Contribution
My Lords, it is a great privilege to follow my noble friend Lady Penn, who once again speaks with great authority on this subject. I apologise that I was unable to speak at Second Reading, but I hope that the Committee will permit me to contribute at this point, given my involvement in some of the issues relating to my amendment in earlier legislation. I also thank the cosignatories to my amendment.
My amendment seeks to apply to digital medical technology that is required or prescribed for children some of the same principles that apply to what we might describe as traditional or physical medical technology. I hope that that is not controversial and I hope that the Minister, when she comes to sum up, will reassure me and the Committee that this is covered.
My amendment sets out that an NHS body can prescribe or recommend a digital technology or tool only where it is satisfied that there is evidence both of its effectiveness and of its safety, with reference to any standards or guidance set out by NICE—or perhaps I should add the MHRA. It would also require any NHS body to assess the risk of harm resulting from the use of the device on which the technology operates. The Committee will be familiar with the types of risk set out in the amendment: access to social media, messaging services, AI chatbots and AI companions and, specifically, functions that are not needed for the medical technology to work.
The amendment would also require the relevant NHS body to provide written guidance to parents and carers on the risks, on how to limit access to other functions and on the safe management of overnight alerts and use. Further, it would prioritise giving children under 16 a device that is purely dedicated to its medical purpose, as one configured to restrict access to its wider functions, as in the case of a smartphone. All of this is subject to the caveat that such restrictions must not impair the clinical effectiveness of the medical technology.
The amendment is needed because children with type 1 diabetes are currently being provided with smartphones carrying an app to monitor their glucose levels. That is obviously essential from the perspective of their diabetes, but some of these—very young—children have ended up seeing pornography and worse on the smartphone that carries that app. In normal circumstances, they would have been far too young to have access to such a device unsupervised.
More broadly, mental health apps are becoming more widespread, which at the very least risks children having their phone by their bed as they use, say, a meditation app to fall asleep. We can all imagine that they may use the phone for other purposes as well. More worryingly, children risk becoming reliant on AI companions and chatbots. I understand that the NHS has assessed the efficacy of a number of these apps. My amendment seeks to close the loophole that means that the device on which those apps sit carries a set of increasingly alarming risks that are neither assessed nor managed currently. As I say, I look forward very much to the Minister’s reply.
Briefly, I am also delighted to add my name to the amendments in the names of my noble friend Lady Penn and the noble Baroness, Lady Cass. When we were debating the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill, now the Act, my noble friend Lady Penn spoke with great clarity and good sense, as she has again today. Her amendments bring a comprehensive and coherent approach to addressing the risks posed by the digital environment in preparing the neighbourhood health plan and to giving health professionals the training that they need to understand these risks. In particular, Amendment 279G would ensure that the parents of every child aged nought to five who receives a universal health review would be able to discuss the risks that their child faces from the digital environment.