Official Development Assistance
Tuesday, 17 November 2026
Contributions
Question
Asked by
Lord McConnell of Glenscorrodale
To ask His Majesty’s Government whether they intend to review the bilateral Official Development Assistance allocations announced in July.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (Lord Wood of Anfield) (Lab)
My Lords, the Government do not intend to change the bilateral official development assistance allocations. The allocations reflect the UK’s modernised approach to international development, focusing resources where we can have greatest impact. Respecting established multi-year budget allocations provides the predictability needed to support better planning for FCDO and FCDO’s partners, and more effective delivery. ODA alone is insufficient. We are drawing on the full breadth of UK expertise to deliver the development that our partners want and need.
Lord McConnell of Glenscorrodale (Lab)
My Lords, Malawi is a key ally of the United Kingdom in southern Africa and it is the poorest peaceful democracy in the world. Despite that, UK aid has made a difference in Malawi over the last 16 years. Over 400,000 students, mostly girls, have been found school places as a result of our support, maternal deaths have decreased and livelihoods have increased. However, there will be a 60% cut in the allocation of UK aid to Malawi in 2026-27, and a 90% cut by 2028-29, taking our contribution to its economy and public services down to £5 million. This is all happening at a time when development challenges are increasing. I am disappointed to hear the Minister’s answer, but I want to ask him two specific questions. When these cuts were announced earlier this year, we were told that the UK would be focusing its expenditure on multilateral institutions and that we would be pressing those international institutions to spend more in the countries where we were cutting the budgets. Have there been discussions with the African Development Bank and the World Bank to replace these funds taken away by the United Kingdom? Will there be other efforts to ensure that Malawi’s economy can grow, with investment and in partnership with the United Kingdom, so that at least some of the aspirations that were laid out earlier this year can be realised, despite the dreadful impact that these cuts are going to have on that country and its people?
Lord Wood of Anfield (Lab)
I thank the noble Lord for his follow-up question and for his constant work in this part of the world and elsewhere, which is an example for us all. It would be wrong of me to deny that there are bilateral cuts affecting countries such as Malawi—there are—but the noble Lord is exactly right that cuts to bilateral aid are being compensated for to a large extent by the reallocation of our grants to multilateral institutions. We have chosen to increase our contribution to the World Bank’s International Development Association, IDA, which delivers two-thirds of its work in Africa and maintains strong support for the African Development Fund. The combination of multilateral ODA and bilateral programmes that operate in sub-Saharan Africa means that we will be spending approximately the same share of FCDO ODA in sub-Saharan Africa as in recent years. The noble Lord is right that this is a matter of forging greater economic links, as well as social connections; that is why activities such as British International Investment, the UK’s development finance institution, which invests 60% of its portfolio in Africa, are so important in this area.
Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon (Con)
My Lords, in 2021, during the UK’s leadership of the G7, a flagship programme was 12 years of quality education for every girl in the world, focused on bilateral funding. We have seen a 50.9% cut in bilateral funding for girls’ education—such education empowers girls, empowers communities and empowers nations. What response does the Minister give to that cut?
Lord Wood of Anfield (Lab)
The noble Lord is right to raise education and girls, and a broader set of issues to do with violence against women and girls, a priority which was set by the previous Government and has been continued by this Government. In the course of the cuts to bilateral aid and the reprofiling, we have continued to prioritise humanitarian need, health, climate and nature, underpinned by economic development and with women and girls at the centre of development efforts, as well as maintaining country allocations in areas that suffer the greatest humanitarian outrages, particularly Ukraine, Sudan and Palestine. Again, this is a matter of responding to an overall cut in the budget. I am not going to walk away from the fact that those cuts have consequences, but maintaining priorities, including in the area that the noble Lord referred to, remains a priority in the development policy.
Lord Bruce of Bennachie (LD)
My Lords, will the Minister give a little more detail as to how we are going to reset our relationship with the dozen or so countries whose aid budget is being cut to £5 million? For example, will he tell us what we are going to be doing not only in Malawi but in Sierra Leone, Kenya and Zambia, which tonight in London are celebrating their long-standing relationship with the UK but have to face the fact that they do not know what the future holds for them?
