B

Baroness Merron (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 17 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

I may have inadvertently given the noble Lord the wrong impression, but to restate: we are required to publish a joint strategy. The important thing about this year’s Crime and Policing Act is also that multi-agency statutory approach. Looking at good practice, as the noble Lord has said, is absolutely part of that. We also expect ICBs to commission specialist stalking services to meet the needs of their populations. This amendment would create a bespoke statutory health duty separate from the Home Secretary’s multi-agency framework, which I fear would risk duplication. I know that it would do so inadvertently but it could also create confusion in what is, as we are all agreed, a critical area. That brings me to Amendment 70 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Barker. The voluntary, community and social enterprise sector plays an absolutely vital role in health and social care, as we have discussed previously, but the Government do not feel that the amendment is the right route to promote its involvement. The provider selection regime already allows ICBs to weight social value and to directly award contracts to well-performing voluntary providers. The Bill also empowers ICBs to financially or otherwise support organisations whose activities benefit the health service. These routes support VCSE organisations according to local need, without guaranteeing work that others may be better placed to undertake. The concern about this amendment is that it would set a harmful precedent of choosing providers by type rather than their ability to provide—something which would go against the Bill’s commitment to neutrality with respect to providers, as we discussed at some length in relation to Clause 10. I turn to Amendment 163, which was also tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Barker; the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, also spoke to it. The noble Baronesses are right that confidentiality is essential in all healthcare settings, particularly in sexual health services. Clause 52 allows us to use regulations to set out which information can or must be made available and who can access it. Our intention is that access should be limited to the information that people need for their role in providing care, and that professionals accessing the record to provide direct care must remain subject to their duties of confidentiality. The anticipated detailed arrangements for sexual health information will need to address patients’ expectations of confidentiality. There are already important protections in law and guidance. Sections 251A and 251B of the Health and Social Care Act 2012 contain exceptions to the duties concerning the NHS number and information-sharing where information concerns, or is connected with, services provided by an anonymous access provider. Information about a person’s health or sex life is also protected as a special category of data. I turn to Clauses 42 and 43, which were spoken to by the noble Baroness, Lady Coffey. I will endeavour to assist if there are areas about which the noble Baroness is still unclear; I would be very happy to pick that up further with her. Clause 42 is a technical change. It brings the statute book on a specific area of commissioning in line with broader commissioning arrangements across primary care. It will not affect patients in rural areas who are eligible to receive medicines from dispensing doctors; they will continue to receive the same service. Clause 43 ensures that ICBs can respond swiftly when exceptional circumstances disrupt access to pharmaceutical services, while maintaining safeguards and national oversight. Section 133 of the NHS Act 2006 would already apply to a disruption affecting the provision of services by dispensing doctors as well as NHS pharmacies. Clause 43 therefore clarifies that ICBs may act in exceptional circumstances regardless of scale. It removes unnecessary provision which would require the Secretary of State themselves to make arrangements, and it clarifies that authorisation to ICBs should be given through directions.

More from Baroness Merron (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.