Contribution
My Lords, I have added my name to Amendments 206 and 245. I am delighted to support the noble Baroness, Lady Hayter of Kentish Town, and commend her work in this area, along with that of the noble Lord, Lord Black, and the noble Baroness, Lady Cass. The case has been made very clearly, and investing to save is something the Government should like. It is so clear. The figures that the noble Lord, Lord Black, set out are quite astonishing. I am grateful to the Royal Osteoporosis Society for its campaigning on universal access to fracture liaison services. It is wonderful that the Government have committed to this.
However, there are real and serious concerns about how the Government have reported progress towards universal fracture prevention services, including through Questions and Answers in this House. There have been several since I took over this brief before the summer. Ministers have cited figures suggesting 92% coverage in England, based on 23 out of 25 integrated care boards having at least one service. These are merged, larger ICBs, so some areas have had no change in service, but are now technically claimed to have a service as part of their larger ICB area. This is a bit like the point I made in Committee the other week: when is a trolley not counted as a trolley? When it has had its wheels removed and it becomes a bed. It is playing with statistics, rather than the reality on the ground that people experience. What matters is the proportion of patients reached, not simply whether a service exists. The point made by the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, about community delivery is an important aspect to ensure the accessibility of this service. The Office for Statistics Regulation recently responded to concerns about these figures, warning that inconsistent reporting could confuse the public about the Government’s commitment and progress towards delivering it. The OSR has called on the department to clarify what it means by coverage and to consider publishing consistent statistics. That is a serious intervention by the independent regulator.
The national audit shows that only 24% of fragility fractures in England are identified by fracture prevention services. That is a very different picture from the 92% that we had cited. This demonstrates why Amendment 206 is needed: it would provide clear milestones, meaningful measures of patient access and regular reporting to Parliament. I think noble Lords can sense the strength of feeling across the Committee in this debate. Will the Government commit to measuring progress by the proportion of eligible patients identified and receiving appropriate care, rather than relying on whether services exist within particular geographical boundaries?
Amendment 245 from the noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, is about ensuring that ICBs establish and support an integrated frailty pathway across all disciplines. This is important if we are to shift to community and stop constant pressure and crisis in acute settings. Frailty, rather than ageing, is the key issue here, and it needs truly integrated care. The frailty front door model that has been described is key to making this work and preventing those long stays in hospital that I am sure we have all known with loved ones in hospital. We need to rebuild some of those services outside that hospital setting. The noble Baroness, Lady Gerada, set this out so clearly and with such knowledge. I hope the Minister will listen to her expertise and support this important amendment. My noble friend Lady Barker made a clear point to explain the reality of this on the ground. I hope the Minister will respond positively to the amendments in this group and the points that have been made.