Lord Wood of Anfield (Lab)
The noble Lord raises an important challenge, and my response to that challenge is partly to say that relations with countries that have been destinations for traditional aid support in the past are not just limited to aid support. There are all sorts of business investment and other wider relationships that continue to be important. The noble Lord mentioned a few countries. I want to refer to Malawi as an example, because I did not actually mention it specifically in response to the noble Lord, Lord McConnell, at the beginning. We remain a long-term partner to Malawi. Here are some examples of the kind of work we are doing: bilateral programmes; shifting from grant-funded service towards investment expertise; systems reform, which is not normally captured in traditional aid flows; helping Malawi to strengthen economic and debt reform through our support to international financial institutions; delivering a major renewable energy project through UK-backed development finance; and developing extensive links with UK universities, businesses and institutions to connect them with Malawi. Similar programmes are vital for supporting countries that, yes, have experienced cuts in bilateral aid assistance from the UK.
Lord Grocott (Lab)
My Lords, can my noble friend give us an indication of what proportion of our aid budget goes via multinational agencies and what proportion is delivered directly and bilaterally? Does he have any information about which of those two methods is the most efficient and effective in getting the aid to where it is most needed?
Lord Wood of Anfield (Lab)
I may have to come back if I have got this wrong, and other noble Lords in the House may have a better answer, but I believe that it is approximately 50% through multilateral institutions. However, we are slightly gearing the increase in that amount, partly to compensate for bilateral cuts elsewhere. The effectiveness depends on the programme. There are certain concentrated populations who benefit extensively from focused bilateral support, but there are region-wide economic investment programmes where multilateral economic institutions, such as the development banks, are going to be crucial partners for the UK in pursuing development goals. Unfortunately, there is no single answer to the noble Lord’s question, but we are looking to leverage multilateral economic institutions much more as a result of the way that we have reprofiled our development spend.
Baroness Sugg (Con)
My Lords, I was recently in Sierra Leone, another country that is having its bilateral aid cut to £5 million, where I saw the devastating impact that cut is having on the lives of women and girls. I note with regret that the new OBR projections mean that the Government are set to miss their ODA commitment of 0.3% by £320 million. Given the fiscal pressures that we face as a country, what is the Government’s view of a different approach to ODA, exemplified by Italy’s Mattei plan, which links development to national interests and works towards strategic priorities rather than spending targets?
Lord Wood of Anfield (Lab)
There is much to be said for thinking about development in a broader sense. In a way, we are living in a period where defence, security and development are all being rethought, and it is incumbent on anyone in a privileged position, such as me and officials who work with us, to rethink things constantly to face the different kinds of challenges. There is no doubt that bilateral cuts will have had an effect. On tracking the 0.3%, the noble Baroness will know that the reason the change was made was to give budgetary certainty to individual programmes over a three-year period. The challenge with tracking 0.3% year after year within a spending review period was that it required reprofiling of multilateral allocations and cutting bilateral programmes in order to hit the 0.3% target when, for example, refugee costs increased. Yes, there is a price to pay, perhaps, in the overall amount, but the programme certainty was judged to be a prize worth having.
Lord Callanan (Con)
My Lords, in 2024, nine members of UN Relief and Works Agency staff in Gaza were sacked over possible links to Hamas. In June this year, 70 more UNRWA staff were sacked over links to Hamas. Did Ministers consider the growing evidence of links between Hamas and UNRWA before announcing £23 million of additional funding for the agency in June? Does the Minister think that that money might be better spent in Malawi or on women and girls?
Lord Wood of Anfield (Lab)
The noble Lord raises an important issue. It is perfectly compatible to take a tough, uncompromising approach to Hamas, as we have done, not just through sanctions on financing vehicles associated with Hamas but in policy more generally, and to support the United Nations and all its agencies in the vital work that they perform, particularly at the moment, given the extraordinary humanitarian situation in Gaza. This is a time when we should be backing the United Nations in its efforts to alleviate an appalling situation.
← Previous
Electricity Demand: Data Centres and Transport
Next →
Cyber Security: Public Sector Dependence on Technology Providers
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5439328.