Contribution
My Lords, I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Stevens of Birmingham, and the noble Earl, Lord Howe, for adding their names to Amendment 104ZA. Between them, they have been in charge of legislation for NHS England and have been in the most senior leadership roles of running it. I, for one, have not had enough of experts, so I am looking forward to what they have to say on this amendment.
This amendment is about a body that did not exist when this Committee began: the transitional special health authority for NHS England’s seven regional teams, which was announced on 4 November after we debated Clause 1. We are told that it is temporary, yet, according to the Health Service Journal, NHS England’s chief operating officer told staff that the word “transitional” must be used,
“not because we’re imagining that it’s a time-limited organisation”.
The chief executive of NHS England then said to the same staff that it was time-limited, but no one could say how time-limited. So, it is temporary, but without a time limit. In Whitehall, nothing lasts quite like the temporary.
Consider what we do not know about these regional offices and the special health authority. We do not know how many staff will transfer, we do not know its budget, we do not know what it will lead for, and we do not know who will lead it. Will it have a chief executive of its own or seven regional directors reporting upwards? We do not know where it is going to go after the temporary arrangement ends. Does it go back into ICBs, back into the department, to the mayoral authorities or nowhere at all?
What we do know is that the regional staff keep their NHS pay and conditions, which a Health Service Journal analysis put at, on average, more than £9,500 a year above the department’s for equivalent posts. I can see the recruitment advert now: “Join the special health authority: better pay, with no end date”. This raises a serious issue about recruitment and retention for roles that are transferred to the department. How would the Government plan for that potential move of staff out of the department into the higher-paid, non-Civil Service roles in the special health authority?
Then there are the savings. When abolition was announced, NHS England and the department employed about 19,000 people, and Ministers pledged to halve that. Some 20 months on, it is still almost 17,000. At that rate, the target will be met sometime in the early 2030s, comfortably after the temporary authority has become permanent. The Minister has told this House that the 50% cut is an ambition, not a target. Ministers promised that there would be savings of £1 billion a year by the end of this Parliament, while the restructuring could cost up to £1.3 billion in one-off payments, so the savings are an ambition and the costs are a certainty.
Meanwhile, the Government have finally found a waiting list that they can grow: the waiting list for redundancy. Staff in one ICB cluster waited two months for NHS England to sign off their departures. NHS England, which has been abolished, is approving other people’s exits while it is waiting for its own. Perhaps the Minister could give them a target. Could I suggest 18 weeks?
What concerns me most are the powers. The Bill hands the Secretary of State a long list of NHS England’s powers, and some new ones also: a broad power to direct ICBs; the appointment, in certain circumstances, of chairs and non-executives of local NHS bodies; and intervention in foundation trusts, including deauthorising them and capping their revenue spending. The Secretary of State can already direct a special health authority to exercise its health service functions, and Clause 28 widens those powers. The letter to all Peers confirms that functions of the Secretary of State can be conferred on this new special health authority.
The statement says that it will not exercise national functions. However, directing the ICB in South Yorkshire is not a national function and appointing the chair of an ICB with problems in the south-west is not a national function. These are precisely the regional functions that this body could be given. Think of how inappropriate it would be for a regional office to appoint the chair of a failing ICB and then mark that organisation’s homework on improvement. The Bill even contemplates a special health authority being given the powers to impose financial penalties—a temporary body handing out potentially permanent fines.
We are told that abolishing NHS England would bring management of the NHS back into democratic control. It is a curious kind of democratic control that takes powers from one quango, gives them to the Minister and then posts them out to another quango by a direction that neither House votes on. That is why proposed new paragraph (a) asks the Government to say, before the body is created, exactly what functions it will exercise.
Let me give noble Lords a concrete example. South Yorkshire has appointed the country’s first deputy mayor for health, Sir Steve Houghton, who also chairs the integrated care board and its £4.6 billion commissioning budget. Here I must correct the record. I spoke earlier to the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, about who he would be accountable to. Having looked again at the Government’s own press release, it says that the role jointly reports to NHS England and the elected mayor. From 1 April, one of those two will not exist. I put the direct question to the Minister: will the new special health authority, via the regional officers, be able to direct him? If the Secretary of State’s powers to direct ICBs is conferred on it, the answer is yes. So who does South Yorkshire’s health commissioner actually work to? Is it the mayor, who people elected; the special health regional office, which nobody elected; the NHS group in the department; or the Secretary of State?
Picture the first real disagreement. The mayor wants money moved into prevention. He seeks investment in housing to prevent damp and mould, wanting to keep people out of hospital. The special health authority, via the regional office, wants waiting lists down by March. Only one can win. Who has the final say? If it is the mayor, put it in the Bill. If it is the special health authority regional officers, stop calling this devolution. Devolution where an unelected regional body can overrule an elected mayor is not devolution; it is delegation with a very shiny badge on it.