—in particular, the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, who put her name to Amendment 206, as well as the noble Lord, Lord Kamall, and my noble friend Lady Hyde. As the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, said, we are an ageing society and that is a triumph, but it brings problems: it brings more fractures, more vulnerability, more frailty. Therefore, this is more urgent than when the Labour Party originally made this promise. It really has to be done. My noble friend said that the ICBs have a responsibility to consider this, but they are not actually delivering it, and they are not going to deliver without a carrot; that is perhaps the kindest word—a kick is another way of putting it. We have to look to the Government to do this. You cannot just want these services; you have to will it. In the words of the noble Lord, Lord Black, you have to fire the starting gun, and we have not got the starting gun. It is not good enough to say that they have concern and that they need to take it into account, because by themselves they are not doing what is needed. Therefore, we need to do some talking, as I think that local services do not realise how much this will save the NHS. I appreciate the offer of a meeting before Report, because at the moment I still think we may need to bring this back. As I said at the beginning, that is not what we want to do. If we could have the meeting with a piece of paper like the one in my hand, with a plan on it, that might keep us happy. I hope the noble Lord, Lord Campbell-Savours, has been watching this—I am sure that he has—and I know that he would like to bring his amendment back on Report, but for the moment I beg leave to withdraw Amendment 94B.
Amendment 94B withdrawn.
Clause 23 agreed.
Clause 24 agreed.
Baroness in Waiting/Government Whip (Baroness Dacres of Lewisham) (Lab)
My Lords, the usual channels have agreed a short break in proceedings. I beg to move that the Committee be adjourned during pleasure for up to 40 minutes. We will therefore resume at 8.24 pm.
Sitting suspended.
Clause 25: Neighbourhood health plan
Amendment 95
Moved by
95: Clause 25, page 18, line 17, at end insert— “(2B) A neighbourhood health plan must set out, by reference to the assessed needs and the respective functions of the responsible local authority and its partner integrated care boards—(a) the changes proposed in the pattern of health services, care and support to strengthen prevention, early intervention and support in people’s homes and communities,(b) how the bodies propose to exercise their commissioning and other relevant functions to achieve those changes, (c) the workforce, provider and community capacity required to deliver the proposed changes and the arrangements for developing that capacity,(d) the resources required, including any proposed reallocation of resources and investment required during transition,(e) any material difference in financial incentives, costs or benefits between the bodies which could impede the proposed changes, and the arrangements proposed to address it, and(f) how progress in implementing the changes and their effects on outcomes for people will be assessed.(2C) In preparing the matters required by subsection (2B), the responsible local authority and its partner integrated care boards must have regard to the need to maintain continuity and safe access to necessary services during transition.”Member's explanatory statement This amendment would require neighbourhood health plans to explain how the statutory partners intend to develop preventive and community-based models of care and support, and how commissioning, resources, capacity and financial arrangements will support the proposed changes. It would also require attention to transitional investment, service continuity and assessment of progress.
Baroness Tyler of Enfield (LD)
My Lords, I shall speak to my Amendments 95, 96 and 98. This is an important group of amendments, primarily around neighbourhood health plans. It takes forward some of the earlier discussions and debates that we have been having about integration and specifically addresses the architecture locally for trying to join everything up. My amendments address three connected issues about neighbourhood health plans: how the shift towards community care will be delivered; how unpaid carers will be supported; and what outcome those plans should achieve. I welcome the Government’s ambition to move care closer to home and to strengthen prevention, but the history of NHS reform tells us that ambition alone does not shift resources. It is telling that, in a Parliamentary Answer last month, the Government confirmed that between 2015 and 2025 the share of NHS commissioning expenditure going to acute services increased from 38.4% to 42.6%, while the share going to primary medical care fell from 8.8% to 8.3%. Those shifts are not really in the directions that we would wish to see. That is why my Amendment 95 matters. It would ask statutory partners to explain how commissioning, investment, workforce and provider capacity would support the changes that they are proposing. In particular, it would place an obligation on them to explain how statutory partners intend to develop preventative and community-based services, the commissioning and workforce arrangements required, and how resources and financial incentives would support the proposed changes. This would recognise that sometimes—social care is actually a good example here—investment by one partner generates savings for another. For example, if a local authority decides to invest in reablement or more care at home, the benefits may often appear in reduced demand for hospital services. There needs to be a way of taking all that into account. It is important to say that this amendment does not prescribe a particular service model or require an arbitrary transfer of resource; it asks local partners to explain how their intended changes will be delivered while safeguarding continuity of care. In responding to this amendment, will the Minister explain whether and how every neighbourhood health plan will be expected to identify the workforce, the provider capacity and the investment needed to develop the proposed shifts? Amendment 96 concerns unpaid carers, and I thank the noble Baronesses, Lady Hollins and Lady Pitkeathley, for adding their names to it. As a reminder, the Carers UK 2025 survey found that just 14% of carers responding felt that they had been asked about their ability and willingness to provide care during the hospital discharge process. We all know, because we talked about this earlier, what problems unpaid carers face. Indeed, in an earlier group I had an amendment about the identification of unpaid carers, because a carer may first become known to a GP, a hospital or a community health service. There should be an opportunity to recognise their needs, provide information and connect them with the appropriate support. Identification is important but not sufficient; it has to be about linking them up with the support available. The Care Act 2014 already establishes assessment responsibilities for adult carers, and the Children Act provides a separate arrangement for young carers and parent carers. My Amendment 96 would not transfer those responsibilities to the NHS; it would require neighbourhood plans to describe how services will connect identification—the subject of my amendment in an earlier group—with information, assessment and support, including arrangements for carers’ own physical and mental health and well-being. When the Minister responds on this amendment, can she explain what the Government’s plans are to ensure that identifying unpaid carers leads to appropriate information, assessment and support?
Finally, I turn very briefly to my Amendment 98, which addresses the wider purposes of care. Again, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Pitkeathley, for adding her name to it. The Care Act well-being principle recognises that good care is about more than treatment or avoiding hospital admissions; it is also about independence, dignity, relationships, participation and a feeling of control over everyday life. These purposes need to be visible in neighbourhood health planning, not overshadowed by NHS activity measures.
Amendment 98 asks statutory partners to have regard to the Care Act’s well-being purposes when preparing their neighbourhood health plans. Again, this is not about creating a new individual assessment regime or transferring those duties to integrated care boards but rather making the well-being purpose of care a key consideration in joint planning.
I am pleased to say that the Local Government Association supports these three amendments. It is worth mentioning that the LGA has raised a specific concern about the replacement of joint local health and well-being strategies with neighbourhood health plans. Where we have existing strategies, they provide a framework for locally determined priorities extending well beyond NHS services to social care, housing, public health and the wider determinants of health.
I end by asking the Minister this. How will the Government ensure that those wider priorities that go beyond NHS services, and the strategic role of health and well-being boards, which are going to be retained, are preserved in these new arrangements? For example, will the guidance require existing commitments to be carried forward or changes to be explained? It would be good to know how these new arrangements will work. I beg to move.
