L

Lord Russell of Liverpool (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I am glad we are talking about this group at a decent time in the morning. I was going to comment the other evening that we were going to talk about children well past their bedtimes and well past some of our bedtimes, so I am glad we are doing it at a time when most of us are more or less awake. I am in broadly in favour of all these amendments. They all point to the fact that, at the moment, we do not have clarity across our health system on exactly what is happening to children, what money is being spent on them, how it is being spent and how effectively it is being spent. That is clearly not a situation we would like to be in. In her Amendment 66, my noble friend Lady Cass spoke about waiting times. As we all know, any delays in the key stages of brain and physical development for young children can have lifelong consequences, not always for the better. I had the privilege of being in the meeting she referred to, which she and my noble friend Lady Kidron held, and which had the heads of many of the royal colleges there. As my noble friend Lady Cass said, there was a sort of “Aha” moment as each of the heads of the royal colleges realised that the concerns they had, and the worrying data they were getting back from clinicians in the field about what they were seeing in children, was being mirrored and echoed in the other colleges. That was a real wake-up moment for all of us, but particularly for them. In relation to Amendment 232, in the names of the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler, and myself, if you do not measure, monitor, collate, understand, publish and debate children’s health outcomes, you are flying blind. You have to enable the identification of best practice and innovation where that is working, and enable careful targeting when one finds areas that are simply not working as they should. I turn briefly to the amendment from my noble friend Lady Finlay. I must confess that I was not familiar with this area, but I know that she speaks from deep personal and professional experience. I can only imagine—I do not even want to imagine—what parents in that situation are going through. It seems that the least we should ask for is that they are treated with a level of understanding and sensitivity, at what is probably one of the worst moments of their lives. To the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Leicester, I have to declare an interest; I am an ex-trustee and governor of Coram. We have been involved in adoption since we were founded in 1739, so we are very familiar with the area. What he described should not really be happening, but it is happening to just over 4,000 children a year. As he mentioned, many of these children, before they are adopted, have had an early life that was pretty traumatic. What has happened to them in early life is not immediately evident at the time they are adopted. It is incredibly important that there is clarity and continuity in understanding exactly what treatment and diagnosis have been made prior to them being adopted, to help the parents understand some of the dilemmas and behaviours that they are encountering, which probably bewilder them, and also the clinicians who are trying to help the families deal with these children. In relation to the many digital amendments on the effects of social media, we all know that this is a real problem. The commonality in all these amendments is a cry for the Government, their advisers, clinicians and all specialists who deal with children, including educationalists, to have a much better understanding than they do of the clearly pernicious effects of technology on the very young. I think the Government are listening. It is one thing to listen; it is another to have to take a clear set of decisions about what you are then going to do about it, and how you will measure whether what you think you should do is actually going to work. That is why I hope the Government will listen carefully to my colleagues such as my noble friend Lady Cass and the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron, who, unlike many of us, actually know what they are talking about. I will now speak to Amendment 249, tabled by my noble friend Lady Cass, which is about health inequalities. A paper by UNICEF UK, Held Back from the Start, shows that health inequalities are already well established, I am afraid, in the first five years of life. The Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health has published a paper this year, State of Child Health, which demonstrates that those inequalities are actually widening. Despite facing longer waits on average and poorer access to services, children under 18 are excluded from age discrimination protections when it comes to accessing public services and are therefore at risk of being overlooked. Without specific mention of children, health inequalities for children are likely to be ignored. Infant mortality in the most deprived areas of this country is about 5.3 deaths per 1,000—more than double the rate in the least deprived areas. Severe obesity is about 9% in the most deprived areas—four times the rate of 2.2% in the least deprived areas. Tooth decay affects one in three children in the poorest communities, as opposed to one in 10 in the most affluent. Those inequalities are staring us in the face. Behind all these statistics are children whose health is being shaped by factors that are wholly outside their control, including poverty, poor housing, food insecurity and unequal access to support. Children in deprived communities are more likely to be exposed to air pollution, damp, mould and overcrowded housing, all of which contribute to worse asthma outcomes. Health inequalities are driven by the conditions into which children are born and grow up. Reducing those inequalities requires action across all departments, not just the NHS and the DHSS, which is why this amendment would require a cross-government strategy and create a duty for all Ministers to have regard to that strategy. The Government, laudably, have produced strategies for men’s health and women’s health, but not for children’s health, and I regard that as unacceptable and a failure of the duty of care.

More from Lord Russell of Liverpool (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.