B

Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I am delighted to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler. My noble friend Lady Cass introduced this whole group, setting out how the amendments are critical, as they state that policy must have a specific focus on children’s health. My Amendment 243 in this group concerns the experience of parents, who when their child is near death have a peri-death situation. Some children have long-standing disabilities and gradually deteriorate. Others have an ongoing serious condition. These children may suddenly become very ill, and a decision has to be made over how active ongoing intervention should be. But there is another group: those children who are fit and well and active one day, and, within an hour or even a minute, life is changed by overwhelming infection, accident or event and the child appears potentially moribund. A 999 call or a “scoop and run” to A&E in a panic takes the child into resus, where parents are told, “We are doing all we can”. When stabilised, the child is often transferred to a major centre. Blue-lighted there, parents are met by bewildering tubes and machines, their world changing before their eyes, clinging to the hope from the words, “We are doing all we can”. Rapidly, they try to adapt, but panic can make some sound aggressive, others dumbstruck. Frantic phone calls attempt to update others in the family and arrange for other children to be cared for. The turmoil goes on. In all this, parents often feel excluded from decision-making. They cannot take in the wealth of information coming their way. All the time, they are hoping for recovery. Then, the body blow: they are told that nothing more can be done and resuscitation measures are to cease, with ventilation withdrawn. If they object, they may be told that the hospital will go to court for a ruling to cease artificial life-sustaining measures. They cannot take it in. Trust evaporates. In desperation, they seek any input they can. Sometimes they hit a brick wall when they ask to see the clinical record, a copy of scan reports and other investigations. When parents are involved at every moment, respected and listened to, they can be taken down to reality gently, in stages. Little acts of kindness are essential. They need to feel and see that clinicians sincerely care. If they feel that staff talk down to them, take a superior “we know best” approach and fail to be open, it all gets worse. These parents carry the grief and scars for the rest of their lives. If their child is dying and they want to take the child home, allowing their last hours to be surrounded by a loving family, then why not? If they want a second, independent opinion, then why not? Resources are no excuse. Care in the community for the child’s extubation, whether in the home or in a children’s hospice, can be far less expensive than in a paediatric intensive care unit.

More from Baroness Finlay of Llandaff (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.