B

Baroness Kidron (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, it is hard not to moved by all the amendments in this group. The words of my noble friend Lady Cass in opening the group keep echoing in my mind as everybody speaks. She said that children need explicit mention, lest they will be forgotten; maybe that is the message of the group in its entirety. I was very pleased to add my name to Amendment 279QG. I thank Arabella Skinner, director of Health Professionals for Safer Screens, for her work in identifying the issues that my noble friend Lady Cass set out and for originally bringing them to our attention. Had I got there in time, I would have also added my name to Amendments 279F and 279G, in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Penn, and indeed to Amendment 279P from the noble Baroness, Lady Barran. I was a huge supporter of the work that the noble Baroness, Lady Penn, did during the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill. She is absolutely right about the need to raise awareness of digital harms to healthcare professionals in the way that she set out. I really hope that the Minister is listening hard, as is the noble Baroness, Lady Barran, whose amendment would ensure that NHS-provided technology is effective, age-appropriate and not connected to unnecessary commercial services. Research by the Digital Futures for Children centre at the LSE, which I chair, has repeatedly found such connections in educational technology. It is unacceptable in education and unacceptable in health. I wish the noble Baroness well with her amendment. Moving to Amendment 279QG, my noble friend Lady Cass has already very ably explained that the difference between an isolated incident and a recognised pattern of harm is often merely the existence of a reporting system. Without that system, warnings are missed, patterns remain invisible and children continue to be exposed. Government Ministers tell us time and again that technology moves too fast for us to anticipate risk and harm, but the record tells a different story. In recent weeks, we have seen headlines across the world about hacked fridges and the dangers of AI toys, as though these were entirely unforeseen developments. In fact, I warned about the risk of connected fridges in 2021, yet only a few weeks ago the Government refused to include food production and distribution in the cyber security Bill. I also instigated a campaign about the risk of AI toys during Covid, and only now are we seeing action. The problem is not the risks emerging too quickly; it is that we respond to the warnings too slowly. We repeatedly make the mistake of failing to act on evidence for an absence of evidence itself, and it is children who pay the price for our delay, yet Governments of all stripes have resisted proposals for the very systems that would allow us to identify those warnings before more harm is done. In the case of online safety, the warnings are all around us. Parents, children and front-line professionals are telling us what they see, but their evidence is too often dismissed as anecdotal rather than recognised as the early warning signs of emerging harm. Tech sector lobbyists insist that evidence is inconclusive, even as recent court disclosures reveal that companies have known about harms associated with their products for years and fought tooth and nail to keep that knowledge secret. Meanwhile Ofcom, our regulator, sets the bar for evidence so high that it has failed to implement certain parts of the Online Safety Act as Parliament intended. For example, Section 11 requires “giving separate consideration to children in different age groups” while Section 12 requires providers to “mitigate and manage the risks of harm to children in different age groups”. Yet Ofcom has said: “we do not currently have a sufficient evidence base on the risk of harm for different age groups”. In 2025, two years after Royal Assent, it called for more research “to build our evidence base to develop additional measures to strengthen our Codes”. More than 18 months later—nearly four years after Royal Assent, which itself came after an eight-year process—those age-differentiated protections are still absent from the children’s codes. That is 12 years in total—there is the maths.

More from Baroness Kidron (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.