L

Lord Singh of Solihull (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I support Amendment 279QP in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Cass. She has made the clinical case with her customary clarity; I wish to add a moral one. I declare my interest as an NHS consultant psychiatrist with expertise in youth mental health. Let me begin with what is not in dispute: to coerce, threaten or abuse a person because they are gay or trans is indeed abhorrent. Those who have endured such practices have been grievously wronged. I do not doubt that the Government’s intentions in publishing the draft conversion practices Bill are honourable, but good intentions are not a legal test. Coercive control, harassment and cruelty to children are already unlawful. The question, therefore, is what the Bill adds and how its provisions will operate in practice. My concern is that unless it is carefully framed, it brings the criminal law into clinical judgment and family life—areas where precision, professional discretion and respect for the family are essential. The draft Bill adopts a broad approach to conversion practices that may unintentionally include the exploratory conversations and therapeutic engagement that are a legitimate part of any clinical assessment. Many young people who come to us are already struggling and distressed. In that state, it will be very hard to say whether any harm flows from the therapeutic assessment or the distress that brought them to us in the first place. Depending on how the Bill’s provisions are interpreted, an ordinary clinical exploration or loving conversation within a family could be alleged to meet the Bill’s threshold. My concern, which is one shared with me by other clinicians, is that the way the Bill is worded blurs the line between legitimate therapeutic exploration and unlawful conduct. Distress alone is not evidence of wrongdoing. In medicine and psychiatry, difficult conversations may cause distress while serving the patient’s long-term interest. The oncologist who gives a diagnosis of cancer causes distress; the psychiatrist who declines to validate a patient’s distorted view of reality may make the patient angry and upset. We do not call this abuse—we call it medicine. The challenge for Parliament is to ensure that legislation directed at genuinely abusive conduct does not inhibit professional judgment exercised in good faith. The draft Bill provides that healthcare is not a conversion practice, unless the practitioner “acts in a way that falls far below the standards reasonably expected of a person in their position”. The Explanatory Notes tell us that this is equivalent to gross negligence, but gross negligence is still measured against a standard. What standard? How is it set and by whom? Nationally and internationally, professional bodies and clinical authorities are yet to agree on the appropriate assessment and treatment of gender-related distress in young people. A protection that rests on contested standards is bound to invite complaints, investigations and prolonged legal uncertainty. That is why the noble Baroness’s amendment matters: it asks Parliament to provide greater clarity about the standards against which clinical conduct should be judged. Furthermore, a law need not lead to convictions to have unintended consequences. The prospect of a complaint, a regulatory investigation or a police interview may itself change behaviour. One can foresee clinicians becoming reluctant to undertake the careful exploration that good practice often requires. Some therapists may conclude that such work is simply not worth the risk. If that happens, the loss will fall on vulnerable young people who need clinicians capable of exploring, rather than assuming, the causes of their distress. For parents, the position raises a different concern. As the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, pointed out, parents have no equivalent statutory carve-out. That naturally raises questions about how ordinary parental conversations might be viewed if disputes later arise about what was said and why. The same lack of clarity that troubles clinicians will trouble families too. Here I come to my moral point: the family is not a creature of the state. Parents were guiding their children through doubt, uncertainty and adolescence long before any statute. An anxious or frightened child turns to a parent in the middle of the night, not to a Minister. Our law has long recognised the importance of family life. In public law proceedings, the family courts reserve compulsory intervention for cases in which a child is suffering or likely to suffer significant harm. The right to respect for private and family life is likewise deeply embedded in our law. Every parent of an adolescent knows that the words “wait”, “not yet” and “let’s think us about this” may sometimes cause anger, frustration or distress, but these are also very often the words of prudence, responsibility and love. A free society should not leave parents unsure whether their ordinary efforts to guide and support their children may later be construed as an offence.

More from Lord Singh of Solihull (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.