Baroness Scott of Needham Market (LD)
My Lords, I tabled Amendment 97, but I start by saying that I agree with every word that has just been said by my noble friend Lady Tyler. My Amendment 97 and the associated Amendment 99 concern the development of neighbourhood health plans and, in particular, how those plans will address the needs of people living with long-term, complex or fluctuating health conditions. Like everyone else, I welcome the Government’s ambition to bring healthcare closer to their communities, but that will not of itself necessarily be enough. We need to use this opportunity to improve access for people who find it very difficult to leave their homes or who are unable to leave their homes at all. Given that I have spoken about it in Committee, the Minister will know that I have a lot of experience of working with people who have ME. Their experience demonstrates how important it is to get this right. Action for ME’s Big Survey found that 82% of respondents with severe or very severe ME have received no follow-up care, no monitoring and no review, either from their GP or their specialist team. This is deeply concerning. Back in 2021, after a very hard-fought campaign, the NICE guidelines for ME were changed. They recommend that people with severe or very severe illness should be offered home visits for assessment and care planning. However, five years later, we find that these recommendations are still not being implemented remotely consistently. After three years, only 28% of NHS trusts and integrated care boards had implemented the updated NICE guidelines. This illustrates the wider problem, whereby national guidance for any kind of condition can set out what good care should look like but, without clear local responsibilities and accountability, there is no guarantee that patients will receive it. Amendment 97 would require neighbourhood health plans to explicitly set out how the needs of people with long-term, complex or fluctuating health conditions are to be met. Amendment 99, in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Londesborough, and which I have signed, would strengthen the guidance underpinning those plans, including provision for identifying unmet needs, establishing appropriate clinical pathways, assessing workforce and service capacity, and monitoring progress. These are practical and proportionate requirements that would not prescribe a single model of care but help ensure that local areas properly consider the needs of patients who are currently, and may continue to be, overlooked. I would be grateful if the Minister could explain how the Government intend to ensure that neighbourhood health plans identify and address the needs of people with complex and fluctuating conditions, particularly those who are housebound or bedbound. I would welcome clarification on how local authorities and integrated care boards will be held accountable when those needs are not being adequately addressed.
Lord Londesborough (CB)
My Lords, I will speak to Amendment 97, in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Scott of Needham Market, to which I added my name. I will speak also to my Amendment 99 in this group, to which the noble Baroness has put her name, for which I am grateful. Both these amendments seek to strengthen Clause 25 and address the critical question of whether the neighbourhood health framework is sufficiently clear about people whose conditions require continuing co-ordinating support but may not always be visible in immediate access or activity measures. The answer, in short, is no, and this is the view held by a host of dedicated organisations, including Alzheimer’s Research UK, Parkinson’s UK, the Migraine Trust and the Neurological Alliance, to name a few. Amendment 97 seeks to build on the existing architecture of neighbourhood care by requiring neighbourhood health plans to set out how the needs of people with long-term, complex or fluctuating health conditions are to be met—in particular, the needs of those suffering from neurological conditions, which impact one out of every six people in England and span more than 600 different conditions, ranging from sudden onset issues such as stroke or traumatic brain injury to progressive diseases such as Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s, to intermittent conditions such as migraine and epilepsy. I should declare that I suffer from migraine and that epilepsy impacts one of my children, but is, thankfully, well controlled. With this hugely significant and diverse group in mind, Amendment 99 would require guidance issued by the Secretary of State under Clause 25(4) to cover the identification of unmet needs, clinical pathways, workforce and service capacity, and accountability arrangements for services supporting those with long-term, fluctuating health conditions. These amendments would support earlier recognition, co-ordinated care and appropriate planning across primary care, and community and specialist services, while preserving local flexibility. Crucially, they would set measurable improvement objectives and make organisational responsibility clear. These amendments are proportionate. They would strengthen the existing NHP process, rather than creating a separate, disease-specific plan or treatment entitlement. By keeping the legal duty broad and non-exhaustive, they would avoid disease-by-disease legislation. Crucially, these amendments would give neurological conditions a clear policy home within neighbourhood planning. Without greater clarity, under-recognised conditions risk being overlooked within broad population priorities. A prime example of this is migraine: a neurological condition that impacts 10 million of us across the UK, for which treatment is underfunded, inconsistent and, at times, misguided, and shows huge regional disparities. Migraine is generally a high-volume but low-complexity condition, meaning that, if optimal treatment pathways are followed efficiently, capacity can be freed up in other parts of the health service. Let me illustrate this. The NHS currently spends around £150 million a year on directly treating migraine, a condition that carries an annual cost to this country of £10 billion to £12 billion, of which more than £1 billion is incurred by the health service itself. How so? We currently have more than 5 million undiagnosed migraineurs, resulting in 2.5 million to 3 million primary care appointments in England per year, 40,000 hospital admissions per year and a huge increase in visits to A&E since the pandemic. Only a third of people diagnosed with migraine are prescribed basic preventive medication within one year of diagnosis. This is hugely inefficient and frustrating, both for the patient and the NHS. The impact on the workforce and the economy is eye-watering, with lost working days and reduced productivity currently running at £8 billion to £10 billion a year. Migraine represents an important test for whether the reforms in the Bill will improve care. As for many neurological conditions, there is currently a postcode lottery of care for migraine. The Migraine Trust tells us that only 26 of England’s 42 integrated care systems have a specialised headache clinic. In conclusion, Amendments 95 and 97 offer critically needed safeguards during NHS restructuring and health devolution—particularly during the transition period, with the uncertainty around national clinical leadership and analytical capacity—and where the less visible conditions lack clear ownership. I hope the Minister and her department will accept these amendments as both constructive and proportionate, or at the very least set out equally robust commitments through statutory guidance.
Baroness Manzoor (Con)
My Lords, Clause 25 concerns neighbourhood health plans and the guidance covering their implementation. I agree that they need to be strengthened to ensure that they lead to measurable improvements in patient care rather than becoming another layer of NHS bureaucracy. I support the general thrust of all these amendments, particularly Amendments 95 and 100. Amendment 95 was so ably and comprehensively covered by the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler of Enfield, and I have no doubt that Amendment 100 will be comprehensively covered by the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada. These amendments could improve the Bill in five ways. First, they would strengthen accountability—today and on other days in Committee, we have heard a lot about accountability and transparency—by requiring local authorities and integrated care boards to publish clear objectives, responsibilities and annual progress reports. Secondly, they would guarantee meaningful public involvement by explicitly including patients, carers, voluntary organisations and seldom-heard communities in designing and reviewing plans. Thirdly, they would protect clinical leadership by requiring GPs, nurses, pharmacists and other front-line professionals to contribute to decisions. Fourthly, they would provide adequate resources by ensuring that plans are supported by identified funding, workforce capacity and realistic implementation timescales. Fifthly and finally, they would ensure that outcomes are measured. We have all been talking about outcomes, which are fundamental and run through the 10-year strategic plan. Measuring outcomes and requiring measurable targets covering prevention, waiting times, access, health inequalities and patient experience are important. Crucially, the neighbourhood health plan should be a statutory delivery commitment, not simply a document that the organisation must have regard to. The Secretary of State should issue guidance setting minimum standards while allowing local flexibility. This would make Clause 25 more practical, transparent and genuinely accountable to local communities. I hope the Minister is able to give the thrust of these amendments and arguments further consideration before Report.
Baroness Gerada (CB)
My Lords, I will speak to Amendment 100 in my name. I thank Impact on Urban Health for its support. I was struck by the speeches of the noble Lord, Lord Londesborough, and other noble Lords about neurological conditions and the need for joined-up care. I have sat though many of the debates on the Bill, and this further reinforces my view that we need a fundamental shift in how we look at the NHS and how we use our hospitals. Hospitals are not just places that people go to but part of our local community, where we do prevention. We need to look at how we use our teams of staff and move consultants and nurses out of hospitals to support integration, and how we use the resources, the money and the expertise.
