Dr Al Pinkerton

Dr Al Pinkerton

Liberal Democrat — Surrey Heath

Speaking in the House of Commons on 18 November 2026

Debate

UK-EU Relations

Contribution

My hon. Friend speaks about these issues with alacrity and knowledge, and has a history of great involvement with them. I do not know whether we can call the things that she refers to “intangibles”, but if they are intangibles, they are perfectly representative of the people-to-people diplomacy that will secure the peace and security of our continent—the original intention of the scheme when it was founded. We are discussing the future of young people. They are not raw material for another tawdry social media clip of the sort that the Conservative party may seek to present in the aftermath of this debate. Consider the timing of this debate. Britain and Europe’s automotive industries have warned that unresolved changes to the rules of origin could lead to the imposition of £1.8 billion in tariffs in 2027 across trade in both directions, as a result of the ratcheting up of the trade and co-operation agreement. Once again, the Conservatives cannot claim that they were not warned about the dangers to our automotive sector. Long before Brexit was pursued or realised, in In one of the Committee Rooms upstairs, Patrick Minford, one of Brexit’s leading economic advocates, gave evidence to a Committee of this House that made that reality plain. When asked whether leaving the European customs union could mean the collapse of the entire UK car industry, Minford acknowledged that we would have to “run…down” the British car industry; he comparing its fate to Britain’s coal and steel industries. Today, with British manufacturing jobs and investment at stake, the Conservatives are still defending the barriers that have put industry at risk. There is something even more troubling here. While the Conservatives remain consumed by the arguments of 2016, the world around us and them has changed profoundly. Russia’s war against Ukraine has shattered the foundations of European security; China is reshaping global industry and supply chains; and American leadership can no longer simply be taken for granted. Economic strength, technological resilience and national security have become inseparable, and the Conservatives’ motion says nothing about the world in which Britain now competes. That is why the Liberal Democrats have proposed an ambitious growth and defence partnership between Britain and Europe. It would restore Britain’s economic strength by ensuring that we rejoined the single market and negotiated a new, bespoke customs union that removed the barriers holding back British business. This would deepen European defence co-operation, and our collective security would be strengthened through joint procurement and defence production, and through closer collaboration with our NATO allies. Economic strength is national security, and in an increasingly dangerous world, Britain cannot afford to be politically or economically weaker, strategically isolated, or politically irrelevant. That brings me to Labour. The Prime Minister has recently discovered the language of honest conversations about Brexit—or perhaps I imagined that. Recognising the damage is not the same as having the courage to repair it. He wants credit for confronting reality and recognising that the Brexit emperor never was wearing a scrap of clothing, while maintaining the very red lines that prevent any meaningful change. That is not pragmatism. It is timid; it is cowardly; and it is costing us billions. Friday’s UK-EU summit should be an opportunity to transform Britain’s relationship with Europe; instead, Labour’s internal divisions have reduced its ambitions to a desire to repair some of the damage while refusing to confront its causes. It is extraordinary that we still need to explain what Adam Smith understood 250 years ago this year: trade creates shared prosperity; there is no requirement for one nation to lose for another to gain. Our geography has not changed—Dover is still 21 miles from Calais—and our economic futures and security interests remain deeply intertwined. The Conservatives remain trapped in the arguments of the past. Labour acknowledges the problem, but lacks the courage to embrace the solution. The Liberal Democrats offer a different future: a Britain strengthened by its partnerships, more prosperous through trade and more secure through co-operation. Our geography is fixed, but our future is not. That is why this motion is not worth the paper that it is written on.

More from Dr Al Pinkerton

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Dr Al Pinkerton's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Dr Al Pinkerton report card.