B

Baroness Barker (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, this is a very important debate on a very important set of amendments. It is important that we recognise at the outset that data and information exist within a context. We are talking about gathering this data in the context of a campaign that has run for the past 10 years, with a constant theme throughout: that being trans is bad and that trans people are a danger to the rest of us. Day after day, we see articles in our newspapers and other media with that subtext. It is a very clever, extensive and well-funded campaign, and has gathered a lot of traction by sheer force of repetition. We already have within the NHS requirements to gather data. Also, principally because of the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, we are working towards an emerging dataset gathered in a neutral way. I happen to be a member of a community that has quite often been on the receiving end of dodgy dossiers and so on produced by those who do not like LGBT people, all using data gathered in a particular way to come to a certain conclusion. This is a welcome moment to throw light on all this. Actually, trans people deserve to have services that are evidence based and to know that the medicine being practised on them is done correctly. They would welcome greater transparency, yet they are fearful of clinicians being forced to gather data in particular ways to arrive at pre-determined outcomes. That is something we need to be very wary of when we look at this. For example, I am interested to know what the noble Baroness, Lady Davies of Devonport, would consider to be “evidence-based medicine”. On her Amendment 275, in the Cass study there is already a legal route for this, but the proposed new clause would make evidence of disclosure go on indefinitely, with no opportunity for anybody to opt out. Consciously written into that is an overriding of patients’ rights. It would be good to get data on detransitioning, too. I would be interested in seeing it, because we have heard different numbers. The noble Baroness, Lady Davies of Devonport, referred to thousands of detransitioners; the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, said 75. It is important that we have reliable data before we go any further with this. I come to the noble Lord, Lord Singh of Solihull. I am an ambassador for the Albert Kennedy Trust, a homelessness charity for LGBT young people who have been kicked out of their homes, as nobody wants to know them. The large majority have been kicked out of their family homes and quite a large number of these young people, who come to us with nowhere else to go, are trans. So not every family is of the loving nature that the noble Lord described. Those young people will inevitably find their way into services. I hope that those services are understanding of them and do not treat them in the dismissive way that others may do. That is what I think the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, was trying to tell us about having therapeutic settings that are not judgmental and do not predetermine an outcome. I know people are saying that it is incredibly difficult to do that—that is what they always say about conversion practices—but I hold to this: people in religions know when they are on the receiving end of conversion practices, as opposed to kind religious ministration. The distinction is not vastly different in medical services. That said, I would welcome a greater emphasis on reliable data, but I question the assumptions that lie behind some of these amendments. Amendment 279QQ by the noble Baroness, Lady Cash, in particular, would pre-empt a whole number of decisions on matters that are currently being investigated by the process led by the noble Baroness, Lady Cass.

More from Baroness Barker (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.