Contribution
My Lords, I have two amendments in this group. Amendment 85 is concerned with women’s centres and ICBs. Amendment 210 is rather wider and concerns a duty of co-operation between NHS bodies, in which ICBs have a pivotal role to play; really, it will get us back to the debate about the role of local government in the health service.
Amendment 85 would require ICBs to work collaboratively with women’s centres to support women facing multiple disadvantages to access timely, joined-up healthcare, particularly including women in the criminal justice system, by helping tackle drivers of offending and improving health and well-being outcomes. It would also help tackle entrenched health inequalities for women affected by physical and sexual abuse, homelessness, poverty, ill health, substance dependence or criminal justice contact facing severe needs and barriers to mainstream care by working with groups including the NHS, ICBs and local authorities.
Many noble Lords here will be well aware—we have had many debates on this over the years, particularly more recently—of the value of women’s centres and the services they offer. My understanding is that they are particularly valuable in providing trauma-informed support and act as a bridge to the NHS and other services. Partnerships between the NHS and women’s centres exist, but often this is patchy and depends on local priorities and relationships. It is interesting that the Ministry of Justice’s Women’s Justice Board has recommended that the Government enhance the female pathway to timely, appropriate support for all women, including requirements for local operational partnership plans to involve women’s specialist services and other health agencies. I would argue that investment by the NHS in these services and supporting these vulnerable women would pay huge dividends in both the life outcomes of those women and the demands being placed on the health service.
My amendment would involve women’s centres in commissioning plans and service decisions, including services for women experiencing multiple disadvantages. That might include practical partnerships, having regard to centres’ views, and identifying, monitoring and reviewing health inequalities and access, reflecting national women’s health policy.
I want to make a general point about ICBs. They do not have a great reputation in relation to working with NGOs and voluntary bodies. This is a real problem. Many national NGOs do not have the resources to relate to the individual ICBs. At the local level, too, they can sometimes find that the health service shuts the door to having proper discussions. My concern about all this is ICBs’ capacity: at the same time as they are being asked to do more things, they have fewer people to do them. There is a real concern here. This is why a lot of our amendments are aimed at keeping services run at the national level. We just do not think ICBs can do this. I make a particular appeal here for women’s centres, because they are so vulnerable in terms of funding and support.
Moving on to my Amendment 210, on partnership, the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, has her own Amendment 94 and her Clause 24 stand part notice, which fit the bill very well. It is really a question of how the Government see the partnership between the NHS and local government going forward. We are in some difficulty. In a sense, this Bill was written before Andy Burnham became Prime Minister. We have a very different attitude of government towards devolution, but unfortunately the Bill is rather stuck in a pre-Burnham era, although the Government have made some welcome changes, including retention of Healthwatch and, of course, the requirement now for ICBs to have a local authority member. We are still left a little vague about where this is going. My noble friend Lord Bradley has asked me three or four times who the heck the nominee of the mayor is accountable to, and I could not provide the answer.