B

Baroness Cass (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, the Government have set themselves the welcome ambition of raising the healthiest generation of children ever, but in this Bill children are not writ large or even small; they are largely absent. I recognise that this is a Bill about structures and systems, rather than specific populations, but past experience shows that health systems are designed around adults, and children need to be the subject of explicit mention in legislation and guidance lest they be forgotten. I make no apology for the fact that this is a large group aimed at prioritising children and young people in this reformed health system. I start with Amendment 66, which is on waiting times. One of the clearest examples of children being overlooked are the excessive waiting times for elective and community health services. For children, a delay in treatment can cause irreparable harm because it impairs physical, and often mental, development. As a result of long waits, children may miss developmental milestones and fall further behind their peers. The report into audiology services by my colleague Camilla Kingdon, another past college president—they keep us engaged after we demit—was published last year and highlighted the issue of long waits. For cochlear implants, implanting at around nine months of age will give children the best chance of natural speech development. The older a child is when they receive their implant, the less their brain is able to rewire itself to recognise the signals. The review quoted one child who waited three and a half years for surgery for a cochlear implant. This is not an isolated incident. Across child health services, we are seeing significant delays for treatment. Only 48% of children and young people are seen within 18 weeks for community services, compared with 86% of adults. Only about two-thirds of children waiting for paediatric hospital services are seen within 18 weeks. Amendment 66 would require the Secretary of State to make waiting-time regulations for children within 12 months. These would require ICBs to act where a child does not receive a specified treatment or service within the specified period. In doing so, it would strengthen accountability for timely access to services and ensure children’s waiting times are routinely measured, monitored and reported, rather than being obscured by broader improvements elsewhere in the system. Amendment 232 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, and my Amendment 249 are aimed at improving transparency for children’s services metrics, focusing on multiple levels within the system. They aim to produce better reporting and a clear strategy to improve outcomes and reduce inequalities. In the interest of efficiency, I will leave the noble Baroness and my noble friend Lord Russell to speak to these amendments. Amendment 279QG is on monitoring emerging risks from digital technology, which I will illustrate with a couple of medical stories. In 2021, a paper appeared in a paediatric journal describing a Covid-19-related increase in childhood tics and tic-like attacks. The authors said: “There is an urgent need to collate systematic data on this group as this is a rare and unusual subtype of tics”. Typically, childhood tics start around five to seven years of age and more commonly affect boys in a ratio of four to one. This new surge of referrals consisted of adolescent girls with a sudden onset of motor and vocal tics of what the authors called a “complex and bizarre nature”. The clinicians concluded that this was a psychological rather than a neurological problem and, in some cases, heavily driven by TikTok influencers. In fact, you could sometimes recognise the influencer from the pattern of the patient’s tics. Because this was a prominent publication, the problem was gradually recognised and understood, helped by the fact that it was also picked up by mainstream media. By contrast, another tragic problem went on for many years before it was acted on: toddlers being accidentally strangled by blind cords. Historically, accidental strangulations from looped blind cords were viewed by families and coroners as isolated, tragic anomalies. These events happen quickly and silently, so they can occur while a parent is briefly elsewhere in the house. In 2004, child death overview panels—CDOPs—were established under the Children Act, so there was more careful scrutiny of child deaths. However, it took until 2018 before the National Child Mortality Database was formed to collate the CDOP data, and suddenly these were no longer isolated incidents but part of a clear pattern. In June 2020, the NCMD issued a safety notice about the dangers of looped blind cords to toddlers and young children. That was a significant delay. The power of sharing information informally and, more importantly, systematically cannot be underestimated. When my noble friend Lady Kidron and I convened a meeting with the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges, the shock in the room was palpable, as college presidents and leaders from different specialties talked about their experiences of the harms from social media. Although each had been worried about what they were seeing in their own arena, the combined impact across so many specialties and the enormity of the problem was instrumental in shifting the dial on the need for action. We do not want to wait until children die and then look at trends on the NCMD. That is why this amendment, which is supported by Health Professionals for Safer Screens, calls for a national system to enable healthcare professionals to report physical, developmental, sensory, psychological or behavioural effects in children that they consider may be associated with digital technology. However, reporting is of no value unless someone is analysing the results and acting on them. Noble Lords will shortly hear from my noble friend Lady Kidron on how that response may work. I end my comments on digital safety by expressing my support for Amendment 279P from the noble Baroness, Lady Barran. It addresses the important issue of the safety of the technology that we in the NHS provide to children and where there should be even greater expectations of safety by design and assessment of any potential harms. My final amendment in this group is about health services for adolescents and young adults. Getting this right is not a trivial matter because, leaving apart the human cost of providing inadequate services for this key group, the financial cost will be incalculable. Between 29% to 34% of 16 year-olds have long-term term physical, mental health, disability or other illnesses, and they should rightly expect holistic and seamless services. If we do not address health problems in adolescence, we will be looking at more young adults who are NEET—that is significant given the release of that report today—and facing lifelong ill health and lost opportunities to participate in and contribute to society. Adolescent and young adult healthcare needs to start in local communities and be delivered through a network of services up to and including specialist care for those with the most complex needs. At present, there is very little mention in the young futures hubs about the inclusion of health. This is a serious missed opportunity, akin to missing out health from the otherwise excellent Sure Start programme.

More from Baroness Cass (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.