Everybody I have listened to over the last few days has their own special case for why their individual disease or patient group requires special treatment. Having been a GP for 40 years, I believe we need a fundamental review of how we use the resources that we have. Forgive me for saying that, but I was very struck and learned a lot about neurological diseases.
My Amendment 100 is very simple. When local authorities and integrated care boards draw up neighbourhood health plans, it would ask them to take reasonable steps to reduce health inequalities arising from the wider determinants of health and to involve meaningfully the communities that face the greatest barriers to taking part. In parts of south London, where I have worked for my entire career, children living a few streets apart can expect very different life experiences—not because of the care we give in general practice, which I hope is the same for all families, but because of the homes they live in, the air they breathe, the food their families can afford and the money that comes in each month.
Every clinician sees this: the child whose asthma will not settle because the flat is damp; the man whose blood pressure rises because of his debts; the mother who knows what a healthy diet looks like but cannot afford it. Up to a fifth of my time in the consulting room is spent on problems that are not clinical at all. I can prescribe an inhaler; I cannot prescribe a dry home. These are health inequalities. The NHS Health Economics Unit estimates that 80% of a person’s health outcomes are shaped by factors outside the health service. The Government’s ambition for a neighbourhood health service is to move from treating sickness to preventing it. But a plan that looks only at services will treat the consequences of poverty, poor housing and polluted air while leaving their causes untouched. This amendment puts those causes on the table.
The second part of the amendment is about who is in the room. Traditional consultation, which I have been privy to many times as a leader, usually happens through surveys, public meetings and online fora. It reaches people who are already heard. It rarely reaches those who are working two jobs, are caring for relatives or, with good reason, do not trust the authorities that are asking them the question. People from racially minoritised communities are twice as likely to need debt advice as the population as a whole. If they are not involved in shaping a plan, the plan will not work for them. Meaningful involvement means going to where people are—their schools, faith groups and community organisations—and listening before decisions are made, not after.
I welcome the Government’s decision to think again about the abolition of Healthwatch. It would have moved the NHS further away from connecting meaningfully with local communities. However, in the context of the shift from hospital communities, simply retaining Healthwatch will not be enough. This is what Amendment 100 seeks to address, through mandating a focus on the wider determinants of health in neighbourhood health plans and ensuring that local people are meaningfully involved.
This amendment sets no new targets. It asks only for reasonable steps and gives local leaders a clear message that neighbourhood health is about creating health, not only treating illness. Does the Minister accept that neighbourhood health plans should explicitly address health inequalities and the wider determinants of health?
Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (CB)
My Lords, I have Amendment 100A in this group, which goes back to the development of a neighbourhood health plan. It would require a neighbourhood health plan to be a co-production between all those professionals involved, carers and those who can speak for those who need rehabilitation and independent living needs to be addressed. Without co-production, you will not have a meaningful plan. If we are to have service transformation that requires prevention and rehabilitation, it must draw on broad clinical expertise. I am back to arguing for the allied health professions out there in the community—the physios, OTs, speech therapists and so on. This is part of core rehabilitation. It would be great if we could prevent everyone becoming ill or having an accident, but these things happen. Getting them back to living as well as possible is essential if they are to be at home and in the neighbourhood, and if we are going to maximise the benefit. I would like to give one example of AHP-led neighbourhood service planning that happened in Surrey Downs. Physios were present at every level from system leadership to first contact. Rehabilitation is embedded from first contact, so the new approach has driven a fall in GP contacts of 11%; a drop in A&E attendances of 35%; a 20% reduction in overnight hospital stays; and therapy waits have reduced from 18 weeks to three weeks. The care planning is centred on the person’s goals, supported self-management and maintaining independence at home—the independence that the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, spoke powerfully about. The integrated working model, with shared leadership, has enabled the closure of a 35-bed acute ward, a £1 million shift into community services and £2 million in acute savings. We cannot ignore that type of evidence: co-production is essential.
Baroness Barker (LD)
My Lords, I do not want to detain the Committee very long at this time of night. I have Amendment 101, which is borne out of the experience of people who work in HIV, where having strongly worked out partnerships—in terms of prevention and of service giving—that are very much rooted in communities has been a key to the success of what has happened over the last 40 years in HIV treatment and care. I take the words of the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, to heart. We can all plead the various causes and conditions that we care about. I have been using my experience, but I have been trying to do it to attack what I see as a much bigger issue. I have thought about this over the weekend, and I want to crystallise it into one question to the Minister: given the reconfiguration of NHS England and the Department of Health, who is responsible for primary care? Can she just tell us where responsibility or accountability for primary care sits? That seems to be one of the big questions to answer, and it underlines all we have been saying for the last few days.
Baroness Pidgeon (LD)
My Lords, I wish to speak to my Amendment 102, which my noble friend Lady Tyler has also spoken to, which would retain joint local health and well-being strategies. I should declare that I am a vice-president of the Local Government Association. The LGA supports the shift towards neighbourhood health, which offers a clear opportunity to bring services closer to people, support earlier intervention and better reflect the realities of how people experience health and care. Councils, as we know, deliver services for adults and children through social care and public health and have strong influence over other areas—housing, employment, education, and so on. They also hold the relationships to convene partners around shared goals and outcomes, which is really important. Health and well-being boards have a critical role to play in delivering more integrated, preventive and neighbourhood-focused services by looking at prevention, health inequalities and the wider determinants of health, as we have been discussing throughout Committee. Neighbourhood health plans, by contrast, are structured around nationally prescribed outcomes relating to primary care access, planned care and so on. While local priorities can be included, national ones are measured, monitored and given prominence. My amendment therefore supports retaining the joint local health and well-being strategy as the overarching framework, with neighbourhood health plans required to be consistent with it. As I said, this is supported by the Local Government Association. The strategy provides a framework for identifying the priorities that matter most to local communities. I understand that lots of councils have told the LGA that, even if the legislation sets out something different, they will continue with their joint local health and well-being strategy, because it has been so successful in strengthening place-based leadership and partnership working. To give a few examples, Sheffield has a good city strategy for tackling health inequalities and wants to keep working together on it. Southampton describes its strategy as a clear, city-wide framework for improving health and, again, reducing inequalities. It does not see the neighbourhood health plans as a replacement. West Berkshire Council also sees the strategy document as far broader than neighbourhood health plans, setting the overall strategic direction on well-being needed right across West Berkshire. Wokingham Borough, Lancashire and Calderdale councils similarly all feel that this is a far more useful document, and that the neighbourhood health plans could feed into it. Retaining these strategies is consistent with the approach that the Government are setting out through Rewiring the State, shifting to local decision-making power on questions that affect their places. That provides that strategic, place-based bridge between neighbourhood-level delivery and regional decision-making which is so important. In the letter last week from the Minister, the Government said that neighbourhood health plans would continue to cover the core matters currently addressed through the strategies that I have mentioned. However, if so many local authorities say they do not think they do that and intend to continue using their overarching joint strategy, they are clearly not convinced by this replacement neighbourhood plan. I ask the Government to really think about this and see whether there is a role for both in making sure we get the planning right locally. The government guidance should provide greater clarity on purpose, accountability and core functions while allowing the flexibility in there. I fully support the other amendments in this group tabled by my noble friend Lady Tyler, particularly her raising once again the important issue of unpaid carers, and that tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Scott, talking about people with ME. I look forward to the Minister’s response.
