Contribution
My Lords, I will speak to Amendment 206 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Hayter, and Amendment 245 in my name.
The challenge facing the NHS is not ageing. Ageing is a triumph. The challenge is frailty. Many in this House demonstrate that those in their 80s and 90s can and do remain vigorous and independent; we see them every day. Yet GPs often see patients decades younger living with frailty. Frailty means reduced physiological reserve. A relatively minor infection, a fall or a change of medication can tip someone from independent living into hospital. Preventing avoidable deterioration and preserving independence must therefore be central to how we care for people as they age. These two amendments address different but closely connected aspects of that challenge. Amendment 206, as we have heard so eloquently, focuses on fracture prevention, and Amendment 245 seeks to ensure that people living with frailty receive properly integrated care.
I turn first to Amendment 206. As a GP, I have seen the devastating consequences of fractures in older people. As we have heard, a broken hip can mark the beginning of a steep decline in someone’s health and independence. I strongly support fracture prevention services, but we must ensure that they do not simply become yet another hospital-based specialty. When I first started in general practice, we worked closely with our district nurses. They would visit at-risk patients in their home and check for trip hazards, poor lighting, diet and whether someone needed a walking aid. Of course, preventing a fracture is important but, as we have heard, we must also ensure that when someone sustains a fragility fracture they are identified, assessed and treated to reduce another. That is the purpose of the fracture liaison services. Seven medical royal colleges —including the Royal College of General Practitioners, which I used to lead—support them, but local areas need staff and resources to deliver them properly. How do the Government intend to support community and primary care services, including district nursing, as part of the commitment to universal fracture prevention services?
I turn to Amendment 245 in my name; I am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, for her support. It is a probing amendment. It would require integrated care boards to ensure that adults living with frailty, or at risk of it, are identified early, assessed promptly and supported by a multidisciplinary team, with hospitals, GPs, community services and social workers working together. ICBs would also have regard to national guidance and standards. In my engagement with Age UK leading up to this, it made a very important point to me: frailty reform cannot begin and end at the hospital front door. We need a pathway that runs end to end, from prevention and rapid assessment to proper support after discharge. Let me take each briefly in turn.
The first area is the front door. When a frail person arrives at hospital, they need a rapid response and someone to ask whether admission can be avoided with the right support in the community. The NHS already knows what good looks like. Walsall shows what this can mean in practice. In one of the most deprived boroughs of England, the hospital runs an acute frailty service for at least 70 hours a week. Alongside it, an integrated front door team of experienced community nurses works in A&E seven days a week. They identify patients who can be cared for safely at home; arrange that care there and then, including up to 72 hours of crisis support; and hand people on to virtual wards and frailty case managers. The trust has avoided more than 5,000 admissions since December 2020 and supported over 1,800 earlier discharges. That is integration: community staff at the hospital front door. These sorts of initiatives are inconsistent within the NHS, as many are. Age UK reports that 32% of people aged 90 and over wait 12 hours or more in A&E. For a frail person, that is not an inconvenience; it causes them real, irreversible harm. The NHS aims for acute frailty services to run at least 70 hours a week in hospitals with a major A&E, but provision remains patchy. How many hospitals currently meet that ambition? Where they do not, what will the Government do about it? Has every A&E now delivered the front door health check that was promised in April 2025?
The second area is assessment and treatment. A moderately to severely frail person may need a geriatrician, a nurse, a physiotherapist, an occupational therapist, a pharmacist and a social worker, all working together. When that does not happen, the cost is high. One in five people with frailty who are admitted as an emergency stay in hospital for more than 21 days, rather than being discharged within hours to community services. Yet the community services are under growing pressure. I mentioned on a previous amendment that the Care Quality Commission reports that we have half as many qualified district nurses per person over 65 as we did in 2012. We must not build a system that is good at spotting frailty but has nowhere to send people afterwards. Hospital assessment must be matched by community services for prevention, rehabilitation and follow-up, and by the staff to deliver. ICBs are responsible for NHS services. Adult social care sits with the local authorities, which are under severe financial pressure. How will the Government make sure that the two have the resources and incentives to work together?
The third and final area is about people getting safely home. Age UK estimates that around 13,000 people are medically fit to leave hospital but are still there, and that is up by 70% since 2021. Too often, there is simply nowhere between hospital and home—but it was not always so. When I first started in general practice, the Tomlinson report was published and highlighted the need for intermediate care centres—step-down, low-threshold, community-based services such as the Lambeth Community Care Centre, where I worked as a GP until it closed in 2005. Patients could be admitted straight from home, receive nursing and rehabilitation, and go home when they were ready. Their own GP stayed involved throughout. That was continuity, integration and a team without walls.
We cannot deliver a shift from hospital to community simply by announcing it. We have to rebuild the services that make that shift possible. The Government have promised a modern service framework for frailty and dementia, due soon, which is welcome, but a framework matters only if it changes care on the ground. I have these questions for the Minister: will the framework set clear, measurable expectations for ICBs? How will performance be monitored? What will happen if ICBs fall short? How will the lessons from the national frailty improvement collaborative reach each part of the NHS? I hope the Minister will set out how ICBs will be given the responsibility and the resources to deliver. Frailty is not a specialty; it is everyone’s business.