Contribution
My Lords, I will speak to my Amendment 232, and I thank the noble Lord, Lord Russell, for adding his name to it. As the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, has highlighted, my amendment is closely related to some important amendments that she has discussed, on waiting times, improving child outcomes and transparency.
More broadly, I am sympathetic to all the amendments in this group; it is a wide-ranging set of amendments, but they are important. I do not have time to go through them all individually, but because it is an issue that I have discussed in the past, I signal my strong support in particular for the amendment from the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Leicester on adopted children requiring the retention of an NHS number—without that, those children can too easily fall through the cracks. This important group is all about promoting and protecting children. We talked about this a little in a few previous groups in Committee, but we have not heard enough about it.
My Amendment 232 seeks to promote and safeguard outcomes for babies, children and young people in the reformed healthcare system envisaged by the Bill. It seeks to address a fundamental question of accountability. As the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, has said, at present children are largely invisible in this important piece of legislation and, in my view, that happens too often in our debates on the NHS. The broad purpose of my amendment is to strengthen the focus on improving outcomes for children and young people by holding the structures that deliver services for them accountable for their progress.
My amendment has three key elements. First, it would require the Secretary of State to publish a national report on children’s outcomes and associated targeted investments. Secondly, it would place a duty on the Secretary of State to establish and publish a national definition of children’s outcomes, aligned with the babies, children and young people’s modern service framework, which I understand is due to be published shortly—the Minister may be able to give an update on this. In essence, this would provide a consistent basis for measuring and reporting progress across England. Thirdly, the amendment would also introduce a new duty on integrated care boards to publish an annual statement, setting out the outcomes achieved for children and young people in their area, detailing any targeted investments made during the financial year to improve those outcomes and explaining how those investments relate to the outcomes reported. That is technically what the amendment seeks to do.
Why do we need this? Past experience shows that children need to be the subject of explicit accountability measures or they simply get overlooked. I point back to the important work of the Darzi report, which highlighted concerns around children’s health services’ capacity and capability to deliver high-quality care for children. It identified deteriorating child health outcomes, raising demand for services as children faced increasing waiting times compared to adults, a shortage of specialist staff and a jarring £191 million cut to their services.
There is currently no consistent reporting on how child health outcomes are improving or deteriorating and how these changes are influencing decision-making, either at national or local level. It is difficult for us to judge how the Government are achieving their ambition, which I strongly support, of raising the healthiest generation of children ever, if there is limited transparency around the extent to which children’s outcomes inform these important investment decisions. If we are serious about achieving that ambition, which I am sure we are, we need to start answering these questions. How are children’s outcomes informing investment decisions? How are children being prioritised in limited resource decisions when ICBs are facing workforce shortages?
The consequence of this current lack of accountability is something that we need to be concerned about. As a brief reminder, the report this year of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, The State of Child Health, paints a worrying picture, with most measures of child health and well-being worsening or showing stalled progress, alongside stark inequalities in outcomes. A new analysis published very recently by the King’s Fund reinforces the urgency of the challenges and very much picks up on those themes that I mentioned from the Darzi report.
For children, as we have heard, these delays can have lifelong consequences. Missing a crucial developmental window can affect speech and language, mobility, physical and social development and learning. Against that backdrop, it becomes even more important that we can join up all the dots on what we spend on children’s services, where the money goes, what we get for it and the outcomes that children experience. In my view, the Bill gives us an important opportunity to strengthen that accountability, and my amendment does just that.
Finally, I want to be clear about what such an approach would not do. It does not in itself prescribe a particular level of spending on children’s services. That is important. Rather, it gives Parliament, policymakers, ICBs and the public much better information about how resources are being allocated, how that varies between areas, what outcomes are being achieved and, ultimately, whether further investment or action is needed. In short, it gives us a much clearer basis on which to hold both national and local systems to account for improving children’s health.