Earl Howe (Con)
My Lords, taken together, this group of amendments, supported by some powerful contributions from noble Lords around the Committee, serves to highlight a range of key questions about the way the Government envisage that health services should in future be planned. We have before us a policy programme which in broad terms promises to simplify current structures and lines of accountability. We need to ask whether that promise is being fulfilled. At the moment, ICBs and local authorities work in partnership to produce integrated care strategies which each ICB then develops into a joint forward plan. Alongside this process, we have health and well-being boards producing joint strategic needs assessments and joint health and well-being strategies that set out how local health and care needs are to be addressed. In many areas of the country, this model has proved effective. Nevertheless, it is a parallel planning structure. That means local plans need to be regularly aligned with one another, which can prove cumbersome. The Government now propose for the joint strategic needs assessment to inform a neighbourhood health plan which will replace the joint health and well-being strategy but which, like its predecessor, will be designed to consider how the NHS, local government and their partners can best improve the health and well-being of people in the area. Integrated care partnerships, integrated care strategies and joint forward plans will disappear.
So far, so much simpler—apparently; but we then need to look at the new role being given to ICBs. We know that ICBs are being reduced in number to cover a much wider footprint than they do at present. We are also told that one of their jobs will be to produce a population health improvement plan. As an ICB will typically cover an area that envelops several local authorities, each population health improvement plan will need to take account of multiple joint strategic needs assessments and neighbourhood health plans. In other words, just like in the current system, there will need to be a constant process of alignment and reconciliation between the different plans.
Being entirely frank, I am not at all sure that this new framework sounds markedly simpler than the structure of decision-making we have at the moment. How exactly will neighbourhood health plans fit into these wider local strategies that ICBs will have to produce?
At the heart of this is the concern raised by my noble friend Lady Manzoor about blurred accountability. The neighbourhood health plan is put together by a health and well-being board, which sits under the umbrella of a local authority, which is the democratically elected commissioner of social care services in an area. I am not clear about how the respective functions, roles and responsibilities of the NHS, on the one hand, and elected local authorities, on the other, are intended to interrelate, especially bearing in mind the wider responsibilities of local authorities for public health and the wider determinants of health more generally.
The picture becomes more complicated when we look at healthcare provision. We are told that new neighbourhood provider structures will be created, both at a local level covering around 50,000 people and at a larger level covering 250,000 people, and that new integrated health organisations or IHOs will hold contracts for care across the whole population. These IHOs will sit between the neighbourhood providers and the ICBs.
I look at the amendments in this group and can well understand why the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, is asking about the extent to which the voluntary sector, along with community providers and social enterprises, will be able to input into neighbourhood health plans. The noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, asks a similar question in her amendment on allied health professionals. She also rightly raises the issue of prevention and rehabilitation for those with care needs.
Input from across the range of health and care providers is surely an essential ingredient of any neighbourhood health plan worth its name, since they are the organisations that will help to form the bedrock of health and care provision in a given area and the partnerships that need to be created. I also very much welcome the reminder from the noble Lord, Lord Londesborough, of the importance of local plans taking account of unmet need, an issue closely bound up with health inequalities, which is the subject of Amendment 100 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada. I am equally behind the concerns of the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, about social care and unpaid carers.
It would be helpful if the Minister could tell us whether these are the sorts of things that will, in due course, be covered by the guidance to which she referred in her helpful letter of 11 November. I expect that the answer to that will be yes, but it is a lot to cover in guidance. I look forward to hearing from her about how these arrangements will work in practice, how duplication in the planning of healthcare provision will be avoided and, in basic terms, how these new structures will fit together in a way that does full justice to the needs of local populations.
Baroness Merron (Lab)
My Lords, I am grateful for this debate and for the group of amendments relating to neighbourhood health, not least because it is the core purpose of our shift from hospital to community and deserves consideration. On Amendment 102, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, the retention of a requirement for health and well-being boards to publish both a joint local health and well-being strategy and a neighbourhood health plan could well cause unnecessary duplication. The reality is that neighbourhood health plans will be prepared jointly by the responsible local authority and its partner integrated care boards through the health and well-being board, and have to be informed by an assessment of local population needs. It is important that we avoid that risk of confusion. I take the point about things working well and the examples she gave, but we are trying to build on the strength of that to make sure we see things in better shape across the country. The noble Earl, Lord Howe, also asked about this whole area, so I hope he will take those comments as answers to his points too. On some of the other points raised by the noble Baroness, I reiterate that neighbourhood health plans are intended to cover those core matters that are currently addressed through the joint local health and well-being strategies. That includes improving health and well-being, reducing health inequalities, supporting prevention and addressing the wider determinants of health, a point rightly spoken to by the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada. Neighbourhood health plans will continue to set out how local government, integrated care boards and their partners will work to improve the health and well-being of their population, drawing on public health, social care and wider local priorities, which is what noble Lords are rightly seeking. I will come back to the point raised about co-production. In developing their plans, health and well-being boards have to involve the people who live or work in the area. The Government will support implementation through guidance developed with local systems. On Amendment 101, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, the neighbourhood health and strategic commissioning frameworks are clear. ICBs and local authorities should develop neighbourhood health plans with wider partners, as I have said, including, importantly, the voluntary, community and social enterprise sector. Statutory guidance on joint strategic needs assessments, which must underpin those plans, also emphasises voluntary sector partnership working. If I understood the question the noble Baroness asked, which was straightforward, I will answer straightforwardly and confirm that ICBs are responsible for commissioning primary care services for their local areas—it sits firmly there. On Amendment 100A, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, who raised the point about co-production, I can reassure her that the neighbourhood health framework sets an expectation that ICBs will work with clinicians, such as allied health professionals, which we heard about in an earlier group, to develop those plans, and recognises the importance of prevention and rehabilitation. Existing statutory duties concerning the prevention and delay of care needs and support for people with care needs will also continue to apply. On Amendments 96 and 98, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, supporting people with care needs and unpaid carers—the groups to which she referred—is a priority of this Government. The existing Care Act 2014 has duties that require local authorities to promote the well-being of people with care needs and carers, and integration of care and support with health services. I assure the noble Baroness that we expect local partners to consider the needs of unpaid carers where these have been identified through the joint strategic needs assessment, alongside other locally identified needs. I agree with the principle raised in Amendment 95 by the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler. The plans will inform the decisions of the responsible local authority and its partner integrated care board or boards, but they should not prescribe individual commissioning decisions. We do not believe that the level of detail being sought belongs in primary legislation. The noble Baroness also asked about practical deliverability in respect of workforce and service capacity. They are important considerations, of course, if we are to deliver effective neighbourhood health services. As noble Lords will be aware, our approach is to ensure flexibility for local areas to determine how they plan their workforce and capacity. In March, we published a neighbourhood health framework to empower local leaders to develop and scale the neighbourhood health services that they need. The framework outlines the national minimum goals—that goes to some of the points raised by the noble Baroness, Lady Manzoor—and the objectives of neighbourhood health. I turn to Amendment 97, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Scott, and Amendment 99, tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Londesborough. I am grateful to the noble Baroness for speaking to her experience of ME, and to the noble Lord for raising neurological conditions. I recall very well his Question in the Chamber, which I was pleased to answer, on migraine, which I know he has much personal experience of. To reiterate, neighbourhood health plans need to be informed by the needs of all the people who live in an area. I know that noble Lords have heard me say this before, but it is our view that prescribing individual conditions or cohorts in primary legislation, which is proposed in the amendment, would reduce the flexibility of local partners to respond to their populations’ particular needs and priorities. It is not a point of ignoring the issues that the noble Lord and the noble Baroness raise; it is about preserving the flexibility to meet the needs properly in the way that they describe. Our neighbourhood health framework builds on existing duties and frameworks that encompass those people who have long-term, complex or fluctuating health conditions, which is a great number of people indeed. The neighbourhood health framework supports ICBs and local authorities to develop locally led neighbourhood health plans. On the issue of accountability, the arrangements that I have outlined do not replace existing accountability for delivery. A number of noble Lords spoke about accountability. To reiterate, it is the case that ICBs are accountable for the NHS services that they commission, and local authorities remain accountable for the services for which they are responsible. Health and well-being boards provide the collective leadership for local neighbourhood health plans, bringing partners together around shared outcomes. National minimum goals and measures, as I mentioned earlier, provide a consistent basis for tracking progress across the country. I very much hear what noble Lords are saying about how we know, how it is delivered, and how accountability is applied.
