Contribution
My Lords, I apologise for not speaking at Second Reading. Unfortunately, I tested positive for Covid on the morning of the debate. Amendment 90 fits very neatly, following the discussion that your Lordships have been having about integration, partnership, collaboration, co-operation and, equally, the need for clear accountability for the pathway of care and treatment of individual patients.
I am enormously grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Bradley, for his support for Amendment 90. It concerns the healthcare of a particular group of people—people in prison. Crucially, it also concerns the continuity of their care when they move between prisons, are released into the community after serving their sentence or move under the supervision of the Probation Service. It seeks to give integrated care boards a very specific duty to take account of their health needs, commissioning appropriate specialist services and, above all, ensuring the continuity of care.
Why is that necessary? I will start with a really shocking statistic: a report published in July this year by Nacro shows that more than one person dies every day in the year following their release from prison. In the last five years, almost 2,500 people have died within a year of leaving prison. Around 40% of those deaths are associated with drug-related causes, but many others are linked to mental health problems, including those associated with alcohol and gambling, and many are preventable. Nacro estimates that up to one in seven drug-related deaths could have been avoided if everyone with a history of opioid dependence received appropriate substitution treatment, for instance, on the day they left prison, yet one in three simply do not. This is a healthcare failure with devastating consequences.
It is not just about deaths: many people who leave prison subsequently return to custody. It is one of the greatest causes of overcrowding in our prisons. Often, the people who return have complex mental health, drug, alcohol or gambling problems that have not been adequately treated. For instance, around 40% of prisoners wait a month or longer for a GP appointment, compared with 12% of the general population. Without action, we are perpetuating a costly cycle of imprisonment, release and reoffending.
These problems exist both inside prison and, particularly, at the point of release, but perhaps the biggest weakness is what happens when someone moves from one part of the criminal justice system to another. Somebody who receives treatment for a serious mental health condition or drug dependency in prison may well be released only to find that their medication, specialist appointments and treatment programme have not followed them. They may have no GP registration, settled accommodation or clear route into community mental health or addiction services. Essential information may not reach the receiving healthcare provider, and it might be that nobody is clear about who is responsible.
My amendment has three main elements. First, it would require ICBs to have due regard to improving the health outcomes of people in prison and those under probation supervision. Secondly, it would require reasonable steps to secure continuity of care when people enter custody, move between prisons, move between areas under community sentences or leave prison and probation services. Thirdly, it would require ICBs to take reasonable steps to ensure access to appropriate specialist services including mental health treatment, drug and alcohol recovery, smoking cessation and gambling disorder services.
I recognise that this represents a new and potentially challenging responsibility for ICBs. Their circumstances vary enormously. For instance, some have several prisons within their boundaries and others have none. But having no prisons locally does not mean having no responsibility, because people are released into every single community and their healthcare needs do not stop at the prison gates. Nor am I suggesting that every ICB should commission every specialist service independently. The Government’s own proposals for regional commissioning arrangements and national guidance could well provide the necessary expertise and consistency. It is welcome that NHS England is establishing a new governance arrangement for gambling harms treatment programmes, including the regional commissioning leads forum.
My amendment is deliberately framed in terms of reasonable steps. It does not prescribe a single delivery model but establishes that these people must be properly considered when health services are planned and commissioned. It is not simply about improving healthcare for offenders; it is about preventing avoidable deaths, reducing reoffending and making our communities safer. If someone leaves prison without the medication, treatment or support they need, we should not be surprised when they become ill, relapse or return to offending.
We have known about this problem for many years. In 2010 a report from the Care Quality Commission and HM Inspectorate of Prisons concluded that the continuity of healthcare when prisoners are released is “inadequate” and seems to be getting worse.
In 2017, recognising
“the need for better continuity of treatment for offenders on release into the community”,
the then Government published Guidance for Improving Continuity of Care Between Prisons and the Community. Yet, despite this, by 2022 academic research papers concluded that the continuity of mental health care for those exiting prison is poor. The Mental Health Act 2025 addressed the problem of acute psychiatric care but did not address the everyday issues faced by the thousands of regular prisoners released each month. Reports, guidance and recommendations have come and gone, but the gaps remain.
The Chief Medical Officer’s major report this year on the health of people in prisons and on probation specifically identifies the transition into prison, between prisons and back into the community as periods of particular risk. It also highlights the poor information sharing between prison healthcare and the wider NHS.
The Bill gives us an opportunity to do something more concrete: to put responsibility firmly into the commissioning framework and ensure that continuity of care is recognised as an essential NHS responsibility. I hope that the Minister will recognise the importance of this issue and either support this amendment or explain how the Government intend to deliver the same clear statutory commitment by other means. We should not accept a system in which the prison gate becomes the point at which healthcare falls through the cracks. I beg to move.