Contribution
The noble Lord makes my point. A person does not necessarily have one doctor or one service; they have multiple needs. Therefore, accountability is not brought about by greater fragmentation; it is about thinking about accountability for the whole pathway, rather than different bits of it. That doctor will have accountability for only part of potentially myriad services that the patient requires. Nobody intends it, nobody designs it and nobody is accountable for the whole. That is what we have to think about.
The amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, requiring a report on the duties to co-operate under Sections 72 and 82 of the 2006 Act, is indeed very sensible. These duties have been on the statute book for a long time, so it is fair to ask a simple question: have they made any measurable difference? If the honest answer is not much then we need to know why before we pile on further duties.
The proposed new clause from the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, would place a duty on integrated care boards to promote collaboration and to consider the effect of commissioning decisions on continuity and long-term provision. That captures something important. Commissioning that unnecessarily fragments a service carries a cost, even when it looks efficient on a spreadsheet. The requirement to publish an assessment in the annual report would add transparency and, importantly, may change some management behaviour.
Our opposition to Clause 24 standing part raises a real question, which the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, talked about. Clause 24 abolishes integrated care partnerships and integrated care strategies. That is the statutory forum that brings the NHS and local government round the same table, with a duty to produce a shared strategy built on the joint strategic needs assessment. It is hard to reconcile a Bill that talks about integration with a clause that removes one of the few statutory bridges between health and local government.
This is where I accept what the noble, Lord, Lord Hunt, said: this is a pre-Burnham prime ministerial Bill. There is a serious question for the Minister to come back to on Report: in light of the fact that the rewiring the state Bill and outcomes are not ready, would it not be wise to drop this whole part of the Bill and keep things as they are, so that when the rewiring the state Bill comes, we can have an integrated health and local government devolution approach, rather than what we are trying to do, which is to come up with a system for health and then later to come up with a system for local government? History tells us that that will not work. I know the Minister will not be able to give that commitment at the Dispatch Box, but I hope she will commit to go away and talk to government and to come back on Report to say whether it is feasible. It is a genuinely helpful suggestion, based on my own personal experience as a former NHS manager and a former council leader. It is a sensible thing to think about.
The amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, on women’s centres deserves particular attention. Many noble Lords have talked about why those centres are important. The amendment recognises that the NHS too often forgets that some of its best routes into care and outcomes do not start in the NHS at all; they start in trusted local community organisations that reach women experiencing multiple disadvantages—women who the formal system frequently fails to reach. Bringing them into planning and commissioning is integration in the truest sense: built around the person, not the institution, bottom-up and rooted in the community. I commend the noble Lord for his amendment and those who have spoken to it, and I suggest that the Minister accepts it.
I have to be candid with the Committee: each of these amendments, valuable as they are, adds to the duty to co-operate on top of a system whose very structure works against co-operation. We keep asking organisations to collaborate while designing a system that rewards them for not doing so. The bigger picture—I accept that it is a bigger debate than this group can resolve—is how the NHS is separated into different funding pots and autonomous trusts and organisations. Acute, community, mental health trusts, primary care, social care, and public health are each funded differently, governed separately and held to account for their own bit of the journey. Each can be judged a success, while the patient’s experience as a whole is a failure. While the Minister may be positive about some of these amendments, the true issues we have to look at are who is responsible for the whole of patient care, how it is funded, and whether the Bill will deal with real integration.
I finish by saying again that I hope that the Minister will think carefully about the rewiring of the state and what is suggested in here, and that she will try to come back with an integrated Bill rather than two parts.