Cyber Security: Public Sector Dependence on Technology Providers
Tuesday, 17 November 2026
Contributions
Question
Asked by
The Lord Bishop of Hereford
To ask His Majesty’s Government what assessment they have made of the cyber security risks of public sector dependence on a small number of technology providers; and what steps they are taking to encourage greater platform diversification.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade (Baroness Lloyd of Effra) (Lab)
Large technology vendors bring benefits through their ability to scale and invest in platform capability and security. However, last week’s Microsoft outage showed that supplier concentration can create resilience risks. The Government Cyber Action Plan sets out how this Government are improving cyber security and digital resilience across the public sector. The Government are taking action to diversify our cloud infrastructure. The national cloud infrastructure programme is intended to reshape the UK cloud market, building a stronger, more diverse supply base.
The Lord Bishop of Hereford
I thank the Minister for that Answer and for referring to the Microsoft outage last week—which I am sure will have inconvenienced many of us and cost many UK businesses a large amount of money, reinforcing our vulnerability given the small number of providers, largely international, of computer services. However, cyber resilience depends not solely on technology but on people. Given the excellent work being undertaken through programmes such as the Cyber Quarter in Hereford to develop expertise in this country, what steps are the Government taking to strengthen the UK’s cyber resilience by cultivating and retaining domestic cyber talent?
Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)
The right reverend Prelate is absolutely right to focus on the many aspects needed to strengthen our cyber resilience, from infrastructure to understanding, board and senior management leadership and, crucially, having the right skill set—the right-skilled professionals and the pipeline. Through TechFirst the Government are investing in developing skills from school-aged pupils to undergraduates and graduates, so that we have the capabilities needed in this country to support our cyber resilience.
Lord Clement-Jones (LD)
My Lords, yesterday the Minister told the House that the Government are “encouraging departments to look at the full range of cloud providers ”.—[ Official Report , 16/11/26; col. 459.] But encouragement has left 46 of the UK’s 48 police forces relying on Microsoft not just for email but to hold much of their data, despite their own national risk assessment warning of exactly this in 2017. Encouragement is clearly not enough. Will the national cloud infrastructure programme set firm targets for reducing that dependence, and when will it report?
Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)
The noble Lord is right to highlight the importance of public procurement and the national cloud infrastructure programme, through which the Government are looking at how their significant cloud demand can be used more strategically to strengthen competition and resilience, diversify supplier choice and support UK technology businesses to take a stronger role in supply chains. The NCIP will launch its formal procurement process by the end of the year.
Baroness Blackwood of North Oxford (Con)
My Lords, I declare my interest as chair of Genomics England and the Health Data Research Service. Cyber incidents affecting health data are particularly grave. The 2024 ransomware attack on Synnovis delayed appointments for more than 11,000 patients. In a statement to this House, the Minister acknowledged that the NHS has more than 80,000 suppliers and limited visibility of dependencies. The NHS has set out proposals to increase resilience through the cyber improvement programme. Can the Minister please set out the progress that has been made in that regard, and the lessons that have been learned from Synnovis?
Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)
The Government have learned from many of the cyber incidents that have happened in recent years. One of the ways we are taking forward lessons from previous incidents is through the cyber security and resilience Bill, which focuses on the leadership needed at all levels of the sectors within the scope of the Bill—the health service is within that scope—and increases the power of the regulators to enforce the standards set under it. Through the security and resilience requirements we will also set standards for data, including on the issues around data protection and data minimisation, which were a feature of the Synnovis attack.
Lord Londesborough (CB)
My Lords, I challenge the Minister on platform diversification. Data from market intelligence firm Tussell shows that large procurement contracts of £100 million-plus accounted for 44% of all public sector IT contracts last year, up from 29% just two years before. Does the Minister agree that, because large contracts favour large incumbents, the pendulum is swinging in the wrong direction? I declare an interest as chairman of Tussell.
Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)
The national cloud infrastructure programme that I referenced a moment ago is in recognition of the fact that the UK Government have considerable spending power, but we need to think carefully about how we use that. The intention and purpose of that programme is to use the Government’s spending power more strategically to strengthen competition, diversify supplier choice and support UK technology businesses. As I mentioned to the noble Lord, Lord Clement-Jones, formal procurement will start by the end of the year. Then, after a period of engagement, we will see the result of that and what it does to the statistics that the noble Lord referred to.
Lord Ranger of Northwood (Con)
My Lords, it is good to hear from the Minister that the Government are looking at diversification. What was the impact on government from the Microsoft incident on Friday, and how was it assessed? What were the fallback procedures, and how did they perform?
Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)
As I set out yesterday, there were impacts on parts of the public sector, but all key operational services—for example, 999 services—were maintained. We saw the Government responding as they should, with a co-ordinated approach. We saw evidence of alternative communication channels being used, but there was disruption to communication. Even this House was disrupted, but the business of the House was not affected. We will learn the lessons, and we expect Microsoft to share its lessons learned report with us. We will continue to learn those lessons and put them into practice to improve our resilience.
Viscount Camrose (Con)
My Lords, the United States has banned the use of DeepSeek in all federal agencies because of security concerns. However, last month we learned here that the Cabinet Office does not centrally record which AI models government departments are using. Do the Government share the US assessment of the risk from DeepSeek and, if so, how are they going about managing any such risks without knowing centrally which models are being used?
Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)
Our approach for looking at risks is to look at what good cyber defence looks like. The advent of new models such as frontier models has not changed the assessment of what government organisations and private sector organisations need to do to build their cyber resilience. In respect of the UK Government, that is in line with the Government Cyber Action Plan.
Lord Birt (CB)
My Lords, Microsoft’s initial report on the origin of last week’s global outage stated that it was caused by a dormant bug on a piece of software introduced just a few weeks ago. What provisions in the cyber security Bill, which the Minister just mentioned, would address that vulnerability?
Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)
Obviously, we are waiting for the full report from Microsoft, to learn the full details of what caused the outage and the disruption, as well as what mitigants were effective in reducing its impact in the Government and in other services. Once we have looked at that carefully, we will see what lessons can be learned. In respect of the cyber security and resilience Bill more generally, cloud computing services are already within the scope of the NIS regulations, which would include, in respect of Microsoft, some email services if they meet the statutory definition of being scalable and elastic. The cyber security Bill is also bringing managed service providers within its scope.
Lord Harper (Con)
My Lords, I will press the Minister on the question from my noble friend on the Front Bench. I listened carefully to her answer, and I do not think she really addressed it. His question was around whether the Government do now, or are going to, track centrally the models used in the AI services they use. Do the Government currently do that and, if not, do they have any plans to do so? If the Minister does not have that information at her fingertips today, will she write to my noble friend and put a copy in the Library of the House?
Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)
I am indeed quite happy to write to the noble Viscount addressing his question and the follow-up from the noble Lord, Lord Harper.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5439329.