Contribution
At my noble friend’s request, I will indeed move Amendment 94B, but I will also speak to Amendment 206 in my name.
My noble friend’s amendment is actually rather simple and quite obvious. It is simply that every ICB must take steps to tackle the health inequalities for those with musculoskeletal health conditions, where improved prevention, diagnosis and treatment are urgently needed.
In fact, that request is along the lines of that in Amendment 206, which stands in my name and those of the noble Baronesses, Lady Pidgeon and Lady Cass, and the noble Lord, Lord Black of Brentwood. We would all much prefer that we did not have to bring this amendment. We have always wanted and would prefer to work with Ministers to deliver on the commitment made by Labour in opposition before the election, and which the Labour Government have reaffirmed both in its 10-year health plan and the women’s health strategy.
That commitment is to ensure that universal—that is the important word—access to fracture prevention services exists across England by 2030. It is an important promise, particularly for women over 50—from looking around, there are quite a few of us here—half of whom will have a fracture because of osteoporosis as, incidentally, will one in five men. We are talking about this being universal; that means available to all, not four hours’ travel away. Patients of this age in particular cannot make that journey. We need a nationally available service.
There are 3 million people in England who live with osteoporosis, yet it is so often undiagnosed and therefore untreated. Having suffered from one fracture, these patients are at greater risk of another. I hardly need say that the consequences are devastating. A broken hip can rob some of their independence, force them into residential care and often shorten their life. Worse, this is unnecessary because we know how to prevent many of these fractures. We have safe, effective medicines, some costing as little as £1 a month. We have an established model of care, which identifies patients after a fracture, assesses their risks, provides treatment and then follows them up. This gives patients access to falls prevention, to strength and balance training, and to support to prevent further fractures. Sadly, however, we are having to table this amendment because too many people are being denied this cheap, cost-effective intervention.
Only a quarter of fragility fractures in England are identified by prevention services. I am ashamed to say that, since the election, the number identified has increased by only 3%. This is desperately disappointing, particularly compared with Wales, where services were rolled out nationwide within 18 months, after a clear ministerial commitment and some pump-priming.
The financial case is persuasive. The Royal Osteoporosis Society shows that universal high-quality services could prevent nearly 50,000 fractures over five years, including 15,000 hip fractures. Any of your Lordships who are still walking around with sticks, or who have had one of those hip replacements, know the inconvenience and hurt that it causes. More than that, perhaps, it would save about £300 million in acute hospital costs and probably close to £300 million in social care. It would release a quarter of a million hospital bed days.
The investment to establish these services is a one-off £90 million. The ongoing costs would then be met by local savings. Such investment would therefore pay for itself within two years. So, what is not to like? Less pain, less harm and less money. It is incomprehensible why the Government will not fulfil their promise to save so much suffering, and save the NHS and social care so much cost.
Fracture prevention services do not have to be provided by a single type of service or clinic; they can be organised in hospitals, primary care, community services or neighbourhood health settings. They offer the chance to put all three of the Government’s proposed shifts into practice—from sickness to prevention, from hospital to community and from analogue to digital—and be a vital part of the women’s health strategy. The amendment would reduce health inequalities, since people in the most deprived areas face a 25% higher chance of osteoporosis—this is always the same with all these issues. Promises do not fulfil themselves by wishful thinking; they have to be planned and made to happen. We have three years left to make Labour’s promise a reality, but we still have no road map for how that will happen. Access to prevention should be available, in the words of our Prime Minister, “in every postcode”.
Amendment 206 is modest. It would require the Secretary of State to publish an implementation plan for delivering universal access by 2030. The plan would set minimum standards and annual milestones, which would be measured, and set out how the Government will address the area differences in access. There would then be a report to Parliament on the progress on the number of eligible patients being identified and treated. That is the important thing: how many patients it reaches.
We are not setting out how every service should work—that is for local NHS organisations to design, provided patients receive the care—and we are not seeking to impose a duty to spend. We are asking the Government to set out how they will deliver the policy they have already committed to.
We have support across the Chamber from Conservatives, Liberal Democrats, the Cross Benches and Labour. We also have medical colleges, trade unions, charities and newspapers—I am sure they are watching this debate tonight—backing us. I know that Ministers understand the importance of this and that the Government want to honour their 2030 commitment to provide services. But we are already two years into government and there is no implementation plan or timetable, yet 2030 is just three years away. The lack of a plan is worrying. If we could get an assurance from my noble friend that we will see an implementation plan with a timetable and measurable targets then we would be happy to work with colleagues, rather than having to bring this back on Report.
Patients have waited long enough. We have seen enough of our colleagues on sticks to know of what we speak. Elderly folk—some of us—and, indeed, some much younger than us deserve to know when they will receive the care that could prevent the next fracture. I beg to move.