L

Lord Hunt of Kings Heath (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I am intrigued by the comments by the noble Lord, Lord Stevens. First, I had not actually come to paragraph 598, and I look forward to doing so in due course. However, it is of course logical if we are serious about devolution, and I will call it devolution for the moment, that the mayor should be the ICB chair, because that is the obvious way to link it back in. Why is the Mayor of the West Midlands not becoming chair of a merged West Midlands ICB, which is the best way to do it? However, the powers under which that mayor operates will be governed by NHS legislation, and I agree with the noble Lord that it is difficult to square what is called devolution with the responsibility of the Secretary of State to retain the national identity of an NHS in which, from all our debates today, we find any variation completely unacceptable. There is a tension running through all of us about this. I have amendments that require uniform provision of services on the one hand, but then on the other I am concerned about centralisation, so this is a very difficult issue. When the noble Lord, Lord Stevens, talked about the “grey book” of 1974, I saw that most noble Lords’ eyes rather glazed over, but I was working in the NHS at the time of the 1974 reorganisation. I did not write the grey book; it was written by McKinsey and Company, at enormous expense, and it was a huge disaster—as its reports often are—because it basically brought in what was called consensus management. The idea was that at the area health authority level and the district management team level—the DMTs ran the hospitals—the senior management team should reach consensus all the time. So there was no boss, and of course the result was that no one made any decisions whatever. It took Ken Clarke—now the noble Lord, Lord Clarke—to come in and get rid of it all, and we then appointed chief executives. What is my point there? When I joined in 1972, we did not have NHS England, the NHS management executive or the NHS agency. We had a branch in the Department of Health called regional liaison, and its responsibility was to oversee the regional hospital boards and the regional health authorities—generally, the NHS. When I saw the proposal for the establishment of an NHS group, I thought: “Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose”—what goes around comes around. We are having a bit of fun here, but the outcome of what the Government are doing is actually quite pragmatic and sensible. We should give them a fair run. We will come back to appointments in the next group. When I was first a Minister in the Department of Health, we used to do all the chair appointments and, if I may say so, we made a very fine job of it, too. We did not appoint political hacks—that is true up to a point; occasionally, we may have appointed political hacks. The noble Baroness, Lady Morris of Bolton, has never forgiven me for sacking her when she was chair of a health authority. The point is that we did it, but life has moved on and it would not be acceptable now. To preview the next group, which I suspect we will now debate on Monday, the best way to ensure that you do not have either a politicisation of the appointment of chairs and non-execs of foundation trusts or a bureaucratisation through using a special health authority is to retain the council of governors, which does the job very effectively now.

More from Lord Hunt of Kings Heath (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.