Contribution
I was pleased to hear several of the points that the noble Baroness, Lady Davies, made. As I am still the DHSC adviser on children’s gender services, I will limit my remarks, because it is clearly for the Minister to respond to many of the points that the noble Baroness made, but I have already stated on the record my concern about the conduct of adult services in not co-operating with the collection of data that would have enabled children and, indeed, young adults to have better information about their treatment choices.
On detransitioners, as the Committee will know, setting up services was one of the recommendations of my review. Again, there is information that has unfortunately not been shared—by a psychiatrist who probably had the greatest experience of seeing detransitioners. He had seen 75, and that is probably the largest series that was examined by a psychiatrist. There was considerable resistance to him sharing that data by the Tavistock, and he has unfortunately now died, so we have lost some valuable data.
My Amendment 279QP relates to another Bill, the draft conversion practices Bill. It relates to the way in which we should assess and treat gender-related distress in children and young people. It is relevant because there is such controversy on what should be a straightforward issue.
After giving evidence to the Draft Conversion Practices Bill Committee yesterday, I went to the theatre to see a production of “Cranford”. The friend I went with thought it would be quite important, given that this is such a stressful and toxic area, for me to relax and see a quiet Victorian drama that was far removed from these issues. The opening scene, which I do not remember in the book, was a father beating his son, who was dressed as a woman. So, it is an issue that follows me. On a serious note, it conveys that these practices have been going on for an extraordinary time, and I do not think that anyone in the Committee would consider conversion practice to be anything other than entirely abhorrent.
The draft conversion practices Bill covers both adults and children, and it encompasses sexual orientation and gender identity, but developmentally, there are important differences between the emergence of sexual orientation and gender identity. It is normal for young people to go through a period of sexual exploration and become clear about their sexual orientation at different ages, although for some, it is a matter of certainty from a very young age. Clearly, there is a complex interplay of biological, genetic and prenatal factors that we do not understand. However, it is clear that this is not a transient phenomenon, regardless of the complexity of family and social circumstances, and that is why conversion therapy is not only abusive but ineffective, even with the consent of the individual.
Gender incongruence or dysphoria in children has much more complex origins and mixed outcomes, and it can be transient. In some cases, biopsychosocial determinants mean that the young person can go on and have a stable trans identity into adulthood. For them, a medical or surgical pathway may be the only way that they can live comfortably without ongoing distress.
However, for many other children and young people, the transgender identification may be a response to a wide range of other issues, including confusion or rejection of being gay, bodily or psychological distress, feeling different—possibly related to a diagnosis of autism and not feeling that they belong in their peer group or same-sex group—trauma and early stressors or sometimes very premature social transition by parents. All these presentations have been described in my review and in a wide range of publications. They have also been seen by clinical staff in the first two years of the new services. In those instances, careful exploration with the child or young person may sometimes lead to the realisation that their gender dysphoria was related to other factors. In some cases, they may revert to their birth-registered gender identity and in some cases they may not.
It is important to state that such exploration is not driven by a preference for one outcome over another—something that is already unacceptable in clinical practice—but rather by the recognition that taking an irreversible medical step when the underlying condition may have been transient will lock that young person into a lifetime of medical treatment. If the trans identity proves to be enduring and stable, the cost of medical treatment in terms of risks and side-effects is trivial compared with the distress of not living in their identified gender. However, it is a very high price to pay when other factors that could resolve over time might not have been identified and addressed.
The majority of children and young people who go through a period of this kind of incongruence resolve it without a medical transition. Teachers will describe the fluctuation in gender identity within their classrooms. Many parents spoke to me during my review about how their child’s gender incongruence had subsequently resolved. It is therefore strange that there is still such intense polarisation about the correct approach to assessing and treating this population. If you go on social media, you will find that I am a conversion therapist, as is the right honourable Wes Streeting, as are many therapists in private practice and those in the new NHS gender services.
Distress is an inevitable part of the therapeutic encounter that can surface difficult or painful feelings. It is all too easy for a young person to leave a consultation feeling hurt, unhappy and angry that they have not received the medical treatment that they want. I have seen social media posts from bad actors who are already circulating and seeking out young people online who may have had an adverse experience with a healthcare professional in this circumstance in an attempt to undermine explorative approaches. If the practitioner is then accused of having fallen far below the standards expected of them, which will then take them out of the carve-out in this Bill, by causing the young person serious alarm or distress, that leads to the question of who should determine those correct standards and how they will be assessed by regulators, the CPS and the courts.
This amendment is an attempt to clarify the position, since professional organisations differ in what they believe those appropriate standards should be. I do not anticipate that the amendment will solve all these problems, since complainants might not accept the findings of my review and the standards that I am proposing. In addition, the real problem is that healthcare professionals will query why they should work in an area where they may be exposed to the risk of criminal prosecution, even if they are subsequently exonerated. This is not a theoretical risk. There are real concerns today in all four of the new services. None the less, I bring this amendment which tries to define an appropriate standard for clinical practice in the hope that it will at least sharpen focus, enable us to consider the lack of consensus and broaden the debate.
There is no carve-out for parents, who are arguably at greater risk within the Bill but are not subject to this amendment. I hope that other ways will be found to protect their appropriate parenting of vulnerable children.