Contribution
My Lords, I support all the amendments in this group but, again, in the interests of efficiency I shall speak only to those in my name, which are Amendments 98A, 279F and 279G. I am grateful to other noble Lords and noble Baronesses for adding their names to these amendments.
These amendments seek to understand how the DHSC, the NHS, integrated care boards and local authorities are approaching children’s digital environments as a public health issue. During the passage of the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill, I pressed the Government to provide advice to parents and carers of children under five on the safe and appropriate use of screens and technology, and I welcome the fact that this has been taken forward, with similar guidance for six to 18 year-olds to follow. I also pressed for guidance for early years settings, where young children spend so much of their time and which are a source of advice and guidance to their parents.
Health has been a missing piece of this puzzle. I should confess that, despite having worked on several previous health Bills, I lack the expertise of many in this Committee on the systems and structures of our health system, so my amendments may get some of the technicalities wrong and I would welcome correction from the Committee or the Minister. Nor do I claim that the proposals are necessarily the solution to ensuring that children grow up in a safer digital environment. We must have higher standards, safety by design, a stronger Online Safety Act and collective action through schools, communities and a whole host of other areas. These amendments are designed to sit alongside those efforts, not instead of them. What I am keen to hear from the Committee and the Minister is whether they agree that a children’s digital environment has sufficient impact on multiple aspects of their health that it warrants proper attention and action from our health system. If so, is the approach taken in these amendments the right one, or is there a better way forward?
On the first question, the impact of the digital environment on children’s health, I believe that the evidence is clear. Let us take just three examples. On eyesight, a 2025 meta-analysis covering 300,000 children found that each additional hour of daily screen time was associated with 21% higher odds of myopia. On language, the Government’s own Children of the 2020s study, published by the DfE, found that two year-olds in the highest fifth for screen time could say 53% of a list of common words, compared with 65% of those in the lowest fifth. These outcomes held when accounting for family income, parental mental health and the home learning environment. The authors note that the greatest apparent impact came when screen time exceeded roughly an hour and a half a day, which is less than the average time that a two year-old spends on screens in the UK at the moment. On physical activity, children who are sedentary in front of screens are, by definition, not doing the active play that their development needs.
These risks become even more real when you look at the data on how much time children are spending on screens or in the digital rather than the physical environment. Some 98% of two year-olds watch screens on a typical day for an average of over two hours. Only a third meet the WHO’s recommendation of no more than an hour of sedentary screen time, and that is down from 46% a decade ago. For one in five two year-olds, the average is not two hours but over five hours a day.
My amendments propose to do three things. First, they would ensure that the health professionals who see almost every family and child—such as health visitors, GPs, practice nurses, school nurses and speech and language therapists—have evidence-based guidance and training on children’s use of screens and digital technology. Amendment 279F would require the Secretary of State
“to publish guidance for health professionals”
within six months, covering children of all ages but with particular attention to those aged nought to five. It would also require the Secretary of State to use existing duties under Section 1F of the National Health Service Act to make training available for those health professionals and would require consultation with the royal colleges, a review of the guidance every three years and a report on the availability and uptake of training within two years.
Secondly, Amendment 279G seeks to build digital environments into the healthy child programme reviews. The five mandatory reviews for children under five are the only universal contacts that pre-school children may have with anyone outside their home. There is currently a single-line reference to discussion of healthy routines and screen use within the guidance for those checks. Although many other areas of messaging are closely related—for example, the sharing of relational health messages and safeguarding considerations—there is nothing detailed or explicit about children’s digital environment and the impact it can have. The healthy child programme also extends to more targeted interventions for those aged six to 18, where children’s digital environments may again be a key consideration in any health issues that they have.
Thirdly, Amendment 98A to Clause 25 would require local authorities and integrated care boards, when preparing neighbourhood health plans, to
“consider the effects … of children’s digital environment”,
particularly for the under-fives, and to set out how any needs identified will be met, involving
“health visitors, school nurses and family hubs”.
None of this asks health professionals to become experts in technology. It asks that the people who families already trust are equipped with consistent and evidence-based advice and that the system as a whole is designed to deliver it. I would be grateful for the Minister’s reflections on these proposals. In particular, can she explain how children’s digital environments are being integrated into public health and the healthy child programme? What training do health visitors, GPs and other health professionals currently receive on this and what further plans do the Government have in this area?