Contribution
My Lords, I will speak first to Amendment 104ZA tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, to which I added my name. The noble Lord, as he so often does, has put his finger on the button. Throughout our consideration of the Bill, we have repeatedly questioned the Government about the practical implications of abolishing NHS England, the costs of the reorganisation and precisely how the new arrangements will operate. We have asked how responsibilities would be transferred, where accountability would ultimately lie and how the Government could be confident that this substantial reorganisation would deliver the efficiencies and improvements in patient care that Ministers have promised—and here we are again. We now learn that, alongside the abolition of NHS England and the transfer of its functions into the department, the Government intend to establish a new special health authority in which to house the seven regional NHS teams, totalling about 3,000 people.
The Government have said that the main justification for abolishing NHS England is to reduce duplication, streamline administration, improve accountability and deliver substantial savings. Yet, like it or not, as with any new public body, this new special health authority will have its own governance arrangements, administrative staffing requirements, operating costs and lines of accountability. As was well said by the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, we are in the dark on so much of that, if not all of it. From the outside, it looks remarkably as though we are just transferring substantial parts of NHS England’s organisational infrastructure into another arm’s-length body. The Secretary of State has described this as a “temporary arrangement” intended to
“support the transition to a more devolved model”,
but we need to ask—as the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, did—what “temporary” means in this context. If it is temporary, what needs to happen before the way is clear for the SHA to be abolished and its functions transferred elsewhere?
As we all know, the creation of this SHA has been born of necessity because of the differing pay structures in the NHS and the Civil Service, so the obvious question is: when in the future is that situation likely to change? The explanation offered by the Secretary of State that she wishes to keep the NHS regional teams closer to the front-line services sounds very much like post hoc rationalising. The regional teams were surely never going to move physically to an office in central London.
That brings me back to the question of cost, which is central to my noble friend Lord Blencathra’s Amendment 279QB. We have already seen estimates suggesting that the redundancy costs associated with abolishing NHS England could reach between £1 billion and £1.3 billion. Those are substantial sums of public money, and it is only reasonable that Parliament should be satisfied that they will result in genuine, lasting savings.
My noble friend Lord Blencathra is unable to be present this evening, but I understand entirely the concern underlying his amendment, which is that we must not find ourselves paying substantial redundancy packages to staff who subsequently return to the NHS in different roles, potentially at considerable additional expense to the taxpayer. I note the comments of the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath, that this is unlikely to happen, but I have personally seen it happen in the past. Surely the minimum we are entitled to expect from the abolition of NHS England is genuine efficiencies. I am sure that the Government wish to achieve that. Can the Minister assure me that the job cuts that are to apply across NHS England will not be imposed in a way that brings headline numbers down but then requires the same expertise to be brought in by the side door under a different cost heading?
Moving back to the amendment from the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, I hope that the Minister can provide some further clarity about the proposed SHA, its funding, its intended lifespan and the arrangements for transferring its functions into the Government’s longer-term model. Ultimately, the test of this reorganisation is not whether the Government can claim to have abolished NHS England but whether the new system will be simpler, more accountable, less expensive and, most importantly, better for patients. I look forward to the Minister’s response.