Finally, I turn to Amendment 100 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada. Reducing inequalities is absolutely a core objective of neighbourhood health. Both the neighbourhood health framework and the strategic commissioning framework for ICBs already emphasise the need and requirement for engagement with seldom heard and underserved people and communities. The Bill requires local authorities and their partner ICBs to involve local people and the communities that they serve when they are preparing plans.
Any Secretary of State guidance to which local authorities and ICBs must have regard will duly reflect the Secretary of State’s requirement, strengthened through the Bill, to have regard to reducing inequalities in access to health services and outcomes achieved through their provision. In my view, therefore, the Health Bill strengthens the focus on reducing inequalities.
Baroness Tyler of Enfield (LD)
My Lords, the hour is late, so I shall keep it as brief as I can. I thank the Minister for the responses she has given, the questions she has answered and some of the explanations she has given, because I found them helpful. I am left, though, with the feeling—I think it was something the noble Earl, Lord Howe, said—that it really is not that straightforward. It all feels quite complicated. I am left with a sense that there is still more thinking to be done about how we are going to get this absolutely right so that these local neighbourhood plans—which are so important and need to be fully joined up, with all the right people involved, all the people who need to have a seat around the table and their voice heard—really are place-based and looking at population needs and how it all fits together. There is a lot to do and a lot to think through. I feel that we need to have another look at it to see whether we can get it a little more straightforward and easier to understand and explain. I suspect that we probably will return to this issue on Report, but I thank everyone who contributed and beg leave to withdraw the amendment.
Amendment 95 withdrawn.
Amendments 96 to 100A not moved.
Clause 25 agreed.
Amendments 101 and 102 not moved.
Clauses 26 and 27 agreed.
Clause 28: Special Health Authorities: establishment and exercise of functions
Amendments 103 and 104
Moved by
103: Clause 28, page 20, line 27, at end insert— “(b) after subsection (5) insert—“(5A) The power under subsection (1) may not be used for the purpose of establishing a body that performs functions only or mainly in respect of Wales.””Member’s explanatory statement This spells out that the power in section 28 of the NHS Act 2006 cannot be used to create a Wales-only Special Health Authority. It is needed because of the removal of the territorial restriction in section 271, which limited the exercise of the power to England.
104: Clause 28, page 20, line 30, at end insert— “(c) after subsection (2) insert—“(3) In this section a reference to a Special Health Authority is to a Special Health Authority which—(a) performs functions only or mainly in respect of England, or(b) neither performs functions only or mainly in respect of England, nor performs functions only or mainly in respect of Wales.””Member’s explanatory statement This clarifies that the power to make regulations about the delegation of Special Health Authority functions is not exercisable in relation to Wales-only Special Health Authorities. It is needed because of the removal of the territorial restriction in section 271, which limited the exercise of the power to England.
Amendments 103 and 104 agreed.
Clause 28, as amended, agreed.
Clause 29 agreed.
Amendment 104ZA
Moved by
104ZA: After Clause 29, insert the following new Clause— “Special Health Authority hosting NHS regional teams: accountability and finance(1) A Special Health Authority may not be established for the purpose of hosting the regional teams of NHS England until the Secretary of State has laid before each House of Parliament a report setting out—(a) the functions to be exercised by that Authority, including any functions of the Secretary of State,(b) the one-off and annual costs of that Authority,(c) the person who will be accounting officer for that Authority,(d) each post in the Department of Health and Social Care to be held at Permanent Secretary level, and the responsibilities of each such post, including for overseeing that Authority,(e) the post holder or post holders to be designated as accounting officer for health service expenditure, including expenditure by that Authority,(f) which post holder will have final responsibility, under the Secretary of State, for that expenditure and for the performance of the regional teams, and how any disagreement between post holders about those matters will be resolved,(g) the annual cost of the posts in paragraph (d) and their supporting offices, compared with the equivalent costs in the Department and NHS England on 31 March 2025,(h) an estimate of the transition costs of the arrangements of which that Authority forms part, including exit, information technology and estates costs,(i) the staffing assumptions on which the expected annual savings from those arrangements are based, including whether staff of that Authority are counted, and(j) an updated impact assessment reflecting those matters.(2) An Authority established for that purpose must be abolished no later than two years after the day on which it is established, unless regulations made by statutory instrument, by the Secretary of State, extend that period.(3) A statutory instrument containing regulations under this section may not be made unless a draft of the instrument has been laid before, and approved by a resolution of, each House of Parliament.”Member’s explanatory statement This new Clause is a probing amendment that would require a report to Parliament before a special health authority for NHS regional teams is established.
