B

Baroness Tyler of Enfield (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I shall speak to my Amendments 95, 96 and 98. This is an important group of amendments, primarily around neighbourhood health plans. It takes forward some of the earlier discussions and debates that we have been having about integration and specifically addresses the architecture locally for trying to join everything up. My amendments address three connected issues about neighbourhood health plans: how the shift towards community care will be delivered; how unpaid carers will be supported; and what outcome those plans should achieve. I welcome the Government’s ambition to move care closer to home and to strengthen prevention, but the history of NHS reform tells us that ambition alone does not shift resources. It is telling that, in a Parliamentary Answer last month, the Government confirmed that between 2015 and 2025 the share of NHS commissioning expenditure going to acute services increased from 38.4% to 42.6%, while the share going to primary medical care fell from 8.8% to 8.3%. Those shifts are not really in the directions that we would wish to see. That is why my Amendment 95 matters. It would ask statutory partners to explain how commissioning, investment, workforce and provider capacity would support the changes that they are proposing. In particular, it would place an obligation on them to explain how statutory partners intend to develop preventative and community-based services, the commissioning and workforce arrangements required, and how resources and financial incentives would support the proposed changes. This would recognise that sometimes—social care is actually a good example here—investment by one partner generates savings for another. For example, if a local authority decides to invest in reablement or more care at home, the benefits may often appear in reduced demand for hospital services. There needs to be a way of taking all that into account. It is important to say that this amendment does not prescribe a particular service model or require an arbitrary transfer of resource; it asks local partners to explain how their intended changes will be delivered while safeguarding continuity of care. In responding to this amendment, will the Minister explain whether and how every neighbourhood health plan will be expected to identify the workforce, the provider capacity and the investment needed to develop the proposed shifts? Amendment 96 concerns unpaid carers, and I thank the noble Baronesses, Lady Hollins and Lady Pitkeathley, for adding their names to it. As a reminder, the Carers UK 2025 survey found that just 14% of carers responding felt that they had been asked about their ability and willingness to provide care during the hospital discharge process. We all know, because we talked about this earlier, what problems unpaid carers face. Indeed, in an earlier group I had an amendment about the identification of unpaid carers, because a carer may first become known to a GP, a hospital or a community health service. There should be an opportunity to recognise their needs, provide information and connect them with the appropriate support. Identification is important but not sufficient; it has to be about linking them up with the support available. The Care Act 2014 already establishes assessment responsibilities for adult carers, and the Children Act provides a separate arrangement for young carers and parent carers. My Amendment 96 would not transfer those responsibilities to the NHS; it would require neighbourhood plans to describe how services will connect identification—the subject of my amendment in an earlier group—with information, assessment and support, including arrangements for carers’ own physical and mental health and well-being. When the Minister responds on this amendment, can she explain what the Government’s plans are to ensure that identifying unpaid carers leads to appropriate information, assessment and support?

More from Baroness Tyler of Enfield (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.