B

Baroness Coffey (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, if the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath, thinks some foundation trusts are not politicised already in their appointments, then I am slightly surprised to hear that. I had not planned to speak on this group, although it is very interesting, as I had hoped we would get to the next group to discuss foundation trusts, but I have a little sympathy for the Minister. The noble Lord, Lord Stevens of Birmingham, talked about tears. That inspired me to think of the band Tears for Fears. One song is “Shout”, with the chorus “let it all out”: perhaps the Minister will do that tonight. Then there is “Everybody Wants To Rule The World”: God knows how many people want to be a Perm Sec at DHSC nowadays. Another famous song of theirs is “Head Over Heels”, in which somebody would rather “talk about the weather”. I appreciate that the Minister is in the hands of her Secretary of State. In the Answer to the Written Question I tabled, specifically to ask what the status would be of current NHS England employees transferred to the proposed agency within the Department of Health and whether those employees will become civil servants, the Answer was: “Further details will be set out in the normal way in due course”. I fear others are going to be slightly disappointed. I suggest, a little more gently, that these fears and concerns are well founded, and not only, as the noble Lord, Lord Stevens of Birmingham, mentioned, those of current employees. I am conscious that I want to get this Bill through as well. I am pro a lot of what the Government are trying to do, but there is a lot of uncertainty, which is not helpful when it comes to delivering the outcomes to patients. Today it is really interesting to see significant parts of the Milburn review. Paragraph 598 has already been referenced and, to some extent, I feel justified in having tabled an amendment earlier in Committee on the Secretary of State having a duty to do that work, because this is exactly what is being said there. I appreciate that the noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, cannot be here tonight, but there are some interesting things going on. His amendment would ban NHS employees who have been made redundant from being re-recruited within five years. That is probably quite extreme, but in the last 12 months a whole load of people have been released and certain things were said then—that they would potentially be able to come back in—and that is now being vetoed. These are real operational issues. I appreciate that it might be uncomfortable for the Government to get into that in today’s debate in Committee, but that uncertainty is not going to help. Change of specification is always uncomfortable, but when you are just waiting to see what the latest “in due course” really means, it is going to be challenging. I think some further amendments could be made to the schedule to allow a wider use of legal powers to transfer people from one status to another to give them certainty. Quite often when there is uncertainty, the best people leave anyway, and you are not left with the best talent. That is critical for this huge transformation that the Government want to make in deciding to take back control in-house and rewire the state. I wish them well in that, but they will not do it if everybody who is the best goes.

More from Baroness Coffey (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.