Lord Scriven (LD)
My Lords, I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Stevens of Birmingham, and the noble Earl, Lord Howe, for adding their names to Amendment 104ZA. Between them, they have been in charge of legislation for NHS England and have been in the most senior leadership roles of running it. I, for one, have not had enough of experts, so I am looking forward to what they have to say on this amendment. This amendment is about a body that did not exist when this Committee began: the transitional special health authority for NHS England’s seven regional teams, which was announced on 4 November after we debated Clause 1. We are told that it is temporary, yet, according to the Health Service Journal , NHS England’s chief operating officer told staff that the word “transitional” must be used, “not because we’re imagining that it’s a time-limited organisation”. The chief executive of NHS England then said to the same staff that it was time-limited, but no one could say how time-limited. So, it is temporary, but without a time limit. In Whitehall, nothing lasts quite like the temporary. Consider what we do not know about these regional offices and the special health authority. We do not know how many staff will transfer, we do not know its budget, we do not know what it will lead for, and we do not know who will lead it. Will it have a chief executive of its own or seven regional directors reporting upwards? We do not know where it is going to go after the temporary arrangement ends. Does it go back into ICBs, back into the department, to the mayoral authorities or nowhere at all? What we do know is that the regional staff keep their NHS pay and conditions, which a Health Service Journal analysis put at, on average, more than £9,500 a year above the department’s for equivalent posts. I can see the recruitment advert now: “Join the special health authority: better pay, with no end date”. This raises a serious issue about recruitment and retention for roles that are transferred to the department. How would the Government plan for that potential move of staff out of the department into the higher-paid, non-Civil Service roles in the special health authority? Then there are the savings. When abolition was announced, NHS England and the department employed about 19,000 people, and Ministers pledged to halve that. Some 20 months on, it is still almost 17,000. At that rate, the target will be met sometime in the early 2030s, comfortably after the temporary authority has become permanent. The Minister has told this House that the 50% cut is an ambition, not a target. Ministers promised that there would be savings of £1 billion a year by the end of this Parliament, while the restructuring could cost up to £1.3 billion in one-off payments, so the savings are an ambition and the costs are a certainty. Meanwhile, the Government have finally found a waiting list that they can grow: the waiting list for redundancy. Staff in one ICB cluster waited two months for NHS England to sign off their departures. NHS England, which has been abolished, is approving other people’s exits while it is waiting for its own. Perhaps the Minister could give them a target. Could I suggest 18 weeks? What concerns me most are the powers. The Bill hands the Secretary of State a long list of NHS England’s powers, and some new ones also: a broad power to direct ICBs; the appointment, in certain circumstances, of chairs and non-executives of local NHS bodies; and intervention in foundation trusts, including deauthorising them and capping their revenue spending. The Secretary of State can already direct a special health authority to exercise its health service functions, and Clause 28 widens those powers. The letter to all Peers confirms that functions of the Secretary of State can be conferred on this new special health authority. The statement says that it will not exercise national functions. However, directing the ICB in South Yorkshire is not a national function and appointing the chair of an ICB with problems in the south-west is not a national function. These are precisely the regional functions that this body could be given. Think of how inappropriate it would be for a regional office to appoint the chair of a failing ICB and then mark that organisation’s homework on improvement. The Bill even contemplates a special health authority being given the powers to impose financial penalties—a temporary body handing out potentially permanent fines. We are told that abolishing NHS England would bring management of the NHS back into democratic control. It is a curious kind of democratic control that takes powers from one quango, gives them to the Minister and then posts them out to another quango by a direction that neither House votes on. That is why proposed new paragraph (a) asks the Government to say, before the body is created, exactly what functions it will exercise. Let me give noble Lords a concrete example. South Yorkshire has appointed the country’s first deputy mayor for health, Sir Steve Houghton, who also chairs the integrated care board and its £4.6 billion commissioning budget. Here I must correct the record. I spoke earlier to the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, about who he would be accountable to. Having looked again at the Government’s own press release, it says that the role jointly reports to NHS England and the elected mayor. From 1 April, one of those two will not exist. I put the direct question to the Minister: will the new special health authority, via the regional officers, be able to direct him? If the Secretary of State’s powers to direct ICBs is conferred on it, the answer is yes. So who does South Yorkshire’s health commissioner actually work to? Is it the mayor, who people elected; the special health regional office, which nobody elected; the NHS group in the department; or the Secretary of State? Picture the first real disagreement. The mayor wants money moved into prevention. He seeks investment in housing to prevent damp and mould, wanting to keep people out of hospital. The special health authority, via the regional office, wants waiting lists down by March. Only one can win. Who has the final say? If it is the mayor, put it in the Bill. If it is the special health authority regional officers, stop calling this devolution. Devolution where an unelected regional body can overrule an elected mayor is not devolution; it is delegation with a very shiny badge on it.
Lord Hunt of Kings Heath (Lab)
My Lords, the whole point is that, when it comes to the health service, we are talking about delegation because of the national nature of the NHS. If you look at what happened in Greater Manchester, it was delegation and not devolution. We need to be very clear that anything that undermines the national nature of the NHS is always going to cause a problem.
Lord Scriven (LD)
Devolution is not the word that I am using; it is language that the Government are using in selling the Bill. Maybe the Minister can answer the very important point that the noble Lord has just raised. If the answer is that they will work it out together, that is not a governance model; it really is hope over reality. When it goes wrong, the people of Barnsley, Doncaster, Rotherham and Sheffield deserve to know whose door to knock on. That is precisely what proposed new paragraph (f) in this amendment asks: who holds final responsibility and accountability, and how will disagreements be resolved? Above all this, sit three Permanent Secretary-level posts—three people who can claim to have the final word usually means that nobody has it. I can already hear the answer delivered by the Secretary of State at the Dispatch Box when something goes wrong: “This is an operational matter that the NHS group and the regional officers need to do. But it may be the system, so I will undertake an independent review. It will be carried out and lessons will be learned”. I hope the Minister will answer these questions today or in writing before Report. First, on 28 October, when I asked the Minister a direct question about whether a stand-alone body was going to be set up, she told the Committee that the intention was to move all staff into the department. But eight days later, in the other place, a special health authority was already being described as a new regional management tier. I do not question the Minister’s good faith, but when was this decision taken and by whom?
Secondly, which functions of the Secretary of State will be conferred to the new special health authority, by what instrument, and will Parliament see them first?
Thirdly, will the government rule out conferring powers of direction, appointment, intervention or financial penalties to ICBs or trusts? Also, have the Government agreed any other red lines on powers that the special health authority shall not have, and if so, what are they?
Fourthly, how many staff will be transferred to the special health authority, at what cost, and will they count towards the savings?
Fifthly, where will the staff go at the end? According to my reading of Clause 29 of this Bill, they can be moved permanently only to another special health authority or an ICB. They can be lent to the department on a ministerial direction, but they would stay on the authority’s payroll, so the department gets the people, and the savings figures do not have to count them. What ends the special health authority? Who decides and where will the staff end up? Finally, if the authority, or this Bill, is not ready by 1 April, what will happen to those staff on that day?
This amendment would not stop the abolition of NHS England. It asks the Government to tell Parliament what this body will do, what its powers are, what it costs, who answers for it, and to come back to this Parliament if it lasts beyond two years. If it is truly temporary, that will cost the Government nothing to answer. If it is not, they should stop calling it temporary and give Parliament a greater understanding of what is happening. I beg to move.
Lord Stevens of Birmingham (CB)
My Lords, I am very pleased to support the probing amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Scriven. He has laid out just now the questions that the whole of the NHS wants answered. We therefore look forward to the Minister doing so before the night is done. Just as in the 1974 reorganisation discussions around the regional tier, it was inevitable that would find ourselves discussing “tears about tiers”; that is essentially what we are discussing in this group. I could not help but think back to Nick Timmins’ magisterial overview of the history of the National Health Service and all its reorganisations. Of the 1974 reorganisation, he said: “Despite the elephantine gestation … the exercise in the end was hopelessly rushed to tie in with local government reorganisation…. By vesting day, vast armies of administrators still did not have their permanent jobs sorted out. Something fittingly known … as the Grey Book eventually provided the broad outline. It looked beautiful on paper while proving something of a disaster on the ground”. The question is: will we ever learn from our own history? The sorts of practical questions that this probing amendment seeks to elicit are clearly questions that need answering. In many respects, it is a pragmatic decision to establish the regional tier through a special health authority, rather than to try and fold that into a central government department and turn those NHS functions into Civil Service functions. It has been entirely predictable that this would be a question that would need answering. Unfortunately, it has been left until the very last minute, so now, as the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, says, we really need to see the detail. Who will be the chair and the board? What powers will the special health authority have. What will be its size and its budget? In particular, what accountability will exist from the special health authority to the ICBs, the foundation trusts and the NHS trusts in those regions? The reason that this is so important is, in part, that the question of the potentially confused accountabilities that the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, has just raised with reference to South Yorkshire assume a new importance today in the light of the report just published by Alan Milburn. Those who have had the chance to read it will have noted, in paragraph 598, the recommendation that the Greater Manchester and South Yorkshire model, whereby the ICB chair is the mayoral health commissioner, should be universalised across the entire NHS by 2029. Therefore, the governance mechanisms would mean that it would be the mayoral health commissioner who would by default be appointed as the ICB chair. Therefore, the questions posed by the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, about what the accountability is to the mayor and what the accountability is to the Secretary of State, and the challenge from the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath—in his return to the Bevanite doctrine of the unified line of command to the Secretary of State not being in any way confused by our entanglements with local government on perhaps something closer to the Morrisonian model—will need answering, and again we look forward to the Minister doing so in the next half hour. We need to know how the SHA is going to work and how the accountability is set. Since we are not necessarily going to get to the next group of amendments on appointments tonight, a solution to a different problem may be available pragmatically through this special health authority. It seems entirely inappropriate that the Secretary of State in Whitehall would personally make over 1,000 appointments to foundation trusts for non-executive directors and chairs, and indeed to NHS-run ICBs. The obvious home for that function would be the special health authority, which was the model adopted through the NHS appointments process from 2001 until it was abolished in 2012. That way, it could be regulated by the Commissioner for Public Appointments. Appointments would be made on merit after a fair, open and transparent process rather than mates and political stooges, and it would put a degree of transparency and arm’s-lengthness into the arrangements for appointing. So there may be a silver lining in this tangled cloud, and we look forward to what the Minister can tell us.
