Contribution
My Lords, I am very pleased to support the probing amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Scriven. He has laid out just now the questions that the whole of the NHS wants answered. We therefore look forward to the Minister doing so before the night is done.
Just as in the 1974 reorganisation discussions around the regional tier, it was inevitable that would find ourselves discussing “tears about tiers”; that is essentially what we are discussing in this group. I could not help but think back to Nick Timmins’ magisterial overview of the history of the National Health Service and all its reorganisations. Of the 1974 reorganisation, he said:
“Despite the elephantine gestation … the exercise in the end was hopelessly rushed to tie in with local government reorganisation…. By vesting day, vast armies of administrators still did not have their permanent jobs sorted out. Something fittingly known … as the Grey Book eventually provided the broad outline. It looked beautiful on paper while proving something of a disaster on the ground”.
The question is: will we ever learn from our own history? The sorts of practical questions that this probing amendment seeks to elicit are clearly questions that need answering.
In many respects, it is a pragmatic decision to establish the regional tier through a special health authority, rather than to try and fold that into a central government department and turn those NHS functions into Civil Service functions. It has been entirely predictable that this would be a question that would need answering. Unfortunately, it has been left until the very last minute, so now, as the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, says, we really need to see the detail. Who will be the chair and the board? What powers will the special health authority have. What will be its size and its budget? In particular, what accountability will exist from the special health authority to the ICBs, the foundation trusts and the NHS trusts in those regions?
The reason that this is so important is, in part, that the question of the potentially confused accountabilities that the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, has just raised with reference to South Yorkshire assume a new importance today in the light of the report just published by Alan Milburn. Those who have had the chance to read it will have noted, in paragraph 598, the recommendation that the Greater Manchester and South Yorkshire model, whereby the ICB chair is the mayoral health commissioner, should be universalised across the entire NHS by 2029. Therefore, the governance mechanisms would mean that it would be the mayoral health commissioner who would by default be appointed as the ICB chair.
Therefore, the questions posed by the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, about what the accountability is to the mayor and what the accountability is to the Secretary of State, and the challenge from the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath—in his return to the Bevanite doctrine of the unified line of command to the Secretary of State not being in any way confused by our entanglements with local government on perhaps something closer to the Morrisonian model—will need answering, and again we look forward to the Minister doing so in the next half hour. We need to know how the SHA is going to work and how the accountability is set.
Since we are not necessarily going to get to the next group of amendments on appointments tonight, a solution to a different problem may be available pragmatically through this special health authority. It seems entirely inappropriate that the Secretary of State in Whitehall would personally make over 1,000 appointments to foundation trusts for non-executive directors and chairs, and indeed to NHS-run ICBs. The obvious home for that function would be the special health authority, which was the model adopted through the NHS appointments process from 2001 until it was abolished in 2012. That way, it could be regulated by the Commissioner for Public Appointments. Appointments would be made on merit after a fair, open and transparent process rather than mates and political stooges, and it would put a degree of transparency and arm’s-lengthness into the arrangements for appointing. So there may be a silver lining in this tangled cloud, and we look forward to what the Minister can tell us.