L

Lord Scriven (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, this been a thoughtful debate but a pretty depressing one when you think about it—not the contributions but the concept that, through legislation, we are having to ask people in a system to work together to improve services for the people who they serve. Fundamentally, that is the basis of these amendments, but it does not detract from the importance of raising the issues and us having the discussion. Let me say from the outset that, unlike the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, we on these Benches support the direction of travel in this group. Integration, collaboration and co-operation are the right ambitions. I would have thought that nobody in the Committee would argue for fragmentation, duplication and services working against each other, but that is precisely my worry. Integration has become one of those words that everybody agrees with and almost nobody delivers. Too often in the NHS, integration is a slogan rather than a reality. Every Health Act I can remember has promised it, every reorganisation has been sold on it, and integrated care boards even have the word in their very title. Yet ask anyone who has spent time in a hospital—as a patient, relative or even as a member of staff—and they will describe something quite different. Even inside one hospital, integration between services can be a no-go area. Departments on the same corridor operate as though they are in different countries. If that is the picture inside one building, think about what it is like across the whole patient pathway. A frail old person goes from a GP to A&E, to an acute ward, to a community bed and back home to a social care package, and each step is run by a different organisation with a different budget, different IT system, different targets and a different board. For the patient and their family, the experience across the health and care system can be a nightmare. This is where I completely disagree with the noble Lord, Lord Redwood. The issue is not integration; it is about accountability for the whole patient pathway. Fragmentation means that accountability is less likely for the whole service.

More from Lord Scriven (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.