Lord Hunt of Kings Heath (Lab)
My Lords, I am intrigued by the comments by the noble Lord, Lord Stevens. First, I had not actually come to paragraph 598, and I look forward to doing so in due course. However, it is of course logical if we are serious about devolution, and I will call it devolution for the moment, that the mayor should be the ICB chair, because that is the obvious way to link it back in. Why is the Mayor of the West Midlands not becoming chair of a merged West Midlands ICB, which is the best way to do it? However, the powers under which that mayor operates will be governed by NHS legislation, and I agree with the noble Lord that it is difficult to square what is called devolution with the responsibility of the Secretary of State to retain the national identity of an NHS in which, from all our debates today, we find any variation completely unacceptable. There is a tension running through all of us about this. I have amendments that require uniform provision of services on the one hand, but then on the other I am concerned about centralisation, so this is a very difficult issue. When the noble Lord, Lord Stevens, talked about the “grey book” of 1974, I saw that most noble Lords’ eyes rather glazed over, but I was working in the NHS at the time of the 1974 reorganisation. I did not write the grey book; it was written by McKinsey and Company, at enormous expense, and it was a huge disaster—as its reports often are—because it basically brought in what was called consensus management. The idea was that at the area health authority level and the district management team level—the DMTs ran the hospitals—the senior management team should reach consensus all the time. So there was no boss, and of course the result was that no one made any decisions whatever. It took Ken Clarke—now the noble Lord, Lord Clarke—to come in and get rid of it all, and we then appointed chief executives. What is my point there? When I joined in 1972, we did not have NHS England, the NHS management executive or the NHS agency. We had a branch in the Department of Health called regional liaison, and its responsibility was to oversee the regional hospital boards and the regional health authorities—generally, the NHS. When I saw the proposal for the establishment of an NHS group, I thought: “Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose”—what goes around comes around. We are having a bit of fun here, but the outcome of what the Government are doing is actually quite pragmatic and sensible. We should give them a fair run. We will come back to appointments in the next group. When I was first a Minister in the Department of Health, we used to do all the chair appointments and, if I may say so, we made a very fine job of it, too. We did not appoint political hacks—that is true up to a point; occasionally, we may have appointed political hacks. The noble Baroness, Lady Morris of Bolton, has never forgiven me for sacking her when she was chair of a health authority. The point is that we did it, but life has moved on and it would not be acceptable now. To preview the next group, which I suspect we will now debate on Monday, the best way to ensure that you do not have either a politicisation of the appointment of chairs and non-execs of foundation trusts or a bureaucratisation through using a special health authority is to retain the council of governors, which does the job very effectively now.
Baroness Coffey (Con)
My Lords, if the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath, thinks some foundation trusts are not politicised already in their appointments, then I am slightly surprised to hear that. I had not planned to speak on this group, although it is very interesting, as I had hoped we would get to the next group to discuss foundation trusts, but I have a little sympathy for the Minister. The noble Lord, Lord Stevens of Birmingham, talked about tears. That inspired me to think of the band Tears for Fears. One song is “Shout”, with the chorus “let it all out”: perhaps the Minister will do that tonight. Then there is “Everybody Wants To Rule The World”: God knows how many people want to be a Perm Sec at DHSC nowadays. Another famous song of theirs is “Head Over Heels”, in which somebody would rather “talk about the weather”. I appreciate that the Minister is in the hands of her Secretary of State. In the Answer to the Written Question I tabled, specifically to ask what the status would be of current NHS England employees transferred to the proposed agency within the Department of Health and whether those employees will become civil servants, the Answer was: “Further details will be set out in the normal way in due course”. I fear others are going to be slightly disappointed. I suggest, a little more gently, that these fears and concerns are well founded, and not only, as the noble Lord, Lord Stevens of Birmingham, mentioned, those of current employees. I am conscious that I want to get this Bill through as well. I am pro a lot of what the Government are trying to do, but there is a lot of uncertainty, which is not helpful when it comes to delivering the outcomes to patients. Today it is really interesting to see significant parts of the Milburn review. Paragraph 598 has already been referenced and, to some extent, I feel justified in having tabled an amendment earlier in Committee on the Secretary of State having a duty to do that work, because this is exactly what is being said there. I appreciate that the noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, cannot be here tonight, but there are some interesting things going on. His amendment would ban NHS employees who have been made redundant from being re-recruited within five years. That is probably quite extreme, but in the last 12 months a whole load of people have been released and certain things were said then—that they would potentially be able to come back in—and that is now being vetoed. These are real operational issues. I appreciate that it might be uncomfortable for the Government to get into that in today’s debate in Committee, but that uncertainty is not going to help. Change of specification is always uncomfortable, but when you are just waiting to see what the latest “in due course” really means, it is going to be challenging. I think some further amendments could be made to the schedule to allow a wider use of legal powers to transfer people from one status to another to give them certainty. Quite often when there is uncertainty, the best people leave anyway, and you are not left with the best talent. That is critical for this huge transformation that the Government want to make in deciding to take back control in-house and rewire the state. I wish them well in that, but they will not do it if everybody who is the best goes.
Lord Hunt of Kings Heath (Lab)
I cannot let the noble Baroness get away with this. NHS managers are hugely dedicated. I totally and utterly reject the thought that people who are remaining in their posts are somehow dead wood. The amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, is ludicrous, as is the idea that, because the Government have instituted a change in structure or reduced the management costs, people who are made redundant should not be allowed to work in the health service. We want people with experience to work in health. We are undermanaged, not overmanaged.
Baroness Coffey (Con)
I think the noble Lord has missed the point. He had the chance to talk specifically to the amendment. I raise this because it is a live situation. People have been made redundant with an expectation that they could be re-recruited, and yet an edict has been put out from within the Department of Health and Social Care that that will not happen. This is not about people who are not dedicated. Of course they are dedicated, but when there is uncertainty and you are offered a permanent job somewhere else, quite often people will take the permanent job. They have mortgages to pay, children to look after and all these other things. That is my whole point about this amendment and the broader schedule. This uncertainty can lead to a bit of banter at this time of night, but it is deadly serious for people whose salary determines where and how they and their families live. That is why getting on and not having uncertainty will be absolutely vital to making sure that we keep the best people working for the best interests of patients right across the country. This is all about rewiring the state. I encourage the Government, Ministers and noble Lords to try to accelerate so that certainty can be given. That will be in the best interests of patients.
