B

Baroness Pidgeon (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I wish to speak to my Amendment 102, which my noble friend Lady Tyler has also spoken to, which would retain joint local health and well-being strategies. I should declare that I am a vice-president of the Local Government Association. The LGA supports the shift towards neighbourhood health, which offers a clear opportunity to bring services closer to people, support earlier intervention and better reflect the realities of how people experience health and care. Councils, as we know, deliver services for adults and children through social care and public health and have strong influence over other areas—housing, employment, education, and so on. They also hold the relationships to convene partners around shared goals and outcomes, which is really important. Health and well-being boards have a critical role to play in delivering more integrated, preventive and neighbourhood-focused services by looking at prevention, health inequalities and the wider determinants of health, as we have been discussing throughout Committee. Neighbourhood health plans, by contrast, are structured around nationally prescribed outcomes relating to primary care access, planned care and so on. While local priorities can be included, national ones are measured, monitored and given prominence. My amendment therefore supports retaining the joint local health and well-being strategy as the overarching framework, with neighbourhood health plans required to be consistent with it. As I said, this is supported by the Local Government Association. The strategy provides a framework for identifying the priorities that matter most to local communities. I understand that lots of councils have told the LGA that, even if the legislation sets out something different, they will continue with their joint local health and well-being strategy, because it has been so successful in strengthening place-based leadership and partnership working. To give a few examples, Sheffield has a good city strategy for tackling health inequalities and wants to keep working together on it. Southampton describes its strategy as a clear, city-wide framework for improving health and, again, reducing inequalities. It does not see the neighbourhood health plans as a replacement. West Berkshire Council also sees the strategy document as far broader than neighbourhood health plans, setting the overall strategic direction on well-being needed right across West Berkshire. Wokingham Borough, Lancashire and Calderdale councils similarly all feel that this is a far more useful document, and that the neighbourhood health plans could feed into it. Retaining these strategies is consistent with the approach that the Government are setting out through Rewiring the State, shifting to local decision-making power on questions that affect their places. That provides that strategic, place-based bridge between neighbourhood-level delivery and regional decision-making which is so important. In the letter last week from the Minister, the Government said that neighbourhood health plans would continue to cover the core matters currently addressed through the strategies that I have mentioned. However, if so many local authorities say they do not think they do that and intend to continue using their overarching joint strategy, they are clearly not convinced by this replacement neighbourhood plan. I ask the Government to really think about this and see whether there is a role for both in making sure we get the planning right locally. The government guidance should provide greater clarity on purpose, accountability and core functions while allowing the flexibility in there. I fully support the other amendments in this group tabled by my noble friend Lady Tyler, particularly her raising once again the important issue of unpaid carers, and that tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Scott, talking about people with ME. I look forward to the Minister’s response.

More from Baroness Pidgeon (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.