B

Baroness Gerada (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I am pleased to support Amendment 87 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon. Many years ago, I served on a local commissioning group, working out how best to care for people with addiction problems. At the same time, I led a local drug and alcohol service. I had an interest—some would say a conflict of interest—and I declared it, but I argued then that the value of that interest far outweighed the risk of a conflict. I knew where the gaps were, who was falling through them and what would work best for patients. More recently, I served as a GP on the board of a foundation trust. I felt then, as I feel now, that it mattered to have a GP in the room where decisions were made, rather than being consulted after they were taken. The Government’s case for removing the primary care seat on integrated care boards is that ICBs should act as strategic commissioners and avoid conflicts of interest. I understand that. But the same assessment also recognised that removing a formal mechanism for collaboration between ICBs and local partners, including primary care, could make that less effective. The Government acknowledge this risk. Conflicts are managed every day through registers, declarations and recusals, as we do in this House. They are not solved by silence. A board that hears from fewer people is not neutral; it is less informed. Let us notice what this amendment does not ask for. It does not ask for a seat. For my part, I would support keeping a GP seat on ICB boards, and so would the Royal College of General Practitioners. But the amendment asks for something much more modest. It asks ICBs to take all reasonable steps to involve primary care in service redesign, in integration, in neighbourhood health and in population health planning. This means early involvement, proper information, a real chance to influence decisions, and feedback on how those views were heard. The board must then publish an annual statement. This is accountability, not capture. Primary care’s voice is also essential to this Bill. The Bill formally sets out how ICBs’ responsibility for commissioning primary care will work. The whole neighbourhood health vision rests on general practice, pharmacy, dentistry and optometry. It would be extraordinary to commission a sector and design its future without consulting it. As the RCGP put it: “GPs bring a unique understanding of how the NHS functions across organisational boundaries because they work at the interface between patients, hospitals, community services, mental health services and social care. They see first-hand where fragmentation, delays and inefficiencies create poor patient experiences and additional pressure across the system”. That is exactly the sort of knowledge that an ICB needs in the room. Like many in this Chamber, I have lived through more NHS reorganisations than we can count. When things worked, it was not only because of the change in structure; it was because of the relationships and trust between those planning services and those delivering them. The Government say that ICB chairs remain free to involve primary care, but a chair’s discretion is not a duty. It depends on good will, which rarely survives tight budgets or a change of chair. Does the Minister accept the principle that ICBs should have a duty to involve primary care in its decisions? If she does, but cannot accept this amendment, how will that involvement be secured?

More from Baroness Gerada (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.