L

Lord Young of Cookham (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, this group of amendments, so ably introduced by the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, identifies a range of challenges that today’s children face, and the amendments come up with a range of solutions that, I hope, will address them. Speaking as a grandparent, I believe that my children face far more challenges bringing up their children than I ever did, for all the reasons that we have been hearing in the debate so far. I have added my name to Amendment 161 from the right reverend Prelate, which would require an adopted child to keep the same NHS number rather than it being changed. It is worth mentioning that, under the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act, every child will have an SUI—single unique identifier—which will enable the child to be tracked through the whole range of services that they may come across. The SUI is going to be the NHS number, which means that, if the adopted child has a new number, they will be the only child not protected by the reforms in the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act—and those may be the children who most need those services. I welcome the guidance that has been given. GPs have been asked to merge the new and the old, but implementation is variable and inconsistent. I will come back to that in a moment. Looking at the current process for issuing a new number, it struck me as excessively bureaucratic. I crave the patience of the Committee to read from the NHS website what actually happens: “The Personal Demographics Service (PDS) National Back Office (NBO) receives notification from the General Register Office (GRO) of all adoptions in England and Wales ... The NBO invalidates the pre-adoptive NHS number on PDS, if it can be identified, and sends the patient’s details … and registered GP practice to PCSE”— Primary Care Support England. “At the same time the NBO will send a patient removal to the practice which will end the patient’s registration with the practice”. It then speeds up: “The NBO allocates a new NHS number with the post-adoptive details as recorded in the adoption order, and sends the details to PCSE ... PCSE sends the details of pre and post adoptive details to the GP practice. PCSE will email the main contact held for that practice, if available. It is important that all practices maintain up-to-date contact details in PCSE Online. PCSE sends a new patient medical record envelope with the new patient updated details and new NHS number to the GP practice”. Two things strike me about that. First, we have a long way to go before an analogue NHS becomes a digital NHS, with envelopes flying around the country. Secondly, it strikes me as rather cumbersome and unnecessary. There is a high risk of error, as the right reverend Prelate identified. Practices have to merge two records, remove the demographic details of family members, add sensitivity reminders and manage disclosure for any subject access request, all manually and child by child. Much of this depends on what particular software the GP practice is using. There is no enforcement, no legal duty and no audit of what actually happens. The question I pose is: what is the information in the original record that prevents it being used? Would it not be much simpler to redact that and keep the same number? The NHS concedes that this could happen. Another NHS website, Dealing with Medical Records for Adopted Patients: a Guide for GP Practices, says: “If the patient is staying registered with your practice … You should not make any changes that conceal or alter the patient’s clinical history, however, steps should be taken to prevent disclosure of their pre-adoptive identity—for example blocking out all references to the previous name and any information that may identify members of the birth family”. Well, why on earth do we have to go through all the processes that I outlined at the beginning if it is simply possible to redact the relevant bits from the records and continue to use those? It seems to me, unless there is a powerful reason to the contrary, that that would be a common-sense approach to the issue that the right reverend Prelate has identified.

More from Lord Young of Cookham (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.