B

Baroness Merron (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I welcome the debate we have just had on this group. I will start by noting the points about the Bill in general. I have heard the observations and points that noble Lords have made about the Bill, particularly in respect of devolution and the change of Prime Minister to Andy Burnham. It is not our view that the Bill conflicts with rewiring the state. This legislation has the flexibility to support devolution, which is not a one-off but rather a continuing process, as we have discussed before. However, I will of course reflect on the points that noble Lords have made. I turn to the Clause 24 stand part notice and Amendments 85, 94 and 210. Clause 24 abolishes the requirement for ICBs and their partner local authorities to form an integrated care partnership. It also abolishes the related requirement for this partnership to prepare and publish an integrated care strategy. I understand the concerns that noble Lords have raised, but these provisions address policy objectives of the 10-year health plan by streaming the number of plans that local health systems are required to produce and supporting local stakeholders to work together more flexibly and effectively —exactly what noble Lords are seeking. The changes recognise that, in many areas, integrated care partnerships have not had the expected impact on local health outcomes and come with significant opportunity costs. However, I assure your Lordships’ Committee that, where existing arrangements are working well, there is nothing in the Bill that prevents local areas continuing to come together to consider how best to integrate services and plan their approach to tackling the challenges they face. As we know, those challenges will vary according to locality. On Amendment 85, I am grateful to my noble friend Lord Hunt for bringing forward a discussion on women’s health centres and the join-up between health and social care. Regarding women’s health centres in particular—spoken to by my noble friends Lord Bradley and Lady Royall of Blaisdon—the existing duties already require integrated care boards to reduce inequalities and, to the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Kamall, to involve the public and voluntary sector partners in planning and commissioning. We have reinforced this through the Renewed Women’s Health Strategy and the NHS 10-year health plan. In both of these, as noble Lords will be aware, tackling inequalities is absolutely key. Additionally, we are prioritising the most disadvantaged areas and the most disadvantaged groups, rather than starting the other way around, which has happened in the past. We are walking towards the challenge, rather than away from it. The women’s health strategy has value way beyond health. It certainly goes into criminal justice, as my noble friend Lord Hunt referred to, and into the drivers of inequality. On how to work with community-based organisations in respect of women’s centres, raised by my noble friend Lord Bradley, there will be a period of design and engagement. Following that, we will set up a women’s voice partnership, through which we will very much focus on the organisations my noble friends have given examples of—those that represent the women who are most excluded from traditional services. I would absolutely expect women who are in contact with the criminal justice system, or who are in danger of doing so, to come into that category. The women’s voice partnership will allow the informing of decision-making and, over time, regional planning and delivery. We are looking to change how we are doing things and making sure that the most unheard women’s voices will be heard. However, the amendment mandates a statutory relationship with women’s centres. We feel that this risks reducing the flexibility ICBs need to design services around local needs and existing partnerships. I can certainly give the assurance, as outlined in the Renewed Women’s Health Strategy, that the role of women’s centres and women’s health hubs that the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay, spoke to is absolutely key. They are a model of prevention work and of neighbourhood healthcare and support, and I hope they will inspire other areas. Turning to Amendment 210, we are strengthening the join-up of healthcare and social care so that people can experience more integrated and person-centred care via the development of neighbourhood health. As the Cabinet statement Rewiring the State sets out, co-operation at local level remains key to success to ensure that services work together as a single coherent system built around the priorities people have. There were questions and debate in this group about the relationship between health and local government. I re-emphasise that the Bill simplifies a rather complex legal framework, to put it mildly. In the future, as we have debated earlier, health and wellbeing boards will be the focal point for collaboration between the NHS and local authorities, to support locally led neighbourhood health plans. The new operating model will be supported by guidance, including the strategic commissioning framework, which makes it clear that effective strategic commissioning depends on partnership between health and local authorities. In addition, national oversight of ICBs will continue to consider the effectiveness of their partnership working, including through feedback from partners, which I think will give considerable opportunity to meet the concerns noble Lords are expressing. The noble Lord, Lord Kamall, asked, if these amendments are not necessary, which is what I am saying, how will ICBs draw on experiences and share good practice? We are able to provide ICBs with guidance, including best practice, and we will continue to do that, including examples of what has worked well. Turning to Amendment 94 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, ICBs already have existing duties, including a duty to promote the integration of health and social care services. They already have the duty to co-operate with local authorities, and their triple-aim duty requires them to consider the wider effects of their decisions on health and wellbeing, the quality of services, and the sustainable and efficient use of resources. It includes consideration of the effect of decisions on health inequalities, and they will be held to account by the Secretary of State in working in this way. I agree that collaboration—a word used by the noble Lord, Lord Redwood—between organisations is fundamental. I hope I can provide, and have provided, reassurance that this is already embedded in ICBs’ ways of working; so the additional requirement is unnecessary because it risks reducing the flexibility ICBs need to design services around local needs.

More from Baroness Merron (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.