Contribution
My Lords, I will speak in support of Amendment 161, to which I have added my name. I thank the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Leicester for tabling the amendment and explaining the situation so clearly.
The origin of these practices—the changing of the NHS number on adoption—comes from the days when adoption was all about a complete and permanent break between the child and their birth family: a new name and a new birth certificate and, with them, a new medical record. But now things really have changed, as we have heard. The Adoption and Children Act 2002 requires courts and agencies to consider the child’s relationship with their birth relatives. Life-story work is now standard practice, with many adopted children keeping in contact with their birth family. We understand now that a child’s history is not something to be erased, but something to be stewarded for them for when they are ready. Yet, as we have heard, the NHS number change practice sticks to the old model. That is not to say that this change is legally stuck here. There is no legal requirement for the NHS numbers to be changed on adoption, in either adoption-related or health-related legislation. I very much hope that the Minister will take this opportunity to think about how this can be addressed.
Nobody supporting this amendment is asking noble Lords to choose between safety and the need to keep a continuous history. When it comes to it, we have shown with children in similar situations that it is possible to do both. For example, a child under a special guardianship order or in long-term fostering kinship care does not have to have their NHS number changed. Their records also contain birth, family details, previous addresses and, sometimes, a child protection history every bit as sensitive as that of an adopted child. So it is happening already, but in different groups.
The NHS manages the sensitive data in these cases through information governance: flagging the record as sensitive, updating the demographics, redacting, as we have heard, or restricting references to previous names and addresses. It is all happening, but with different groups of children. That protects the child without needing to clean the record. There is no reason why adopted children should be treated differently.
I emphasise the point that the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, made at the start of this important debate. Last year, the Sullivan review on data on sex and gender concluded that issuing children with new NHS numbers posed a “serious safeguarding risk” and should be halted urgently. The Secretary of State responded positively, directing that the process of changing NHS numbers for people under the age of 18 be stopped with immediate effect. So the Government have already formally accepted that changing a child’s NHS number and the loss of the continuity of that record can cause clinical and safeguarding harm and they have shown that it can be stopped using the same national back-office process that the noble Lord, Lord Young of Cookham, explained so eloquently. It can be done. If it is a serious safeguarding risk for one group of children, I suggest that it should be tackled for all groups of children.
I finish with some words from an adopted child, who said: “I would rather my NHS number stayed the same, because it leads to confusion of what has happened to me before I was adopted. This means key information about me isn’t easily known, like medical conditions I’ve had, and I don’t want this to lead to more problems in my future. Being adopted can make you feel out of place, like you have a big label that says, ‘Look at me: I’m different’. I’m the same boy I was before I was adopted. Even though things have changed in good ways for me, I still want to feel properly connected to who I was before”. I hope that the Minister will be able to consider practical ways of addressing this challenge.