Earl Howe (Con)
My Lords, I will speak first to Amendment 104ZA tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, to which I added my name. The noble Lord, as he so often does, has put his finger on the button. Throughout our consideration of the Bill, we have repeatedly questioned the Government about the practical implications of abolishing NHS England, the costs of the reorganisation and precisely how the new arrangements will operate. We have asked how responsibilities would be transferred, where accountability would ultimately lie and how the Government could be confident that this substantial reorganisation would deliver the efficiencies and improvements in patient care that Ministers have promised—and here we are again. We now learn that, alongside the abolition of NHS England and the transfer of its functions into the department, the Government intend to establish a new special health authority in which to house the seven regional NHS teams, totalling about 3,000 people. The Government have said that the main justification for abolishing NHS England is to reduce duplication, streamline administration, improve accountability and deliver substantial savings. Yet, like it or not, as with any new public body, this new special health authority will have its own governance arrangements, administrative staffing requirements, operating costs and lines of accountability. As was well said by the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, we are in the dark on so much of that, if not all of it. From the outside, it looks remarkably as though we are just transferring substantial parts of NHS England’s organisational infrastructure into another arm’s-length body. The Secretary of State has described this as a “temporary arrangement” intended to “support the transition to a more devolved model”, but we need to ask—as the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, did—what “temporary” means in this context. If it is temporary, what needs to happen before the way is clear for the SHA to be abolished and its functions transferred elsewhere? As we all know, the creation of this SHA has been born of necessity because of the differing pay structures in the NHS and the Civil Service, so the obvious question is: when in the future is that situation likely to change? The explanation offered by the Secretary of State that she wishes to keep the NHS regional teams closer to the front-line services sounds very much like post hoc rationalising. The regional teams were surely never going to move physically to an office in central London. That brings me back to the question of cost, which is central to my noble friend Lord Blencathra’s Amendment 279QB. We have already seen estimates suggesting that the redundancy costs associated with abolishing NHS England could reach between £1 billion and £1.3 billion. Those are substantial sums of public money, and it is only reasonable that Parliament should be satisfied that they will result in genuine, lasting savings. My noble friend Lord Blencathra is unable to be present this evening, but I understand entirely the concern underlying his amendment, which is that we must not find ourselves paying substantial redundancy packages to staff who subsequently return to the NHS in different roles, potentially at considerable additional expense to the taxpayer. I note the comments of the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath, that this is unlikely to happen, but I have personally seen it happen in the past. Surely the minimum we are entitled to expect from the abolition of NHS England is genuine efficiencies. I am sure that the Government wish to achieve that. Can the Minister assure me that the job cuts that are to apply across NHS England will not be imposed in a way that brings headline numbers down but then requires the same expertise to be brought in by the side door under a different cost heading? Moving back to the amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, I hope that the Minister can provide some further clarity about the proposed SHA, its funding, its intended lifespan and the arrangements for transferring its functions into the Government’s longer-term model. Ultimately, the test of this reorganisation is not whether the Government can claim to have abolished NHS England but whether the new system will be simpler, more accountable, less expensive and, most importantly, better for patients. I look forward to the Minister’s response.
Baroness Merron (Lab)
My Lords, I appreciate the debate we have just had and the questions that have been put. I will answer some of the headline questions but I will write answers to others, in view of the time. Overall, I reassure the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, and express my appreciation for my noble friend Lord Hunt’s support. The noble Lord, Lord Stevens, used the word pragmatic about establishing a special health authority; it is rather important that we come back to that, because that is exactly what we are doing. Parliament has already provided a very clear process for establishing special health authorities under Section 28 of the National Health Service Act 2006, so it is not an unusual or random thing, or something that we have just come up with; it dates back to then. To answer some of the questions in broad terms about establishing the special health authorities: we will follow the process set out in that legislation. We will set out the authority’s general functions, governance arrangements and appointments in the establishment order and regulations, which, as statutory instruments, will be subject to scrutiny by both Houses of Parliament in the usual way. The noble Earl, Lord Howe, raised a question—I hesitate to put words into his mouth, but I will summarise it as I heard it—about whether this is just NHS England being reincarnated in some way. No, it is not. NHS England is a national organisation. It has wide-ranging statutory and operational responsibilities. A special health authority would very much be a smaller body with a narrow, regional remit. It would not be a new national HQ for the NHS; there is no national policy or operational role, and we will not allocate resources across the National Health Service. Those responsibilities would be with the department, with ICBs or with other appropriate organisations. The authority will be directly accountable to the Secretary of State, so there will be clear democratic oversight. Where a direction is necessary, we expect the special health authority to work closely with Ministers to determine what action is needed. The Government very much recognise the importance of financial oversight throughout this transition, including costs, savings and value for money. Costs will be set out through the usual financial reporting processes. We do not expect the organisational home of the regions to materially affect their overall size or cost. On some of the points that the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, raised, we have signalled that this should be a temporary arrangement—and I shall use another word that the noble Lord referred to—that will support the transition to a more devolved model, reflecting the fact that regional arrangements that we are putting in place for 1 April next year may evolve depending on how the NHS develops, including the ways they support local areas as devolution continues. The devolution agenda is still emerging, so we do not wish to set an arbitrary countdown for any subsequent reform. It is not an omission; it is just a reality that we find ourselves with. The additional statutory requirements in Amendment 104ZA would overlap with existing requirements. We believe they would add process and risk delay, and we therefore consider it unnecessary. I absolutely recognise Parliament’s legitimate interest in this process, and we will keep Parliament appropriately informed. Noble Lords will be pleased for me to remind them that tomorrow there is an information session where they will have the opportunity to discuss the details of this. That is one way in which we will do this. I will refer only briefly to Amendment 279QB tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, on the basis that nobody spoke to it—I think that is correct. Safeguards are in place. We have voluntary redundancy programmes implemented within NHS England, commissioning support units and integrated care boards. They all include contractual exit arrangements that require all employees who leave under voluntary redundancy and then obtain employment with another NHS employer up to 12 months afterwards to repay some or all of their redundancy payments. My noble friend Lord Hunt made a very direct assessment of the amendment. I can more politely say that we think the requirements in the amendment are disproportionate and would be unnecessary in that they would restrict NHS organisations from recruiting experienced staff where their skills are needed, so it would go significantly further without adding anything.
Lord Scriven (LD)
My Lords, because of the hour, I will be very brief. I thank all noble Lords who have spoken in the debate. We have prodded, poked and tried to get answers. I appreciate that the Minister has given us an overview. To use the Tears for Fears song “Woman in Chains”, I feel that the chains of responsibility are there. To use another Tears for Fears song, we asked her to “Break it Down Again”, but at this moment she is not able to break down exactly what will happen. I understand that it is pragmatic and there may be issues that the Government will use in the special authority, but the key is that there are five months before 1 April when all this has to be in place. As the noble Baroness, Lady Thornton, said on a previous amendment, this is a Bill of moving parts. It has now become a Bill of new parts with great uncertainty. I am sure we will want to return to this before Report, and I hope the Minister can answer some of those questions in more detail. With that said, I beg leave to withdraw the amendment.
Amendment 104ZA withdrawn.
House resumed.
House adjourned at 10 pm.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5439330.