L

Lord Redwood (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, Amendment 94 invites us to support the idea of integration and collaboration, led by the ICBs, between all the other health bodies in their area. These are two rather different words. Integration is a very popular word with those who are doing the integrating. They assume that their view will prevail, that they have the perfect answer for an integrated service and that they will make the wise decisions. But those who are being integrated might not see it like that. They might feel that the integration plan dilutes their role. It may damage their approach to the problem, which may be a perfectly reasonable approach, or it may even entail the loss of their job. The integrators normally get the good jobs; the anti-integrators are usually the ones on the losing side. It would be a pity to put into legislation a requirement that ICBs had to develop a plan for integrating local services when they might have much more pressing things to do, to sort out the quality of the services for which they are directly responsible. There may be no easy integrated plan that carries sufficient support or can be carried through without dislocation and damage to local services. It is more difficult to disagree with collaboration. It is a very warm word. Many of us here like to collaborate more than we go in for political disagreement. It is one of the characteristics of your Lordships’ House, which means that we can quite often make a contribution by working together. But the danger of embedding collaboration as a supreme virtue into this legislation is that there have been quite a lot of examples in the past—under Governments of all different hues—of collaborative working between different parts of the public sector, under loosely organised arrangements, so that no one is ever to blame. What then happens is that, instead of the collaborative working getting rid of the gaps in service or making sure that people do not fall down the gaps, there are gaps in service that none of the participants in the collaborative scheme feels it is their duty to fill; or they assume wrongly that someone else is filling it. We then have disasters, and inquiries that identify that there were strategic problems. They say it was a system failure because no one in the collaborative system—often there are many well-paid people in the collaborative system—placed themselves in a position where they took responsibility and, therefore, could take the blame. Again, I think we should proceed with caution on an amendment that, well-intentioned though it is, suggests that there is some new, higher level of collaboration out there, which has not far been achieved, that would be uniquely virtuous and uniquely wise, capable of filling gaps and dealing with service deficiencies. If you have systems that are completely integrated under a single controlling mind—or, more often, a group controlling mind—it is then difficult to get innovation and positive change, and it is difficult for people who have been badly handled by that system to get proper redress. The system closes around and defends itself. It defends all its actions, both upwards, for those above at Secretary of State level who might criticise, and certainly downwards, where patients are harmed or do not get the service they want but are told that all is perfect because, “Isn’t it wonderful that we have an integrated collaborative service?” I rest my case.

More from Lord Redwood (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.